2
J. Saxena et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. xxx (2015) xxx–xxx
A series of ortho- and para-substituted ethynylphenyl carbon-
ates (4–7) and carbamates (8–11) was synthesized from commer-
cially available phenol and aniline precursors (see Supporting
information). The carbonates were isolated via
a three-step
process, with yields ranging from 9% to 57%. The carbamates were
synthesized in a single step, resulting in 37% to 65% yields. The
identities of these novel molecules were confirmed by nuclear
magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and elemental analysis.
When screened in an Ellman assay,37 all compounds inhibited
AChE in the micromolar range, with IC50s ranging from 28 to
Figure 1. Choline p-chloromethylphenyl carbonate iodide (1),28,29 Bechet’s
chloromethyldihydrocoumarin antiprotease (2),30,31 and a generic ynenol furyl
lactone (3).35
86 lM (Table 1). Out of the series, carbamate 8 was the most
potent inhibitor and represents a promising lead for further study.
The carbamates proved to be approximately two times more
potent AChEIs than the carbonates. The mode of AChE binding of
many known carbamate AChEIs (e.g., rivastigmine, physostigmine)
involves carbamoylation of the active site serine residue followed
by restoration of the active enzyme.38 A critical hydrogen bonding
interaction between the nitrogen atom of the carbamate and the
histidine residue of the catalytic triad could therefore be responsi-
ble for the enhanced potency of the carbamates relative to the car-
bonates.38 When all other structural elements are conserved,
changing the choline mimic from a 3,3-dimethylbutyl to a 2-
(trimethylsilyl)ethyl moiety does not have a significant impact
on AChE inhibition. It is interesting to note that the para-substi-
tuted ethynyls were slightly more potent than the ortho-ethynyls
in the carbonate series, perhaps due to steric constraints in the
active site gorge of the enzyme.39
Following incubation of AChE with each inhibitor and subse-
quent gel filtration, 80–100% of enzyme activity was recovered
(Table 1). Interestingly, a higher percentage of enzyme activity
was recovered following incubation of AChE with the carbamates
(85–100%) compared to the carbonates (60–83%), with the excep-
tion of carbamate 11. This difference may be because the more
hydrophobic carbonates lead to formation of an acylated enzyme
complex which is slower to reactivate than the corresponding car-
bamylated enzyme complex.40 Slow reactivation of other lipophilic
acyl complexes of various esterases has been reported
previously.40–42
the active site of the enzyme.28,29 Considering the structural and
functional similarities between 1 and 2, it was proposed that the
AChE inactivation mechanism by 1 involves a quinone methide
intermediate.28 Unfortunately, 1 proved ineffective when screened
against fully-developed adult insects, and it was only modestly
effective against immature larvae. Furthermore, in control experi-
ments, 1 was unable to cross biological membranes and proved
unstable both in solution and in the solid state, an occurrence
traced to its chloromethyl moiety.28,29 Despite the limitations of
this molecule as a pesticide, it has served as a structural platform
for the synthesis and optimization of selective and potent AChEIs
by our group.32–34
It is well known in other mechanism-based inhibitors that a ter-
minal unsubstituted ethynyl group on an aromatic ring or on an
sp2 carbon can act as an electrophilic surrogate for a halomethyl.
For example, ynenol furyl lactones (3, Fig. 1) serve as irreversible
inhibitors of human leukocyte elastase apparently through tran-
sient formation of an electrophilic allenone.35 Considering the doc-
umented similarities in reactivity between conjugated ethynyls
and halomethyls, we chose to design a new class of ethynylphenyl
candidate inhibitors (Fig. 2).
Uncharged isosteres of choline have moderate affinities for
AChE, with inhibition constants (Ki) of 7.5 mM and 3.3 mM
reported for 3,3-dimethyl-1-butanol and 2-(trimethylsilyl)ethanol,
respectively.36 As such, many of the molecules designed by our
group, including the molecules presented herein (Fig. 2), contain
one of these moieties to provide cholinesterase recognition.32–34
Substitution of the nitrogen-based choline analog with a carbon-
or silicon-based analog may also address the inherent instability
and poor membrane permeability of carbonate 1, while maintain-
ing potent anticholinesterase activity. Furthermore, we decided to
replace the p-chloromethyl moiety of 1 with an ethynyl group
(vide infra) because the chloromethyl proved to be a source of
instability in other studies.28,29
Table 1
IC50 values, percent recoveries of AChE activities, percent reductions of TPA-induced
edema, cLogP, and PSA values for ethynylphenyl carbonates and carbamates
a
#
IC50
(
lM)
% AChE
recovery
% red.
(TPA)b
cLogPe
PSAh
(Å2)
Ethynylphenyl carbonates
Presented herein is the synthesis of a series of ethynylphenyl
carbonates and carbamates linked to lipophilic ACh mimics. Not
only do these molecules have the potential to target inflammation,
they may also dually target AD through AChE inhibition and
inflammation suppression, potentially through the cholinergic
anti-inflammatory pathway.
4
5
6
7
86
59
80
62
1
2
3
2
83
83
78
8
5
4
18
22
nd
nd
4.41
4.41
24.1
25.1
24.2
25.2
f
—
—
f
60 11
Ethynylphenyl carbamates
8
9
10
11
Tacrine
28.4
34.3
38.1
34.4
9
1
1
1
100
95
96
85
95
9
39c
nd
3.73
3.73
27.5
29.4
27.6
29.5
28.4g
3
5
5
f
Irritant
—
—
40d
f
0.058 0.005
nd
2.91g
a
IC50 values represent mean S.D. Individual experiment is performed at least in
duplicate; source of AChE is electric eel (Electrophorus electricus); enzyme was
incubated for 30 min with 52
l
M inhibitor at 25 °C.
b
nd: not determined.
c
Value differs from positive control (TPA only) based on one-way ANOVA, with P
<0.05.
d
Value differs from positive control (TPA only) based on one-way ANOVA, with P
<0.10.
e
cLogP values calculated using ChemBioDraw Ultra 14.0.
f
g
h
cLogP values could not be calculated.
Calculations performed on free base.
PSA values calculated using Spartan’14 V1.1.4.
Figure 2. Ethynylphenyl carbonates (4–7) and carbamates (8–11).