G Model
CCLET-3457; No. of Pages 5
Z.-L. Zhou et al. / Chinese Chemical Letters xxx (2015) xxx–xxx
3
Table 3
[C3SO3HDoMim]HSO4 was the most efficient one, giving the
highest yield.
Synthesis of pyrimidinones 4(a–j) from aromatic aldehydes, cyclopentanone and
urea.a
As shown in Table 1 (entries 1–6), in the absence of IL, the yield
was only 49% using sulfuric acid as catalyst. The IL, [C3SO3H-
Doim]HSO4, was found to give the best result at 80 8C compared
with other imidazolium salt-based ILs such as [HMim]HSO4 and
[C3SO3HMim]HSO4, or hyamine-based ILs. The possible reason for
this was that [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4 with
a distinct sulfonic
functional group and long carbon chain could make it soluble in
organic phase, which was beneficial for the interactions between
catalyst and substrates. On the other hand, imidazole cation could
form coordination bonds with the carbonyl oxygen, which
performed better than the hyamine ion. With [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4
as a model catalyst, the screening of catalyst loading was then
carried out. The result revealed that 5 mmol% was the most
suitable proportion, more loading or less could not enhance the
product yield (entries 6–9). Reaction temperature significantly
affected the reaction. The rise of the temperature from 50 8C to
80 8C led to an increased yield from 73% to 80% (entries 6 and 10),
while a decreased yield was obtained when the temperature was
over 100 8C (entries 11 and 12). Then the impact of reaction time
on yield (entries 6 and 13–15) was investigated and the highest
yield was obtained after 1 h. These results indicated that lower
temperature and shorter reaction time may result in incomplete
reaction while overheating and prolonged time led to complicated
side reactions.
Entry
Ar
Time (h)
Yield (%)b
Product
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Ph
1
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
80
4a
4b
4c
4d
4e
4f
p-CH(CH3)2Ph
p-CH3OPh
o-CH3OPh
m-CH3OPh
o-ClPh
59(54)c
75(70)c
77
66
76
m-ClPh
82
4g
4h
4i
p-ClPh
85
m-NO2Ph
p-NO2Ph
89
96
4j
a
Reaction conditions: aldehyde/urea/cyclopentanone = 2:1:1, 5 mmol [C3SO3H-
Doim]HSO4 relative to aromatic aldehyde, 80 8C.
b
Yields refer to those of purified isolated products characterized by spectro-
scopic data (1H NMR).
c
The reaction time was run for 1 h.
The ratio of benzaldehyde, urea and cyclopentanone should be
2:1:1 to produce pyrimidinones in theory. To explore the influence
of the ratio on this reaction, we attempted to modify the ratio in
various ways. Corresponding control reactions were performed
and the results indicated that even when the amount of
cyclopentanone or urea was doubled, there is almost no increase
in yield (entries 6 and 16–19). In other words, excessively used
cyclopentanone and urea barely enhanced the yield with the
participation of [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4, which is contrasted to the
research of Zhang [16].
In addition, using [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4 as a catalyst, the effect of
gas and solvent on the reaction was also investigated, as shown in
Table 2. N2 was used as a protection gas to screen the reaction
conditions compared with air (entries 1 and 2). The results showed
that N2 protection could increase the yield. In other words,
materials in air containing CO2, O2, H2O, etc. did not have an
influence on the Biginelli-type reaction. Besides, four common
organic reagents, such as toluene, benzene, n-hexane, n-heptane,
were chosen as solvents in this reaction (entries 3–6). It was found
that solvent-free condition under atmosphere gave the best result
with a yield of 80% after 1 h. A probable reason would be that
solvation effect hindered the catalytic effect of IL. So N2 protection
and organic solvent could be avoided to afford a simple and green
process. Thus the reaction worked well while being exposed to air
under solvent-free conditions.
Several substituted aromatic aldehydes were applied to this
condensation reaction with cyclopentanone and urea to produce
corresponding pyrimidinones. The results were summarized in
Table 3. Aromatic aldehydes with both electron donating (entries
2–5) and electron withdrawing groups (entries 6–10) could
participate this reaction effectively. Aldehydes with electron
withdrawing groups reacted with cyclopentanone and urea
smoothly to give the corresponding products in higher yields
compared with the ones with electron donating groups. So we
attempted to prolong the reaction time moderately for aldehydes
with electron donating groups to increase the yields as much as
possible (entries 2–5). In addition, the high stereo-hindrance effect
was another vital reason for the relatively low yield as seen in the
case of para-isopropylbenzaldehyde. We found that the nature and
position of substitution on the aryl ring did have an influence on
reactivity. Apparently, substrates with strong electron-withdraw-
ing group (entries 9 and 10) gave evidently increased yields,
compared with the weak ones (entries 6–8). In addition, the para-
substituted aldehyde could afford a higher yield than the meta- and
ortho-substituted ones. So it was proposed that as for the attack of
carbon in aldehyde group by nucleophilic species, benzaldehyde
with electron-withdrawing substituent group was easier than that
with the electron-donating one.
Considering the widespread use of sulfur-containing inter-
mediates in the medical fields [24], thiourea was used in place of
urea in this reaction. Under the optimized conditions, the synthesis
of pyrimidinones with aromatic aldehydes, cyclopentanone and
thiourea was achieved, as shown in Table 4. In view of electronic
effect, sulfur exhibited stronger electron-donating ability than
oxygen. Thus, unlike urea, reactions of thiourea proceeded
smoothly to give targeted products in yields ranging from 66%
to 90% with high purity. But reaction time would be prolonged to
achieve a higher yield. We believed that expanding the reaction
from urea to thiourea would be meaningful to synthesize
biologically active pyrimidinone scaffolds.
In order to examine the scope and generality of this procedure,
we extended the methodology to different aromatic aldehydes.
Table 2
The effect of solvent and gas on the reaction.a
Entry
Solventb
Gas
Yield (%)c
1
2
3
4
5
6
–
–
80
80
77
77
78
78
–
N2
N2
N2
N2
N2
Toluene
Benzene
n-Hexane
n-Heptane
On the basis of our experimental results and literature
reports about the synthesis of pyrimidinones [16,25], and
previous studies of ILs-catalyzed condensation reactions [26,27],
a possible mechanism for the synthesis of pyrimidinones catalyzed
by [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4 was proposed as shown in Scheme 2.
a
Reaction conditions: benzaldehyde/urea/cyclopentanone = 2:1:1, 80 8C/1 h, the
loading of ILs [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4 (5 mmol) relative to benzaldehyde.
b
The volume of added solvent was 50 mL.
c
Yields refer to those of purified isolated products.
Please cite this article in press as: Z.-L. Zhou, et al., Bronsted acidic ionic liquid [C3SO3HDoim]HSO4 catalyzed one-pot three-component
Biginelli-type reaction: An efficient and solvent-free synthesis of pyrimidinone derivatives and its mechanistic study, Chin. Chem. Lett.