Organic Letters
Letter
product 3mc could be detected. Considering the substituents
with different electronic properties, these observations further
indicated that electron-withdrawing substituents in the phenyl
and electron-donating groups in the isoquinoline could enhance
the reactivity. 1,3-Indanedione could also react with these
substrates well to form spiro structures with relatively lower
yields, which might be due to its poor nucleophilic ability and
high steric hindrance (3jd, 3od, and 3pd). However, ethyl
acetoacetate, benzoyl acetonitrile, p-trifluoromethylphenylace-
tonitrile, or acetylacetone was not reactive under the catalytic
system presented here.
The aforementioned results have shown that indoline-fused
tetrahydroisoquinolines can be constructed from N-phenyl-
tetrahydroisoquinolines and appropriate nucleophiles over an
available CuCoFe-LDH catalyst. Furthermore, the trans-
formation of the geminal dinitriles in the resultant indoline-
fused tetrahydroisoquinoline 3aa has been tried (Scheme 4).
the substrate. Furthermore, the surface copper valence for
CuCoFe-LDH was identified through XPS spectra. As illustrated
in Figure S8, the core fitting peaks of Cu 2p3/2 could be fitted at
932.7 and 934.6 eV, indicating the mixed valence of Cu+ and
Cu2+.12 To identify the effect of the valence of copper species,
CuCl and CuCl2 were tested in the reaction (entries 8 and 9,
respectively). Excellent catalytic activity for the transformation
of 1a could be obtained, but the selectivity for 3aa were quite
low, giving 6a as the main product (78% yield), consistent with
previously reported results.13 In contrast, only a trace of 6a was
observed in the case of CuCoFe-LDH. These results suggested
that Cu species (both Cu+ and Cu2+) accelerate the trans-
formation of 1a, but the combination of Cu, Co, and Fe is
essential for the formation of 3aa. Therefore, a synergistic effect
among Cu, Co, and Fe probably exists in this transformation.
Radical scavengers [BHT (2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol)
and CCl3Br] significantly suppressed the reaction (entries 10
and 11, respectively), implying that a radical intermediate
probably forms during the reaction.
Scheme 4. Transformation of the Resultant Indoline-Fused
Tetrahydroisoquinoline 3aa
In the classical CDC transformation, iminium has been
proven to be the intermediate,14 which was also verified by the
MS-ESI analysis of the reaction filtrate without any nucleophile
(Figure S9) in the study presented here. Kinetic isotopic effect
(KIE) experiments were also conducted to gain further
information about the catalytic domino reaction (Scheme 5).
Scheme 5. Kinetic Isotopic Effect Experiments
Oxidative treatment of 3aa under the CuCl2/TBHP (tert-butyl
hydroperoxide) oxidation conditions led to methyl 2-[1-oxo-
3,4-dihydroisoquinolin-2(1H)-yl]benzoate (5a) with a high
yield of 81%. To the best of our knowledge, the cleavage mode
has not been reported, and the structure of 5a has been
confirmed by X-ray analysis. Then, we carried out the reductive
elimination in toluene using AIBN (azodiisobutyronitrile) and
tributyltin hydride as a reducing system,11 and an excellent 93%
yield of 5,6-dihydroindolo[2,1-a]isoquinoline-12-carbonitrile
(5b) was obtained. These transformations will facilitate further
application of the protocol presented here. Moreover, when the
reaction of 1a was scaled up to 1.05 g (5.0 mmol), a satisfactory
55% yield of 3aa could be obtained (Scheme S3), demonstrating
the good practicability of the protocol.
To elucidate the catalytic behavior of CuCoFe-LDH, a series
of controlled experiments were carried out (Table S3). In the
absence of a catalyst, 67% conversion and 12% selectivity to 3aa
were detected (entry 2), indicating the catalytic function of
CuCoFe-LDH. The results of the experiments performed under
different atmospheres (entries 3 and 4) suggested that oxygen is
crucial for the efficient transformation. To identify the active
catalytic site, some hydrotalcite-like compounds with different
cations in the brucite layers have been investigated (XRD
patterns can be found in Figure S7). Although CuMgAl-LDH
and CuCoAl-LDH exhibited excellent catalytic activity for the
transformation of 1a (entries 5 and 6, respectively), the
selectivity to 3aa was quite low. In the case of Co2Fe-LDH,
both conversion and selectivity were markedly low (entry 7),
implying that Cu species played an important role in activating
When 2-phenyl-1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline-1-d (1a-d1) was
subjected to the reaction, an intramolecular isotopic kH/kD of 3.3
was calculated from the ratio of the signal intensity in the GC-
MS analysis (Scheme 5i). This observation suggested a more
important contribution from C−H bond cleavage than from
electron transfer in the rate-determining step,15 and a hydrogen
atom transfer (HAT) process should occur predominantly for
C−H bond cleavage. An obvious secondary kinetic isotope
effect on the benzene ring (intermolecular kH/kD = 2.1)
indicated that C−C bond formation occurs before C−H bond
cleavage (Scheme 5ii).16
Then, we focused on the catalytic behavior of CuCoFe-LDH
in the transformation of 4aa to 3aa (Table S4). Without a
catalyst, an only 13% conversion and 67% selectivity were
observed (entry 2),17 indicating the catalytic activity of
CuCoFe-LDH in the cyclization. The reaction proceeded well
with decreased reactivity in the absence of oxygen (entry 3),
which might be due to the adsorbed oxygen on the catalyst. The
control experiments with different catalysts suggested that the
Cu+ was crucial for this coupling between Csp3−H and Csp2−H.
6323
Org. Lett. 2021, 23, 6321−6325