Self-Assembly of Metallo-Supramolecules under Kinetic or Thermodynamic Control: Characterization of Positional Isomers Using Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy

Article abstract of DOI:10.1021/jacs.0c03459

Coordination-driven self-assembly has been extensively employed to construct a variety of discrete structures as a bottom-up strategy. However, mechanistic understanding regarding whether self-assembly is under kinetic or thermodynamic control is less exp

Full text of DOI:10.1021/jacs.0c03459

Subscriber access provided by BIU Pharmacie | Faculté de Pharmacie, Université Paris V
Article
Self-Assembly of Metallo-Supramolecules under Kinetic or
Thermody-namic Control? Characterization of Positional
Isomers Using Scanning Tunneling Spectroscopy
Lei Wang, Bo Song, Yiming Li, Lele Gong, Xin Jiang, Ming Wang, Shuai
Lu, Xin-Qi Hao, Zhenhai Xia, Yuan Zhang, Saw Wai Hla, and Xiaopeng Li
J. Am. Chem. Soc., Just Accepted Manuscript • Publication Date (Web): 20 Apr 2020
Downloaded from pubs.acs.org on April 20, 2020
Just Accepted
“Just Accepted” manuscripts have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. They are posted
online prior to technical editing, formatting for publication and author proofing. The American Chemical
Society provides “Just Accepted” as a service to the research community to expedite the dissemination
of scientific material as soon as possible after acceptance. “Just Accepted” manuscripts appear in
full in PDF format accompanied by an HTML abstract. “Just Accepted” manuscripts have been fully
peer reviewed, but should not be considered the official version of record. They are citable by the
Digital Object Identifier (DOI®). “Just Accepted” is an optional service offered to authors. Therefore,
the “Just Accepted” Web site may not include all articles that will be published in the journal. After
a manuscript is technically edited and formatted, it will be removed from the “Just Accepted” Web
site and published as an ASAP article. Note that technical editing may introduce minor changes
to the manuscript text and/or graphics which could affect content, and all legal disclaimers and
ethical guidelines that apply to the journal pertain. ACS cannot be held responsible for errors or
consequences arising from the use of information contained in these “Just Accepted” manuscripts.
is published by the American Chemical Society. 1155 Sixteenth Street N.W.,
Washington, DC 20036
Published by American Chemical Society. Copyright © American Chemical Society.
However, no copyright claim is made to original U.S. Government works, or works
produced by employees of any Commonwealth realm Crown government in the course
of their duties.

Page 1 of 10
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
!"#$A%%!&'"( )# *!+,"")$ -./,&)"!0-"!% -12!/ 341!+40 )/
56!/&)2(1,&40 7)1+/)"8 76,/,0+!/49,+4)1 )# :)%4+4)1," ;%)&!/% <%41=
0,1141= 5-11!"41= .!0+/)%0).(
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
!" #$%&'(' )* +*%&'(' ,"-"%& "'(' !.! /*%&'0 1"% 2"$%&'3 4"%& #$%&'3 +56$" 6'('! 1"%78" 9$*'!
:5!%5$" 1"$'0 ,6$% :5$%&';'<'= +$> #$" 9.$;'< $%? 1"$*@!%& ";'(
(A!@$BC-!%C *D E5!-"FCBG' H%"I!BF"CG *D +*6C5 J.*B"?$' K$-@$' J.*B"?$ LLMNO' H%"C!? +C$C!F
0A!@$BC-!%C *D 4$C!B"$.F +P"!%P! $%? Q%&"%!!B"%&' H%"I!BF"CG *D R*BC5 K!S$F' A!%C*%' K1 TMNOL' H%"C!? +C$C!F
3+C$C! U!G $V*B$C*BG *D +6@B$-*.!P6.$B +CB6PC6B! $%? 4$C!B"$.F' E*..!&! *D E5!-"FCBG' 2"."% H%"I!BF"CG' E5$%&P56%' 2"."%
WLOOWN' E5"%$
!E*..!&! *D E5!-"FCBG' :5!%&X5*6 H%"I!BF"CG' :5!%&X5*6' 9!%$% YZOOZN' E5"%$
<R$%*FP"!%P! $%? K!P5%*.*&G A"I"F"*%' AB&*%%! R$C"*%$. $V*B$C*BG' !-*%C' [ MOYL\' H%"C!? +C$C!F
=A!@$BC-!%C *D ]5GF"PF' ^.? A*-"%"*% H%"I!BF"CG' R*BD*._' `"B&"%"$ NLZN\' H%"C!? +C$C!F
!"#$%&'( )*+,--./0123,).-*41-*05 0123,).-*41-,3 60.)*360)5 0*-7/,00*)8-95 04,::6:; +1::*-6:; )643.04.295
+*32936<6:*
A !"#A$"% E**B?"%$C"*%7?B"I!% F!.D7$FF!-V.G 5$F V!!% !SC!%F"I!.G !-@.*G!? C* P*%FCB6PC $ I$B"!CG *D ?"FPB!C! FCB6PC6B!F $F $
V*CC*-76@ FCB$C!&Ga 9*>!I!B' -!P5$%"FC"P 6%?!BFC$%?"%& B!&$B?"%& >5!C5!B F!.D7$FF!-V.G "F 6%?!B _"%!C"P *B C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.
"F .!FF !S@.*B!?a K* ?$C!' F6P5 -!P5$%"FC"P "%I!FC"&$C"*% 5$F V!!% ."-"C!? C* ?"FC"%PC' $FF!-V.!? FCB6PC6B!Fa [C FC".. B!-$"%F $ D*B-"?$V.!
P5$..!%&! C* FC6?G C5! _"%!C"P $%? C5!B-*?G%$-"P V!5$I"*B *D F!.D7$FF!-V.G FGFC!-F >"C5 -6.C"@.! $FF!-V.!? "F*-!BF ?6! C* C5! .$P_
*D P5$B$PC!B"X$C"*% -!C5*?Fa 9!B!"%' >! 6F! $ FC!@>"F! FCB$C!&G >5"P5 P*-V"%!? $ F!.D7B!P*&%"C"*% $%? F!.D7$FF!-V.G @B*P!FF C*
P*%FCB6PC &"$%C -!C$..*7F6@B$-*.!P6.!F >"C5 b @*F"C"*%$. "F*-!BF "% F*.6C"*%a #"C5 C5! 5!.@ *D 6.CB$5"&57I$P66-' .*>7C!-@!B$C6B!
FP$%%"%& C6%%!."%& -"PB*FP*@G $%? FP$%%"%& C6%%!."%& F@!PCB*FP*@G' >! >!B! $V.! C* 6%$-V"&6*6F.G ?"DD!B!%C"$C! WY "F*-!BF *% C5!
F6VFCB$C! >5"P5 P*BB!F@*%? C* b "F*-!BF "% F*.6C"*%a K5B*6&5 -!$F6B!-!%C *D WMN FCB6PC6B!F' C5! !S@!B"-!%C$. @B*V$V"."CG *D !$P5
"F*-!B >$F *VC$"%!? $%? P*-@$B!? >"C5 C5! C5!*B!C"P$. @B*V$V"."CGa +6P5 $ P*-@$B"F*% $.*%& >"C5 ?!%F"CG D6%PC"*%$. C5!*BG cAJKd
P$.P6.$C"*% F6&&!FC!? C5$C $.C5*6&5 V*C5 _"%!C"P $%? C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*. !S"FC!? "% C5"F F!.D7$FF!-V.G' C5! "%PB!$F!? !S@!B"-!%C$.
@B*V$V"."C"!F *D "F*-!BF P*-@$B!? C* C5!*B!C"P$. @B*V$V"."C"!F F5*6.? V! $CCB"V6C!? C* C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.a
&'()*+,-(.*'
5!."P$C! $FF!-V.!? VG
$
CB"F7V"@GB"?"%! ."&$%? P*6.?
@B*&B!FF"I!.G P*%I!BC "%C* C5! P"BP6.$C! 5!."P$C!' P*BB!F@*%?"%&
)!P$6F! *D "CF "%CB"%F"P ?G%$-"P %$C6B!' F!.D7$FF!-V.G "F $V.!
C* *B&$%"X! F6"C$V.! -*.!P6.$B P*-@*%!%CF "%C* -*B!
F*@5"FC"P$C!? F6@B$-*.!P6.$B !%C"C"!F VG I"BC6! *D %*%P*I$.!%C
"%C!B$PC"*%FaW KG@"P$..G' F!.D7$FF!-V.G "%I*.I!F -6.C"@.!
B!I!BF"V.! @B*P!FF!F *D ?"FF*P"$C"*%' $FF*P"$C"*%' $%?
B!*B&$%"X$C"*% "% >5"P5 C5! FCB6PC6B!F *B @B*@!BC"!F P$% V! C6%!?
VG @5GF"P$. P*%?"C"*%F *B !SC!B%$. FC"-6.6FaN +C6?"!F 5$I!
B!I!$.!? C5$C D$PC*BF F6P5 $F ."&$%? &!*-!CBG' -!C$.
"*%Fe$%"*%F' B!$PC"*% C"-!' C!-@!B$C6B!' P*%P!%CB$C"*%' $%?
F*.I!%C P$% $DD!PC C5! D"%$. @B*?6PCF *D F!.D7$FF!-V.GaL )!G*%?
C5!F! D$PC*BF' C5! $FF!-V.!? FCB6PC6B!F P*6.? $.F* V! ?!C!B-"%!?
VG _"%!C"P P*%CB*. *B C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.aNV [% C5! -$f*B"CG
*D FGFC!-F' C5! B!I!BF"V.! $%? >!$_' %*%7P*I$.!%C "%C!B$PC"*%F
D$I*B C5!B-*?G%$-"P$..G P*%CB*..!? FCB6PC6B!F >"C5 *@C"-6-
P*%?"C"*%FaY [% P*%CB$FC' _"%!C"P$..G P*%CB*..!? F!.D7$FF!-V.G
P$% D*B- "%!BC FCB6PC6B!F 6F"%& .!FF .$V".! "%C!B$PC"*%F'Z *B
-!C$FC$V.! @B*?6PCF C5$C $B! _"%!C"P$..G CB$@@!? $C .*P$.
-"%"-$M7T $%? -$G V! D6BC5!B CB$%FD*B-!? C* -*B! FC$V.!
@B*?6PCF 6@*% @B*.*%&!? B!$PC"*% C"-!aT [% *%! *D C5!
@"*%!!B"%& >*B_F' !5% $%? P*>*B_!BF B!I!$.!? C5$C C5! CB"@.!
C* C5! F>"CP5 DB*- _"%!C"P P*%CB*. C* C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.aT$
[% J6f"C$gF F!.D7$FF!-V.!? 4% @*.G5!?B$' C5!G >!B!
N%
P*%F"?!B!? $F C5!B-*?G%$-"P$..G P*%CB*..!? @B*?6PCF >5!% % h
M' WN' *B NYa #5".! D*B % i NY' C5! _"%!C"P CB$@@"%& "F %* .*%&!B
%!&."&"V.!aMP AF F6P5' 4LO MO $%? 4Yb Y\ $FF!-V.!? VG C5! F$-!
."&$%? >"C5 ]?c[[d >!B! P$C!&*B"X!? $F _"%!C"P$..G $%?
C5!B-*?G%$-"P$..G P*%CB*..!? @B*?6PCF' B!F@!PC"I!.GaT? [C "F
>*BC5 %*C"%& C5$C C5!F! $FF!-V."!F &!%!B$..G &$I! ?"FC"%PC
$FF!-V.!? FCB6PC6B!F B!&$B?"%& _"%!C"P *B C5!B-*?G%$-"P
P*%CB*.' D$P"."C$C"%& ?!C$".!? P5$B$PC!B"X$C"*%a
+6@B$-*.!P6.$B "F*-!B"F- 5$F V!!% >!.. FC6?"!? "%
P**B?"%$C"*% @*.G-!BF $%? -!C$.7*B&$%"P DB$-!>*B_F >5"P5
5"&5.G B!.G *% PBGFC$. !%&"%!!B"%& C* P*%D"B- C5! FCB6PC6B!
!S@."P"C.Gab [% P**B?"%$C"*%7?B"I!% F!.D7$FF!-V.G *D ?"FPB!C!
-!C$..*7F6@B$-*.!P6.!F' -*B! $CC!%C"*% >$F D*P6F!? *% @B!P"F!
P*%CB*. *I!B C5! F5$@! $%? F"X! *D $FF!-V."!Fa\ K5B*6&5 P$B!D6.
?!F"&%' $ F"%&.! -!C$..*7F6@B$-*.!P6.! B$C5!B C5$% $ -"SC6B! *D
"F*-!BF
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 2 of 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 3 of 10
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 4 of 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 5 of 10
Journal of the American Chemical Society
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 6 of 10
"8E71 2? ";1 "*(87 F'1)0: G1HI *< F.0;( &6*=1)6 $87-,78(1+ <)*= 9/"
1
[F*-!B
Q%!B&G
8
E
-
+
1
<
0
;
2
3
4
"#$%&'
"#&%#(
"#&%)&
"#'%*(
"#'%)'
"#$%(#
"#*%#&
"#*%$*
5
6
7
8
9
#! D"BFC -!$F6B!? C5! A^+ *D C5! -!C$. f6%PC"*%F *D $
B!D!B!%P! -*.!P6.! JDNOV' >5"P5 P*%C$"%F *%.G *%! CG@! *D
-!C$. "*% k6c[[d "% "CF *6C!B-*FC B"%&a K5! *VC$"%!? +K+ ?$C$ "%
$ F"%&.! -*.!P6.! F5*>!? $ ?"FC"%PC $I!B$&! V$%?&$@ *D Nab !`
cJ"&6B! +Y\d' >5"P5 .$C!B F!BI!F $F C5! B!D!B!%P! C* "?!%C"DG
mC@G7k6c[[dpC@Gia AF $ D*..*>"%& FC!@' C5! +K+ ?$C$ >$F
P*..!PC!? D*B $.. C5! C>!.I! -!C$. f6%PC"*%F "% C5! *6C!B-*FC B"%&
*D $ F"%&.! !A F6@B$-*.!P6.!a ADC!B P$B!D6. $%$.GF"F *D C5! ?$C$
$%? P.$FF"DG"%& C5! I$.6!F "%C* C>* &B*6@F' $% $I!B$&! *D Nab !`
V$%?&$@ >$F *VF!BI!? D*B F"S -!C$. f6%PC"*%F >5"P5 P*6.? V!
$FF"&%!? C* mC@G7k6c[[dpC@Gi $PP*B?"%& C* C5! B!D!B!%P!a
4!$%>5".!' $% $I!B$&!? V$%?&$@ *D NaY !` >$F D*6%? D*B C5!
*C5!B F"S .*V!F' P*BB!F@*%?"%& C* mC@G7J!c[[d7C@Gi cJ"&6B! Y)p
Y4da AF F6P5' >! $B! $V.! C* ?"DD!B!%C"$C! !$P5 J!c[[d DB*-
k6c[[d V$F!? *% C5! V$%?&$@ "% $ F"%&.! -*.!P6.! $%?
F6PP!FF"I!.G ?!C!B-"%! C5! CG@! *D "F*-!BF *6C *D C5! D*6BC!!%
@*FF"V.! *% C5! F6VFCB$C! cJ"&6B!F Z)' ZQ' Z9' ZUda
5
F5*>% "% K$V.! W' "F*-!B 8 5$F C5! 5"&5!FC C*C$. !%!B&G *D
WNaLM !` P*-@$B!? C* C5! .*>!FC *%! *D pWbaNb !` D*B "F*-!B
;K >5"P5 "F F6&&!FC!? $F C5! C5!B-*?G%$-"P$..G P*%CB*..!?
@B*?6PC $-*%& b "F*-!BFa A%? C5! !%!B&G .!I!.F *D *C5!B
"F*-!BF $B! $.F* "% $&B!!-!%C >"C5 *6B @B*@*F!? CB!%?a AC C5"F
@*"%C' >! P$% P*%P.6?! C5$C C5! &!%!B$C"*% *D C5!F! @*F"C"*%$.
"F*-!BF >$F ?!C!B-"%!? VG _"%!C"P $%? C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.F
F"-6.C$%!*6F.Gj >5".! C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*. -"&5C @.$G $
-*B! @B!?*-"%$%C B*.! D*B C5! "F*-!BF >"C5 "%PB!$F!?
@B*V$V"."C"!F P*-@$B!? C* C5!*B!C"P$. @B*V$V"."C"!Fa #!
F@!P6.$C!? C5$C C5! ."&$%?F P*6.? "%"C"$..G F!.D7$FF!-V.! >"C5
:%c[[d C* D*B- C5! _"%!C"P$..G FC$V.! "F*-!BF V$F!? *%
-$C5!-$C"P$. FC$C"FC"PF' C5!% C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*. !%$V.!?
C5! F!.D7$FF!-V.G C* B!$BB$%&! C5! ?"FCB"V6C"*% $%? !%5$%P!? C5!
D*B-$C"*% *D C5! -*B! !%!B&G7D$I*B!? FCB6PC6B!FaLN
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
$*'-7,6.*'6
[% P*%P.6F"*%' >! 5$I! F6PP!FFD6..G P*%FCB6PC!? $ F!B"!F *D
CB"-!C$.."P F6@B$-*.!P6.!F "% *%! @*C 6F"%& C5! FCB$C!&G *D F!.D7
B!P*&%"C"*% $%? F!.D7$FF!-V.Ga K5B*6&5 F!.D7B!P*&%"C"*%'
J!c[[d' E*c[[d *B EBc[[[d F!.!PC"I!.G P**B?"%$C!? >"C5 C5! @B!7
*B&$%"X!? -!C$.7*B&$%"P ."&$%? C* D*B- !SP.6F"I! "%C!B-!?"$C!F
C5$C >!B! _"%!C"P$..G CB$@@!?a K5! F6VF!l6!%C F!.D7$FF!-V.G
>"C5 C5! >!$_.G P**B?"%$C"%& -!C$. "*% :%c[[d $DD*B?!? C5! D"%$.
F6@B$-*.!P6.!F !A7!$ >"C5 -*B! ?"I!BF"CG C5B*6&5 C5!
D*B-$C"*% *D b @*F"C"*%$. "F*-!BFa K5! "%C!B-!?"$C!F $%? C5!
F6@B$-*.!P6.!F >!B! >!.. P5$B$PC!B"X!? VG -$FF F@!PCB*-!CBG
$%? R4k F@!PCB*FP*@Ga !A >$F ?"B!PC.G I"F6$."X!? 6F"%&
H9`7 K7+K4 $%? $.. C5! b "F*-!BF "% F*.6C"*% cP*BB!F@*%?"%&
C* WY "F*-!BF *% F6VFCB$C!d >!B! F6PP!FFD6..G "?!%C"D"!? 6F"%&
+K+ C* @B*V! C5! .*P$. P5!-"P$. !%I"B*%-!%C >"C5 C5! A^+ $C
C5! $C*-"P .!I!.a 4*B! "-@*BC$%C.G' C5! *PP6BB!%P! *D
F6@B$-*.!P6.$B "F*-!B"F- "% *6B FGFC!- >$F D*6%? C* V!
?!C!B-"%!? VG C5!B-*?G%$-"P $%? _"%!C"P P*%CB*.
P*..$V*B$C"I!.G 6F"%& FC$C"FC"P$. FC6?G $%? AJK P$.P6.$C"*%a A%?
C5!"B P*%CB"V6C"*%F >!B! l6$%C"C$C"I!.G 6%?!BFC**? C5B*6&5 C5!
?!I"$C"*% V!C>!!% C5! C5!*B!C"P$. @B*V$V"."CG $%? !S@!B"-!%C$.
@B*V$V"."CG -!$F6B!? DB*- C5! +K+ -!C5*? >! ?!I!.*@!?a
K5!B!D*B!' C5"F FC6?G ?!-*%FCB$C!F C5$C >! $B! $V.! C* FC6?G C5!
_"%!C"P $%? C5!B-*?G%$-"P D!$C6B!F *D F6@B$-*.!P6.$B
"F*-!B"F- $C F"%&.! -*.!P6.$B .!I!. "% $ P*-@."P$C!? FGFC!-a
A??"C"*%$..G' C5*F! CB"-!C$.."P -!C$..*7F6@B$-*.!P6.!F -$G
"%CB*?6P! -!C$.7?!@!%?!%C @B*@!BC"!F $%? *DD!B @*C!%C"$.
*@@*BC6%"C"!F D*B D6C6B! $@@."P$C"*%Fa
+6P5 +K+ -!$F6B!-!%CF >!B! !SC!%?!? C* $ C*C$. *D WMN
F6@B$-*.!P6.!F cJ"&6B!F +ZOp+ZTd' >5"P5 $..*>!? 6F C*
P5$B$PC!B"X! $.. C5! WY "F*-!BF *% C5! A& cWWWd F6BD$P! cJ"&6B!F
Y)pY4' +Zbd D*B ?"FCB"V6C"*% $%$.GF"Fa +6VF!l6!%C FC$C"FC"P$.
FC6?G >$F @!BD*B-!? C* "%I!FC"&$C! C5! !S@!B"-!%C$. $%?
C5!*B!C"P$. @B*V$V"."CG ?"FCB"V6C"*%Fa ^I!B$..' C5! !S@!B"-!%C$.
@B*V$V"."C"!F cA!d V$F"P$..G D*..*>!? C5! CB!%? *D C5! C5!*B!C"P$.
@B*V$V"."C"!F cABd c!S$-"%!? VG P5"7Fl6$B! C!FC D*B
"%?!@!%?!%P!' K$V.! +W7+Ld V6C ?"F@.$G!? I$B"$C"*%F DB*-
"F*-!BF cJ"&6B! ZRda [C F5*6.? V! %*C!? C5$C AB "F P$.P6.$C!?
-$C5!-$C"P$..G cJ"&6B! +Z\d $%? "F @B"-$B".G I"!>!? $F C5!
B!F6.C *D F!.D7$FF!-V.G 6%?!B _"%!C"P$. P*%CB*.a K* V!CC!B @B!F!%C
C5! I$B"$C"*%F V!C>!!% A! $%? AB ' >! P$.P6.$C!? C5! B!.$C"I!
+ , -./ " / 23/ 4
?!I"$C"*% 6F"%& C5! D*B-6.$
cJ"&6B! +MOd
1
0
1
$%? C5! B!F6.CF >!B! @.*CC!? "% 5"FC*&B$- $F F5*>% "% J"&6B! Z^a
[F*-!BF 8 $%? ; 5$I! C5! F$-! AB *D OaOLWL' V6C !S@!B"-!%C$.
B!F6.C F5*>!? $% *@@*F"C! CB!%? >5"P5 .!$? C* $ %!&$C"I! I$.6!
*D 7OaYW D*B "F*-!B 8' >5".! 5"&5!FC z I$.6! *D nWaTT D*B "F*-!B
;a 4!$%>5".!' "F*-!BF E' -' $%? < $.. F5*>!? %!&$C"I! I$.6!F
$%? "F*-!BF +' 1' $%? 0 F5*>!? @*F"C"I! I$.6!Fa K5!F! B!F6.CF
"-@."!? C5$C C5! F!P*%? "%CB$-*.!P6.$B P*-@.!S$C"*% -"&5C %*C
V! ?*-"%$C!? VG _"%!C"P P*%CB*. *%.G' C5!B-*?G%$-"P P*%CB*.
$.F* @.$G!? $% "-@*BC$%C B*.! >5"P5 .!$? C* $% !%!B&G7V"$F!?
"F*-!B ?"FCB"V6C"*%a
E*%F"?!B"%& C5$C C5! ?"DD!B!%P! *%.G P*-!F DB*- C5! B!.$C"I!
@*F"C"*% *D k6 IF J! "% C5! *6C!B-*FC B"%& "% C5! P5!-"P$.
FCB6PC6B! *D "F*-!BF' 87;' >! @B*@*F!? C5$C C5! FGFC!- P*6.? V!
!%!B&G7D$I*B!? >5!% C5! F$-! _"%?F *D -!C$.F *% C5! *6C!B
.$G!B >!B! %!"&5V*B"%& *% $?f$P!%C ."&$%?Fa [% *C5!B >*B?F' C5!
C*C$. !%!B&G *D C5! !"&5C "F*-!BF F5*6.? D*..*> F6P5 $ CB!%?r
8iE' -' <i+' 1' 0i; V$F!? *% C5! "%PB!$F"%& %6-V!B *D F$-!
%!"&5V*B"%& -!C$. "*%F *% $?f$P!%C ."&$%?F cJ"&6B! +Ybda ^6B
5G@*C5!F"F >$F D6BC5!B F6@@*BC!? VG C5!*B!C"P$. P$.P6.$C"*%F' "%
>5"P5' ?!%F"CG D6%PC"*%$. C5!*BG cAJKd >$F $@@."!? C* P$.P6.$C!
C5! C*C$. !%!B&G *D !$P5 "F*-!B VG 6F"%& C5! `"!%%$ AV "%"C"*
+"-6.$C"*% ]$P_$&! c`A+]d P*?! >"C5 C5! 96VV$B? D
cAJKnDd P*BB!PC"*%FaLW R*C! C5$C *%.G -!C$. "*%F "% C5! "F*-!BF
>!B! !SCB$PC!? C* F"-@."DG C5! P$.P6.$C"*% cJ"&6B! +Wda AF
A >7;A5?@ 7>A5?A5
-..)/+41= ;1#)/&,+4)1
+G%C5!C"P ?!C$".F' ."&$%?F $%? P*-@.!S!F P5$B$PC!B"X$C"*% "%7
P.6?"%& 9 R4k' WLE R4k' NA E^+,' NA R^Q+,' Q+[74+'
W
K#[474+' +K4 $%? +K+ F@!PCB$ $B! "%P.6?!? "% F6@@*BC"%&
"%D*B-$C"*%a K5! +6@@*BC"%& [%D*B-$C"*% "F $I$".$V.! DB!! *D P5$B&!
*% C5! AE+ ]6V."P$C"*%F >!VF"C!a
A<5B>C ;AD>C*A5;>A
7)//!%.)1241= A-+6)/
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 7 of 10
Journal of the American Chemical Society
4!?"$C!? k$C"*%$. +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D +6@B$-*.!P6.$B7KB6%P$C!?
S"$*@!%&."W{6FDa!?6
K!CB$5!?B$a A3.4@ G,+-@ A4,<@ '46@ D@'@A@ @MMM' FR' WLbO7WLbYa cPd +6%'
8a7Jaj [>$F$' 2aj ^&$>$' Aaj [F5"?*' ,aj +$C*' +aj ^X!_"' Kaj +!"' ,aj
,$-$&6P5"' Uaj J6f"C$' 4a +!.D7AFF!-V.!? 4NY Yb ]*.G5!?B$ $%? K5!"B
+5$B@ +CB6PC6B$. +>"CP5 H@*% +6VC.! "&$%? `$B"$C"*%a '46*:4* @M2M'
KOP' WWYY7WWYTa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
F5.${$%.a&*I
GTX5$%&{*?6a!?6
A-+6)/ 7)1+/4'-+4)1%
a#a ')a+a $%? ,a a P*%CB"V6C!? !l6$..Ga
cZd c$d [V6_6B*' Jaj U6F6_$>$' Kaj J6f"C$' 4a A K5!B-$..G
+>"CP5$V.! 4*.!P6.$B *P_a /6!FC7K!-@.$C!? +G%C5!F"F *D
$
>C7;@
U"%!C"P$..G +C$V.! R$%*F"X!? E$&!a N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ 2LLP' EOT'
bZMW7bZMNa cVd E5!@!."%' ^aj Hf-$' 2aj )$BB$%' ]a Qaj 6FVG' ]a 2a
+!l6!%C"$.' U"%!C"P$..G E*%CB*..!? +G%C5!F"F *D 46.C"P*-@*%!%C
+C!B!*"F*-!B"P AFF!-V."!Fa A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @M2@' ME' YW\Y7
YW\Ta cPd 1"!' Ka7:aj "$*' +a7,aj /6*' Uaj 6' 1aj A*%&' 1aj 96$%&'
4aj 4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj E5!%&' +a :a Aaj "6' 1aj #!F?!-"*C"F' Eaj
R!>_*-!' /a ka E*%FCB6PC"*% *D $ 9"&5.G +G--!CB"P R$%*F@5!B! `"$
$ ^%!7]*C k!$PC"*% *D $ KB"FC!B@GB"?"%! "&$%? >"C5 k6c[[da N@ A)@
HI*)@ '.4@ @M2C' EKL' bWMZ7bWMba
!" #$%&r OOOO7OOON7LTTb7NbWY
)* +*%&r OOOO7OOON7YLLT7bYb1
,"-"%& "r OOOO7OOOL7YMON7L\OZ
1"% 2"$%&r OOOO7OOOL7NWYL7LZ\M
4"%& #$%&r OOOO7OOON7ZLLN7ObOY
1"%78" 9$*r OOOO7OOOL7W\YN7bLO\
+$> #$" 9.$r OOOO OOON MYML \TWY
1"$*@!%& "r OOOO7OOOW7\MZZ7\ZZW
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
cMd c$d ]$B$FP5"I' `aj EB!&*7E$.$-$' 4aj [F5"7"' Kaj ]$?V!B&' Ea 2aj
K"--!B-$%' ]aj k!"%5*6?C' Aa Ra 4*.!P6.$B |E5$@!B*%!F} /6"?! C5!
A)+!%
K5! $6C5*BF ?!P.$B! %* P*-@!C"%& D"%$%P"$. "%C!B!FCFa
+@*%C$%!*6F J*B-$C"*% *D
$ WZ7E*-@*%!%C 9G?B*&!%7)*%?!?
AFF!-V.Ga N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @MM@' EOU' TMLb7TML\a cVd K$F5"B*' +aj
K*-"%$&$' 4aj U6F6_$>$' Kaj U$>$%*' 4aj +$_$-*C*' +aj ,$-$&6P5"'
Uaj J6f"C$' 4a ]?[[7A"B!PC!? AG%$-"P AFF!-V.G *D $ A*?!P$@GB"?"%!
"&$%? "%C* Q%?7E$@@!? $%? ^@!% K6V!Fr K5! [-@*BC$%P! *D U"%!C"P
E*%CB*. "% +!.D7AFF!-V.Ga A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @MMB' UO' LNMT7LNTOa
cPd J6f"C$' Aaj H!?$' ,aj +$C*' +aj ,*_*G$-$' 9aj 4"X6%*' Raj
U6-$F$_$' Kaj J6f"C$' 4a +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D 4LO MO
[P*F"?*?!P$5!?B*%a HI*)@ @M2O' E' \W7WOWa
cTd c$d 9$F!%_%*@D' )aj !5%' 2a74aj )*6-!?"!%!' Raj !"X!' Qaj `$%
A*BFF!.$!B' Aa U"%!C"P $%? K5!B-*?G%$-"P E*%CB*. "% +!.D7AFF!-V.Gr
+!l6!%C"$. J*B-$C"*% *D "%!$B $%? E"BP6.$B 9!."P$C!Fa A:;*S@ HI*)@
Q:+@ !<@ 2LLP' KR' LNMZ7LNMba cVd 9*B"' Aaj ,$-$F5"C$' Ua7[aj J6f"C$' 4a
U"%!C"P +!.D7AFF!-V.Gr +!.!PC"I! EB*FF7E$C!%$C"*% *D K>* +C!B"P$..G
A"DD!B!%C"$C!? ]?[[7E**B?"%$C"*% k"%&Fa A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @MMC'
UK' ZOWM7ZOW\a cPd ,$-$%$_$' 4aj ,$-$?$' ,aj +!"' ,aj ,$-$&6P5"'
Uaj U*V$G$F5"' Ua +!.!PC"I! J*B-$C"*% *D $ +!.D7AFF!-V."%& 9*-* *B
9!C!B* E$I"C$%? E$&! `"$ 4!C$. E**B?"%$C"*% )$F!? *%
K5!B-*?G%$-"P *B U"%!C"P E*%CB*.a N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @MMO' EOP'
WZLW7WZL\a c?d J6f"C$' Aaj H!?$' ,aj +$C*' +aj 4"X6%*' Raj U6-$F$_$'
Kaj J6f"C$' 4a +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D K!CB$I$.!%C /*.?V!B& ]*.G5!?B$ DB*-
WYY +-$.. E*-@*%!%CFa G,+13* @M2O' MUT' ZML7ZMMa
cbd c$d 4*6.C*%' )aj :$>*B*C_*' 4a 2a JB*- 4*.!P6.!F C* EBGFC$.
Q%&"%!!B"%&r~ +6@B$-*.!P6.$B [F*-!B"F- $%? ]*.G-*B@5"F- "%
R!C>*B_ +*."?Fa HI*)@ %*J@ @MM2' ETE' WMN\7WMZba cVd :5$%&' 2a7]aj
96$%&' 1a7Eaj E5!%' 1a74a +6@B$-*.!P6.$B [F*-!B"F- "% E**B?"%$C"*%
]*.G-!BFa HI*)@ '.4@ %*J@ @MML' KP' NLbZ7NL\Ma cPd U$B-$_$B' Aaj
]$6.' Aaj ]*-V!"B*' Aa 2a a k!P!%C A?I$%P!F *% +6@B$-*.!P6.$B
[F*-!B"F- "% 4!C$. ^B&$%"P JB$-!>*B_Fa H390+!:;H.)) @M2N' EF'
YMMM7YM\Za
c\d c$d E5$_B$V$BCG' kaj 46_5!Bf!!' ]a +aj +C$%&' ]a 2a
+6@B$-*.!P6.$B E**B?"%$C"*%r +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D J"%"C! K>*7 $%?
K5B!!7A"-!%F"*%$. Q%F!-V.!Fa HI*)@ %*J@ @M22' EEE' MbWO7M\Wba cVd
"6' ,aj 96' Eaj E*-*CC"' Aaj #$B?' 4a Aa +6@B$-*.!P6.$B
ABP5"-!?!$% E$&!F AFF!-V.!? >"C5 TN 9G?B*&!% )*%?Fa '46*:4*
@M22' KKK' YLM7YYOa cPd AG-!' 2a7Jaj )!I!F' 2a Qaj E$-@V!..' Ea 2aj
!"&5' Aa Aa K!-@.$C! +G%C5!F"F *D 4*.!P6.$B U%*CFa HI*)@ '.4@ %*J@
@M2B' UO' WTOO7WTWNa
A73A>EF?@G*?A5
K5"F B!F!$BP5 >$F F6@@*BC!? VG R$C"*%$. [%FC"C6C!F *D 9!$.C5
ckOW/4WNbOLTda HF! *D C5! E!%C!B D*B R$%*FP$.! 4$C!B"$.F' $%
^DD"P! *D +P"!%P! 6F!B D$P"."CG' >$F F6@@*BC!? VG C5! Ha+a
A!@$BC-!%C *D Q%!B&G' ^DD"P! *D +P"!%P!' ^DD"P! *D )$F"P Q%!B&G
+P"!%P!F' 6%?!B E*%CB$PC R*a AQ7AEON7OME9WWLZTa K5! $6C5*BF
C5$%_ ABa QC5$% Aa 9".. cH%"I!BF"CG *D E5"P$&*d D*B C5! P*--!%CF
$%? F6&&!FC"*%Fa
C?D?C?A7?
cWda c$d ]5".@' Aaj +C*??$BC' 2a Ja +!.D7AFF!-V.G "% ^B&$%"P
+G%C5!F"Fa '9:-*++ 2LL2' EFFE' YYZ7YZba cVd A$I"F' Aa `aj ,!5' ka 4aj
k$G-*%?' Ua Ra +6@B$-*.!P6.$B AFF!-V.G AG%$-"PFa A3.4@ G,+-@
A4,<@ '46@ D@ '@ A@ @MM@' \\' YT\LxYT\Ma cPd !5%' 2a74a JB*-
+6@B$-*.!P6.$B E5!-"FCBG K*>$B?F E*%FC"C6C"*%$. AG%$-"P
E5!-"FCBG $%? A?$@C"I! E5!-"FCBGa HI*)@ '.4@ %*J@ @MMN' KL'
WZWxWMOa
cNd c$d 4PE*%%!..' Aa 2aj #**?' Ea +aj R!!.$_$%?$%' ]a ]aj R"CFP5_!'
2a ka +C"-6."7k!F@*%F"I! 4!C$.p "&$%? AFF!-V."!Fa HI*)@ %*J@ @M2D'
EEM' TTN\7TT\La cVd "6' aj G6' /aj "6' Eaj 2"$%&' Jaj ,6$%' Aaj +6%'
8aj :5*6' Uaj E5!%' 8aj 9*%&' 4a E*%CB*..$V.! k!$FF!-V.G *D $
AG%$-"P 4!C$..*P$&!r JB*- K5!B-*?G%$-"P E*%CB*. C* U"%!C"P
E*%CB*.a HI*)@ !13@ N@ @M2N' OK' YZM7YMWa
cLd c$d 9$F!%_%*@D' )aj !5%' 2a74aj )*6-!?"!%!' Raj A6@*%C7
/!BI$"F' Aaj `$% A*BFF!.$!B' Aaj U%!"F!.' )aj J!%F_!' Aa +!.D7
AFF!-V.G *D K!CB$7 $%? 9!S$%6P.!$B E"BP6.$B 9!."P$C!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@
'.4@ 2LLN' EEF' WO\ZM7WO\MNa cVd +C!@5!%F*%' Aaj AB&!%C' +a ]aj k""F7
2*5$%%!FF!%' Kaj K"?-$BF5' [a +aj #$B?' 4a Aa +CB6PC6B!F $%? AG%$-"P
)!5$I"*B *D $B&! ]*.G5!?B$. E**B?"%$C"*% E$&!Fr A% H%6F6$. E$&!7
C*7E$&! [%C!BP*%I!BF"*%a N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M22' EKK' bZb7bTOa cPd
)*.."&!B' 2a aj k*%F*%' Ka Uaj ^&$>$' 4aj R"CFP5_!' 2a ka +*.I!%C
QDD!PCF H@*% /6!FC )"%?"%& $%? AG%$-"PF *D $ J![[ E$&!a N@ A)@
HI*)@ '.4@ @M2C' EKL' WYZYZ7WYZZLa c?d 1"!' Ka7:aj Q%?B!F' Ua 2aj /6*'
:aj 6?.*>' 2a 4aj 4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj +$6%?!BF' 4a 2aj #!F?!-"*C"F'
Eaj R!>_*-!' /a ka E*%CB*..!? [%C!BP*%I!BF"*% *D +6@!B@*F!?7
)"FCB"$%&.!' ^PC$5!?B*%' $%? E6V*PC$5!?B*% E$&!F E*%FCB6PC!? HF"%&
$ +"%&.!' K!B@GB"?"%G.7)$F!? ]*.G."&$%? $%? :%Nna N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@
@M2O' EKP' WNLYY7WNLYTa c!d :5$%&' Kaj :5*6' a7]aj /6*' 1a78aj E$"'
a71aj +6%' 8a7Ja A?$@C"I! +!.D7AFF!-V.G $%? [%?6P!?7J"C
KB$%FD*B-$C"*%F *D A%"*%7)"%?"%& 4!C$.7^B&$%"P 4$PB*PGP.!Fa G,+@
H.))1:@ @M2N' P' WZb\b7WZ\OMa cDd #$%&' aj :5$%&' :aj 2"$%&' 1aj
[BI"%' 2a Aaj "6' Eaj #$%&' 4aj "' 1a +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D K!CB$-!B"P $%?
9!S$-!B"P K!B@GB"?"%!7)$F!? 4$PB*PGP.!F HF"%& E?c[[d' :%c[[d' $%?
J!c[[da Q:.3;@ HI*)a @M2P' MR' LZYb7LZZba
Y
Y
cWOd c$d +P56.CX' Aaj "' 1aj )$B_$_$CG' )aj 4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj
#!F?!-"*C"F' Eaj R!>_*-!' /a ka +C*"P5"*-!CB"P +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D
[F*-!B"P' +5$@!7]!BF"FC!%C' +6@B$-$PB*-*.!P6.$B )*>C"! $%?
)6CC!BD.G +CB6PC6B!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M2@' EKU' TMTN7TMTZa cVd ,6'
9a72aj "6' :a74aj ,"%' +a7,aj #6' Uaj #!"' :a7#aj ]$%' 4a E$&!7
^@!%"%& +6@B$-*.!P6.$B [F*-!B"F- "% E6c[[d E*-@.!S!Fa Q:.3;@
HI*)@ H.))1:@ @M2N' PL' NNL7NNMa cPd +$-$%CB$G' +aj )$%?"' +aj
E5$%?' Aa Ua A!F"&% *D $ A*6V.!7A!P_!B E**B?"%$C"*% E$&! k!I"F"C!?
C* 4$_! R!> E$&!F $%? QS!-@."DG "&$%? [F*-!B"F-a V*6-0+*6: N@
$3;@ HI*)@ @M2L' EM' WWN\7WWYOa
cYd c$d 9$F!%_%*@D' )aj !5%' 2a74aj U%!"F!.' )a ^aj )$6-' /aj
J!%F_!' Aa +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D $ E"BP6.$B A*6V.! 9!."P$C!a A:;*S@
HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ !:;-@ 2LLO' KM' WbLb7WbYOa cVd !"%"%&!B' +aj J$%' 2aj
+P5-"CX' 4aj +C$%&' ]a 2a ABP5"-!?!$% +*."?Fr KB$%F"C"*% 4!C$.
cWWd c$d :5$*' aj R*BC5B*@' )a 9aj :5!%&' ,a7kaj ,$%&' 9a7)aj !!'
9a 2aj !!' ,a 4aj ]$B_' 2a ,aj E5"' Ua7#aj +C$%&' ]a 2a +!.D7+!.!PC"*% "%
C5! +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D [F*-!B"P +6@B$-*.!P6.$B +l6$B!F DB*-
H%FG--!CB"P$. )"FcY7]GB"?G.dAP!CG.!%! "&$%?Fa N@ $3;@ HI*)@ @MMP'
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 8 of 10
RK' MZbO7MZbMa cVd +*%&' )aj U$%?$@$.' +aj /6' 2aj :5$%&' Uaj k!!F!'
+6@B$-*.!P6.!F HF"%& K!B@GB"?"%! $%? ]GBG."6- +$.CFa N@ A)@ HI*)@
Aaj ,"%&' ,aj #$%&' aj #$%&' 9aj "' ,aj #$%&' 4aj 6' +aj 9$*' 1a7
8aj "' 1aj 16' )aj "' 1a +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D ]*.GPGP."P +6@B$-*.!P6.!F
HF"%& "%!$B 4!C$.7^B&$%"P "&$%?Fa G,+@ H.))1:@ @M2P' F' YZTZa cPd
!>"F' 2a Qa 4aj K$BX"$' Aaj #5"C!' Aa 2a ]aj 2!.DF' Ua Qa E*%D*B-$C"*%$.
E*%CB*. *D ]?N Y AFF!-V."!F >"C5 H%FG--!CB"P$. "&$%?Fa HI*)@ '46@
@M@M' EE' MTT7MbLa
cWNd c$d #6' 9a7)aj #$%&' 8a74a E*%FCB6PC"*% *D 9!C!B*-!C$.."P
E$&!F >"C5 KB"@*?$. 4!C$..*."&$%?Fa A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @MML' UP'
TLYL7TLYZa cVd 4!%&' #aj )B!"%!B' )aj k"FF$%!%' Uaj K5*V6B%' 2a Aaj
E.!&&' 2a Uaj R"CFP5_!' 2a ka A +!.D7AFF!-V.!? 4b M E6V"P E$&! K5$C
+!.!PC"I!.G Q%P$@F6.$C!F $B&! AB*-$C"P /6!FCFa A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@
!<@ @M22' MT' LYT\7LYbLa cPd :5*6' 1a7]aj "6' 2aj :5$%' +a7:aj ,$%&'
2a7kaj "' Aaj R&' Ua74aj +6%' ka #a7,aj E5!' Ea74a A 9"&57+G--!CBG
E**B?"%$C"*% E$&! DB*- Lb7 *B MN7E*-@*%!%C +!.D7AFF!-V.Ga N@ A)@
HI*)@ '.4@ @M2@' EKU' bOYN7bOYZa
'.4@ @M2L' EUE' WLWbT7WLW\Za cVd :5$%&' ,aj E$.6@"C$%' 2a ]aj k*f$F'
Kaj K6-V.!F*%' kaj QBV.$%?' /aj U$--!B!B' Eaj Af$G"' Ka 4aj #$%&'
+aj E6BC"FF' a Aaj R&*' Aa Kaj H..*$' +a Qaj k$@!%%!' /aj 9.$' +a #a A
E5"B$. 4*.!P6.$B ]B*@!..!B A!F"&%!? D*B H%"?"B!PC"*%$. k*C$C"*%F *% $
+6BD$P!a G,+@ H.))1:@ @M2L' ET' LTYN7LTZWa
cW\d c$d J!!%FCB$' ka 4a +P$%%"%& K6%%!."%& +@!PCB*FP*@Ga '137@ '46@
2LLC' OFF/KTT' \MZ7\T\a cVd 16!' ,aj A$CC$' +aj 9*%&' +aj k!"D!%V!B&!B'
kaj 9!%?!BF*%' 2a [aj U6V"$_' Ea ]a R!&$C"I! A"DD!B!%C"$. k!F"FC$%P! "%
C5! +P$%%"%&7K6%%!."%& +@!PCB*FP*@G *D ^B&$%"P 4*.!P6.!Fa AI90@
%*J@ V@ 2LLL' MF' kTbZN7kTbZZa cPd `!%!-$' a Eaj 2$%FF!%' 2a #aj
)6"C!.$$B' 4a kaj #".?É!B' 2a #a /aj !-$G' +a /aj U*6>!%5*I!%' a
]aj A!__!B' Ea +@$C"$..G k!F*.I!? +P$%%"%& K6%%!."%& +@!PCB*FP*@G
*% +"%&.!7#$..!? E$BV*% R$%*C6V!Fa AI90@ %*J@ V@ @MMM' LO' ZNLb7
ZNYYa c?d "' :aj "' ,aj :5$*' ,aj #$%&' 9aj :5$%&' ,aj +*%&' )aj "'
1aj 6' +aj 9$*' 1a78aj 9.$' +a7#aj K6' ,aj "' 1a +G%C5!F"F *D
4!C$..*@*.G-!BF $%? A"B!PC `"F6$."X$C"*% *D C5! +"%&.! ]*.G-!B
E5$"%a N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M@M' EUO' MW\M7MNOZa
cNOd c$d +*%&' )aj U$%?$@$.' +aj /6' 2aj :5$%&' Uaj k!!F!' Aaj ,"%&'
,aj #$%&' aj #$%&' 9aj "' ,aj #$%&' 4aj 6' +aj 9$*' 1a78aj "' 1aj
16' )aj "' 1a +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D ]*.GPGP."P +6@B$-*.!P6.!F HF"%&
"%!$B 4!C$.7^B&$%"P "&$%?Fa G,+@ H.))1:@ @M2P' F' YZTZ7YZbYa cVd
#$%&' aj "6' kaj /6' 2aj +*%&' )aj #$%&' 9aj 2"$%&' 1aj :5$%&' Uaj
9$%' 1aj 9$*' 1a78aj )$"' +aj #$%&' 4aj "' 1aj 16' )aj "' 1a +!.D7
AFF!-V.G *D +6@B$-*.!P6.$B JB$PC$.F DB*- /!%!B$C"*% W C* Za N@ A)@
HI*)@ '.4@ @M2P' EUT' WYObT7WYO\Ma
cNWd c$d `$"?G$%$C5$%' `$"?G$%$C5$% /aj R$"B' )$.$P5$%?B$% Ha
R6P.!*V$F! ^S"?$C"*% *D ARA VG cK!B@GB"?G.dE5B*-"6-c[[[d
A!B"I$C"I!Fa !13@ N@ Q:.3;@ HI*)@ @MMC' OTTU' WbYO7WbYMa cVd :$B!' Aaj
A*"FC$6' )aj R*X$BG' 9aj )!F%$B?' Eaj /6Ñ%Ñ!' aj +6DDB!%' ,aj ]!.Ñ' Aa7
aj 9$6F!B' Aaj ]"&6!C' Ea EB[[[ $F $% A.C!B%$C"I! C* k6[[ "% 4!C$..*7
+6@B$-*.!P6.$B E5!-"FCBGa &,-+.:@ B3,:0@ @M2N' UL' b\\N7\OO\a
cNNd c$d E5*>' 9a +aj E*%FC$V.!' Qa Eaj 9*6F!PB*DC' Ea Qaj U6."P_!'
Ua 2aj K$*' ,a #5!% Q.!PCB*% QSP5$%&! [F E5!-"P$. QSP5$%&!p
AFF"&%-!%C *D W9 R4k +@!PCB$ *D ]$B$-$&%!C"P E*V$.Cc[[d7N'NorMo'NÇ7
K!B@GB"?"%! E*-@.!S!Fa &,-+.:@ B3,:0@ @MMD' O' NLM7NLTa cVd
E*%FC$V.!' Qa Eaj 9$BB"F' Uaj 9*6F!PB*DC' Ea Qaj R!6V6B&!B' 4aj
:$-@!F!' 2a Aa K6B%"%& Ö4cK@GdNÜRn Q-VB$P!F $%? E97Å
[%C!B$PC"*%F *% $%? ^DD "% 9*-*.!@C"P E*V$.Cc[[d $%? E*V$.Cc[[[d
)"FcN'NorMo'NÇ7K!B@GB"?"%!d E*-@.!S!Fa H390+!:;H.))@ @M2M' EO'
N\Y\7N\MWa
cNLd c$d J"!.?' 4a 2aj 4$G' )a aj E.!-!%CF' ]aj KF$%$_CF"?"F' 2aj
Q$FC*%' Ea 2aj "%P*.%' +a Ja [%CB$-*.!P6.$B E*-@.!S$C"*% "% 4*?"D"!?
á7EGP.*?!SCB"%Fr A ]B!@$B$C"I!' R6P.!$B 4$&%!C"P k!F*%$%P! $%? ]5
K"CB$C"*% +C6?Ga N@ HI*)@ '.4@5 A*3W6: B3,:0@E @MMM' T' WNZW7WNZba cVd
]"&6!C' Ea J"I! K5!B-*?G%$-"P A!FPB"V!BF D*B A??B!FF"%& +!B!%?"@"CG
"% C5! +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D ]*.G%6P.!$B E*-@.!S!F "% +*.6C"*%a HI*)@
H.))1:@ @M2M' UL' MNO\7MNLWa cPd [5$B$' Kaj ^56B$' 9aj +5"B$5$-$' Eaj
J6B6X*%*' Kaj +5"-$?$' 9aj 4$CF66B$' 9aj U"C$-6B$' ,a 4!C$. [*%7
A"B!PC!? AG%$-"P +@."P"%& *D ARA C5B*6&5 /.*V$. E*%D*B-$C"*%$.
E5$%&! VG [%CB$-*.!P6.$B E*-@.!S$C"*%a G,+@ H.))1:@ @M2D' L'
MMYO7MMYba
cNYd c$d 2!%%"%&F' ]aj #B"&5C' ]a J*B-$C"*% *D $ 4*.C!% /.*V6.!
[%C!B-!?"$C! Q$B.G "% C5! U"%!C"P J*.?"%& ]$C5>$G *D A@*-G*&.*V"%a
'46*:4* 2LLB' OLO' b\N7b\Ma cVd A*VF*%' Ea 4aj à$."' Aaj U$B@.6F' 4a
]B*C!"% J*.?"%&r A ]!BF@!PC"I! DB*- K5!*BG $%? QS@!B"-!%Ca A:;*S@
HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ 2LLP' KR' bMb7b\La cPd :5$%&' 4aj AVB$-F' Eaj #$%&'
aj /"XX"' Aaj 9!' aj "%' kaj E5!%' ,aj *..' ]$CB"P_ 2aj ]$FP$.'
2*5% 4aj :5$%&' 2a7Da +CB6PC6B$. )$F"F D*B E$.-*?6."% $F $ AG%$-"P
E$.P"6- +!%F*Ba '+314+13*' @M2@' OT' \WW7\NLa
cNZd c$d R!>_*-!' /a kaj #$%&' ]aj 4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj E5*' Ka 2aj
4*5$@$CB$' ]a ]aj "' +aj 9>$%&' +a79aj 6_*G$%*I$' ^aj QP5!&*G!%'
aj ]$.$&$..*' 2a Aaj [$%P6' `aj 9.$' +a7#a R$%*$FF!-V.G *D $ JB$PC$.
]*.G-!Br A 4*.!P6.$B â+"!B@"%F_" 9!S$&*%$. /$F_!Câa '46*:4* @MMO'
KEO' WTbN7WTbZa cVd2"$%&' :aj "' ,aj #$%&' 4aj "6' Aaj ,6$%' 2aj
E5!%' 4aj #$%&' 2aj R!>_*-!' /a kaj +6%' #aj "' 1aj #$%&' ]a
E*%FCB6PC"%& 9"&57/!%!B$C"*% +"!B@"äF_" KB"$%&.!F VG 4*.!P6.$B
]6XX."%&a A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @M2N' ML' WWYZO7WWYZZa cPd #$%&' aj
+*%&' )aj U5$."D!' +aj "' ,aj 4"%&' a72aj )$"' +aj 16' ,aj ,6' 9aj #$%&'
4aj #$%&' 9aj "' 1a [%CB*?6P"%& +!I!% KB$%F"C"*% 4!C$. [*%F "%C*
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
cWLd c$d +5"I$%G6_' Aaj k!V!_' 2a +*P"$. [F*-!BF "% Q%P$@F6.$C"*%
E*-@.!S!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @MM@' EOU' WNOTY7WNOTZa cVd
U*V$G$F5"' Uaj [F5""' Uaj +$_$-*C*' +aj +5"B$F$_$' Kaj ,$-$&6P5"' Ua
/6!FC7[%?6P!? AFF!-V.G *D K!CB$P$BV*SG.7E$I"C$%? $%? K!CB$cL7
]GB"?G.d7E$I"C$%? "%C* $ 9!C!B*?"-!B"P E$@F6.! `"$ 9G?B*&!% )*%?F
6
$%? E9x9$.*&!% $%?e*B E9x [%C!B$PC"*%r~ E*%CB*. *D C5! ^B"!%C$C"*%
*D C5! Q%P$@F6.$C!? /6!FCa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @MMB' EOM' WOMWZ7WOMNYa
cPd +5"I$%G6_' Aaj k!V!_' 2a' [F*-!B"P E*%FC!..$C"*%F *D Q%P$@F6.$C"*%
E*-@.!S!F +C*B! [%D*B-$C"*% *% C5! R$%*-!C!B +P$.!a A%&!>a E5!-a
[%Ca Q?a @MMB' UO' MbY7MbMa c?d ,$-$%$_$' 4aj +5"I$%G6_' Aaj k!V!_'
2a +C!B!*P5!-"FCBG "% +!.D7AFF!-V.!? Q%P$@F6.$C"*% E*-@.!S!Fr
E*%FC!..$C"*%$. [F*-!B"F-a A3.4@ G,+-@ A4,<@ '46@ D@'@A@ @MMC' ETE'
NMM\7NMTNa c!d Af$-"' Aaj K5!*?*B$_*@*6.*F' /aj ]!CF$.$_"F' [a Aaj
k!V!_ 2Ba' 2a +*P"$. [F*-!BF *D ]"P*."%!F "% $ +-$.. +@$P!a HI*)@ !13@
N@ @M2B' EF' WTO\N7WTO\Ma
cWYd c$d AV*6B$5-$' 9aj 4*6.C*%' )aj UB$ICF*I' `aj :$>*B*C_*' 4a
2a +6@B$-*.!P6.$B [F*-!B"F- "% E**B?"%$C"*% E*-@*6%?Fr~ R$%*FP$.!
4*.!P6.$B 9!S$&*%F $%? E5$"%Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @MM@' EOU' \\\O7
\\\Wa cVd ?6 ].!FF"F' 4aj )$BV*6B' a 2a +6@B$-*.!P6.$B [F*-!B"F- $%?
+*.I$C*-*B@5"F- "% $ R*I!. E**B?"%$C"*% E*-@*6%?a &,-+.:@ B3,:0@
@M2@' UE' Lb\Z7Lb\ba
cWZd c$d K"--!B-$%' ]aj `!BV**-' #aj I$% `!&&!.' Ja Ea 2a 4aj I$%
A6G%5*I!%' 2a ]a 4aj k!"%5*6?C' Aa Ra
A R*I!. KG@! *D
+C!B!*"F*-!B"F- "% E$."SwYyAB!%!7)$F!? E$BP!@.!S!Fa A%&!>a E5!-a
[%Ca Q?a Q%&.a 2LLC' KK' NLYZ7NLYba cVd K6PP"' Ja Eaj k6?_!I"P5' Aa 4aj
k!V!_' 2a +C!B!*P5!-"P$. k!.$C"*%F5"@F V!C>!!% Q%P$@F6.$C!?
4*.!P6.!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ 2LLL' EOE' Y\Nb7Y\N\a cPd U*V$G$F5"'
Uaj [F5""' Uaj ,$-$%$_$' 4a ^B"!%C$C"*%$. [F*-!B"F- $%? )"%?"%&
AV"."CG *D R*%FG--!CB"P$. /6!FCF Q%P$@F6.$C!? "% $ +!.D7AFF!-V."%&
9!C!B*?"-!B"P E$@F6.!a HI*)@ !13@ N@ @MMD' EE' YTNZ7YTLYa
cWMd KF6X6_"' +aj HP5"-$B6' Kaj 4"_$-"' 4aj U"C$&$>$' 9aj
U*V$G$F5"' Ua 4!P5$%"F- *D ^B"!%C$C"*%$. [F*-!B"F- *D
H%FG--!CB"P$. /6!FCF "% $ 9!C!B*?"-!B"P E$@F6.!r A%$.GF"F VG AV
[%"C"* 4*.!P6.$B ^BV"C$. E$.P6.$C"*%Fa N@ AI90@ HI*) V@ @M2M' EEU'
ZLLZ7ZLYWa
cWTd c$d #".?' Aaj #"%C!B' Aaj +P5.ÄCC!B' Jaj +P56V!BC' Ha +a
A?I$%P!F "% C5! J"!.? *D Å7E*%f6&$C!? N'NorMo'NÇ7K!B@GB"?"%!Fa HI*)@
'.4@ %*J@ @M22' UT' WYZ\7WZWWa cVd E5$_B$V*BCG' +aj R!>_*-!' /a ka
K!B@GB"?"%!7)$F!? 4!C$..*F6@B$-*.!P6.$B E*%FCB6PCFr K$".*B!?
4*%*-!BF C* ]B!P"F! N?74*C"DF $%? L?74!C$..*P$&!Fa HI*)@ '.4@ %*J@
@M2P' UR' L\\W7YOWMa cPd J6' 2a79aj !!' ,a79aj 9!' ,a72aj E5$%' ,a7Ka
J$P".! +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D 4!C$..*7+6@B$-*.!P6.$B k"%&7"%7k"%& $%?
+@"?!B>!V +CB6PC6B!F HF"%& 46.C"I$.!%C K!B@GB"?"%! "&$%?Fa A:;*S@
HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @M2D' MU' MNLW7MNLZa c?d #$%&' +a7,aj J6' 2a79aj "$%&'
,a7]aj 9!' ,a72aj E5!%' ,a7+aj E5$%' ,a7Ka 4!C$..*7+6@B$-*.!P6.$B
+!.D7AFF!-V.G *D
$
46.C"P*-@*%!%C A"CB"&*% )$F!? *%
E*-@.!-!%C$BG K!B@GB"?"%! "&$%? ]$"B"%&a N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M2O'
EKP' LMZW7LMZYa c!d :5$%&' :aj #$%&' 9aj #$%&' 1aj "' ,aj +*%&' )aj
)*.$B"%>$' ^aj k!!F!' ka Aaj :5$%&' Kaj #$%&' 1a78aj E$"' 2aj 16' )aj
#$%&' 4aj "6' Eaj ,$%&' 9a7)aj "' 1a +6@!BF%*>D.$_!Fr +C!@>"F!
+!.D7AFF!-V.G $%? AG%$-"P QSP5$%&! *D k5*-V6F +C$B7+5$@!?
+6@B$-*.!P6.!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M2N' EKF' bWTY7bWbZa
cWbd c$d #$%&' 9aj "' ,aj ,6' 9aj +*%&' )aj 6' +aj 9$*' 1a78aj
:5$%&' ,aj #$%&' 4aj 9.$' +a7#aj "' 1a E*-V"%"%& +G%C5!F"F $%?
+!.D7AFF!-V.G "% ^%! ]*C C* E*%FCB6PC E*-@.!S N? 4!C$..*7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Page 9 of 10
Journal of the American Chemical Society
K!B@GB"?"%!7)$F!? +6@B$-*.!P6.!Fr +!.D7AFF!-V.G $%? AG%$-"P
*% A$-$&! KB$%F"C"*% "% :!*."C!F 6%?!B Q.!PCB*% )!$- [BB$?"$C"*%a
AI90@ %*J@ V@ @M22' PK' WWLYOba cVd +6F"' Kaj U*C$_*F_"' 2aj AB!%$.' kaj
U6B$FP5' +aj 2"$%&' 9aj +_$_$.*I$' `aj +C!@5$%' ^aj UB$F5!%"%%"_*I' Aa
`aj U$6@@"%!%' Qa [aj U$"F!B' Haj 4!G!B' 2a Ea AC*-"FC"P A!FPB"@C"*% *D
Q.!PCB*% )!$- A$-$&! "% R"CB*&!%7A*@!? /B$@5!%! $%? +"%&.!7
#$..!? E$BV*% R$%*C6V!Fa AH' G,:. @M2@' L' bbLT7bbYMa cPd Q&!BC*%'
ka Ja 4!P5$%"F-F *D k$?"$C"*% A$-$&! "% )!$-7+!%F"C"I! +@!P"-!%F'
D*B K!- APP!.!B$C"%& `*.C$&!F V!C>!!% WO $%? LOO UIa X643.04@ %*0@
B*4I@ @M2@' RM' WZZO7WZZMa
"&$%? QSP5$%&! +C6?Ga N@ A)@ HI*)@ '.4@ @M@M' EUO' WbWW7WbNWa
cNMd c$d 9*$&.6%?79GX!B' Ea +aj E*6%C!B-$%' Aa Qaj E.!--!B' Aa Qa
A%5G?B*6F ]B*C!"% [*%Fa HI*)@ %*J@ 2LLL' FF' LOLT7LObOa cVd UB6I!'
Aaj E$@B"P!' Uaj $I!%?*--!' kaj #*..FP5.ã&!B' 2a 4aj +P5*?!B' +aj
+P5BÉ?!B' 9a `aj R"CFP5_!' 2a kaj E*6&%*%' Ja )a aj +P5$..!G' Ea Aa
[*%74*V"."CG 4$FF +@!PCB*-!CBG D*B C5! k$@"? A!C!B-"%$C"*% *D C5!
K*@*.*&G *D [%C!B.*P_!? $%? U%*CC!? 4*.!P6.!Fa A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@
!<@ @M2L' MP' WWLNY7WWLNba
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
cNTd c$d "' 1aj E5$%' ,a7Kaj R!>_*-!' /a kaj #!F?!-"*C"F' Ea
/B$?"!%C K$%?!- 4$FF +@!PCB*-!CBG [%C!BD$P!? >"C5 [*% 4*V"."CG
+!@$B$C"*% D*B C5! E5$B$PC!B"X$C"*% *D +6@B$-*.!P6.$B ABP5"C!PC6B!Fa
A:,-@ HI*)@ @M22' PK' WNbY7WN\Oa cVd +*%&' )aj :5$%&' :aj #$%&' Uaj
9F6' Ea79aj )*.$B"%>$' ^aj #$%&' 2aj "' ,aj ,"%' /a78aj k"I!B$' Qaj
,$%&' 9a7)aj "6' Eaj 16' )aj "' 1a A"B!PC +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D $ NA $%?
LA +C$B *D A$I"?a A:;*S@ HI*)@ Q:+@ !<@ @M2N' ML' ZNZb7ZNMNa
cNbd c$d 6?.*> [[[' 2a 4aj /6*' :aj +P56.CX' Aaj +$B_$B' kaj
4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj #!F?!-"*C"F' Eaj R!>_*-!' /a ka /B*6@ b
4!C$..*-$PB*PGP.!F p +G%C5!F"F' E5$B$PC!B"X$C"*%' $%? +C$V"."CGa !13@
N@ Q:.3;@ HI*)@ @M2D' OTEM' ZMMN7ZMMba cVd E5$_B$V*BCG' +aj 9*%&' #aj
Q%?B!F' Ua 2aj 1"!' Ka7:aj #*fC$F' aj 4**B!D"!.?' Ea Raj #!F?!-"*C"F'
Eaj R!>_*-!' /a ka K!B@GB"?"%!7)$F!?' J.!S"V.! KB"@*?Fr JB*- $
9"&5.G +G--!CB"P R$%*F@5!B! C* K!-@!B$C6B!7A!@!%?!%C'
[BB!I!BF"V.!' LA [F*-!B"P 4$PB*-*.!P6.$B R$%*P$&!Fa N@ A)@ HI*)@
'.4@ @M2N' WL\' LOWN7LONOa
cLOd c$d A! J!GC!B' +aj A! +P5BGI!B' Ja Ea K>*7A"-!%F"*%$.
+6@B$-*.!P6.$B +!.D7AFF!-V.G ]B*V!? VG +P$%%"%& K6%%!."%&
4"PB*FP*@Ga HI*)@ '.4@ %*J@ @MMB' KO' WL\7WZOa cVd A! J!GC!B' +aj A!
+P5BGI!B' Ja Ea +!.D7AFF!-V.G $C C5! "l6"?e+*."? [%C!BD$P!r~ +C-
k!I!$.Fa N@ AI90@ HI*) V@ @MMD' ETF' YN\O7YLONa cPd +C!@$%!%_*' `aj
#ÄBC5%!B' Ja 9"!B$BP5"P$. +!.D7AFF!-V.G *D EGP."P AG! ABB$GF "%C*
K>*7A"-!%F"*%$. 9*%!GP*-V R$%*%!C>*B_Fa '),-- @MMP' U' NWZb7
NWMWa
cLWd c$d 9"B6%F"C' ]a Q.!PCB*B!?6PC"*% *D E$BV*% A"*S"?! C* 4!C5$%!
*% E*@@!B' E*@@!Bp+".I!B' $%? E*@@!Bp/*.? E$C$.GFCFr A AJK +C6?Ga
N@ AI90@ HI*)@ H@ @M2B' EER' bNMN7bNMba cVd "%' Ea7,aj :5$%&' aj
:5$*' :aj 1"$' :a A!F"&% ]B"%P"@.!F D*B E*I$.!%C ^B&$%"P JB$-!>*B_F
$F QDD"P"!%C Q.!PCB*P$C$.GFCF "% E.!$% Q%!B&G E*%I!BF"*% $%? /B!!%
^S"?"X!B ]B*?6PC"*%a A<J@ X,+*3@ @M2N' N\' WMOMMLZ7WMOMMYNa
cLNd U"%&' ka )aj +".$&5"7A6-"CB!FP6' [aj å*I$&*' [a U"%!C"P `!BF6F
K5!B-*?G%$-"P [F*-!BF *D C5! A!.C$5!?B$. E*V$.C$?"P$BV$V*B$%!Fa
Q:.3;@ HI*)@ @MML' UP' ZObb7ZO\Za
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
cN\d c$d H&6B.6' ^aj 9$6F' 2aj /6%$>$%' Aa Aaj K5*-$F' 4a /aj
4$5!F5>$B"' +aj KF$@$CF"F' 4aj 4_5*G$%' Ua Aa k$?"*.GF"F C* U%*P_7
ACS Paragon Plus Environment

Journal of the American Chemical Society
Page 10 of 10
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
ACS Paragon Plus Environment