2
T. M. F. Alves et al. / Tetrahedron Letters xxx (2016) xxx–xxx
by silica gel chromatography of 2,5-trans (8a–h) and 2,5-cis
(9a–h) THFs in moderate to poor yields and good diastereoselectiv-
ities in favor of 8a–h (2,5-trans). The relative stereochemistry was
confirmed by NOE experiments of both 8b/9b diastereoisomers.10
Better diastereoselectivities were obtained at 60 °C, but a reduction
in the yield also occurred. When comparing the reaction involving
the compounds 7a and 7h, erosion of diastereoselectivity was
observed for electron-donating aromatic substituents.
HO
O
N
N
(7S,10S)-boivinianin B
N
F
O
O
O
N
N
N
N
Despite the quantitative consumptions of starting materials the
isolated yields after flash chromatography were lower than
expected. We were not able to assess the yields from NMR using
an internal standard of the crude material due to paramagnetic
character of the cobalt catalyst, which produced broad signals in
most cases. To examine these results further, we collected kinetic
information by monitoring the cyclization of alkenols 7b and 7h
at 60 °C via quantitative GC–MS analysis. The consumption of
starting material and formation of cyclized products were moni-
tored and the changes in concentration are plotted as a function
of time in Figure 3. After approximately 2 and 3 h, respectively,
the starting material was completely consumed for the reactions
of 7b and 7h. The amount of products remains unchanged after this
point, with yields of 49% for 7b and 54% for 7h. The achieved
diastereoselectivity ratios were 5.7:1 for 8b:9b and 1.2:1 for
8h:9h. Additionally, the diastereomeric ratios of the products are
nearly constant with respect to conversion.
While the diastereoselectivities obtained from the kinetic
progress were very similar to those obtained from isolated prod-
ucts after silica gel chromatography, the yields decrease by approx.
30–40%. Pagenkopf obtained similar results for 2,5,5-trisubstituted
THF.3c We hypothesize in our case a product decomposition by a
ring opening due to exposure to silica gel through the formation
of a stable tertiary carbocation.
F
N
SCH 45009
Figure 1. Examples of biologically active compound containing 2,2,5-trisubstituted
THF structural motifs.
termination version for construction of the 2a core (Table 1). In this
initial screening, we used 1,4-cyclohexadiene (1,4-CHD) as a
reducing agent (Table 1). The combination of CoL2 (3, 5, or 6)
(Fig. 2), 1,4-CHD (20 equiv) in toluene and open flask conditions
(atmospheric air), catalyzed the reaction to afford the expected
THFs (2a–c) and complete conversion of alkenol 1a after 4 h
(entries 1–3). The mass balance was a critical issue leading us to
suspect that under these conditions we had decomposition of the
starting material and/or product. A more sterically bulky alkenol
could also be associated with the lower selectivity due to repulsive
interaction in catalyst coordination.3c Aiming to improve the
reaction conditions, we systematically varied the concentration.
At lower and higher concentrations (entries
4
and 5,
respectively), we experienced difficulties in achieving acceptable
yields. It is noteworthy that when only 1,4-CHD is used as
solvent, as described by Hartung,5,7 decomposition of the starting
material was observed (entry 6). The best yield was achieved with
0.06 M employing catalyst 5 at 15 mol % (entry 7). We were not
able to reduce the catalyst loading, as 7.5 mol % of 5 lead to a
reduced reaction yield, producing 2a in only 13% (entry 8). No sub-
strate consumption occurred in the absence of O2 and 1,4-CHD
(entry 9). Finally, the alkenol 1b (entry 10) lead to similar results
to 1a, revealing a minor influence of an electron withdrawing
group on aromatic ring on this reaction. However, it was noted a
higher yield for the alkenol 1c (entry 11) possessing an electron
donating group.
Finally, a control experiment was performed in order to verify if
the presence of the catalyst was critical to induction of selectivity.
The alkenol 7g was cyclized in the presence of p-TSA (1 equiv) and
CH2Cl2 (0.06 M), at room temperature affording
a separable
mixture by silica gel chromatography of 8g:9g in 58% yield with
no diastereoselectivity (dr = 1:1), proving the importance of the
catalyst in this reaction.
Oxidative termination
The alkenol 1a0 possessing a trisubstituted double bond also
generated the cyclic product 2a0 in 31% yield (Scheme 3). However,
attempts to lengthen the alkyl chain proved to be unfruitful as no
products were observed with the alkenol 1a00 even after 24 h, with
partial recovery of the starting material.
With the best reaction condition in hand, we next investigated
the diastereoselectivity of the Mukaiyama cyclization with
alkenols 7a–h (Scheme 4). The reaction gave a separable mixture
In a second stage of this study, we explored the oxidative
termination version of the Mukaiyama cyclization. In this screen-
ing, we used catalysts 3–6 (Fig. 2), t-BuOOH as additive, and i-PrOH
as solvent under O2 (1 atm) atmosphere. Surprisingly, as shown in
Table 2, we were unable to obtain the cyclized product 10 under
oxidative termination for alkenols 1a–c. Depending on the cobalt
OH
OH
OH
CoL2, O2
O
R
radical functionalization
R
R
ref 3c
reductor
60-80 ˚C
oxidative termination
reductive termination
dr 2:1 to 5:1
R = alkyl, aryl, alkynyl
CoL2
O2, H2X
X
OH
R'
O
SR
OH
Br
R
CoL2, O2
O2
R'
R
O
O
O
RS-SR
R
R
R
iPrOH
1,4-CHD
ref 4-9
reductor
60-80 ˚C
O
R
dr > 95:5
R' = alkyl, H
BrCCl3
1,4-CHD
EWG
1,4-CHD
X
OH
R
R'
O
1,4-CHD
CoL2, O2
R'
R
H
this work
H
O
reductor
60-80 ˚C
O
R
R
EWG
R' = Aryl
Scheme 1. Synthetic variations of Mukaiyama oxidative cyclization.
Scheme 2. Scope of the Mukaiyama oxidative cyclization.