Study of the Addition of Monoalkylphosphonic Acids
J . Org. Chem., Vol. 66, No. 11, 2001 3771
phorated 1:1 adducts 3 and 4, versus time (the secondary
phosphorated derivatives were taken into account in the
calculation of the proportions, but they are not repre-
sented on the graphs).
These graphs show, as well without solvent as in
chloroform, that the reaction is excessively fast since a
significant ethephon consumption, about 50%, is observed
immediatly after the start of the reaction. Thereafter, the
ethephon consumption does not progress any more, which
is explained by the rearrangement reactions of part of
the oxirane rings (the increase of ethephon content of
about 10%, which is noticed during the first 30 min of
the reaction carried out in chloroform is probably due
to the hydrolysis of part of the phosphorated 1:1 ad-
ducts according to eq 9). It is especially significant to
note that it is the regioisomer 4, that is the 1:1 adduct
with the phosphorated group fixed on the most substi-
tuted carbon of the oxirane, which really results from
the addition of 1 onto 2, whereas this same regioisomer
is not present after 24 h of reaction. It is also impor-
tant to specify that the totality of 1 is consumed during
the first minutes of the reaction, which explains why
the proportion of residual ethephon remains almost
constant thereafter, this proportion corresponding to that
of 1 transformed in nonphosphorated secondary deriva-
tives.
F igu r e 6. 1H, 31P, and 13C NMR characteristics of 3 (CDCl3,
δ in ppm).
F igu r e 7. Secondary products derived from 2 obtained during
the reaction of 1 with 2.
mixture (Figure 1) from their specific chemical shifts
beforehand obtained from the bibliography (in the case
of 6 and 79) or after synthesis of the compound (in the
case of 8 prepared by addition of water onto 2 catalyzed
by cerium ammonium nitrate10).
The secondary derivatives that represent about 51%
of the compounds obtained from 2 are distributed as
follows: 43.6% of 8, 5.5% of 7, and 1.8% of 6 (determined
from the intensities of the respective characteristic
signals noticed on the 1H NMR spectrum). Consequently,
only 49% of 2 was really transformed in phosphorated
adducts.
Kin etic Stu d y of th e Ad d ition of 1 on to 2. The
evolution of the reactional mixture composition versus
time was followed by 31P NMR, by comparing the intensi-
ties of the various peaks characteristic of the phospho-
rated products present in the mixture. To stop the
reaction, each sample was plunged into a bath main-
tained at -40 °C until NMR analyses that were also
carried out at low temperature (-20 °C).
Thereafter, an evolution of the mixture composition in
1:1 phosphorated adducts formed is noticed since the
initially formed regioisomer 4 disappears gradually to
reach a final proportion of 5%. At the same time, the
dioxaphospholanes 5 and the regioisomer 3 appear within
the first seconds of the reaction. As the global proportion
in dioxaphospholanes increases during the first 2 h and
then decreases, that of the regioisomer 3 follows a
constant increase during the time to reach respectively
30% after 8 h of reaction in CDCl3 and 25% without
solvent.
Consequently, the formation of the dioxaphospholanes
5 and afterward, that of the 1:1 adduct 3 in which the
phosphorated entity is on the less substituted carbon of
the oxirane ring, would be the result of several successive
conversions from the regiosiomer 4 initially formed.
Because the proportions of dioxaphospholane adducts 5
decrease after 2 h of reaction, it was deduced that the
formation of the regiosiomer 3 observed after long dura-
tions of reaction occurred from the dioxaphospholane
intermediate.
The kinetic studies were realized without solvent
(Figure 8, graph A) and then in CDCl3 (Figure 8, graph
1
B). H and 31P NMR spectra were obtained in CDCl3.
The analysis of the 31P NMR spectra of samples taken
at different times showed the presence of four main
phosphorated adducts, that is one more than in the final
mixture after 24 h of reaction. The secondary phospho-
rated derivatives also formed during the addition of 1
onto 2 are minority (∼10% of the totality of the organo-
phosphorated compounds for the reaction carried out in
the absence of solvent and ∼5% for that carried out in
chloroform).
From these results, a mechanism was suggested (Fig-
ure 10). The addition of ethephon on the epoxides would
occur according to the following way. Initially, after acid
activation of the oxirane ring, a regioselective binding of
the phosphorated group on the most hindred carbon of
the oxirane ring, that is the most stable carbocation, leads
to the 1:1 adduct 4. Thereafter, 4 gives the dioxaphos-
pholane 5 by elimination of a molecule of water.6 The
dioxaphospholane adduct 5, very sensitive to acid hy-
drolysis, can then generate the regioisomer 3 which is
more stable than 4 (Figure 10).
The 31P NMR analysis of the sample taken immediatly
after the start of the reaction was surprising because it
revealed the instantaneous formation of high proportions
of the regioisomer corresponding to the fixation of the
phosphorated group on the more substituted carbon of
the oxirane, that is 4 (Figure 9). Until now, the adduct 4
was not identified in the crude mixtures characterized
after 24 h of reaction, because it is immediately trans-
formed into dioxaphospholane.
The secondary reactions can be easily explained ac-
cording to the acidity of the reaction medium and the
presence of water formed in situ during the cyclization
step which leads to the dioxaphospholane structure
(Figure 10). The ketone 6 and the allylic alcohol 7 result
from a rearrangement of the epoxide, a well-known
reaction that can occur in acid medium11-13 (eq 8). The
The kinetic curves (Figure 8) show the evolution of the
contents in ethephon 1, dioxaphospholanes 5, 1:1 phos-
(9) Pouchet, C. J .; Behnke, J . The Aldrich Library of 13C and 1H
NMR, 1993.
(10) Iranpoor, N.; Baltork, I. M.; Zardaloo, F. S. Tetrahedron 1991,
47(47), 9861.