L. Gentilucci et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 51 (2010) 2576–2579
2577
Table 1
2. Results and discussion
Synthesis of dipeptides Xaa-Trp 3a–d by F-C reaction of indole with dipeptides Xaa-
Dha 2a–d promoted by different Lewis acids, at 0 °C for 24 h in DCM (with the
exception of entries 1 and 2)
As anticipated in the introduction, indoles undergo Friedel-
Crafts (F-C.) alkylation with N-Ac-Dha methyl ester in the presence
Entry
Lewis acid
Equiv
3
Yieldc (%)
S,S/S,R
of Lewis acids, giving racemic 3-indolyl-a
-amino acids.15 Since we
a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Yb(OTf)3
1
1
4
2
4
2
2
2
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
3.5
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
b
b
c
20
55
5
—
22/78
—
—
—
—
—
—
50/50
24/76
45/55
35/65
55/45
62/38
50/50
30/70
were interested in optically pure amino acids, we thought to carry
out a diastereoselective version of this reaction with dipeptides of
type Xaa-Dha, taking advantage of the asymmetric induction ex-
erted by Xaa. The protected dipeptides Xaa-Dha 2 were easily ob-
tained from dipeptides Xaa-serine 1, prepared in turn by standard
in-solution peptide synthesis, using 1-ethyl-3-[3-dimethylamino-
propyl]carbodiimide hydrochloride (EDC-HCl) and 1-hydroxyben-
zotriazole hydrate (HOBt) as activating agents (Supplementary
data). The dehydration of 1 with N,N0-disuccinimidyl carbonate
(DSC) and N,N-diisopropylethylamine (DIPEA) gave 2 in very
good yield,19 isolated by flash chromatography over silica gel
(Scheme 1).
Initially, the reaction was tested with indole. The treatment of
Pro-Dha 2a with a Lewis acid and indole, in the presence of 3 Å
molecular sieves, afforded the protected dipeptide Pro-Trp 3a as
a mixture of diastereoisomers (Scheme 1). Yields and diastereo-
meric ratios strongly varied depending on the Lewis acid selected
(Table 1). In the absence of molecular sieves, the reaction gave var-
iable quantities of by-products arising from peptide bond and/or
ester hydrolysis, as revealed by reversed phase (RP)-HPLC and elec-
tron-spray (ES)-MS analyses. On the other hand, molecular sieves
lead to better yields, while the unreacted starting material was
recovered unaltered.
The diastereomeric ratios of the reaction mixtures (Table 1)
were measured by normal phase-HPLC, with an analytical Kromasil
Diol column. The separation of the diastereoisomers by analytical
RP-HPLC under different conditions was unfeasible. Racemization
was excluded on the basis of chiral HPLC by using a CHIRALPAK
IC column. The configuration of the newly created stereocentre
on Trp was determined by comparison with that of the authentic
samples of (S,S)-3a and (S,R)-3a, prepared by standard peptide syn-
thesis in solution from the commercially available amino acids.
Yields (Table 1) were determined after isolation by flash chroma-
tography over silica gel.
The use of 1 equiv of ZnOTf2, FeCl3, InF3, CeCl3, RuCl3 and
Yb(OTf)3 gave no reaction or traces of the dipeptide 3a. Other Lewis
acids, MgBr2, BBu2OTf, TiCl4, Cu(OTf)2, Sc(OTf)3, ZrCl4, AlEtCl2 and
AlEt2Cl (1 equiv), gave the product 3a in low yields (<5%, data
not shown). All reactions were carried out at 0 °C for 24 h in dichlo-
romethane (DCM).
b
Yb(OTf)3
MgBr2
BBu2OTf
TiCl4
CuOTf2
ScOTf3
ZrCl4
AlEtCl2
AlEt2Cl
AlEtCl2
AlEt2Cl
AlEtCl2
AlEt2Cl
AlEtCl2
AlEt2Cl
5
15
10
10
25
70
60
65
55
65
55
55
35
c
d
d
a
b
c
DCE, reflux.
DCE, MW, 400 W.
After isolation by flash chromatography over silica gel.
(DCE) for 24 h, 3a was obtained in 20% yield (entry 1) and when
the reaction was conducted under microwave (MW) irradiation
(400 W) for 3.5 h, yield increased up to 55%, with a satisfactory
22/78 diastereomeric ratio in favour of (S,R)-3a (entry 2).
Making use of a catalytic amount of Yb(OTf)3 led to a drop of the
yield, while the use of a excess seemed inexpedient, for the high
molecular weight of such Lewis acid. Reactions with MgBr2,
BBu2OTf, TiCl4, Cu(OTf)2, Sc(OTf)3 and ZrCl4 were slightly improved
by increasing the amount of Lewis acid (yields 5–25%, Table 1,
entries 3–8).
Finally, in the presence of an excess of AlEtCl2 (3.5 equiv)15 the
reaction gave the desired dipeptide 3a in reasonable yield, after
isolation by flash chromatography over silica gel, albeit with a dis-
appointing 50/50 diastereomeric ratio (entry 9). On the other hand,
in the presence of AlEt2Cl (3.5 equiv) the reaction gave lesser
amount of 3a, but with a reasonable 24/76 diastereomeric ratio,
in favour of the (S,R)-3a stereoisomer (entry 10).
The eventual effect of the residue Xaa preceding Dha and the
protecting groups R, R1 on yield and stereoselectivity was exam-
ined. The reaction of indole with the dipeptide Phe-Dha 2b oc-
curred with comparable yield, but with lower stereoselectivity
(entries 11 and 12). Changing the methyl ester with a benzyl ester
(2c) lead to a moderate stereoselectivity, in favour of the isomer
(S,S)-3c (entries 13 and 14). The presence of a Boc-protecting group
(2d) instead of Fmoc gave lower yield and selectivity (entries 15
and 16).
Increasing time and temperature gave negligible improve-
ments. The only exception was Yb(OTf)3; indeed, performing the
reaction with 1 equiv of Yb(OTf)3 at 80 °C in dichloroethane
O
O
H
N
aa
H
N
aa
The configuration of Trp in the dipeptides 3b–d was determined
by comparison with authentic samples, prepared by standard pep-
tide synthesis in solution. Interestingly, apart from the slightly dif-
ferent yields, changing the ester allowed preparing preferentially
the dipeptides containing either (S)-Trp or (R)-Trp. Besides, the
analysis of the crude reaction mixtures revealed no trace of concur-
DSC, DIPEA
R
R
OR1
X
OR1
X
DCM/CH3CN
r.t.
OH
2
(90%)
1
Indole, Lewis acid
3Å mol sieves, DCM
0ºC
rent a
-amidoalkylation reaction.15,20
The reaction of 2a with substituted indoles in the presence of
3.5 equiv of AlEt2Cl or AlEtCl2 (Scheme 2) was performed at 0 °C
for 24 h in DCM and in the presence of 3 Å molecular sieves (Sup-
plementary data). The reaction afforded the dipeptides 3e–o (Table
2). For the moment, we were mainly interested in verifying the
applicability of the procedure to diverse kinds of indoles, therefore
the diastereoselectivity issue was not faced in detail. The absolute
configurations of the diastereoisomers were determined by com-
parison of the chiral-HPLC analyses with that of 3a.
O
H
N
R
a: R = Fmoc, Xaa = Pro, R1 = Me
b: R = Fmoc, Xaa = Phe, R1 = Me
c: R = Fmoc, Xaa = Pro, R1 = CH2Ph
d: R = Boc, Xaa = Pro, R1 = Me
X
OR1
NH
aa
3
Scheme 1. Synthesis of the protected dipeptides Xaa-Dha 2a–d and Lewis acid-
induced F-C alkylation of indole.