factor 3b (SF3b).[8] SF3b, consisting of seven proteins,[9] is re-
quired for pre-mRNA splicing and is part of the spliceo-
some, a complex of approximately 200 proteins and small
nuclear RNAs (snRNAs) that catalyzes RNA splicing.[10] Al-
though the specific molecular target of FR901464 has not
yet been determined, it is likely that it is either spliceosomal
associated protein (SAP)135 or SAP155.[8] The same re-
search group also showed that the splicing inhibition of p27
by FR901464 was linked to cell cycle arrest.[8] These studies
indicate that the anticancer activity of FR901464 is directly
linked to pre-mRNA splicing inhibition. This is potentially a
breakthrough because splicing processes have never been
exploited as therapeutic targets or biomarkers in cancer
medicine. Moreover, post-transcriptional RNA modifica-
tions are an increasingly important theme in biology,[11] for
which FR901464 or its analogues may be used as a chemical
tool. Very recently, the Webb group reported the promising
in vivo antitumor activity of an FR901464 analogue, which
further supports the idea that FR901464 analogues could be
antitumor drugs.[12]
by the Kitahara group, is more active than FR901464 in en-
hancing gene expression of a reporter gene.[23] Unfortunate-
ly, the semi-quantitative description of the activity does not
allow for complete quantitative assessment. Moreover, the
methoxy group at the anomeric center without neighboring
electron-withdrawing groups is acid-sensitive,[24] which raises
the question of whether spliceostatin A is simply an
FR901464-prodrug with enhanced cell permeability. Alter-
natively, the improved activity could be a result of the im-
proved stability of spliceostatin A as compared to
FR901464.[23] The 1-desoxy FR901464, prepared by the Ja-
cobsen group, is slightly more active against Jurkat cells
than FR901464.[17] This analogue shows an important feature
about FR901464: its active form contains a cyclic B-ring. It
is not clear whether the 1-hydroxy group participates in mo-
lecular recognition, because the improved stability of 1-
desoxy FR901464 and loss of the hydroxy group may com-
promise each other, resulting in slightly better anticancer ac-
tivity. We recently substituted the 1-hydroxy group with a
methyl group and found that this analogue, meayamycin,
was 100 times more potent against human breast cancer
MCF-7 cells than FR901464.[22] Moreover, it is more potent
than 1-desoxy FR901464 and should be more stable than
spliceostatin A. Therefore, in this work, all of the analogues
contain the geminal dimethyl group at the C1 position.
Not surprisingly, several pharmaceutical companies re-
cently used reporter assays related to those that the Nakaji-
ma group employed, and discovered a series of new natural
products with biological profiles similar to that of
FR901464.[13,14] The most notable natural products are the
pladienolides,[14] a derivative of which is currently in phase I
trials as the first drug candidate with splicing inhibitory ac-
tivity.[15]
Results and Discussion[25]
In addition to the significance of using splicing inhibitors
as antitumor agents, there is a great need to develop chemi-
cal probes for RNA splicing because the process is not very
tractable with currently available biological methods. As the
first natural product that inhibits pre-mRNA splicing,
FR901464 is now considered a prototype compound for
splicing inhibitors. Given the unique mode of action in con-
junction with its antitumor activity, we envision that
FR901464 or its analogues will be widely used in oncology
and RNA biology. Thus, it is important to understand the
structure–activity relationships (SAR) of FR901464, which
would enable the rational design of more potent analogues
that are compatible with in vivo experiments.
The epoxide moiety: The C3-cyclopropyl analogue
1
(Scheme 1) was prepared by the Jacobsen group and showed
to be inactive even at a concentration of 4 mm (i.e., more
than three orders of magnitude less active than
FR901464).[17] This result implies that the epoxide may be
crucial for the biological activity of FR901464, but it was
not clear whether the oxygen atom or the electrophilicity of
the epoxide was important. If the electrophilicity is impor-
tant, such a notion would be contradictory to the Yoshida–
Kitahara teamꢁs statement that FR901464 does not form a
covalent bond with its target protein.[8] In light of this poten-
tial discrepancy, we set out to prepare non-epoxide ana-
logues that still contain the oxygen atom at the C3 position
(Scheme 2).
Synthetic studies of FR901464: The Jacobsen group accom-
plished the first total synthesis of FR901464[16] and systemat-
ically studied the structure–activity relationship of this natu-
ral product.[17] The results of their SAR studies are de-
scribed throughout this article where they are directly relat-
ed to our studies. The second total synthesis was accom-
plished by the Kitahara group,[18] who later improved their
synthetic scheme.[19] Our group reported the third total syn-
thesis of FR901464 in 2006,[20,21] and later disclosed how the
combination of the epoxide at the C3 position and the hy-
droxy group at the C1 position caused the decomposition of
FR901464.[22]
Compound 2[22] was reduced with LiAlH4 to a diol, which
was protected as an acetal to give 3 in 67% yield for the
two steps (Scheme 2A). This acetal was subjected to olefin
cross metathesis conditions with the previously prepared
diene 4 and Ru-1[26] to give the cross-coupled compound in
41% yield. The acetal of this compound was hydrolyzed
under acidic conditions to give analogue 5 in 66% yield.
To arrive at two similar analogues, alcohol 6[22] was used
as the starting material. The alcohol was protected as its
PMB ether with 74% yield, and its epoxide was subsequent-
ly opened with KOH to give diol
7 in 77% yield
(Scheme 2B). Diol 7 was cleaved by the action of NaIO4,
and the resulting ketone was immediately reduced with l-se-
lectride to give alcohol 8 as a single diastereomer. Alcohol 8
The C1-hydroxy group of FR901464: Spliceostatin A
(Scheme 1), the 1-methoxy analogue of FR901464, prepared
896
ꢀ 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Chem. Eur. J. 2011, 17, 895 – 904