D. J. Sheffler et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 1062–1066
1065
ing, and since 12a was a racemate (90% cis at the bridgehead), and
thus a mixture of 8 compounds, we then attempted to separate the
mixture by chiral SFC. We were able to separate three peaks off the
1–3, 12 and 20. Thus, chemistry was quickly developed to access
these cores (Scheme 3). Starting from commercially available N-
Boc-azetidine-3-carboxylic acid 21 or N-Boc-piperidine-4-carbox-
ylic acid 22, conversion to the Weinreb amide and treatment with
an aryl, heteroaryl or aliphatic Gringard reagent provided 23 and
24, respectively. Condensation with hydroxylamine, reduction
and acylation afforded amides 25 and 26. Finally, removal of the
Boc moiety and sulfonylation of the secondary amine led to puta-
tive, racemic GlyT1 inhibitor series 27 and 28.
As shown in Table 3, the homologated azetidine-based analogs
27 were uniformly more potent than the corresponding homolo-
gated piperidine-based analogs 28, affording GlyT1 inhibitors with
low nanomolar potency. While the 2,4-dichlorobenzamide was the
most potent congener, other benzamides displayed a wide range of
SFC, two as single species (GlyT1 IC50s > 10 lM), and one as a
mixture (GlyT1 IC50 = 34 2 nM); however, we were unable to
definitively assign the absolute stereochemistry. An enantioselec-
tive synthetic route (Scheme 2) was employed to quickly access
the pure cis-(3a,6a)-enantiomers 20a and 20b (Fig. 4).21 Following
the work of Beebe,21 azomethine ylide precursor 13 underwent a
dipolar cycloaddition reaction with cyclopentenone to give the
key racemic ketone 14, with cis-stereochemistry at the ring junc-
tion. Enantiomeric resolution via the (R)-tert-butyl sulfonamide
provided (3aS,6aR)-15 and (3aR,6aS)-15, which were subsequently
separated by silica gel chromatography, in accord with literature
precedent.21 Scheme 2 shows the complete route to 20a, employ-
ing (3aR,6aS)-15. Here, reduction with NaBH4 delivered 16,
followed by deprotection under acidic conditions to the primary
amine 17. Acylation, removal of the benzyl protecting group and
sulfonylation provided 20a, the (3aR,4R,6aS) isomer. By employing
(S)-tert-butyl sulfinamide, the other cis-(3a,6a)-enantiomers,
(3aR,4S,6aS) and (3aS,4R,6aR) could not be accessed.21 For the
isomers that could be obtained, enantiospecific inhibition was
noted with 20a, possessing a GlyT1 IC50 of 433 nM, while the other
GlyT1 potency (GlyT1 IC50s from 80 nM to 7 lM). Moreover, in the
azetidine series 27, the aryl/heteroaryl R1 moieties could be re-
placed with aliphatic groups and retain potency (R1 = iPr, GlyT1
IC50 = 394 nM; R1 = n-Pr, GlyT1 IC50 = 185 nM; R1 = cycPr, GlyT1
IC50 = 253 nM), whereas the corresponding analogs in the piperi-
dine series 28 were inactive.
Representative members from both 27 and 28 were evaluated
for their effect on enzyme kinetics of [14C]-glycine transport, and
both were shown to be competitive with glycine, as well as selec-
isomer 20b was inactive (GlyT1 IC50 > 10
lM). Interestingly, these
tive versus GlyT2 (IC50 > 30 lM). Initial evaluation in our in vitro
analogs were weak to inactive relative to racemic 12a, and sug-
gests that the active isomer(s) are either the trans-(3a,6a)-isomers
or the other cis congeners, and synthetic efforts to access both are
underway. Thus, 12b, derived from a scaffold-hopping exercise
employing 1–3, led to a novel [3.3.0]-based GlyT1 inhibitor with
in vitro properties comparable to other advanced GlyT1 inhibitors
in short order, and for which a U.S. patent was issued.22
In parallel, we were also preparing and evaluating other
piperidine bioisosteres and modifications to 1–3 to further access
additional novel intellectual property (IP) space. Modeling work
suggested that 4-position homologated piperidines, as well as
3-position homologated azetidines overlapped favorably with
DMPK assays demonstrated that 27c was stable in fortified rat liver
microsomes (75% parent remaining at 90 min), possessed a good
unbound fraction in rat (fu = 14%) and clean CYP profile (IC50-
s > 10 lM). An oral plasma:brain level (PBL) study with oral dosing
(10 mg/kg p.o. in 0.5% methocellulose) of 27c afforded a low
BrainAUC:PlasmaAUC of 0.11. SCF separation of the 27c enantiomers
led to the isolation of the two pure enantiomers, and one was quite
active (IC50 = 39 nM) while the other proved much weaker
(IC50 = 900 nM). In consultation with the Johnston group, they
developed an asymmetric synthesis of 27c, via chiral proton catal-
ysis of a secondary nitroalkane addition to an azomethine, and we
were able to elucidate that the potent enantiomer had the (S)-con-
figuration.23 Overall, the low brain:plasma ratios of these series,
11, 12, 27 and 28 diminished enthusiasm; however, the scaffold
hopping strategy again secured robust IP position for both the 27
and 28 series of GlyT1 inhibitors.24,25
In summary, we were able to successfully further scaffold hop
from 3, originally derived at from a scaffold hopping exercise from
1 and 2, and develop three new series for which US patents were
granted without the need for an HTS campaign. This was critical,
as the time required to perform a SPA-based HTS campaign and
identify/optimize the hits would have required far more time and
uncertain IP position in a highly crowded and competitive space.
These new series retained the potency and selectivity of the
advanced compounds from which they were derived, but did suffer
from only modest CNS exposure. Finally, all of these new series
displayed enantioselective inhibition of the GlyT1 transporter.
Further refinements are in progress and will be reported in due
course.
Table 3
Structures and activities of analogs 27 and 28
H
R1
N
R2
O
n
n
N
O
S
O
R3
27, n = 1
28
, n = 2
a
Compound
R1
R2
R3
GlyT1 IC50 (lM)
27a
28a
2,4-diClph
627
1500
N
27b
28b
2,4-diClPh
39
N
Acknowledgments
Me
201
This work was supported by the NIH/NIMH under a National
Cooperative Drug Discovery and Development grant U01
MH08795. D.J.S. is a recipient of a National Alliance for Research
on Schizophrenia and Depression (NARSAD)–Dylan Tauber Young
Investigator Award. Vanderbilt is a member of the MLPCN and
houses the Vanderbilt Specialized Chemistry Center for
Accelerated Probe Development supported by U54 MH084659.
The support of William K. Warren, Jr. who funded the William K.
Warren, Jr. Chair in Medicine (to C.W.L.) is gratefully
acknowledged.
N
N
27c
28c
2,4-diClPh
2,4-diClPh
68
46
N
Me
N
S
27d
28d
40
N
Me
374
a
IC50s represent single determinations performed in triplicate.