À
C S Coupling
COMMUNICATION
those signals corresponding to
the complex [(Xant
ACHTUNGTRENNUNGphos)ACHTUNGTRENNUNGPd-
AHCTUNGERTG(NNUN dba)] were observed (Fig-
ure 1A, IV). Clearly, these re-
sults indicate that Xantphos is
a
highly efficient ligand in
forming the complex with
[Pd2A(dba)3] compared with
G
CHTUNGTRENNUNG
CyPF-tBu. Most interestingly,
free CyPF-tBu was no longer
detected in the mixed-ligand
system (Figure 1A, V), thus
suggesting that Xantphos pro-
moted the ligation of CyPF-tBu
to Pd, probably through rapid
ligand exchange.
Further 31P NMR studies
were carried out on the oxida-
tive-addition step after adding
the substrate 1 into solutions of
both the two individual single-
ligand systems and into a solu-
tion of the mixed-ligand system
(Figure 1B). In the single-
ligand system of [Pd2ACHTUNGTRENNUNG(dba)3]/
Xantphos/1 (Figure 1B, II), we
observed that the NMR signals
for the [(Xantphos)PdACHTUNGTRENNUNG(dba)]
complex disappeared, whereas
a new signal corresponding to
the oxidative complex [(Xant-
phos)Pd(1)] emerged. Notably,
the NMR signal of free Xant-
Scheme 4. Aryl thiolation of heteroaryl substrates using the Pd/Xantphos/CyPF-tBu mixed-ligand system. Re-
action conditions (exceptions, see below): aryl halide (0.10 mmol), thiol (0.12 mmol), [Pd
(0.0050 mmol), [Pd]/[ligand]=1:1.1, [Xantphos]/[CyPF-tBu]=3:1, Et3N (0.70 mmol), toluene (2.0 mL), reflux
at 1158C, 4 h. [a] Double the catalyst loading, 20 h. [b] N,N-Diethylmethylamine (1.0 mmol) instead of Et3N,
16 h. [c] Scale-up synthesis with aryl halide (0.50 mmol), thiol (0.60 mmol), [Pd2A(dba)3] (0.025 mmol), [Pd]/[li-
gand]=1:1.1, [Xantphos]/[CyPF-tBu]=3:1, Et3N (3.5 mmol), toluene (10 mL), reflux at 1158C, 24 h.
2ACHTUNGTNER(NUNG dba)3]
A
ACHTUNGTRENNUNG
C
ACHTUNGTRENNUNG
AHCTUNGTRENNUNG
bromotriazole ribonucleoside 3 (Scheme 4, 7a–c). Addition-
ally, and more importantly, the exceedingly challenging
chlorinated heteroaryl substrates 4–6 could also afford the
corresponding products in good to excellent yields
(Scheme 4, 7c, 8a–c, 9a–c).[10] Collectively, these data dem-
onstrate the extraordinary power of this mixed-ligand cata-
phos also reappeared, thus suggesting that free Xantphos
was released from Pd complexes upon the addition of 1.
This conclusion was further supported by the large amount
of free Xantphos observed in the mixed-ligand system (Fig-
ure 1B, III). On the contrary, there was no free CyPF-tBu
observed in the mixed-ligand system, thus highlighting that
1 preferentially reacts to form the oxidative-addition inter-
À
lyst for C S coupling in general.
To gain more insight into how the two ligands work in
harmony to boost the catalytic activity, we undertook
31P NMR analysis to investigate the different catalytic sys-
tems based on the knowledge that both Xantphos and
CyPF-tBu are phosphine ligands and have characteristic sig-
nals in 31P NMR spectra. We found that considerable
amounts of free CyPF-tBu remained in the single-ligand
mediate with the [(CyPF-tBu)Pd
ACHTUNGERTN(NUNG dba)] complex rather than
with the [(Xantphos)Pd(dba)] complex. This result implies
AHCTUNGTRENNUNG
that ligand exchange at the level of Pd complexes involved
in the oxidative-addition steps also favors the formation of
an adduct containing CyPF-tBu, and consequently enhances
the whole reaction. Notably, oxidative addition of a substrate
onto [(CyPF-tBu)PdACTHNUTRGNEUNG
(dba)] is usually fast.[2a] Taking all argu-
system of [Pd
G
ments together, we postulate a general mechanism for this
C-S cross coupling reaction catalyzed by the mixed-ligand
Pd catalyst where Xantphos favorably promotes the forma-
tion of the active Pd catalyst while CyPF-tBu plays a major
role in the catalytic reaction (Figure 2).
To support the above hypothesis, we performed cyclic vol-
tammetry (CV) studies on both the single-ligand and mixed-
ligand catalytic systems.[12] CV allows a more precise and de-
scriptive investigation of the mechanistic features because
unlike NMR spectroscopy, it can routinely be used to detect
NMR signals corresponding to free CyPF-tBu (Figure 1A,
III). Consequentially, only a small amount of the catalytic
complex [(CyPF-tBu)Pd
(dba)3]/CyPF-tBu system, a behavior that was revealed by
the weak NMR signals corresponding to [(CyPF-tBu)Pd-
ACHTUNGTRENNUNG
(dba)].[11] Clearly, these data reflect that the Pd complex for-
mation with CyPF-tBu alone was not efficient. Unlike
CyPF-tBu, no NMR signal for free Xantphos was observed
in the spectrum of the CATHUNGTREN[NNUG Pd2ACHTUNREGTG(NNUN dba)3]/XantACTHUNGTRENpNUGN hos system; only
Chem. Eur. J. 2013, 19, 17267 – 17272
ꢁ 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
17269