L. Chen, et al.
Bioorganic&MedicinalChemistry28(2020)115596
towards α-Syn aggregation. Based on our previous work,4 The ThT
fluorescence maximum emission wavelength were optimized as 482 nm
(λem = 482 nm) under excitation light at 450 nm (λex = 450 nm). The
method of inhibitory activities investigation of compounds was de-
scribed in supporting materials. The ThT FI of blank group was mea-
sured without compound, and thereby obtained the maximal FI. The FI
value of blank group was set as 1 (100%). The ratio of FI of the tested
system within compound to that of blank group was defined as the
relative fluorescence intensity (RFI) (Fig. 1). In fact, there was a posi-
tive correlation between the percent reduction of RFI and the inhibitory
activity of the evaluated compound.
Scheme 1. Reported natural phenolic acid inhibitors on α-Syn aggregation.
In detail, the RFIs of first series of compounds—fluorobenzoyl p-
phenylenediamines (1aa-1fe) were shown in Fig. 1A. The RFIs of
methyl-protected-GA (1ga-1gi and 2aa-2ba, except 2bb) were shown
in Fig. 1B. More importantly, Fig. 1C showed the RFIs of mono- or di-
GA and other mono-acyl p-phenylenediamines without GA component
as control (1b-1f and 2a-2b). In order to describe the inhibition activity
more conveniently, the ThT RFI was transformed to α-Syn aggregation
inhibition ratio by the formula: α-Syn aggregation inhibition
ratio = 100% (RFI of blank group)-x% (RFI of compound group). In
summary, the lower RFI corresponding to the higher inhibitory activity
against α-Syn aggregation, thereby the ratio intuitively reflected the
modification of GA which enhance its lipophilicity and anti-aggregation
performance on α-Syn, should be an efficient approach to discover
novel inhibitors of α-Syn aggregation.
Based on the present evidence above and our hypothesis,4 we focus
on design suitable small molecules containing phenolic acids, which
have strong binding force with the core of non-amyloid-beta component
(NACore), interfere with the formation of β-sheets structure, block the
formation of oligomer nuclei in early stage, and further prevent the
development of α-Syn fibrillation. In the present work, a series of amide
derivatives of GA and other phenolic acids were design and synthesized,
which possess sheet-like conjugated structure and suitable LogP value.
Their inhibitory activities against α-Syn aggregation were evaluate and
the structure–activity-relationship (SAR) studies were studied.
ratio towards α-Syn aggregation from 1.9% to 42.1%. Compounds 1ab-
1ae were comprised of benzoyl and fluorobenzoyl moieties liked by p-
phenylenediamine, and only 1ae containing block of tetrafluorobenzoyl
displayed more than 30% inhibition ratio (31.2%). Compounds 1fb-1fe
were comprised of (E)-3-(pyridin-4-yl)acryloyl and fluorobenzoyl moi-
eties, among of which, 1fc and 1fd displayed 42.1% and 31.4% in-
hibition ratio, respectively. Apparently, 1fc containing 2,4-di-
fluorobenzoyl has shown better inhibitory activity than 1fd. Other
compounds containing bi-fluorobenzoyl blocks have shown lower in-
hibitory activities.
2. Results and discussion
2.1. Chemistry
Based on our previous work,4 we designed a series of aromatic
amide derivatives, which possess sheet-like conjugated structure as the
potential inhibitor of α-Syn aggregation. The first series of compounds
was unilateral or bilateral flurobenzoyl p- phenylenediamines (1a-1f
and 1aa-1fe). As our main goal, the second series of compounds con-
taining phenolic acyl were designed as N-acyl p-phenylenediamines and
N,N'-diacyl p-phenylenediamines (1g-1gi and 2aa-2ba). Furthermore,
as the most impotant analogues with exposed hydroxyl, 3g, 3gd-3gi
and 4aa-4ba were prepared via demethylation reaction.
From Table 2, compounds 1ga-1gi contain block of methyl-pro-
tested gallic acyl on one side, and on the other side, the blocks are
substituted benzoyls groups or (E)-3-(pyridin-4-yl)acryloyl. Compound
1gd with (E)-3-(pyridin-4-yl)acryloyl demonstrated slight higher ratio
(33.5%) than 1ga, 1gb, 1gc and 1gf, which contain benzoyl or fluor-
obenzoyl on the same side (17.7%, 11.8%, 10.4% and 4.9%). For-
tunately, compound 1gi, N,N’-di(3,4,5-trimethoxybenzoyl) p-phenyle-
nediamine, has shown good inhibitory activity (83.4%).
Firstly, the N-acyl p-phenylenediamine compounds as intermediates
(1a-1g and 2a-2b) were prepared from p-phenylenediamine and dif-
ferent carboxylic acids, such as fluorobenzoic acids, 3,4,5-trimethox-
ybenzoic acid, sulfonic acids and (E)-3-(pyridin-4-yl)acrylic acid via
mono-acylation in medium yields. These reactions were carry out using
2-(7-azobenzotriazole)-N, N, N', N'-tetramethylurea hexafluoropho-
sphate (HATU) as coupling agent and triethylamine as base.13 Fur-
thermore, N,N'-diacyl p-phenylenediamines were synthesized by the
similar approaches. Compound 1aa-1gi and 2aa-2bb were obtained
from 1a to 1g and 2a-2b via further acylation under HATU/ triethy-
lamine in medium to high yields (Scheme 2).
Compounds 2aa-2ba contain block of methyl-protested gallic acyl
on one side, and on the other side, sulfonyls. Tosylate analogue 2aa
showed better ratio than 2ba, which possessed pyridine-3-sulfonyl
group (34.1% vs 22.7%). In particular, compound 2bb, N,N’-di(pyr-
idine-3-sulfonyl) p-phenylenediamine, has shown medium inhibitory
activity (57.2%).
Table 3 indicated various inhibitory activities with different amide
derivatives of GA. Firstly, mono-amide derivatives of p-phenylenedia-
mine, 1f, 1b and 1c displayed the decreasing trend of inhibitory ac-
tivities (42.4%, 34.1% and 16.6%). Mono-sulfonamide derivatives 2a
and 2b, also showed low ratio (15.9% and 15.4%). Noticeably, they all
have lower inhibitory activities than that of GA (78.2%). On the con-
trary, 3g (N-gallic acyl p-phenylenediamine) demonstrated a higher
activity (84.2%) than GA.
and 4aa-4ba) were obtained by demethylation of 1g, 1gd-1gi and 2aa-
2ba respectively under boron tribromide in medium to high yields
2.2. Biological evaluation
2.2.1. In vitro inhibitory activities of the synthesized compounds against α-
Syn aggregation by ThT fluorescence assay
For the bi-amide derivatives, 3gd-3gi and 4aa-4ba have shown
medium to high inhibitory activities from 39.0% to 94.4%. Compounds
3gd-3gi contained one block of gallic acyl and another block of sub-
stituted benzoyl. Among these analogues, 3gf containing fluorobenzoyl
groups displayed outstanding activity comparing with its corresponding
precursor 1gf (Table 2) (85.8% vs 4.9%). The similar trend was found
in 3gd and 1gd (48.9% vs 33.5%). Surprisingly, 3gi which containing
two identical gallic acyl groups displayed lower ratio comparing with
Thioflavin T (ThT) fluorescence assay is a valid method to evaluate
the inhibitory activities of compounds against α-Syn aggregation. ThT
shows weak fluorescence intensity (FI) in monomeric α-Syn, α-Syn
oligomer nuclei or in α-Syn fibril-free system. On the contrary, ThT
displays strong FI in the presence of α-Syn fibrils. ThT FI can quanti-
tatively reflect the kinetics and abilities of compounds inhibiting
2