Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
The possible reaction mechanisms leading to cyclopro-
panes and the kinetically unusual formation of ethylene were
examined on a model system by means of DFT calculations
(Figure 3). Initially, a purely dissociative mechanism analo-
gous to the proposed formation of carbenes from carbenoids
of Pd[28] and Ni[29] was considered. Complete dissociation of
the triflate anion from the activated carbenoid 12 leads to the
formation of a gold methylidene 13 from which cyclopropa-
nation of norbornene can occur without an apparent barrier
(Supporting Information, Figure S31). This scenario is how-
ever unlikely as the energy required to split a neutral
molecule into two charged species is prohibitively high
(70.9 kcalmolÀ1). Nevertheless, a species corresponding to
cationic [(JohnPhos)AuCH2]+ could be experimentally
detected upon ESI-MS of 1a, suggesting that in sufficiently
energetic conditions gold(I) carbenes can be accessed from
stable carbenoids.
Cyclopropanation can alternatively occur via a three-
centered transition state TS-I, in analogy to the Simmons–
Smith reaction,[31] leading to [LAuOTf] (14) and cyclopro-
pane 4b (Figure 3). This pathway is energetically accessible
and can be considered competent for the formation of
cyclopropanes. Alternative mechanisms involving reductive
elimination from metallacyclobutane[32] structures were also
considered but found to be unlikely (Supporting Information,
Figure S33). No path for the formation of ethylene from two
carbenoids 12 could be located. It should be noted that, to the
best of our knowledge, no homocoupling of a Simmons–Smith
carbenoid has been reported to date. Ethylene most probably
arises from the coupling of two bridging methylene units in
a dimeric structure as originally proposed for Re[22] and Sc[33]
methylidenes and found experimentally in well-characterized
Co[34] and Rh[35] complexes (Scheme 5).
oxidative addition.[37] The AuI center in this intermediate can
perform an intramolecular SN2 type attack on the CH2OTf
moiety bound to the AuIII center over TS-III, yielding 17 in
a second oxidative addition step. Since the formation of 15
(RDS according to our calculations) and the ethylene
extrusion are both unimolecular reactions, the experimentally
observed first order decay of 7a can be rationalized in terms
of our proposed mechanism. The difference in activation
energies for cyclopropanation and ethylene formation pro-
cesses accounts for the observed reactivity pattern, while
cyclopropanations can be performed at very low temper-
atures, ethylene generation only reaches completion after
more than one hour at room temperature.
In summary, we have developed a simple method for the
preparation of well-defined gold(I) carbenoids [LAuCH2Cl]
that, upon activation with a chloride scavenger, exhibit the
reactivity expected from gold carbenes in solution, that is,
homocoupling, olefin cyclopropanation, and Buchner reac-
tion. We expect these complexes to become a useful tool for
the examination and mechanistic understanding of processes
involving gold carbenes in solution, particularly elusive
methylidenes, which have been so far primarily studied in
the gas phase.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge funding from MINECO (CTQ2013-42106-P,
Severo Ochoa Excellence Accreditation 2014–2018, SEV-
2013-0319, and FPI fellowship to C.G.M.), the European
Research Council (Advanced Grant No. 321066), the
AGAUR (2014 SGR 818), Swiss National Science Foundation
(Early Postdoc. Mobility fellowship to J.M.S.T.), and CERCA
Programme/ Generalitat de Catalunya. We thank Prof. Pedro
J. Pꢁrez and Dr. Manuel R. Fructos at CIQSO (University of
Huelva) for their help in the quantification of gaseous
ethylene. We also thank the reviewers of this manuscript for
their valuable suggestions, Dr. Dirk Spiegel for additional
work, and the help of the ICIQ X-ray and NMR research
support units.
To reach the analogous dimeric structure 17 (Figure 3),
from which ethylene can be generated with a low energy
barrier over transition state TS-IV, we propose the involve-
ment of the neutral gold carbene 15. This species can be
formed by migration of the triflate anion from the carbon
atom to the gold center via TS-II. Intermediate 15 exhibits
a distorted trigonal planar geometry around gold center and
À
a short Au CH2 bond length (1.906 vs. 2.087 ꢀ in 12). Triflate
À
remains coordinated to gold as evidenced by the Au O
distance (2.281 vs. 2.101 ꢀ in 14). Three-gold(I) complexes
bearing two neutral ligands and one halogen are known and
have been structurally characterized.[36] The analogous spe-
cies 15b could be located using the complete JohnPhos ligand
and despite the increased steric demand imposed by the full
ligand 15b lies only 28.8 kcalmolÀ1 above the parent carbe-
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Keywords: Buchner reaction · carbenes · carbenoids ·
cyclopropanation · gold
noid 7a (Supporting Information, Figure S35). Carbene 15
I
À
can react with one molecule of carbenoid 12 to yield the Au
AuIII dimer 16 without an apparent barrier by a formal
[1] B. K. Carpenter, J. N. Harvey, A. J. Orr-Ewing, J. Am. Chem.
455; c) G. H. W. Andrew, Curr. Org. Synth. 2006, 3, 499 – 555.
4533 – 4551; b) Y. Wang, M. E. Muratore, A. M. Echavarren,
Scheme 5. Reported formation of ethylene from well-characterized
dimeric complexes of Co[34] and Rh[35] containing two bridging methyl-
ene units.
4
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!