Angewandte
Chemie
(16:1; Table 1, entries 3 and 4). Further experiments revealed
that the use of chiral semicorrin ligands[16] 3c and 3d showed a
significant rate enhancement compared with 3b, while main-
taining an excellent level of asymmetric induction (e.r. = 98:2;
Table 1, entries 5–7). The use of other alcohols did not lead to
further improvement (Table 1, entries 8 and 9). Notably, the
allylation essentially did not proceed in the absence of InI,
and InI3 proved to be substantially less effective (Table 1,
cyclohexyl) proved to be less efficient in terms of asymmetric
induction.
We then examined indium(I)-catalyzed asymmetric cro-
tylation (Table 2). Initial trials with hydrazone 1a and a-
methylallyl boronate rac-5 under our reported conditions,[7c]
Table 2: Asymmetric indium(I)-catalyzed crotylation of 1 with rac-5.
entries 10 and 11).[17]
I
À
We consider this asymmetric In catalysis for C C bond
formation remarkable for a number of reasons: 1) Contrary
to reported reactions of InI halides with Lewis bases
(ligands),[4,5,8] we did not observe disproportionation of
InI.[18] 2) To the best of our knowledge, an enantiomeric
ratio of 98:2 for product 4a is to date the best result for metal-
catalyzed asymmetric allylation of aromatic imine deriva-
tives.[19] 3) These findings reveal the critical role of chiral
ligands (L*) 3a–d in stabilizing the labile InI[4,5,8] and in
creating excellent environments for asymmetric induction.
Entry
1
a/g
a-Adduct 6: R
Yield anti-6/syn-6 e.r.
[%][c]
(anti-6)
1
1a >99:1 6a: Ph
1b >99:1 6b: 4-HOC6H4
85
98
19:1
11:1
19:1
7:1
8:1
11:1
97:3
94:6
96.5:3.5
94.5:5.5
96:4
96.5:3.5
94:6
92:8
2[a]
3
1c >99:1 6c: 4-MeOC6H4 86
1d >99:1 6d: 3-MeOC6H4 90
1h >99:1 6h: 4-MeC6H4
1k >99:1 6k: 3-furyl
1l >99:1 6l: 2-thienyl
1p >99:1 6p: 4-ClC6H4
Next, we investigated the scope of hydrazones
1
4
(Scheme 1). Various aromatic substrates bearing functional-
ities such as free hydroxy, methoxy, tertiary amino, and nitro
groups were allylated in high yields with enantiomeric ratios
of up to 98:2. Furthermore, O-, S-, and N-containing hetero-
cycles proved to be excellent substrates with enantiomeric
ratios of up to 97.5:2.5. Aliphatic hydrazones such as 1o (R =
5[b]
6[b]
7
quant
98
quant 15:1
83 17:1
8
[a] Use of L* 3c: the opposite enantiomer was obtained as the major
enantiomer. [b] Reaction temperature: À208C. [c] Yield of isolated a-
adduct 6 after purification on silica gel (PTLC).
in the presence of various chiral ligands, provided the desired
product 6a with disappointing regio-, diastereo-, and enan-
tioselectivites.[15] After extensive experimentation,[15] high a/g
and anti/syn ratios as well as high asymmetric induction could
be obtained with InI and L* 3d in EtOH (a/g = > 99:1, anti/
syn = 19:1, e.r. = 97:3; Table 2, entry 1). These optimized
reaction conditions were applicable to various hydrazones 1;
all aromatic and heteroaromatic substrates tested were
converted exclusively into a-adducts 6 in high yields with
anti/syn ratios of up to 19:1 and enantiomeric ratios of up to
96.5:3.5 (Table 2, entries 2–8). The present work constitutes
the first systematic crotylation study with a broad variety of
imine derivatives; several characteristic features of this
asymmetric InI catalysis are noteworthy: 1) The unusual
a selectivity[20] observed with rac-5 contrasts its exclusive
g selectivity in the absence of a catalyst[21a] and under Lewis or
Brønsted acid catalysis;[21b,c] this rare a selectivity suggests B-
to-In transmetalation prior to C C bond formation.[22] 2) The
À
use of 5 in racemic form provided enantiomerically enriched
anti-6[15] as the major product; in this context, it is noted that
the preparation of a-substituted allyl boronates of type 5 in
enantiomerically enriched form is not trivial.[23] 3) This
diastereoselective reaction avoids the use of geometrically
enriched or pure crotyl reagents, typically required to
selectively form products of type 6. 4) Our catalytic InI
method provides substantially higher regioselectivity and
configurational selectivities for product 6a compared with a
recently reported stoichiometric In0 Barbier procedure.[24]
Next, we employed a-chloroallyl boronate rac-7 (Table 3),
which is a rarely used nucleophile that adds in the absence of a
Scheme 1. Scope for asymmetric indium(I)-catalyzed allylation of 1
with 2. [a] Yield of (R)-4a–o isolated after purification on silica gel
(PTLC). [b] Reaction temperature was À208C.
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2010, 49, 1838 –1841
ꢀ 2010 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1839