Catalytic synthesis of 1-arylethylphosphonates by the hydrogenation of unsaturated precursors in the presence of chitosan-based palladium catalysts

Article abstract of DOI:10.1134/S1070428006070116

Three-component silica-supported palladium-containing systems based on chitosan were synthesized and studied by scanning electron microscopy. These systems showed catalytic activity in the hydrogenation (including chemoselective hydrogenation) of α,β-unsa

Full text of DOI:10.1134/S1070428006070116

&DWDO\WLFꢀ6\QWKHVLVꢀRIꢀꢁꢂ$U\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢀꢀ
E\ꢀWKHꢀ+\GURJHQDWLRQꢀRIꢀ8QVDWXUDWHGꢀ3UHFXUVRUVꢀLQꢀWKHꢀ3UHVHQFHꢀꢀ
RIꢀ&KLWRVDQꢂ%DVHGꢀ3DOODGLXPꢀ&DWDO\VWVꢀꢀ
(ꢃꢀ'ꢃꢀ)LQDVKLQD ꢄꢀꢀ9ꢃꢀ,ꢃꢀ,VDHYD ꢄꢀꢀ/ꢃꢀ0ꢃꢀ.XVWRY ꢄꢀꢀ1ꢃꢀ6ꢃꢀ*XO\XNLQD ꢄꢀꢀꢀ
*
ꢃꢀ1ꢃꢀ%RQGDUHQNR ꢄꢀꢀDQGꢀꢀ,ꢃꢀ3ꢃꢀ%HOHWVND\D
ꢀ
=HOLQVNLLꢀ,QVWLWXWHꢀRIꢀ2UJDQLFꢀ&KHPLVWU\ꢁꢀ5XVVLDQꢀ$FDGHP\ꢀRIꢀ6FLHQFHVꢁꢀ/HQLQVNLLꢀSUꢂꢀꢃꢄꢁꢀ0RVFRZꢁꢀꢅꢅꢆꢆꢆꢅꢀ5XVVLDꢀꢀ
HꢇPDLOꢈꢀOPN#LRFꢂDFꢂUXꢀ
ꢀ
)DFXOW\ꢀRIꢀ&KHPLVWU\ꢁꢀ0RVFRZꢀ6WDWHꢀ8QLYHUVLW\ꢁꢀ9RURE¶HY\ꢀJRU\ꢀꢅꢁꢀ0RVFRZꢁꢀꢅꢅꢆꢆꢆꢉꢀ5XVVLDꢀ
HFHLYHGꢂ'HFHPEHUꢂꢃꢄꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢆꢂ
EVWUDFW²7KUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂVLOLFDꢇVXSSRUWHGꢂSDOODGLXPꢇFRQWDLQLQJꢂV\VWHPVꢂEDVHGꢂRQꢂFKLWRVDQꢂZHUHꢂ
5
$
V\QWKHVL]HGꢂDQGꢂVWXGLHGꢂE\ꢂVFDQQLQJꢂHOHFWURQꢂPLFURVFRS\ꢈꢂ7KHVHꢂV\VWHPVꢂVKRZHGꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂDFWLYLW\ꢂLQꢂWKHꢂ
K\GURJHQDWLRQꢂꢉLQFOXGLQJꢂFKHPRVHOHFWLYHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢊꢂRIꢂ ꢅ ꢇXQVDWXUDWHGꢂSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGVꢂDQGꢂWKHLUꢂHVWHUVꢈꢂ
0
RGLILFDWLRQꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂRQꢂWKHꢂVLOLFDꢂVXUIDFHꢂZLWKꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂFRQVLGHUDEO\ꢂHQKDQFHVꢂWKHꢂVWDELOLW\ꢂDQGꢂ
DFWLYLW\ꢂRIꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢈꢂ
'2,ꢅꢂꢋꢁꢈꢋꢋꢎꢌꢑ6ꢋꢁꢒꢁꢌꢃꢐꢁꢁꢄꢁꢒꢁꢋꢋꢄꢂ
8
SꢇWRꢇGDWHꢂUHTXLUHPHQWVꢂLPSRVHGꢂRQꢂVHOHFWLYHꢂ PHWDOꢂLRQꢂDSSHDUVꢂWRꢂEHꢂLVRODWHGꢂIURPꢂWKHꢂQHLJKERULQJꢂ
FDWDO\WLFꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂSURFHVVHVꢂLPSO\ꢂQRWꢂRQO\ꢂKLJKꢂ PHWDOꢂLRQVꢍꢂꢉꢎꢊꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂYDULRXVꢂIXQFWLRQDOꢂ
SHUIRUPDQFHꢂDQGꢂVHOHFWLYLW\ꢂEXWꢂSULPDULO\ꢂWKHLUꢂFRPꢇ JURXSVꢅꢂZKLFKꢂPDNHVꢂLWꢂSRVVLEOHꢂWRꢂXVHꢂFKLWRVDQꢂ
SOLDQFHꢂZLWKꢂHFRORJLFDOO\ꢂFOHDQꢂWHFKQRORJ\ꢂVWDQGDUGVꢂ ZLWKRXWꢂSUHOLPLQDU\ꢂPRGLILFDWLRQꢂꢉLQꢂFRQWUDVWꢅꢂFHOOXORVHꢂ
ꢉVXFKꢂDVꢂUHF\FOLQJꢂRIꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢅꢂZDVWHOHVVQHVVꢅꢂDQGꢂ FDQQRWꢂEHꢂXVHGꢂDVꢂVXSSRUWꢂXQOHVVꢂSUHOLPLQDULO\ꢂSKRVꢇ
XVHꢂRIꢂHFRORJLFDOO\ꢂVDIHꢂVROYHQWVꢊꢈꢂ$ꢂSRVVLEOHꢂZD\ꢂRIꢂ SKRU\ODWHGꢊꢍꢂꢉꢌꢊꢂHDV\ꢂUHJHQHUDWLRQꢂIURPꢂZDVWHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ
VROYLQJꢂWKLVꢂSUREOHPꢂFRQVLVWVꢂRIꢂGHYHORSPHQWꢂRIꢂQHZꢂ RIꢂKLJKꢇFRVWꢂFRPSRQHQWVꢂE\ꢂEXUQLQJꢂWKHꢂRUJDQLFꢂVXSꢇ
FDWDO\WLFꢂV\VWHPVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂRIꢂWUDQVLWLRQꢂPHWDOꢂFRPꢇ
SOH[HVꢂLPPRELOL]HGꢂRQꢂYDULRXVꢂSRO\PHULFꢂVXSSRUWVꢅꢂLQꢇ
FOXGLQJꢂRUJDQLFꢂRQHVꢈꢂ,QꢂWKHꢂUHFHQWꢂ\HDUVꢅꢂELRSRO\PHUVꢂ
ꢉVSHFLILFDOO\ꢂSRO\VDFFKDULGHVꢂVXFKꢂDVꢂFHOOXORVHꢅꢂFKLWLQꢅꢂ
DQGꢂFKLWRVDQꢊꢂKDYHꢂUHFHLYHGꢂZLGHꢂDSSOLFDWLRQꢂIRUꢂ
KHWHURJHQL]DWLRQꢂRIꢂKRPRJHQHRXVꢂFDWDO\VWVꢈꢂ
SRUWꢂDQGꢂVXEVHTXHQWꢂH[WUDFWLRQꢍꢂꢉꢆꢊꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂ
FKLUDOꢂFDUERQꢂDWRPVꢂLQꢂDꢂPRQRPHUꢂXQLWꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢈꢂ
&
KLWRVDQꢂLVꢂZLGHO\ꢂXVHGꢂLQꢂYDULRXVꢂILHOGVꢂRIꢂFKHPꢇ
LVWU\ꢂ>ꢌ@ꢅꢂLQFOXGLQJꢂFDWDO\VLVꢂ>ꢆ@ꢈꢂ6RPHꢂH[DPSOHVꢂRIꢂDSꢇ
SOLFDWLRQꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂZLWKꢂSODWLQXPꢂPHWDOVꢂ
DVꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂIRUꢂVHOHFWLYHꢂOLTXLGꢇSKDVHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂ
SRO\XQVDWXUDWHGꢂDQGꢂSRO\IXQFWLRQDOꢂFRPSRXQGVꢂKDYHꢂ
EHHQꢂUHSRUWHGꢂ>ꢆ±ꢐ@ꢈꢂ
&
KLWRVDQꢂLVꢂDꢂOLQHDUꢂSRO\VDFFKDULGHꢂZKRVHꢂSRO\ꢇ
PHULFꢂFKDLQꢂFRQVLVWVꢂRIꢂ ꢇꢋꢅꢌꢇFRQQHFWHGꢂJOXFRVDPLQHꢂ
UHVLGXHVꢈꢂ7KHꢂVRXUFHꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂLVꢂFKLWLQꢍꢂWKHꢂODWWHUꢂLQꢂ
7KHꢂJRDOꢂRIꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQWꢂVWXG\ꢂZDVꢂWRꢂVHDUFKꢂIRUꢂQHZꢂ
WXUQꢂLVꢂLVRODWHGꢂIURPꢂVKHOOVꢂRIꢂVKULPSVꢅꢂFUDEVꢅꢂDQGꢂRWKHUꢂ HIIHFWLYHꢂ KHWHURJHQHRXVꢂ ꢉUHF\FODEOHꢊꢂ FKLWRVDQꢇEDVHGꢂ
UWKURSRGDꢂVSHFLHVꢅꢂWKHꢂRYHUDOOꢂQXPEHUꢂRIꢂZKLFKꢂLVꢂ FDWDO\WLFꢂV\VWHPVꢂIRUꢂVHOHFWLYHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂ ꢅ ꢇ
$
WUHPHQGRXVꢈꢂ$PRQJꢂDOOꢂNLQGVꢂRIꢂDPHQGHGꢂRUJDQLFꢂ XQVDWXUDWHGꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGVꢂDQGꢂWKHLUꢂ
UHVRXUFHVꢅꢂVWRFNVꢂRIꢂFKLWLQꢂDUHꢂFRPSDUDEOHꢂRQO\ꢂZLWKꢂ HVWHUVꢈꢂ7KHꢂODWWHUꢂZHUHꢂVHOHFWHGꢂDVꢂPRGHOꢂVXEVWUDWHVꢅꢂ
WKRVHꢂRIꢂFHOOXORVHꢈꢂ7DNLQJꢂLQWRꢂDFFRXQWꢂXQLTXHꢂSURSꢇ
HUWLHVꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢅꢂWKHꢂIROORZLQJꢂLWVꢂSRWHQWLDOꢂDGYDQꢇ
WDNLQJꢂLQWRꢂDFFRXQWꢂWKHꢂNQRZQꢂELRORJLFDOꢂDFWLYLW\ꢂRIꢂWKHꢂ
FRUUHVSRQGLQJꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂSURGXFWVꢅꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWK\OSKRVSKRꢇ
WDJHVꢂDVꢂVXSSRUWꢂIRUꢂPHWDOꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂVKRXOGꢂEHꢂQRWHGꢂ QDWHVꢅꢂZKLFKꢂDUHꢂSKRVSKRUXVꢇFRQWDLQLQJꢂDQDORJVꢂRIꢂꢂ
ꢋ±ꢎ@ꢏꢂꢉꢋꢊꢂFRPSOHWHꢂDEVHQFHꢂRIꢂWR[LFLW\ꢅꢂWKHꢂDELOLW\ꢂWRꢂ ꢃꢇDU\OSURSLRQLFꢂDFLGVꢂFRQVWLWXWLQJꢂDꢂFODVVꢂRIꢂQRQVWHURLGꢂ
>
XQGHUJRꢂELRGHJUDGDWLRQꢅꢂDQGꢂFRPSDWLELOLW\ꢂZLWKꢂFHOOVꢂ DQWLSKORJLVWLFꢂDQGꢂDQDOJHWLFꢂGUXJVꢅꢂVXFKꢂDVꢂ1DSUR[HQꢂ
RIꢂDQ\ꢂSODQWꢂRUꢂDQLPDOꢍꢂꢉꢃꢊꢂWKHꢂDELOLW\ꢂWRꢂHQVXUHꢂKLJKꢂ DQGꢂ,EXSURIHQꢈꢂ7KHUHꢂDUHꢂSXEOLVKHGꢂGDWDꢂDFFRUGLQJꢂWRꢂ
PHWDOꢂGLVSHUVLW\ꢂRYHUꢂWKHꢂVXSSRUWꢂVXUIDFHꢅꢂIRUꢂFKHODWHGꢂ ZKLFKꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQHVꢂH[KLELWꢂQHJDWLYHꢂLQRWURSꢇ
ꢀꢀꢁꢂ

&
$7$/<7,&ꢂꢂ6<17+(6,6ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂꢋꢇ$5</(7+</3+263+21$7(6ꢂꢂ
ꢀꢀꢋꢂ
LFꢂ>ꢀ@ꢅꢂ&D ꢇDQWDJRQLVWLFꢂ>ꢀꢅꢂꢋꢁ@ꢅꢂQHXURSURWHFWLYHꢂ>ꢋꢁ@ꢅꢂ +\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ,ꢊꢂDQGꢂ
GLHWK\OꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHꢂꢉ,,ꢊꢂLQꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂ
SDOODGLXPꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂEDVHGꢂRQꢂFKLWRVDQꢂDQGꢂLWVꢂGHULYDWLYHVꢂ
DQGꢂSV\FKRWURSLFꢂDFWLYLW\ꢂ>ꢋꢁ@ꢅꢂLQKLELWꢂF\FORR[\JHQDVHꢂ
>
>
ꢋꢋ@ꢅꢂDQGꢂDFWꢂDVꢂUHDFWLYHꢂLPPXQL]DWLRQꢂKDSWHQHVꢂꢂ
ꢋꢃꢅꢂꢋꢎ@ꢈꢂ2[RYDQDGLXPꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢂZHUHꢂ
5
QRꢈꢂ
XQꢂ
3Gꢅꢂꢂ
PROꢂꢓꢂ
VKRZQꢂWRꢂKDYHꢂDꢂOD\HUHGꢂVWUXFWXUHꢂZKLFKꢂPDNHVꢂWKHVHꢂ
FRPSRXQGVꢂSURPLVLQJꢂIRUꢂGHVLJQꢂRIꢂIXQFWLRQDOꢂPDWHULꢇ
DOVꢂ>ꢋꢌ@ꢈꢂ)LQDOO\ꢅꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢂDUHꢂZLGHO\ꢂ
XVHGꢂLQꢂV\QWKHWLFꢂSUDFWLFHꢅꢂLQꢂSDUWLFXODUꢂDVꢂUHDJHQWVꢂLQꢂ
WKHꢂ+RUQHUꢂUHDFWLRQVꢈꢂ
6XEVWUDWHꢂ &DWDO\VWꢂ
6ROYHQWꢂ <LHOGꢅꢂꢓꢂ
ꢁ
ꢁ
ꢋꢂ
ꢃꢂ
,ꢀ
$ꢁꢂ
$ꢆꢂ
$ꢁꢂ
$ꢆꢂ
$ꢆꢂ
$ꢆꢂ
%ꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢋꢈꢋꢂ
ꢁꢈꢐꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢐꢂ
ꢁꢈꢐꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢃꢈꢆꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢎꢈꢆꢂ
ꢁꢈꢀꢂ
ꢎꢈꢃꢂ
ꢎꢈꢃꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢋꢁꢁꢂ
ꢒꢒꢂꢉꢋꢁꢁꢊꢂ
ꢀꢌꢂꢉꢎꢁꢊꢁꢂ
ꢁꢁꢐꢂ
,ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢁꢎꢂ
ꢌꢂ
ꢁꢆꢂ
,ꢂ
0H2+ꢂ
(W2+ꢂ
0H2+ꢂ
(W2+ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢁ
,ꢂ
:HꢂSUHYLRXVO\ꢂSURSRVHGꢂDꢂFRQYHQLHQWꢂJHQHUDOꢂ
SURFHGXUHꢂIRUꢂWKHꢂV\QWKHVLVꢂRIꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂ
DFLGVꢂDQGꢂWKHLUꢂHVWHUVꢂYLDꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂDFFHVꢇ
VLEOHꢂ ꢅ ꢇXQVDWXUDWHGꢂSUHFXUVRUVꢂZLWKꢂDPPRQLXPꢂ
IRUPDWHꢂLQꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂ3Gꢑ&ꢂ>ꢋꢆ@ꢈꢂ7KHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂꢂ
ꢋꢇDU\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢂ ZLWKꢂ PROHFXODUꢂ K\GURJHQꢂ
ZDVꢂSHUIRUPHGꢂIRUꢂWKHꢂILUVWꢂWLPHꢂXVLQJꢂ>3GꢉWꢇ%X 32ꢊꢇ
ꢉWꢇ%X 32ꢊꢉWꢇ%X 32+ꢊ@ꢂDVꢂKRPRJHQHRXVꢂSDOODGLXPꢂ
FDWDO\VWꢂDQGꢂGLHWK\OꢂDQGꢂGLSKHQ\OꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\Oꢇ
SKRVSKRQDWHVꢂDVꢂH[DPSOHVꢂ>ꢋꢄ@ꢈꢂ6WHUHRVHOHFWLYHꢂKRPRꢇ
JHQHRXVꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂDꢂVHULHVꢂRIꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWKHQ\Oꢇ
SKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGVꢂDQGꢂWKHLUꢂHVWHUVꢂRYHUꢂFKLUDOꢂUXWKHQLXPꢂ
,,ꢂ
,,ꢂ
,ꢂ
ꢁꢁꢁꢂ
ꢁ
ꢁ
ꢁ
ꢁ
ꢄꢂ
ꢒꢂ
ꢐꢂ
ꢀꢂ
ꢁꢁꢁꢂ
ꢁꢋꢆꢂ
,,ꢀ
,ꢂ
%ꢂ
0H2+ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢁꢁꢁꢂ
&ꢀ
ꢁꢃꢀꢂ
ꢋꢁꢂ
ꢋꢋꢂ
ꢋꢃꢂ
ꢋꢎꢂ
ꢋꢌꢂ
ꢋꢆꢂ
ꢋꢄꢂ
ꢋꢒꢂ
ꢋꢐꢂ
,ꢂ
&ꢂ
0H2+ꢂ
(W2+ꢂ
0H2+ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢁꢄꢃꢂ
,ꢂ
&ꢂ
ꢁꢋꢒꢂ
,,ꢀ
,ꢂ
&ꢂ
ꢁꢎꢒꢂ
'ꢁꢀ
'ꢆꢂ
'ꢆꢂ
'ꢆꢂ
'ꢆꢂ
'ꢆꢂ
ꢋꢁꢁꢂ
,ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢋꢁꢁꢂ
>
ꢋꢆꢅꢂꢋꢒ@ꢂDQGꢂLULGLXPꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂ>ꢋꢐ@ꢂZDVꢂDOVRꢂUHSRUWHGꢈꢂ
,ꢂ
+2ꢂ
ꢋꢁꢁꢂ
ꢌꢌꢂꢉꢐꢃ ꢊꢂ
ꢁꢎꢌꢂ
$
OGHDꢂDQGꢂ$OSHUꢂ>ꢋꢀ@ꢂPDGHꢂDQꢂDWWHPSWꢂWRꢂXVHꢂ
,ꢂ
+2ꢂ
KHWHURJHQHRXVꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂLQꢂWKHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂ ꢅ ꢇXQꢇ
VDWXUDWHGꢂSKRVSKRQDWHVꢍꢂWKHꢂDXWKRUVꢂVKRZHGꢂWKDWꢂWKHꢂ
K\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂGLHWK\OꢂHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHꢂVPRRWKO\ꢂ
RFFXUVꢂLQꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂDꢂUXWKHQLXPꢂFRPSOH[ꢂLPPRꢇ
ELOL]HGꢂRQꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHꢂRIꢂPRGLILHGꢂPRQWPRULOORQLWHꢂ
,,ꢀ
,,ꢀ
0H2+ꢂ
(W2+ꢂ
ꢁꢐꢋꢂ
ꢂ5HDFWLRQꢂWLPHꢂꢌꢂKꢈꢂꢂ
ꢂ5HF\FOHGꢂFDWDO\VWꢈꢂꢂ
ꢂ<LHOGꢂꢋꢁꢁꢅꢂꢋꢁꢁꢅꢂꢀꢐꢅꢂDQGꢂꢀꢀꢓꢂLQꢂWKHꢂVHFRQGꢅꢂWKLUGꢅꢂIRXUWKꢅꢂDQGꢂILIWKꢂ
ꢂ FDWDO\WLFꢂVHULHVꢅꢂUHVSHFWLYHO\ꢈꢂ
ꢂ$WꢂURRPꢂWHPSHUDWXUHꢈꢂꢂ
ꢂ5HDFWLRQꢂWLPHꢂꢆꢂKꢈꢂ
>ꢋꢀ@ꢈꢂ$QꢂXQGRXEWHGꢂDGYDQWDJHꢂRIꢂWKLVꢂSURFHGXUHꢂLVꢂWKDWꢂ
QRꢂUHPRYDOꢂRIꢂWKHꢂUXWKHQLXPꢂFRPSOH[ꢂIURPꢂWKHꢂVXSSRUWꢂ
ZDVꢂREVHUYHGꢂGXULQJꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂSURFHVVꢍꢂWKHUHIRUHꢅꢂ
WKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂFDQꢂEHꢂUHXVHGꢈꢂ+RZHYHUꢅꢂWKHꢂDXWKRUVꢂGLGꢂ
QRWꢂVXFFHHGꢂLQꢂH[WHQGLQJꢂWKHꢂGHYHORSHGꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂ
SURFHGXUHꢂWRꢂRWKHUꢂXQVDWXUDWHGꢂSKRVSKRQDWHVꢅꢂIRUꢂLQWURꢇ
DQGꢂDFFXPXODWLRQꢂRIꢂVLJQDOVꢂIURPꢂWKHꢂWDUJHWꢂSURGꢇꢂ
XFWVꢅꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWK\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂ,,,ꢂꢉ ꢂꢃꢀꢈꢀꢂSSPꢅꢂ
GXFWLRQꢂRIꢂVXEVWLWXHQWVꢂWRꢂWKHꢂGRXEOHꢇERQGHGꢂFDUERQꢂ &' 2'ꢊꢂDQGꢂLWVꢂGLHWK\OꢂHVWHUꢂ,9ꢂꢉ ꢂꢎꢁꢈꢃꢂSSPꢅꢂ
DWRPVꢂLQKLELWHGꢂWKHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂSURFHVVꢈꢂ)RUꢂH[DPSOHꢅꢂꢂ &'2'ꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂUHVXOWVꢂDUHꢂFROOHFWHGꢂLQꢂWDEOHꢂꢉ6FKHPHꢂꢋꢊꢈꢂ
ꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHꢂDQGꢂSURSꢇꢋꢇHQ\OSKRVSKRꢇ
QDWHꢂWXUQHGꢂRXWꢂWRꢂEHꢂFRPSOHWHO\ꢂLQDFWLYHꢂXQGHUꢂWKHꢂ
DERYHꢂFRQGLWLRQVꢈꢂ
6FKHPHꢀꢁꢃꢀ
,
QꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQWꢂZRUNꢂZHꢂXVHGꢂDVꢂPRGHOꢂVXEVWUDWHVꢂꢂ
ꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ,ꢊꢂDQGꢂLWVꢂGLHWK\Oꢂ
HVWHUꢂ,,ꢂWRꢂHVWLPDWHꢂWKHꢂHIILFLHQF\ꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢇFRQꢇ
WDLQLQJꢂV\VWHPVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂLQꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂ
K\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢈꢂ7KHꢂUHꢇ
DFWLRQVꢂZHUHꢂFDUULHGꢂRXWꢂLQꢂDꢂERLOLQJꢂVROYHQWꢂꢉZDWHUꢅꢂ
PHWKDQROꢅꢂRUꢂHWKDQROꢊꢂDWꢂDꢂK\GURJHQꢂSUHVVXUHꢂHTXDOꢂWRꢂ
,
ꢅꢂ,,,ꢅꢂ5ꢂ ꢂ+ꢍꢂ,,ꢅꢂ,9ꢅꢂ5ꢂ ꢂ(Wꢈꢂ
,QLWLDOO\ꢅꢂZHꢂWHVWHGꢂ3GꢇFRQWDLQLQJꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂ
DWPRVSKHULFꢂꢉꢋꢂDWPꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂSURJUHVVꢂRIꢂUHDFWLRQVꢂZDVꢂ EDVLVꢂRIꢂVLOLFDꢇVXSSRUWHGꢂFKLWRVDQꢏꢂ.66ꢂVLOLFDꢂJHOꢂQRꢈꢂꢎꢅꢂ
PRQLWRUHGꢂE\ꢂ 3ꢂ105ꢂVSHFWURVFRS\ꢅꢂIROORZLQJꢂGLVDSꢇ
JUDLQꢂVL]Hꢂꢁꢈꢌ±ꢁꢈꢄꢂꢉ$ꢁꢊꢂDQGꢂꢁꢈꢃꢆ±ꢁꢈꢌꢆꢂPPꢂꢉ$ꢆꢊꢈꢂ,Qꢂ
SHDUDQFHꢂRIꢂWKHꢂVLJQDOVꢂEHORQJLQJꢂWRꢂLQLWLDOꢂFRPSRXQGVꢂ ERWKꢂFDVHVꢅꢂWKHꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢂLQꢂWKHꢂ
ꢂꢉ ꢂꢋꢆꢈꢀꢂSSPꢅꢂ&'2'ꢊꢂDQGꢂ,,ꢂꢉ ꢂꢋꢒꢈꢋꢂSSPꢅꢂ&'2'ꢊꢂ FDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂꢁꢈꢁꢆꢂZWꢂꢓꢈꢂ&KLWRVDQꢂPHWDOꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂDUHꢂ
,
5
866,$1ꢂꢂ-2851$/ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂ25*$1,&ꢂꢂ&+(0,675<ꢂꢂꢂ9ROꢈꢂꢂꢌꢃꢂꢂꢂ1Rꢈꢂꢂꢒꢂꢂꢂꢃꢁꢁꢄꢂ

ꢀ
ꢀꢃꢂ
),1$6+,1$ꢂꢂHWꢂDOꢈꢂ
LPPRELOL]HGꢂRQꢂWKHꢂVLOLFDꢂVXUIDFHꢂWRꢂHQODUJHꢂWKHꢂFDWDꢇꢂ
O\VWꢂVXUIDFHꢂDQGꢂKHQFHꢂWRꢂLQFUHDVHꢂDFFHVVLELOLW\ꢂRIꢂFDWDꢇ
2QꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂRIꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢇPRGLILHGꢂFKLWRVDQꢂ
ZHꢂSUHSDUHGꢂVLOLFDꢇVXSSRUWHGꢂPHWDOꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂFRQWDLQꢇ
O\WLFDOO\ꢂDFWLYHꢂFHQWHUVꢈꢂ:KLOHꢂVWXG\LQJꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂ LQJꢂꢁꢈꢁꢆꢂꢉ'ꢁꢊꢂDQGꢂꢋꢂPROꢂꢓꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢂꢉ'ꢆꢊꢈꢂ%RWKꢂ
DFWLYLW\ꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢅꢂFRSSHUꢅꢂDQGꢂFREDOWꢇFRQWDLQLQJꢂ WKHVHꢂWKUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂV\VWHPVꢂVKRZHGꢂDꢂKLJKꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂ
FKLWRVDQꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂLQꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂDQGꢂR[LGDWLRQꢂ DFWLYLW\ꢂLQꢂWKHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ,ꢂLQꢂZDWHUꢏꢂWKHꢂ
SURFHVVHVꢅꢂLWꢂZDVꢂVKRZQꢂWKDWꢂWKUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂV\VWHPVꢂ \LHOGꢂRIꢂ,,,ꢂZDVꢂꢋꢁꢁꢓꢂꢉUXQꢈꢂQRVꢈꢂꢋꢎ±ꢋꢆꢊꢅꢂDQGꢂLWꢂDOPRVWꢂ
LQꢂZKLFKꢂWKHꢂPHWDO±FKLWRVDQꢂFRPSOH[ꢂLVꢂLPPRELOL]HGꢂ GLGꢂQRWꢂGHFUHDVHꢂDIWHUꢂUHSHDWHGꢂXVHꢂRIꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂꢉꢀꢐ±
RQꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHꢂRIꢂDꢂZLGHꢇSRUHꢂPLQHUDOꢂVXSSRUWꢂSRVVHVVꢂ ꢀꢀꢓꢂLQꢂWKHꢂIRXUWKꢂDQGꢂILIWKꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂVHULHVꢍꢂUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢆꢊꢈꢂ
WKHꢂKLJKHVWꢂHIILFLHQF\ꢂ>ꢃꢁ±ꢃꢎ@ꢈꢂ
7KHꢂUDWHꢂRIꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂZDVꢂFRQVLGHUDEO\ꢂORZHUꢂDWꢂ
URRPꢂWHPSHUDWXUHꢏꢂWKHꢂ\LHOGꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ,,,ꢂZDVꢂꢋꢌꢓꢂLQꢂꢂ
ꢋꢂKꢅꢂZKLOHꢂLWꢂLQFUHDVHGꢂWRꢂꢐꢃꢓꢂZKHQꢂWKHꢂUHDFWLRQꢂWLPHꢂ
ZDVꢂSURORQJHGꢂWRꢂꢆꢂKꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢄꢊꢈꢀ
&
DWDO\VWꢂ$ꢁꢂZDVꢂIRXQGꢂWRꢂEHꢂHIIHFWLYHꢂLQꢂWKHꢂK\GURꢇ
JHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂ,ꢂLQꢂZDWHUꢏꢂWKHꢂUHDFWLRQꢂ
ZDVꢂFRPSOHWHꢂLQꢂꢋꢂKꢅꢂ\LHOGLQJꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWK\OSKRVꢇ
SKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ,,,ꢊꢂDVꢂWKHꢂRQO\ꢂSURGXFWꢂLQꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂ
&DWDO\VWꢂ'ꢆꢂDOVRꢂHQVXUHGꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂHVWHUꢂ,,ꢍꢂ
OHVVꢂWKDQꢂꢋꢂPROꢂꢓꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢂꢉVHHꢂWDEOHꢅꢂUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢊꢈꢂ KRZHYHUꢅꢂWKHꢂUHDFWLRQꢂZDVꢂVORZHUꢂWKDQꢂZLWKꢂDFLGꢂ,ꢏꢂ
&
DWDO\VWꢂ$ꢆꢂZLWKꢂVPDOOHUꢂJUDLQVꢂZDVꢂOHVVꢂDFWLYHꢏꢂDIWHUꢂꢂ HYHQꢂZKHQꢂWKHꢂDPRXQWꢂRIꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂLQFUHDVHGꢂWRꢂ
ꢋꢂKꢅꢂWKHꢂFRQYHUVLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ,ꢂZDVꢂꢒꢒꢓꢅꢂDQGꢂDERXWꢂꢌꢂKꢂ ꢎꢈꢃꢂPROꢂꢓꢅꢂWKHꢂ\LHOGꢂRIꢂVDWXUDWHGꢂFRPSRXQGꢂ,9ꢂLQꢂꢋꢂKꢂ
ZDVꢂQHFHVVDU\ꢂWRꢂFRPSOHWHꢂWKHꢂSURFHVVꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢃꢊꢈꢂ
KHꢂUDWHꢂRIꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂVOLJKWO\ꢂGHFUHDVHVꢂLQꢂ
JRLQJꢂIURPꢂZDWHUꢂWRꢂPHWKDQROꢂꢉFIꢈꢂUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢋꢂDQGꢂꢎꢊꢅꢂ
DQGꢂWKHꢂUHDFWLRQꢂVKDUSO\ꢂVORZVꢂGRZQꢂZKHQꢂHWKDQROꢂLVꢂ
XVHGꢂDVꢂVROYHQWꢏꢂWKHꢂ\LHOGꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ,,,ꢂLQꢂHWKDQROꢂLQꢂWKHꢂ
UHDFKHGꢂꢎꢌꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢒꢊꢂRUꢂꢐꢋꢓꢂꢉUXQꢈꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢐꢊꢂLQꢂERLOLQJꢂ
PHWKDQROꢂRUꢂHWKDQROꢅꢂUHVSHFWLYHO\ꢈꢂ:DWHUꢂZDVꢂQRWꢂWHVWHGꢂ
DVꢂVROYHQWꢂLQꢂWKHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂHVWHUꢂ,,ꢂRZLQJꢂWRꢂLWVꢂ
SRRUꢂVROXELOLW\ꢈꢂ
7
3UREDEOHꢂUHDVRQVꢂIRUꢂWKHꢂREVHUYHGꢂGLIIHUHQFHVꢂLQꢂWKHꢂ
SUHVHQFHꢂꢂRIꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ$ꢆꢂZDVꢂDVꢂORZꢂDVꢂꢐꢓꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢌꢊꢈꢂ FDWDO\WLFꢂDFWLYLWLHVꢂRIꢂWKUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂV\VWHPVꢂ$ꢁꢑ$ꢆꢂ
KHVHꢂGDWDꢂPD\ꢂEHꢂUDWLRQDOL]HGꢂWDNLQJꢂLQWRꢂDFFRXQWꢂWKHꢂ DQGꢂ'ꢁꢑ'ꢆꢂDUHꢂVSHFLILFꢂPRUSKRORJLHVꢂDQGꢂVWUXFWXUHVꢂRIꢂ
NQRZQꢂVROXELOLW\ꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂLQꢂGLOXWHꢂDFLGVꢂ>ꢃꢌ@ꢈꢂ3UHꢇ
WKHꢂFDWDO\VWVꢈꢂ7KLVꢂDVVXPSWLRQꢂZDVꢂFRQILUPHGꢂE\ꢂWKHꢂ
7
VXPDEO\ꢅꢂZDWHUꢂDQGꢂPHWKDQROꢂꢉUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢋ±ꢎꢊꢂSURPRWHꢂ UHVXOWVꢂRIꢂVWXG\LQJꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHꢂRIꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂ$ꢁꢂDQGꢂꢂ
DSSUHFLDEOHꢂUHPRYDOꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂIURPꢂWKHꢂVLOLFDꢂVXUIDFHꢂ 'ꢆꢂE\ꢂVFDQQLQJꢂHOHFWURQꢂPLFURVFRS\ꢂꢉVHHꢂILJXUHꢊꢈꢂ$Wꢂꢂ
>
UHPRYDOꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂIURPꢂILQHUꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ$ꢆꢂRFFXUVꢂWRꢂꢂ DꢂPDJQLILFDWLRQꢂRIꢂîꢆꢁꢁꢁꢅꢂZHꢂFDQꢂFOHDUO\ꢂVHHꢂDꢂWKLQꢂ
DꢂOHVVHUꢂH[WHQWꢂꢉFIꢈꢂUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢋꢂDQGꢂꢃꢊ@ꢅꢂVRꢂWKDWꢂWKHꢂ ILOPꢂZLWKꢂQRꢂEUHDNVꢂIRUPHGꢂE\ꢂWKHꢂ3G±FKLWRVDQꢂFRPꢇ
FDWDO\VLVꢂEHFRPHVꢂHVVHQWLDOO\ꢂKRPRJHQHRXVꢈꢂ,QꢂIDFWꢅꢂ SOH[ꢂRQꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHꢂRIꢂ$ꢁꢂSDUWLFOHVꢍꢂWKHꢂILOPꢂIORZVꢂLQWRꢂ
ZKHQꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ$ꢁꢂZDVꢂXVHGꢂUHSHDWHGO\ꢂLQꢂPHWKDQROꢅꢂWKHꢂ SRUHVꢂRIꢂWKHꢂVXSSRUWꢂWRꢂIRUPꢂDꢂXQLIRUPꢂFRDWLQJꢈꢂ,QꢂWKHꢂ
\
(
LHOGꢂRIꢂ,,,ꢂIHOOꢂGRZQꢂIURPꢂꢀꢌꢂWRꢂꢎꢁꢓꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢎꢊꢈꢂ FDVHꢂRIꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ'ꢆꢅꢂWKHꢂPHWDO±SRO\PHUꢂFRPSOH[ꢂRQꢂWKHꢂ
WKDQROꢂSRRUO\ꢂGLVVROYHVꢂFKLWRVDQꢅꢂDQGꢂWKHꢂKHWHURꢇ
VLOLFDꢂVXUIDFHꢂIRUPVꢂDꢂQRQXQLIRUPꢂFUXVWꢇOLNHꢂFRDWLQJꢂ
JHQHRXVꢂFDWDO\VWꢂVKRZVꢂDꢂORZꢂDFWLYLW\ꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢌꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂ UDWKHUꢂWKDQꢂWKLQꢂILOPꢈꢂ3KRWRJUDSKVꢂRIꢂ'ꢆꢂVDPSOHVꢂ
VDPHꢂSDWWHUQꢂZDVꢂREVHUYHGꢂIRUꢂQHXWUDOꢂVROXWLRQVꢂRIꢂ REWDLQHGꢂDIWHUꢂWKHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂSURFHVVꢂVKRZꢂWKDWꢂWKHꢂ
HVWHUꢂ,,ꢂLQꢂDOFRKROVꢏꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂLQDFWLYHꢅꢂDQGꢂQRꢂ FRDWLQJꢂVWUXFWXUHꢂLVꢂFRQVHUYHGꢈꢂ7KHUHIRUHꢅꢂWKLVꢂFDWDO\VWꢂ
K\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂWKHꢂVXEVWUDWHꢂRFFXUUHGꢂꢉUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢆꢅꢂꢄꢊꢈꢂ DOPRVWꢂGRHVꢂQRWꢂORVHꢂLWVꢂDFWLYLW\ꢂDIWHUꢂꢆꢂFDWDO\WLFꢂVHULHVꢂ
ꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢆꢊꢈꢂ
,WꢂLVꢂNQRZQꢂWKDWꢂPRGLILFDWLRQꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂꢉDVꢂDꢂUXOHꢅꢂ
DWꢂWKHꢂDPLQRꢂJURXSꢊꢂE\ꢂWUHDWPHQWꢂZLWKꢂYDULRXVꢂFURVVꢇ
:LWKꢂꢋꢇꢉꢌꢇFKORURSKHQ\OꢊHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂ
OLQNLQJꢂDJHQWVꢂLQFUHDVHVꢂLWVꢂVWDELOLW\ꢂLQꢂDFLGꢂPHGLXPꢂꢂ ꢉ9ꢊꢂDVꢂVXEVWUDWHꢂZHꢂHVWLPDWHGꢂWKHꢂSRVVLELOLW\ꢂRIꢂXVLQJꢂ
ꢃꢅꢂꢃꢆ@ꢈꢂ:HꢂKDYHꢂV\QWKHVL]HGꢂDQGꢂWHVWHGꢂWZRꢇFRPꢇ
FKLWRVDQꢇEDVHGꢂSDOODGLXPꢂFDWDOV\VWVꢂIRUꢂFKHPRVHOHFWLYHꢂ
>
SRQHQWꢂKHWHURJHQHRXVꢂSDOODGLXPꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂ UHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂꢋꢇDU\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHVꢂKDYLQJꢂODELOHꢂ
RIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂPRGLILHGꢂE\ꢂ ꢇNHWRJOXWDULFꢂDFLGꢂꢉFDWDO\VWꢂ%ꢅꢂ VXEVWLWXHQWVꢂLQꢂWKHꢂDURPDWLFꢂULQJꢈꢂ7KHUHꢂDUHꢂSXEOLVKHGꢂ
SDOODGLXPꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂꢃꢂPROꢂꢓꢊꢂDQGꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂ GDWDꢂGHPRQVWUDWLQJꢂVXFFHVVIXOꢂDSSOLFDWLRQꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQ±
ꢉFDWDO\VWꢂ&ꢅꢂSDOODGLXPꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂꢋꢂZWꢂꢓꢊꢈꢂ&DWDO\VWꢂ SDOODGLXPꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂLQꢂERWKꢂVHOHFWLYHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂ
%
ꢂWXUQHGꢂRXWꢂWRꢂEHꢂLQDFWLYHꢂLQꢂWKHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ FKORULQHꢇFRQWDLQLQJꢂVXEVWUDWHVꢂꢉHꢈJꢈꢅꢂFKORURQLWUREHQꢇ
,
ꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢒꢊꢂDQGꢂHVWHUꢂ,,ꢂꢉUXQꢂQRꢈꢂꢐꢊꢈꢂ&DWDO\VWꢂ&ꢂZDVꢂ ]HQHꢊꢂZLWKRXWꢂK\GURGHFKORULQDWLRQꢂDQGꢂUHGXFWLYHꢂGHꢇ
PRUHꢂHIIHFWLYHꢂꢉFIꢈꢂUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢀꢂDQGꢂꢒꢅꢂꢋꢃꢂDQGꢂꢐꢊꢅꢂEXWꢂLWVꢂ FKORULQDWLRQꢂꢉHꢈJꢈꢅꢂRIꢂFKORURSKHQROꢊꢂ>ꢆ@ꢈꢂ$VꢂZHꢂVKRZHGꢂ
DSSOLFDWLRQꢂZDVꢂFRPSOLFDWHGꢂE\ꢂDSSUHFLDEOHꢂIRUPDWLRQꢂ LQꢂ>ꢋꢆ@ꢅꢂWKHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ9ꢂꢉ ꢂꢋꢆꢈꢒꢂSSPꢅꢂ&'2'ꢊꢂ
RIꢂFROORLGꢂV\VWHPVꢏꢂWKHꢂUHDFWLRQꢂPL[WXUHVꢂLQꢂUXQꢂQRVꢈꢂꢀꢂ ZLWKꢂDPPRQLXPꢂIRUPDWHꢂRYHUꢂ3Gꢑ&ꢂZDVꢂDFFRPSDQLHGꢂ
DQGꢂꢋꢁꢂZHUHꢂFOHDUO\ꢂJHOꢇOLNHꢈꢂ
E\ꢂK\GURGHFKORULQDWLRQꢂWRꢂJLYHꢂDQꢂDSSUR[LPDWHO\ꢂHTXLꢇ
5
866,$1ꢂꢂ-2851$/ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂ25*$1,&ꢂꢂ&+(0,675<ꢂꢂꢂ9ROꢈꢂꢂꢌꢃꢂꢂꢂ1Rꢈꢂꢂꢒꢂꢂꢂꢃꢁꢁꢄꢂ

&
$7$/<7,&ꢂꢂ6<17+(6,6ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂꢋꢇ$5</(7+</3+263+21$7(6ꢂꢂ
ꢀꢀꢎꢂ
ꢉDꢊꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢉEꢊꢂ
PRODUꢂPL[WXUHꢂRIꢂꢋꢇꢉꢌꢇFKORURSKHQ\OꢊHWK\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂ
DFLGꢂꢉ9,ꢍꢂ ꢂꢃꢀꢈꢎꢂSSPꢅꢂ&' 2'ꢊꢂDQGꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWK\Oꢇ
SKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ,,,ꢍꢂ ꢂꢃꢀꢈꢀꢂSSPꢅꢂ&' 2'ꢊꢂꢂ
ꢉ6FKHPHꢂꢃꢊꢈꢂ$QꢂDQDORJRXVꢂSDWWHUQꢂZDVꢂREVHUYHGꢂLQꢂWKHꢂ
HOHFWURFKHPLFDOꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ9ꢂDWꢂDꢂSDOODGDWHGꢂ
SODWLQXPꢂHOHFWURGHꢂ>ꢃꢄ@ꢈꢂ0RGLILFDWLRQꢂRIꢂWKHꢂHOHFWURGHꢂ
VXUIDFHꢂZLWKꢂFDGPLXPꢂFRQVLGHUDEO\ꢂLPSURYHGꢂWKHꢂ
VHOHFWLYLW\ꢂIRUꢂFRPSRXQGꢂ9,ꢅꢂEXWꢂWKHꢂFRQYHUVLRQꢂRIꢂ
LQLWLDOꢂDFLGꢂ9ꢂZDVꢂQRWꢂFRPSOHWHꢂRZLQJꢂWRꢂVHOIꢇLQKLELꢇ
WLRQꢈꢂ7KHꢂ\LHOGꢂRIꢂWDUJHWꢂDFLGꢂ9,ꢂZDVꢂꢆꢀꢓꢂDWꢂDꢂFRQYHUꢇ
VLRQꢂRIꢂꢄꢌꢓꢂꢉPD[LPDOO\ꢂDWWDLQDEOHꢊꢂ>ꢃꢒ@ꢈꢂ
ꢉFꢊꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢉGꢊꢂ
6
FKHPHꢀꢆꢃꢀ
ꢉHꢊꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢉIꢊꢂ
,
QꢂWKHꢂUHGXFWLRQꢂRIꢂDFLGꢂ9ꢂZLWKꢂK\GURJHQꢂLQꢂERLOLQJꢂ
ZDWHUꢂLQꢂWKHꢂSUHVHQFHꢂRIꢂ'ꢆꢂWKHꢂFRQYHUVLRQꢂZDVꢂꢀꢌꢓꢂLQꢂ
ꢋꢂKꢅꢂDQGꢂWKHꢂ\LHOGꢂRIꢂ9,ꢂZDVꢂꢒꢋꢓꢈꢂ7KLVꢂUHVXOWꢂDOORZVꢂXVꢂ
WRꢂDQWLFLSDWHꢂWKDWꢂSDOODGLXPꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂ
FKLWRVDQꢂFRXOGꢂHQVXUHꢂFKHPRVHOHFWLYHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂ
RIꢂSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂ9ꢈꢂ6WXGLHVꢂLQꢂWKLVꢂOLQHꢂZLOOꢂEHꢂ
FRQWLQXHGꢈꢂ
ꢉJꢊꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢂꢉKꢊꢂ
:HꢂFDQꢂFRQFOXGHꢂWKDWꢂWKUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂSDOODGLXPꢇ
FRQWDLQLQJꢂV\VWHPVꢂRQꢂWKHꢂEDVLVꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂDSSOLHGꢂ
RQWRꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHꢂRIꢂZLGHꢇSRUHꢂVLOLFDꢂJHOꢂDUHꢂDFWLYHꢂLQꢂ
WKHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWHQK\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂ
ꢉ,ꢊꢂDQGꢂGLHWK\OꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQDWHꢂꢉ,,ꢊꢅꢂDVꢂ
ZHOOꢂDVꢂLQꢂWKHꢂFKHPRVHOHFWLYHꢂK\GURJHQDWLRQꢂRIꢂꢂ
ꢋꢇꢉꢌꢇFKORURSKHQ\OꢊHWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ9ꢊꢈꢂ6WXGLHVꢂ
E\ꢂVFDQQLQJꢂHOHFWURQꢂPLFURVFRS\ꢂVKRZHGꢂIRUPDWLRQꢂRIꢂ
WZRꢂNLQGVꢂRIꢂVXSSRUWHGꢂFDWDO\VWVꢏꢂILOPꢂDQGꢂFUXVWꢇOLNHꢈꢂ
6
FDQQLQJꢂHOHFWURQꢂPLFURVFRS\ꢂSKRWRJUDSKVꢂRIꢂWKHꢂVXUIDFHVꢂꢂ
RIꢂVLOLFDꢂDQGꢂWKUHHꢇFRPSRQHQWꢂFDWDO\VWVꢏꢂꢉDꢅꢂEꢊꢂVLOLFDꢂSDUWLFOHꢅꢂ
ꢉFꢅꢂGꢊꢂ$ꢁꢅꢂꢉHꢅꢂIꢊꢂ*ꢆꢅꢂDQGꢂꢉJꢅꢂKꢊꢂUHF\FOHGꢂ*ꢆꢍꢂPDJQLILFDWLRQꢂꢂ
ꢉDꢅꢂFꢅꢂHꢅꢂJꢊꢂîꢃꢁꢁꢂDQGꢂꢉEꢅꢂGꢅꢂIꢅꢂKꢊꢂîꢆꢁꢁꢁꢈꢂ
7
KHꢂODWWHUꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂREWDLQHGꢂE\ꢂPRGLILFDWLRQꢂRIꢂ
-
(2/ꢂVFDQQLQJꢂPLFURVFRSHꢍꢂVDPSOHVꢂZHUHꢂSUHOLPLꢇ
VLOLFDꢇVXSSRUWHGꢂFKLWRVDQꢂZLWKꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢅꢂDQGꢂLWꢂ
FDQꢂEHꢂXVHGꢂUHSHDWHGO\ꢂZLWKRXWꢂDSSUHFLDEOHꢂORVVꢂLQꢂ
FDWDO\WLFꢂDFWLYLW\ꢈꢂ
QDULO\ꢂFRDWHGꢂZLWKꢂDꢂWKLQꢂOD\HUꢂRIꢂJROGꢂRQꢂDꢂ-)&ꢇꢋꢋꢁꢁ(ꢂ
VHWXSꢈꢂ
0
HWKDQROꢂZDVꢂKHDWHGꢂXQGHUꢂUHIOX[ꢂRYHUꢂPDJQHVLXPꢂ
PHWKR[LGHꢂDQGꢂGLVWLOOHGꢈꢂ(WKDQROꢂZDVꢂKHDWHGꢂXQGHUꢂ
UHIOX[ꢂRYHUꢂFDOFLXPꢂHWKR[LGHꢂDQGꢂGLVWLOOHGꢈꢂꢋꢇ3KHQ\Oꢇ
(;3(5,0(17$/ꢂ
7
KHꢂ 3ꢂ105ꢂVSHFWUDꢂZHUHꢂUHFRUGHGꢂRQꢂDꢂ%UXNHUꢂ HWKHQ\OSKRVSKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ,ꢊꢅꢂGLHWK\OꢂꢋꢇSKHQ\OHWKHQ\Oꢇ
$
YDQFHꢇꢌꢁꢁꢂVSHFWURPHWHUꢂꢉꢋꢄꢃꢂ0+]ꢊꢍꢂWKHꢂFKHPLFDOꢂ SKRVSKRQDWHꢂꢉ,,ꢊꢅꢂDQGꢂꢋꢇꢉꢌꢇFKORURSKHQ\OꢊHWKHQ\OSKRVꢇ
VKLIWVꢂZHUHꢂPHDVXUHGꢂUHODWLYHꢂWRꢂꢐꢆꢓꢂ+32 ꢈꢂ7KHꢂ SKRQLFꢂDFLGꢂꢉ9ꢊꢂZHUHꢂV\QWKHVL]HGꢂDVꢂGHVFULEHGꢂLQꢂ>ꢋꢆ@ꢈꢂ
FDWDO\VWꢂVXUIDFHꢂZDVꢂVWXGLHGꢂXVLQJꢂDꢂ-60ꢇꢆꢎꢁꢁ/9ꢂ &KLWRVDQꢂLVRODWHGꢂIURPꢂFUDEꢂVKHOOVꢂꢉPROHFXODUꢂZHLJKWꢂ
5
866,$1ꢂꢂ-2851$/ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂ25*$1,&ꢂꢂ&+(0,675<ꢂꢂꢂ9ROꢈꢂꢂꢌꢃꢂꢂꢂ1Rꢈꢂꢂꢒꢂꢂꢂꢃꢁꢁꢄꢂ

ꢀ
ꢀꢌꢂ
),1$6+,1$ꢂꢂHWꢂDOꢈꢂ
ꢋꢁꢁꢁꢁꢁꢂWRꢂꢋꢆꢁꢁꢁꢁꢅꢂGHJUHHꢂRIꢂGHDFHW\ODWLRQꢂRIꢂDPLQRꢂ DWRPLFꢂDEVRUSWLRQꢂVSHFWURVFRS\ꢈꢂ7KHꢂSUHSDUHGꢂSDOODꢇ
JURXSVꢂꢒꢁꢓꢅꢂZDWHUꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂꢎꢂPROꢂꢓꢍꢂSURGXFHGꢂLQꢂ GLXPꢂFRPSOH[HVꢂZLWKꢂFKLWRVDQꢂDQGꢂPRGLILHGꢂFKLWRVDQVꢂ
.
RUHDꢊꢂZDVꢂXVHGꢈꢂ
ZHUHꢂFKDUDFWHUL]HGꢂE\ꢂ,5ꢂ)RXULHUꢂVSHFWURVFRS\ꢂDQGꢂꢂ
ꢇUD\ꢂSKRWRHOHFWURQꢂVSHFWURVFRS\ꢍꢂWKHLUꢂVSHFWUDOꢂSDꢇ
UDPHWHUVꢂFRLQFLGHGꢂZLWKꢂWKRVHꢂUHSRUWHGꢂLQꢂ>ꢃꢃ@ꢈꢂ
;
&
DWDO\VWVꢀ$ꢁꢀDQGꢀ$ꢆꢃꢂ$PRUSKRXVꢂVLOLFDꢂꢉ.66ꢂꢂ
QRꢈꢂꢎꢅꢂJUDLQꢂVL]Hꢂꢁꢈꢌ±ꢁꢈꢄꢂRUꢂꢁꢈꢃꢆ±ꢁꢈꢌꢆꢂPPꢅꢂUHVSHFꢇ
WLYHO\ꢍꢂ6 ꢂ ꢂꢌꢆꢁꢂP ꢑJꢍꢂPRLVWXUHꢂFDSDFLW\ꢂꢋꢈꢌꢂPOꢑJꢊꢅꢂꢂ
3URFHGXUHꢀIRUꢀFDWDO\WLFꢀH[SHULPHQWVꢃꢂ$ꢂIODVNꢂ
ꢋꢂJꢅꢂZDVꢂLPSUHJQDWHGꢂZLWKꢂꢋꢈꢃꢂPOꢂRIꢂDꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂ HTXLSSHGꢂZLWKꢂDꢂPDJQHWLFꢂVWLUUHUꢅꢂUHIOX[ꢂFRQGHQVHUꢂZLWKꢂ
SDOODGLXP±FKLWRVDQꢂFRPSOH[ꢂSUHSDUHGꢂDFFRUGLQJꢂWRꢂWKHꢂ Dꢂ:XUW]ꢂDGDSWHUꢅꢂEXEEOHꢂFRXQWHUꢅꢂDQGꢂDꢂFDSLOODU\ꢂSDVꢇ
SURFHGXUHꢂGHVFULEHGꢂLQꢂ>ꢃꢃ@ꢈꢂ7KHꢂLPSUHJQDWHGꢂVRUEHQWꢂ VLQJꢂWKURXJKꢂWKHꢂUHIOX[ꢂFRQGHQVHUꢂWRꢂWKHꢂERWWRPꢂRIꢂWKHꢂ
ZDVꢂSODFHGꢂLQꢂDꢂꢁꢈꢆꢂ0ꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂ1D2+ꢂIRUꢂꢋꢆꢂPLQꢅꢂ IODVNꢂZDVꢂFKDUJHGꢂZLWKꢂꢁꢈꢃꢌꢂPPROꢂRIꢂDSSURSULDWHꢂVXEꢇ
ILOWHUHGꢂRIIꢅꢂZDVKHGꢂZLWKꢂVHYHUDOꢂSRUWLRQVꢂRIꢂGLVWLOOHGꢂ
ZDWHUꢂXQWLOꢂQHXWUDOꢂZDVKLQJVꢅꢂILOWHUHGꢂRIIꢅꢂDQGꢂGULHGꢂ
ILUVWꢂIRUꢂꢃꢌꢂKꢂLQꢂDLUꢂDQGꢂWKHQꢂIRUꢂꢋꢁꢂKꢂXQGHUꢂUHGXFHGꢂ
SUHVVXUHꢈꢂ
VWUDWHꢂDQGꢂꢌꢂPOꢂRIꢂDꢂVROYHQWꢈꢂ7KHꢂIODVNꢂZDVꢂILOOHGꢂZLWKꢂ
DUJRQꢂWKURXJKꢂWKHꢂFDSLOODU\ꢅꢂDQGꢂDꢂVSHFLILHGꢂDPRXQWꢂRIꢂ
FDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂDGGHGꢈꢂ$UJRQꢂVXSSO\ꢂZDVꢂWHUPLQDWHGꢅꢂDQGꢂ
K\GURJHQꢂZDVꢂSDVVHGꢂWKURXJKꢂWKHꢂVDPHꢂFDSLOODU\ꢈꢂ7KHꢂ
&
DWDO\VWVꢀ %ꢀ DQGꢀ &ꢃꢂ&KLWRVDQꢂZDVꢂPRGLILHGꢂZLWKꢂ PL[WXUHꢂZDVꢂKHDWHGꢂXQGHUꢂUHIOX[ꢂZLWKꢂVWLUULQJꢂIRUꢂꢂ
JOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂDFFRUGLQJꢂWRꢂWKHꢂSURFHGXUHVꢂGHVFULEHGꢂ DꢂVSHFLILHGꢂWLPHꢂLQꢂDꢂFRQWLQXRXVꢂVWUHDPꢂRIꢂK\GURJHQꢈꢂ,Wꢂ
LQꢂ>ꢃꢆꢅꢂꢃꢐꢅꢂꢃꢀ@ꢅꢂDQGꢂZLWKꢂ ꢇR[RJOXWDULFꢂDFLGꢅꢂDVꢂGHꢇ
ZDVꢂWKHQꢂFRROHGꢅꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂILOWHUHGꢂRIIꢂWKURXJKꢂꢂ
VFULEHGꢂLQꢂ>ꢎꢁ@ꢈꢂ7KHꢂPRGLILHGꢂSRO\PHUVꢂZHUHꢂWUHDWHGꢂ DꢂVPDOOꢂOD\HUꢂRIꢂVLOLFDꢂJHOꢅꢂWKHꢂVROYHQWꢂZDVꢂGLVWLOOHGꢂRIIꢂ
ZLWKꢂDQꢂDTXHRXVꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂ1D 3G&O ꢂꢉSDOODGLXPꢂFRQꢇ
RQꢂDꢂURWDU\ꢂHYDSRUDWRUꢅꢂDQGꢂWKHꢂUHVLGXHꢂZDVꢂGLVVROYHGꢂ
FHQWUDWLRQꢂꢋꢂZWꢂꢓꢂUHODWLYHꢂWRꢂWKHꢂSRO\PHUꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂPL[WXUHꢂ LQꢂ&'2'ꢂDQGꢂDQDO\]HGꢂE\ꢂ 3ꢂ105ꢂVSHFWURVFRS\ꢈꢂ
ZDVꢂVWLUUHGꢂIRUꢂꢎꢂKꢅꢂDQGꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂILOWHUHGꢂRIIꢅꢂ
7
KLVꢂVWXG\ꢂZDVꢂSHUIRUPHGꢂXQGHUꢂILQDQFLDOꢂVXSSRUWꢂ
ZDVKHGꢂZLWKꢂVHYHUDOꢂSRUWLRQVꢂRIꢂGLVWLOOHGꢂZDWHUꢅꢂDQGꢂ
GULHGꢂIRUꢂꢃꢌꢂKꢂLQꢂDLUꢈꢂ
E\ꢂWKHꢂ5XVVLDQꢂ)RXQGDWLRQꢂIRUꢂ%DVLFꢂ5HVHDUFKꢂꢉSURMHFWꢂ
QRVꢈꢂꢁꢆꢇꢁꢎꢇꢎꢎꢁꢋꢎꢂDQGꢂꢁꢌꢇꢁꢎꢇꢎꢀꢁꢋꢒꢇ*)(1ꢊꢈꢂ
&
DWDO\VWꢀ'ꢁꢂZDVꢂSUHSDUHGꢂDVꢂGHVFULEHGꢂDERYHꢂIRUꢂ
ꢁꢂDQGꢂ$ꢆꢂIURPꢂDPRUSKRXVꢂVLOLFDꢂJHOꢂꢉ.6.ꢅꢂꢁꢈꢃ±ꢂ
ꢈꢌꢂPPꢅꢂ6 ꢂ ꢂꢌꢆꢁꢂPꢑJꢅꢂPRLVWXUHꢂFDSDFLW\ꢂꢋꢈꢌꢂPOꢑJꢊꢈꢂ
$
ꢁ
5()(5(1&(6ꢂ
%
HIRUHꢂWUHDWPHQWꢂZLWKꢂDONDOLꢅꢂWKHꢂVRUEHQWꢂLPSUHJQDWHGꢂ ꢂꢂꢋꢈꢂ<DQJꢅꢂ-ꢈ+ꢈꢂDQGꢂ9LJHHꢅꢂ*ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ ,QRUJꢂꢀ %LRFKHPꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢋꢅꢂ
ꢂ
YROꢈꢂꢌꢋꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢒꢈꢂ
ZLWKꢂWKHꢂSDOODGLXP±FKLWRVDQꢂFRPSOH[ꢂZDVꢂWUHDWHGꢂZLWKꢂ
DQꢂDTXHRXVꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂꢉFDOFXODWHGꢂ ꢂꢂꢃꢈꢂ&KLHVVLꢅꢂ(ꢈꢂDQGꢂ3LVSLVDꢅꢂ%ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ0ROꢂꢀ&DWDOꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢌꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢐꢒꢅꢂ
ꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢋꢒꢒꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢎꢈꢂ&KHUQHWVNLLꢅꢂ9ꢈ1ꢈꢂDQGꢂ1LIDQW¶HYꢅꢂ1ꢈ(ꢈꢅꢂ5RVꢂꢀ.KLPꢂꢀ=Kꢈꢅꢂ
ꢋꢀꢀꢒꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢌꢋꢅꢂQRꢈꢂꢋꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢐꢁꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢌꢈꢂ.XPDUꢅꢂ0ꢈ1ꢈ9ꢈ5ꢈꢅꢂ5HDFWꢂꢀ)XQFWꢂꢀ3RO\PꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢁꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢌꢄꢅꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢋꢈꢂ
GHJUHHꢂRIꢂFURVVꢇOLQNLQJꢂꢋꢃꢓꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂRIꢂ
SDOODGLXPꢂLQꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂZDVꢂꢁꢈꢁꢆꢂPROꢂꢓꢈꢂ
ꢂ
&DWDO\VWꢀ'ꢆꢃꢂ$PRUSKRXVꢂVLOLFDꢂꢉ.6.ꢅꢂꢁꢈꢃ±ꢁꢈꢌꢂPPꢅꢂ
6
ꢂ ꢂꢌꢆꢁꢂPꢑJꢅꢂPRLVWXUHꢂFDSDFLW\ꢂꢋꢈꢌꢂPOꢑJꢊꢅꢂꢃꢂJꢅꢂZDVꢂ
ꢂ
LPSUHJQDWHGꢂꢂZLWKꢂꢎꢈꢁꢂPOꢂRIꢂDꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂFKLWRVDQꢂLQꢂ
ꢋꢓꢂDFHWLFꢂDFLGꢈꢂ7KHꢂLPSUHJQDWHGꢂVRUEHQWꢂZDVꢂWUHDWHGꢂ
ZLWKꢂꢎꢈꢒꢂPOꢂRIꢂDQꢂDTXHRXVꢂVROXWLRQꢂꢉꢆꢁꢂYROꢂꢓꢊꢂRIꢂ
JOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂLQꢂꢋꢁꢂPOꢂRIꢂPHWKDQROꢂRYHUꢂDꢂSHULRGꢂRIꢂꢂ
ꢋꢂKꢂꢉFDOFXODWHGꢂGHJUHHꢂRIꢂFURVVꢇOLQNLQJꢂꢋꢁꢓꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂ
VDPSOHꢂZDVꢂZDVKHGꢂZLWKꢂPHWKDQROꢂDQGꢂGULHGꢂLQꢂDLUꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢆꢈꢂ*XLEDOꢅꢂ(ꢈꢅꢂ3URJꢂꢀ3RO\Pꢂꢀ6FLꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢆꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢎꢁꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢒꢋꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢄꢈꢂ+DQꢅꢂ+ꢈꢇ6ꢈꢅꢂ-LDQJꢅꢂ6ꢈꢇ1ꢈꢅꢂ+XDQJꢅꢂ0ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ-LDQJꢅꢂ<ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
3RO\Pꢂꢀ$GYꢂꢀ7HFKQROꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢄꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢒꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢒꢁꢌꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢒꢈꢂ7DQJꢅꢂ/ꢈꢇ0ꢈꢅꢂ0HQJꢅꢂ=ꢈꢇ+ꢈꢅꢂ+XDQJꢅꢂ0ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ-LDQJꢅꢂ<ꢈꢇ
<ꢈꢅꢂ5HDFWꢂꢀ3RO\PꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢆꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢌꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢃꢆꢋꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢐꢈꢂ:HLꢅꢂ:ꢈꢇ/ꢈꢅꢂ=KXꢅꢂ+ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ=KDRꢅꢂ&ꢈꢇ/ꢈꢅꢂ+XDQJꢅꢂ0ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ
-LDQJꢅꢂ<ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ5HDFWꢂꢀ)XQFWꢂꢀ3RO\PꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢌꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢆꢀꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢎꢎꢈꢂ
ꢂꢂꢀꢈꢂ%HOOXFFLꢅꢂ&ꢈꢅꢂ*XDOWLHULꢅꢂ)ꢈꢅꢂ6FDSHFFKLꢅꢂ6ꢈꢅꢂ7HRGRULꢅꢂ(ꢈꢅꢂ
%XGULHVLꢅꢂ5ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ&KLDULQLꢅꢂ$ꢈꢅꢂ)DUPDFRꢅꢂꢋꢀꢐꢀꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢌꢌꢅꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢋꢋꢄꢒꢈꢂ
ꢋꢁꢈꢂ%RQGDUHQNRꢅꢂ 1ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ /HUPRQWRYDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ1ꢈꢅꢂ %RQGDUHQꢇꢂ
ꢂ
7KHꢂDERYHꢂVXFFHVVLYHꢂWUHDWPHQWꢂRIꢂVLOLFDꢂZLWKꢂFKLWRVDQꢂ
ꢂ
DQGꢂJOXWDUDOGHK\GHꢂZDVꢂUHSHDWHGꢂꢎꢂWLPHVꢈꢂ7KHꢂVLOLFDꢇ
VXSSRUWHGꢂFKLWRVDQꢂWKXVꢂREWDLQHGꢂZDVꢂWUHDWHGꢂZLWKꢂꢂ
DQꢂDTXHRXVꢂVROXWLRQꢂRIꢂ1D3G&O ꢂꢉꢁꢈꢁꢄꢂJꢂLQꢂꢋꢆꢂPOꢂRIꢂ
ZDWHUꢊꢈꢂ7KHꢂVDPSOHꢂZDVꢂZDVKHGꢂZLWKꢂZDWHUꢂDQGꢂPHWKꢇ
DQROꢂDQGꢂGULHGꢂLQꢂDLUꢈꢂ7KHꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢂLQꢂ
WKHꢂFDWDO\VWꢂꢉꢃꢈꢃꢋꢁꢂJꢊꢂZDVꢂꢋꢂZWꢂꢓꢂꢉꢁꢈꢁꢃꢃꢂJꢊꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
NRꢅꢂ *ꢈ1ꢈꢅꢂ *XO\XNLQDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ 'ROJLQDꢅꢂ 7ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ %DFKXꢇꢂ
ULQꢅꢂ6ꢈ2ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ%HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ.KLPꢂꢇ)DUPꢂꢀ=Kꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢎꢅꢂ
YROꢈꢂꢎꢒꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢒꢈꢂ
7
KHꢂFRPSOHWHQHVVꢂRIꢂSDOODGLXPꢂDGVRUSWLRQꢂZDVꢂ
FKHFNHGꢂE\ꢂDQDO\]LQJꢂZDVWHꢂSDOODGLXPꢂVROXWLRQVꢂDQGꢂ
ZDVKLQJVꢂE\ꢂVSHFWURSKRWRPHWU\ꢈꢂ7KHꢂFRQFHQWUDWLRQꢂRIꢂ
SDOODGLXPꢂLQꢂWKHꢂFDWDO\VWVꢂZDVꢂDOVRꢂGHWHUPLQHGꢂE\ꢂ
ꢋꢋꢈꢂ-XQJꢅꢂ .ꢈ:ꢈꢅꢂ -DQGDꢅꢂ .ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂ 6DQILOLSSRꢅꢂ 3ꢈ-ꢈꢅꢂ DQGꢂꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
:DFKWHUꢅꢂ0ꢈꢅꢂ%LRRUJꢂꢀ 0HGꢂꢀ &KHPꢂꢀ /HWWꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢄꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢄꢅꢂꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢃꢃꢐꢋꢈꢂ
5
866,$1ꢂꢂ-2851$/ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂ25*$1,&ꢂꢂ&+(0,675<ꢂꢂꢂ9ROꢈꢂꢂꢌꢃꢂꢂꢂ1Rꢈꢂꢂꢒꢂꢂꢂꢃꢁꢁꢄꢂ

&
$7$/<7,&ꢂꢂ6<17+(6,6ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂꢋꢇ$5</(7+</3+263+21$7(6ꢂꢂ
ꢀꢀꢆꢂ
ꢋꢃꢈꢂ/Rꢅꢂ &ꢈꢇ+ꢈ/ꢈꢅꢂ :HQWZRUWKꢅꢂ 3ꢈꢅꢂ -XQJꢅꢂ .ꢈ:ꢈꢅꢂ <RRQꢅꢂ -ꢈꢅꢂ ꢃꢋꢈꢂ.XFKHURYꢅꢂ $ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ )LQDVKLQDꢅꢂ (ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂ .UDPDUHYDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
$VKOH\ꢅꢂ-ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ-DQGDꢅꢂ.ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ$Pꢂꢀ&KHPꢂꢀ6RFꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢒꢅꢂ
YROꢈꢂꢋꢋꢀꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢋꢁꢃꢆꢋꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
5RJDFKHYDꢅꢂ9ꢈ%ꢈꢅꢂ=H]LQꢅꢂ$ꢈ%ꢈꢅꢂ6DLGꢇ*DOL\HYꢅꢂ(ꢈ(ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ
.XVWRYꢅꢂ/ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ0DFURPROꢂꢀ6\PSꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢎꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢁꢌꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢋꢒꢆꢈꢂ
ꢃꢃꢈꢂ.UDPDUHYDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ 6WDNKHHYꢅꢂ $ꢈ<Xꢈꢅꢂ 7NDFKHQNRꢅꢂ 2ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢋꢎꢈꢂ'DWWDꢅꢂ$ꢈꢅꢂ:HQWZRUWKꢅꢂ3ꢈꢅꢂ6KDZꢅꢂ-ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ6LPHRQRYꢅꢂ$ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
.OHPHQW¶HYꢅꢂ.ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ*UXQHUWꢅꢂ:ꢈꢅꢂ)LQDVKLQDꢅꢂ(ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ
.XVWRYꢅꢂ/ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ0ROꢂꢀ&DWDOꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢌꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢁꢀꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢀꢒꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
-DQGDꢅꢂ .ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂ -ꢂꢀ $Pꢂꢀ &KHPꢂꢀ 6RFꢈꢅꢂ ꢋꢀꢀꢀꢅꢂ YROꢈꢂ ꢋꢃꢋꢅꢂꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢋꢁꢌꢄꢋꢈꢂ
ꢃꢎꢈꢂ,VDHYDꢅꢂ9ꢈꢅꢂ,YDQRYꢅꢂ$ꢈꢅꢂ.R]ORYDꢅꢂ/ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ6KDUIꢅꢂ9ꢈꢅꢂ6WXGꢂꢁꢀ
6XUIꢂꢁꢀ6FLꢁꢀ&DWDOꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢃꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢋꢌꢎꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢌꢎꢆꢈꢂ
ꢃꢌꢈꢂ<LQꢅꢂ0ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ<XDQꢅꢂ*ꢈꢇ/ꢈꢅꢂ:Xꢅꢂ<ꢈꢇ4ꢈꢅꢂ+XDQJꢅꢂ0ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ
ꢋꢌꢈꢂ-RKQVRQꢅꢂ-ꢈ:ꢈꢅꢂ%URG\ꢅꢂ-ꢈ)ꢈꢅꢂ$OH[DQGHUꢅꢂ5ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ3LODUVNLꢅꢂ%ꢈꢅꢂ
DQGꢂ.DWULW]N\ꢅꢂ$ꢈ5ꢈꢅꢂ&KHPꢂꢀ0DWHUꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢁꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢋꢀꢐꢈꢂ
ꢋꢆꢈꢂ*XO\XNLQDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ 'ROJLQDꢅꢂ 7ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ %RQGDUHQNRꢅꢂ *ꢈ1ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢀ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
-LDQJꢅꢂ<ꢈꢇ<ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ 0ROꢂꢀ &DWDOꢂꢀ $ꢈꢀ &KHPꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢀꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢋꢌꢒꢅꢂꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢀꢎꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
%HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ %RQGDUHQNRꢅꢂ 1ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ +HQU\ꢅꢂ -ꢈꢇ&ꢈꢅꢂ
/DYHUJQHꢅꢂ 'ꢈꢅꢂ 5DWRYHORPDQDQDꢇ9LGDOꢅꢂ 9ꢈꢅꢂ DQGꢂꢂ
*HQHWꢅꢂ-ꢈꢇ3ꢈꢅꢂ5XVVꢂꢀ-ꢂꢀ2UJꢂꢀ&KHPꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢃꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢎꢐꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢆꢒꢎꢈꢂ
ꢃꢆꢈꢂ*XLEDOꢅꢂ(ꢈꢅꢂ9RQꢂ2IIHQEHUJꢂ6ZHHQH\ꢅꢂ1ꢈꢅꢂ=LNDQꢅꢂ0ꢈ&ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
9LQFHQWꢅꢂ7ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ7RELQꢅꢂ-ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ,QWꢂꢀ -ꢂꢀ %LROꢂꢀ 0DFURPROꢈꢅꢂ
ꢃꢁꢁꢋꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢐꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢌꢁꢋꢈꢂ
ꢋꢄꢈꢂ&KRꢅꢂ,ꢈ6ꢈꢂDQGꢂ$OSHUꢅꢂ+ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ2UJꢂꢀ&KHPꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢌꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢆꢀꢅꢂꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢌꢁꢃꢒꢈꢂ
ꢋꢒꢈꢂ*RXOLRXNLQDꢅꢂ 1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ 'ROJLQDꢅꢂ 7ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ %HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
ꢃꢄꢈꢂ6DIRQRYDꢅꢂ7ꢈ<Dꢈꢅꢂ*XO\XNLQDꢅꢂ1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ1RYDNRYVND\Dꢅꢂ<Xꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
$VWDI¶HYꢅꢂ(ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ%RQGDUHQNRꢅꢂ*ꢈ1ꢈꢅꢂ3HWULLꢅꢂ2ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ7VLUOLꢇꢂ
QDꢅꢂ*ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ%HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ(OHNWURNKLPL\Dꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢃꢅꢂ
YROꢈꢂꢎꢐꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢆꢋꢆꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
+HQU\ꢅꢂ-ꢈꢇ&ꢈꢅꢂ/DYHUJQHꢅꢂ'ꢈꢅꢂ5DWRYHORPDQDQDꢇ9LGDOꢅꢂ9ꢈꢅꢂ
DQGꢂ*HQHWꢅꢂ-ꢈꢇ3ꢈꢅꢂ7HWUDKHGURQꢈꢀ$V\PPHWU\ꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢋꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢋꢃꢅꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢎꢋꢀꢈꢂ
ꢃꢒꢈꢂ6PLUQRYDꢅꢂ1ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂ*XO\XNLQDꢅꢂ1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ$VWDI¶HYꢅꢂ(ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ3HWꢇꢂ
ꢋꢐꢈꢂ*RXOLRXNLQDꢅꢂ1ꢈ6ꢈꢅꢂ'ROJLQDꢅꢂ7ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ%RQGDUHQNRꢅꢂ*ꢈ1ꢈꢅꢂ
ꢂ
ꢀ
ULLꢅꢂ2ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ7VLUOLQDꢅꢂ*ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ%HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ(OHNWURꢇ
NKLPL\DꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢃꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢎꢐꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢒꢁꢆꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
ꢂ
%HOHWVND\Dꢅꢂ ,ꢈ3ꢈꢅꢂ ,O\LQꢅꢂ 0ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ 'DYDQNRYꢅꢂ 9ꢈ$ꢈꢅꢂ DQGꢂ
3IDOW]ꢅꢂ $ꢈꢅꢂ 7HWUDKHGURQꢈꢀ $V\PPHWU\ꢅꢂ ꢃꢁꢁꢎꢅꢂ YROꢈꢂ ꢋꢌꢅꢂꢂ
Sꢈꢂꢋꢎꢀꢒꢈꢂ
ꢃꢐꢈꢂ5XL]ꢅꢂ0ꢈꢅꢂ6DVWUHꢅꢂ$ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ*XLEDOꢅꢂ(ꢈꢅꢂ5HDFWꢂꢀ )XQFꢂꢀ
3RO\PꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢁꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢌꢆꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢋꢆꢆꢈꢂ
ꢃꢀꢈꢂ<RVKL]XNDꢅꢂ.ꢈꢅꢂ/RXꢅꢂ=KꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ,QRXHꢅꢂ.ꢈꢅꢂ5HDFWꢂꢀ )XQFꢂꢀ
3RO\PꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢁꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢌꢌꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢌꢒꢈꢂ
ꢃꢁꢈꢂ)LQDVKLQDꢅꢂ(ꢈ'ꢈꢅꢂ.UDPDUHYDꢅꢂ1ꢈ9ꢈꢅꢂDQGꢂ.XVWRYꢅꢂ/ꢈ0ꢈꢅꢂ ꢎꢁꢈꢂ0X]]DUHOOLꢅꢂ 5ꢈ$ꢈ$ꢈꢂ DQGꢂ =DWWRQLꢅꢂ $ꢈꢅꢂ ,QWꢂꢀ -ꢂꢀ %LROꢂꢀ
0DFURPROꢂꢀ6\PSꢈꢅꢂꢃꢁꢁꢎꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢃꢁꢌꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢃꢁꢆꢈꢂ
0DFURPROꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢐꢄꢅꢂYROꢈꢂꢐꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢋꢎꢒꢈꢂ
ꢀ
ꢋꢀꢈꢂ$OGHDꢅꢂ5ꢈꢂDQGꢂ$OSHUꢅꢂ+ꢈꢅꢂ-ꢂꢀ 2UJDQRPHWꢂꢀ &KHPꢈꢅꢂꢋꢀꢀꢐꢅꢂ
YROꢈꢂꢆꢆꢋꢅꢂSꢈꢂꢎꢌꢀꢈꢂ
ꢂ
ꢀ
ꢂ
ꢀ
5
866,$1ꢂꢂ-2851$/ꢂꢂ2)ꢂꢂ25*$1,&ꢂꢂ&+(0,675<ꢂꢂꢂ9ROꢈꢂꢂꢌꢃꢂꢂꢂ1Rꢈꢂꢂꢒꢂꢂꢂꢃꢁꢁꢄꢂ