K. O. Yerdelen et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 25 (2015) 5576–5582
5577
Figure 1. Structures of some AChE inhibitors: donepezil and indanone-based donepezil analogues (94 and 95) reported as AChE inhibitors.
amide moiety and evaluated their biological activities, including
inhibitory effects on ChEs and Ab42 aggregation with their antiox-
idant and metal chelating abilities.
and with higher selectivity indexes (2.9–40.1). Among them, p-flu-
oro and o-fluoro analogue substitutes (compounds 6 and 20) dis-
played the highest inhibitory activities against AChE with IC50
In our previous studies, we have also evaluated a series of ter-
tiary amide derivatives bearing ortho-, meta-, and para-substituted
N-benzylaniline rings as potent ChE inhibitors. From those studies,
we have been able to describe that a carbonyl group of a tertiary
amide moiety can interact with the CAS of AChE. It was also deter-
mined to be a crucial structural part for cholinesterase, and espe-
cially AChE, inhibition. The study went on to observe that the
compounds, which have highly electronegative atoms on the phe-
nyl ring, exhibited a considerable increase in AChE inhibition.25–29
In this study, the 5,6-dimethoxy-indanone ring, which was
inherent in the chemical structure of donepezil, has been the main
consideration in the design of new AChE inhibitors in order to cre-
ate a positive contribution on cholinesterase inhibition. To reduce
the cost of research and save time, in silico studies were used for
preliminary assessment before synthesizing the compounds
against AChE via the Sybyl X molecular docking program. For the
in silico study, various docking parameters (e.g., total score, polar
score, D_score, PMF_score) of the designed compounds were eval-
uated and molecular simulation studies were performed on a few
molecules of each. The results showed that the designed com-
pounds are likely to interact with amino acid residues in the cat-
alytic site of AChE. The docking scores are given on Table 3 in
Supplementary file.30
values of 0.11
AChE inhibitors in the series, compounds 8 and 22 (para- and
ortho-bromo analogues), were found with IC50 values of 0.14
and 0.12 M, respectively. Comparison of the non-substituted
compound 1 and the other substituted compounds demonstrated
that the introduction of halogen, methyl, ethyl, methoxy, and
ethoxy groups at ortho-, meta-, and para-positions of the phenyl
ring increased anti-AChE activity 1.09–11.5-fold.
lM and 0.08 lM, respectively. The other potent
lM
l
During the evaluation of the effects of different substituent
positions on anti-AChE activity, it was observed that the ortho-
methyl-substituted compound 16 exhibited approximately twice
as much anti-AChE activity than the para- and meta-methyl-substi-
tuted compounds 2 and 9. It was observed that para-, meta-, and
ortho-ethyl substituted compounds have equivalent AChE inhibi-
tion activity. A similar situation was also found to be valid for
the AChE inhibition activities of the methoxy-, ethoxy-, and
chloro-substituted compounds at different positions (o-, m-, p-).
Fluoro- and bromo-substituted compounds (6, 20 and 8, 22) at
para- and ortho-positions exhibited at least twice as much potent
anti-AChE activity than m-substituted derivatives (13 and 15). As
shown in Table 1, the most potent compound, 20, had a high level
of AChE inhibitor selectivity (SI = 40.1). Moreover, other potent
compounds, like 7, 8, and 21, had high selectivity for AChE. These
results indicate that substitutions of the phenyl group often had
a positive effect on anti-AChE activity. Substitution of the halogen
group at any phenyl ring position seemed to have a crucial effect
on AChE inhibition. The cause of this contribution may be the high
electronegativity of halogen atoms. The IC50 values of target com-
pounds revealed that they ranged from moderate to good when
We synthesized some 5,6-dimethoxy-indanone-2-carboxamide
derivatives containing ortho-, meta-, and para-substituted sec-
ondary aromatic amines via the pathway outlined in Scheme 1.
Synthesis of the compounds was realized using well-established
methods and reaction details are given in Supplementary file.30
The microwave irradiation method was used for the final step of
the reaction under the following conditions: 300 W; 15 psi;
170 °C; 10 min. All experimental and spectral data of the
used as BuChE inhibitors (2.10–7.10
14 exhibited the best BuChE inhibition with IC50 values of 2.24,
2.10, and 2.24 M, respectively (Table 1). The tendency for the
lM). Compounds 9, 11, and
target compounds are shown on Tables
2
and 4 in
l
Supplementary file.30
structure–activity relationship found in AChE inhibitory activity
was not found in BuChE inhibitory activity. When the activity
results are generally evaluated, it is clear that all the meta- and
para-substituted compounds offered more positive contribution
toward BuChE inhibition than ortho-substituted compounds.
Beside this, the meta-OCH3-substituted compound (11) was found
The AChE and BuChE inhibitory activities of the compounds
were examined by the method described by Ellman,31 using AChE
from an electric eel and BuChE from an equine serum. Donepezil
was used as the reference standard. As shown in Table 1, the com-
pounds (1–22) clearly showed potent inhibitory activity against
AChE with IC50 values ranging from 0.08 to 0.92
lM concentra-
to be the most potent anti-BuChE inhibitor (IC50 = 2.10 lM) in the
tions. On the other hand, all synthesized compounds were found
significantly more effective inhibitors towards AChE than BuChE,
series. The overall evaluation of these results is that no statistically
significant correlation was found between the physicochemical