A. Dandia et al. / Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 394 (2014) 244–252
249
Table 1
Table 2
a
Comparison of catalytic activity of catalyst for the synthesis of indolo[2,3-
b]quinoxaline derivatives .
Effect of solvent on the synthesis of indolo[2,3-b]quinoxaline derivatives (3a) .
a
Entry
Solvent
Time (min)
Yield (%)*
Yield (%)*
−1
TOF (h )
Entry
Catalyst
Time (min)
1
2
3
4
5
Ethanol
10
10
10
10
10
69
54
46
74
95
1.
2.
3.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
–
60
38
36
34
30
25
10
10
28
42
44
47
56
71
95
95
–
298
330
373
504
767
2565
5415
Methanol
Acetonitrile
Water
CdSO4 (10 mol%)
CdCl2 (10 mol%)
CdNO3 (10 mol%),
Powder CdS (10 mol%)
CdS NPs (10 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (10 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Ethylene glycol
a
Reaction conditions: isatin (1 mmol), ortho-phenylenediamine (1 mmol) and
5
mol% of catalyst under microwave irradiation.
Isolated yield.
*
a
Reaction conditions: isatin (1 mmol) and ortho-phenylenediamine (1 mmol) in
ethylene glycol (5 ml) under microwave irradiation.
*
Isolated yield.
method (Table 3). The enhancement of catalytic activity in MW
might be due to the fact that nanocatalyst act as a susceptor and
absorb microwave irradiation [28], thus they can serve as an inter-
nal heat source for the reactions which enhance the overall capacity
to absorb MW in the reaction mixture and prevented the deac-
tivation of nanocatalyst during the reaction. The model reaction
was also studied by varying microwave power and temperature. It
improve the metal-time yields and also increase the reaction rate
per exposed metal site i.e., the turn over frequency.
3.6. Catalytic performance for the synthesis of
indolo[2,3-b]quinoxaline derivatives
◦
was concluded that 300 W power output at 80 C was required to
To examine the catalytic activity of nanoparticles in the chemos-
elective synthesis of indolo[2,3-b]quinoxalines, isatin (1 mmol)
and ortho-phenylenediamine (1 mmol) were chosen as model sub-
strates for the reaction in ethylene glycol (5 ml) under microwave
irradiation. A control experiment was conducted in the absence of
catalyst. The reaction was incomplete even after 60 min, though for-
mation of a small amount of 3a (28%) was observed. Thus the initial
efforts were focused on the systematic evaluation of various cata-
lyst systems. As shown in Table 1, when the reaction was carried out
in the presence of catalytic amount of CdS NPs, the desired product
accomplish maximum conversion to product. Furthermore, to take
advantage of the highly efficient green protocol, the reaction was
scaled up to 10 mmol.
In order to study the generality of this procedure, a variety of
substituted isatins were subjected to this reaction (Fig. 9). Isatins
bearing electron withdrawing groups reacted faster with slightly
improved yields as compared to the isatins having electron donat-
ing counter parts. The application of the reaction to heteroatomic
diamines has also been explored. The results suggest that, the reac-
tion proceeds well in the optimized conditions. Further, the analysis
of the final product by ICP-AES showed that there was no nanocat-
alyst present in the final product.
3
a was isolated with 71% yield. Further, the study of catalytic abil-
ity of Cu doped CdS nanoparticles showed that doping increases the
product yield up to 95% and reduces the reaction time (10 min) with
the decreased catalyst loading (5 mol%). It was found that the best
result in terms of turnover frequency (TOF) could be achieved by
using Cu doped CdS NPs catalyst (5 mol% loading). It shows that the
CdS NPs were active in reaction with a turn-over frequency (TOF)
In the reaction of isatins with 1,2-diamines, the formation
of the required indolo[2,3-b]quinoxalines is accompanied by the
occurrence of 3-imino-isatin, spirobenzimidazole, and ring-opened
quinoxalinone as side products and sometimes these products have
been isolated as the main product. The present protocol gives
indolo[2,3-b]quinoxalines selectively and exclusively. The struc-
−
1
of 767 h is observed. When the Cu doped CdS NPs were used,
−1
ture of the products 3a-k was established by IR, 1H, C NMR
13
the activity was septupled to (TOF) 5415 h . This finding indicates
that doping of Cu promotes the activity and selectivity of CdS NPs
and higher concentration of acidic sites gives more products in the
reaction. Therefore, lower catalyst loading is required for this trans-
formation compared to many other catalytic systems, thus showing
that this method is superior to the other methods in terms of yield
and reaction time.
and mass spectrometric studies. For instance, the IR spectrum of
−
1
the product 3a showed characteristic bands at 1625 cm corre-
sponding to the C N group in the cyclic ring system. In the 1
H
NMR of 3a, only one exchangeable hydrogen with chemical shift
between 11.94 and 12.21 ppm was observable. This hydrogen can
be assigned as the NH of indole moiety of the final structure along
with characteristic signals with appropriate chemical shift and cou-
pling constant for the eight protons of the two aromatic moieties.
In order to ascertain the effect of solvent, the reaction was car-
ried out using different solvents. The superiority of ethylene glycol
as a solvent as compared to commonly employed solvents is quite
evident from the results summarized in Table 2.
The model reaction was also investigated under different non-
conventional and conventional conditions and the overall findings
are given in Table 3. Under MW, the catalytic activity of Cu doped
CdS NPs was found to be 18-fold higher than the conventional
13
The C NMR spectrum of 3a demonstrated signals at ı 143.9 and
145.7 ppm due to two C N group in the tetra cyclic ring system. The
+
mass spectrum of 3a showed a molecular ion peak at 219.0 (M) . In
the IR spectrum, the disappearance of two C O of the oxindole ring
along with the appearance of a signal due to C N further proved the
formation of quinoxaline derivatives instead of other products. This
Table 3
a
Dependency of catalytic activity of catalysts under different nonconventional and conventional conditions .
◦
Yield (%)*
−1
TOF (h )
Entry
Condition
Catalyst
Temp. ( C)
Time (min.)
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Conventional
Ultrasound
Microwave
Microwave
Microwave
Microwave
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
Cu doped CdS NPs (5 mol%)
80
80
60
70
80
90
90
60
10
10
10
10
48
54
42
68
95
95
304
513
2394
3876
5415
5415
a
*
Reaction conditions: isatin (1 mmol), ortho-phenylenediamine (1 mmol) and 5 mol% of catalyst in ethylene glycol (5 ml).
Isolated yield.