ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
LETTER
Table 3. Antibacterial Activity of the 4-Oxo-4-phenylbut-2-
enoates against H37Rv
enzyme, presumably due to favorable interactions between the
enzyme and the halogens at the 2- and 4-positions. A current goal
of our research program is to develop butenoates with increased
affinity for the enzyme but reduced electrophilicity, thus improv-
ing the selectivity of MenB inhibition by increasing the likelihood
that adduct formation would occur on the enzyme. In this regard,
we note the recent discussions concerning the utility of covalent
enzyme inhibitors that contain appropriately tuned electrophilic
groups.21
Finally, in addition to providing a promising starting point for
the development of MenB inhibitors, the work described here
also serves to reinforce issues that can arise with leads identified
through HTS.22 Although the present leads are stable in DMSO,
their reactivity under aqueous conditions reinforces the necessity
to consider compound stability under the assay conditions
employed, which is of particular importance for measurements
that require prolonged incubation such as antibacterial assays. In
the present work, the use of a coupled assay that included free
CoA resulted in the discovery of CoA adducts that bind with high
affinity to MenB and that represent a promising foundation for
the development of novel antibacterial agents that target mena-
quinone biosynthesis in M. tuberculosis as well as other patho-
genic bacteria that have this pathway. Importantly, our data also
support the proposal that MenB may be an appropriate target in
nonreplicating populations of M. tuberculosis.
a MIC determined in the microplate dilution assay under aerobic
conditions. b MIC determined in the in low oxygen recovery assay
against NRP-MTB. ND, not determined. Cytoxicity assays indicated
c
that the selectivity index of 2b and 3b is greater than 20.
(Table 3, MIC = 0.64 μg/mL). Indeed, 3b also had potent
activity in a low oxygen recovery assay (LORA) against non-
replicating M. tuberculosis (NRP-MTB) (Table 3, MIC = 1.5 μg/
mL), which is promising given that apart from rifampicin (MIC =
0.4 μg/mL), many current drugs are inactive against NRP-
MTB.16 Interestingly, it has been reported that the menB gene
is upregulated when H37Rv is grown under oxygen-limiting
conditions,17 supporting the possibility that this enzyme is an
intracellular target for the CoA adducts. On the basis of these
results, we propose that protection of the acid aids the entry of
the compounds into the cell where they then undergo reaction-
(s), such as a Michael addition by CoA, which results in the
formation of the antibacterial species. Although we cannot rule
out the possibility that the compounds react with other nucleo-
philes in the cell, we observed that the addition of 1,4-dihydroxy-
2-naphthoic acid (DHNA; 100 μg/mL) to the media was able to
rescue the growth of M. tuberculosis H37Rv that had been treated
with 2b or 3b at 2ꢁ MIC. DHNA is a downstream product of the
MenB reaction that has previously been used in complementa-
tion experiments to elucidate the order and identity of enzymes
that comprise the menaquinone biosynthesis pathway.18 Thus,
the ability of DHNA to rescue growth supports our current
hypothesis that the Michael acceptors inhibit menaquinone
biosynthesis in M. tuberculosis.
’ ASSOCIATED CONTENT
S
Supporting Information. Detailed experimental proce-
b
dures for the synthesis of compounds and biological assays. This
acs.org.
’ AUTHOR INFORMATION
Corresponding Author
*Tel: 970-491-2902. E-mail: Richard.Slayden@colostate.edu
(R.A.S.). Tel: 631-632-7907. Fax: 631-632-7934. E-mail: peter.
tonge@sunysb.edu (P.J.T.).
Funding Sources
We thank NERCE/NSRB for assistance with compound screen-
ing (NIH Grant AI057159). This work was funded by the NIH
Grants AI044639, AI070383, and AI058785 to P.J.T.
Further studies are required to confirm that CoA addition and
MenB inhibition occur within the cell and to fully elucidate the
mechanism of action of these compounds. In addition, it will be
important to further improve the affinity of the adducts for MenB
and also to replace the CoA portion of the adducts by more
druglike groups, and in this regard, we note the studies by Pereira
et al. in which inhibitors of E. coli acetyltransferase GlmU were
identified that occupy the CoA binding site in this enzyme.19
Because the benzoylacrylic acid and CoA bind to adjacent sites
on MenB, we are also exploring the possibility that MenB
catalyzes adduct formation in an analogous fashion to that
observed, for example, in the assembly of inhibitors via in situ
click chemistry.20 It is interesting to note that the IC50 values for
enzyme inhibition by the parent 2-aminobutanoates (Table 1)
correlate with their stability and hence reactivity of the butenoate
that is formed. There is also a correlation between IC50 and Ki
values for inhibition of MenB by the resulting adducts, indicating
that the more electrophilic butenoates bind more tightly to the
’ REFERENCES
(1) Bloom, B. R.; Murray, C. J. Tuberculosis: Commentary on a
reemergent killer. Science 1992, 257, 1055–1064.
(2) Boshoff, H. I.; Barry, C. E., 3rd. Tuberculosis—Metabolism and
respiration in the absence of growth. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 2005, 3, 70–80.
(3) Gengenbacher, M.; Rao, S. P.; Pethe, K.; Dick, T. Nutrient-
starved, non-replicating Mycobacterium tuberculosis requires respiration,
ATP synthase and isocitrate lyase for maintenance of ATP homeostasis
and viability. Microbiology 2010, 156, 81–87.
(4) Andries, K.; Verhasselt, P.; Guillemont, J.; Gohlmann, H. W.;
Neefs, J. M.; Winkler, H.; Van Gestel, J.; Timmerman, P.; Zhu, M.; Lee,
E.; Williams, P.; de Chaffoy, D.; Huitric, E.; Hoffner, S.; Cambau, E.;
Truffot-Pernot, C.; Lounis, N.; Jarlier, V. A diarylquinoline drug active
on the ATP synthase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Science 2005,
307, 223–237.
(5) Lu, X.; Zhang, H.; Tonge, P. J.; Tan, D. S. Mechanism-based
inhibitors of MenE, an acyl-CoA synthetase involved in bacterial
menaquinone biosynthesis. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 2008, 18, 5963–
5966.
822
dx.doi.org/10.1021/ml200141e |ACS Med. Chem. Lett. 2011, 2, 818–823