Letter
Ruthenium-Catalyzed Isomerization of ortho-Silylanilines to Their
para Isomers
sı
*
ACCESS
ABSTRACT: The catalytic ortho to para transposition of a silyl group in aniline
derivatives is described. [RuCl2(p-cymene)]2/BINAP in conjunction with a Cu(OAc)2
additive serves as a potent catalytic system. This method is also applicable to the
isomerization of 2-silylpyrrole derivatives to the corresponding 3-silyl isomers.
he substitution pattern of polysubstituted arenes has a
Tcritical impact on their chemical, physical, and biological
properties, and therefore, the development of methods for the
selective synthesis of polysubstituted arenes with the desired
arrangement of substituents is now one of the most important
subjects in the field of synthetic organic chemistry. In this
context, a number of methods that allow for the site-selective
introduction of a functional group to an aromatic compound
have been reported.1 Another approach to this end would be
the selective interconversion of positional isomers of
polysubstituted arenes, such as that between ortho, meta, and
para isomers of disubstituted arenes. This approach is
potentially powerful, because it would permit a positional
isomer that is difficult to access by direct introduction methods
to be synthesized. Reported transposition reactions of
substituents on a benzene ring are summarized in Scheme 1.
It would be possible to cause an alkyl group to migrate around
an aromatic ring with the aid of Brønsted or Lewis acids via a
reversible Friedel−Crafts-type reaction, which would result in
the formation of a mixture of positional isomers (Scheme 1a).2
The isomerization of ortho- or para-bromophenol to a meta
isomer was reported to be mediated by a superacid (SbF5−
HF) via an arenium cation intermediate (Scheme 1b, top).3
The 1,2-transposition of a halide group could also occur via an
anionic mechanism, a reaction that is known as the halogen
dance reaction (Scheme 1b, bottom).4 A silyl group of 1,2-
bis(silyl)arenes can migrate in a 1,2-fashion to form a meta
isomer with the aid of CF3CO2H (Scheme 1c).5 The reversible
transposition of an ester group is catalyzed by a palladium
complex, presumably via the oxidative addition of a C(acyl)−
O bond and decarbonylation (Scheme 1d).6 Herein, we report
on the ruthenium-catalyzed isomerization of ortho-silylaniline
derivatives to the corresponding para isomers (Scheme 1e).
Unlike the acid-catalyzed reaction (Scheme 1c),5 the exclusive
1,3-migration of a silyl group is possible by the use of a
transition metal catalyst.
using the o-silylaniline derivative 1a in the presence of a series
of transition metal catalysts. Although the expected product
was not observed, the corresponding para isomer 2a was
unexpectedly formed. Given that no catalytic 1,3-silicon
migration reactions have been reported to date, we focused
our attention on optimizing this catalytic isomerization
reaction. Finally, compound 2a was obtained in 73% isolated
yield when compound 1a was reacted in the presence of
[RuCl2(p-cymene)]2 (10 mol %), ( )-BINAP (20 mol %),
and Cu(OAc)2 (1.2 equiv) in toluene at 180 °C for 15 h (entry
1 in Table 1). Although no product was formed in the absence
of a ruthenium catalyst (entry 2), several other transition metal
complexes exhibited some levels of catalytic activity: [RhCl-
(cod)]2 (75%), [Cp*RhCl2]2 (18%), [Cp*IrCl2]2 (45%),
Ni(OAc)2 (7%), and Pd(OAc)2 (44%). The yield of
compound 2a was significantly lowered in the absence of an
added ligand (32%, entry 3), and ( )-BINAP proved to be an
optimal ligand among the ligands that were examined: dppm
(47%), dppe (57%), dppp (59%), dppb (69%), Xantphos
(28%), PCy3 (65%), and P(p-tolyl)3 (41%).8 The addition of
Cu(OAc)2 is required for the formation of compound 2a
(entry 4), and the yield was diminished to 34%, with 13% of
compound 1a being recovered and 24% of a protodesilylated
product being formed when the amount of Cu(OAc)2 was
reduced to 20 mol % (entry 5). Other copper salts, such as
CuCl (13%), CuI (10%), and CuBr2 (0%), were much less
effective. It is important to note that, when compound 1a was
exposed to CF3CO2H-catalyzed conditions,5 which were used
for the isomerization of bis(silyl)arenes (Scheme 1c),
compound 2a was obtained in only 14% yield, with a
Received: July 8, 2021
During the course of our studies on catalytic carbon−silicon
bond activation reactions,7 we examined annulation reactions
© XXXX American Chemical Society
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX
A