Electrоchemical carboxylation of CCl4
Russ.Chem.Bull., Int.Ed., Vol. 58, No. 2, February, 2009
301
acetic acid was isolated in almost quantitative yield, m.p. being
57—58 °С. The structure was confirmed by the 13С NMR
spectrum (DMSOꢀd6, δ: 92.0 (CCl3), 164.2 (CO)).
Note that because of the low solubility of ZnBr2 in МеCN
the contribution of steps с and d presented in Scheme 2 is
insignificant and only addition of more soluble ZnCl2
assist a deeper chemical reduction of zinc trichloroacetate
(cf. entries 3 and 4, Table 3).
Thus, the regularities of ССl4 electrocarboxylation preꢀ
sented is Scheme 2 allow one to describe the mechanism
of this process at the qualitative level. It is quite possible
that the real process of ССl4 electrocarboxylation is more
complicated. However, we succeeded to reveal its key
steps. The obtained conclusions are valid regardless
of whether the primary electrocarboxylation product is
(Cl3CCOO)2Zn or Cl3CCOOZnСl.
Synthesis of zinc dichloroacetate was carried out according
to a similar (see above) procedure using ZnO (8.14 g, 0.1 mol)
and dichloroacetic acid (28.37 g, 0.22 mol). After evaporation
the mother liquor was a thick viscous syrup from which the
crystalline salt (31.18 g, 97% based on ZnO) was obtained after
drying (8 h, 2 Torr, 50 °С). Found (%): C, 14.99; Cl, 44.41; Zn,
20.25; H, 0.66 (average of two determinations). C4H2Cl4O4Zn.
Calculated (%): C, 14.935; Cl, 44.183; Zn, 20.346; H, 0.622.
13С NMR (DMSOꢀd6), δ: 67.53 (CHCl2), 168.31 (CO).
The following data finally convince that the zinc dichloroꢀ
acetate was obtained (the elemental analysis results give some
error on Zn determination): after the salt obtained it was acidified
with concentrated HCl followed by extraction with ether and
evaporation, dichloroacetic acid was isolated, whose structure
was confirmed by the 13С NMR spectrum (DMSOꢀd6, δ: 66.3
(CHCl2), 167.3 (CO)).
Testing of the stability of zinc triꢀ and dichloroacetates in
DMF and MeCN. A weighed sample (0.005 mol) of Zn trichloroꢀ
acetate (1.95 g) or Zn dichloroacetate (1.61 g) was placed in the
corresponding solvent (40 mL), the mixture was stirred at room
temperature for certain time (1 or 4 h), and then the solvent was
distilled off at reduced pressure, and the resulting residue
was weighed. The results obtained are given in Table 1.
Experimental
Electrolysis was carried out in an undivided cell equipped
with a thermometer, a magnetic stirrer, a cooling jacket, and a
device for СО2 bubbling including the system of its drying over
H2SO4 followed by purification from acid traces. In addition,
СО2 flow was passed through a vessel with CCl4 before its inlet
into the electrochemical cell. As it was shown by special test,
this made it possible to avoid CCl4 losses due to blowing out
when СО2 bubbling during electrolysis.
Electrocarboxylation of CCl4 in DMF. Experiments on
electrocarboxylation in DMF are given in Tables 2 and 3 for
comparison. These procedures, as well as procedures for product
isolation, have earlier been described1 in detail and remained
almost unchanged when MeCN was used as the solvent.
Electrocarboxylation of CCl4 in MeCN (general procedure
using entry 5 (Table 4) as an example). A 0.2 М solution
(100 mL) of Bu4NBr in MeCN and CCl4 (23.0 g, 0.15 mol) were
placed in the cell, and this solution was saturated with CO2 for
10 min. Then, continuing CO2 bubbling, electrolysis with the
current I = 0.6 A was carried out at Т = 20 °C. In some
experiments, additives were introduced to the electrolyte, for
example, ZnCl2 (2.0 g, 0.015 mol) (entry 4, Table 3). After
6900 C charge (23.8% Q) was passed, the electrolysis was
stopped, the electrodes were dried and weighed, and MeCN
was distilled off from the electrolyte in a water bath at reduced
pressure. After MeCN was removed, a solid residue containing
chloroacetates, which were transformed into methyl esters of
the corresponding chloroacetic acids for identification, was
formed.
Methyl esters of (poly)chloroacetic acids (exemplified by
entry 5, Table 4). After MeCN was distilled off, the solid residue
was dissolved in MeOH (25 mL) and treated with a solution
of H2SO4 in MeОН (8 mL of concentrated H2SO4 in 50 mL of
MeОН) with stirring. The mixture was stored at room temperaꢀ
ture for 24 h, diluted with water to 500 mL, and extracted with
ether (3×80 mL). The ethereal extract was washed with a
saturated aqueous solution of NaHCO3 and water (2×50 mL),
dried for 24 h over MgSO4, and filtered. The ether was distilled
off, and the residue was distilled in vacuo (45—65 °С at 40 Torr).
The product, a mixture of methyl esters of trichloroꢀ, dichloroꢀ,
and monochloroacetic acids, was obtained (3.43 g). The methyl
esters were identified by 1H NMR spectroscopy (solvent DMSOꢀd6)
by comparing their spectra with the spectra of the authentic
samples. Methyl trichloroacetate (MET). 1Н NMR (DMSOꢀd6),
Electrocarboxylation was carried out in the galvanostatic
regime, using the B5ꢀ49 dc source and passing a specified quantity
of electricity. The process was monitored with a coulometer
designed at the workshop of the Institute of Organic Chemistry.
A stainless steel plate (S = 42 cm2) served as the cathode, and
the anode was a Zn rod (S = 33 cm2). Prior to electrolysis the Zn
electrode was activated, namely, it was stored for 1 min in a
dilute (1 : 4) aqueous hydrochloric acid, washed with distilled
water, and dried.
The supporting electrolyte was a 0.1 or 0.2 М solution of
Et4NBr or Bu4NBr in MeCN or DMF. Before use, quaternary
ammonium salts (pure) were recrystallized from ethanol and
dried by heating on a water bath of a rotary evaporator at reduced
pressure for 6 h; MeCN, DMF, and tetrachloromethane were
purified as described in Refs 7—9, respectively.
To identify and determine the yield of zinc (poly)chloroꢀ
acetates, they were transformed into the corresponding methyl
(poly)chloroacetates according to the earlier1 developed proceꢀ
dure. Mixtures of the esters were analyzed by 1H NMR spectroꢀ
scopy (solvent DMSOꢀd6) on a Bruker ACꢀ200 instrument,
comparing their spectra with the spectra of the authentic
samples.
Synthesis of zinc trichloroacetate. Trichloroacetic acid
(35.94 g, 0.22 mol) was added to a ZnO suspension (8.14 g,
0.1 mol) in water (50 mL), and the mixture was stirred until
ZnO dissolved almost completely. The reaction mixture was
filtered, and the mother liquor was concentrated by evaporation
in vacuo. Residues of water and trichloroacetic acid were removed
from the salt obtained by drying (8 h, 2 Torr, 50 °С). The salt
was obtained in a yield of 38.26 g (98% based on ZnO). Found
(%): C, 12,21; Cl, 54,67; Zn, 16,67 (average of two deterꢀ
minations). C2Cl6O4Zn. Calculated (%): C, 12,29; Cl, 54,56;
Zn, 16,76. 13С NMR (DMSOꢀd6), δ: 95.0 (CCl3), 164.4 (CO).
The salt obtained was acidified with concentrated HCl
followed by extraction with ether and evaporation, and trichloroꢀ