10.1002/cmdc.201800271
ChemMedChem
COMMUNICATION
hydrogen bonding network. Substitution elsewhere on the
aromatic ring or deviation from an isoindoline core perturbs
recruitment of the known neo-substrates. Perhaps unsurprisingly
given the mechanism of action, affinity for CRBN appears not to
be the sole determinant for neo-substrate degradation, as some
molecules binds to CRBN with an increased affinity yet fail to
induce degradation. Indeed, even amongst the compounds which
do induce degradation, CRBN affinity appears not to be predictive
of cellular activity – Compound 17 binds with roughly 2-fold less
affinity than Pomalidomide and Compound 19 however both
Compounds 17 and 19 have greatly reduced effect on protein
degradation and proliferation when compared to Pomalidomide.
More important are structural changes which, even when subtle,
can completely abrogate the degradation of the neo-substrate.
This is most likely due to perturbation of the required protein-
protein interaction as even subtle changes, such as fluorination in
the 5 position (Compound 8), drastically effecting hydrophobicity
of the combined protein/ligand surface (see S.I.) and presumably
therefore prevent trimer formation. A similar change in surface
characteristics may also be responsible for the reduced activity of
compound 17 compared to thalidomide, although to a lesser
extent since the 4 position is less buried at the interface. These
subtle differences highlight the inherent difficulty in designing
molecular glues.
In summary, we report a rapid, chromatography free synthesis of
2 FDA approved drugs as well as more than 20 additional
analogues, along with the structure degradation relationships
(SDR) for these new compounds which highlight the inherent
challenge in developing molecules which function via this
mechanism. We identified two previously uncharacterized
thalidomide analogues with anti-proliferative activity in a cellular
multiple myeloma model. Furthermore, we have identified several
compounds with improved pharmacological properties and/or
increased CRBN binding affinity which may be useful as recruiting
elements for PROTACs. It is also conceivable that these new
molecules are able to induce the degradation of additional neo-
substrates or indeed inhibit the binding of natural substrates to
CRBN, perhaps providing a useful tool to discover currently
unknown substrates of CRBN. Finally, we hope this efficient
synthetic method will prove useful to those engaged in the exciting
field of targeted protein degradation.
employee of Arvinas, LLC. Other authors declare no conflict
of interests.
Footnotes
† Alternatively, tert-Butyl 2,6-dioxopiperidin-3-ylcarbamate is
commercially available.
‡ Phthalic acid heated to 150°C in TFE for 2 hours under
microwave conditions is converted into the anhydride.
Keywords: Protein Degradation • Immunomodulatory Drugs •
Imides • Condensation Reactions • Cereblon
1.
2.
3.
4.
R. A. Kyle and S. V. Rajkumar, Clinical Lymphoma and Myeloma, 2009,
9, 278-288.
M. Q. Lacy and S. V. Rajkumar, American Journal of Hematology, 2010,
85, 95-96.
J. B. Bartlett, K. Dredge and A. G. Dalgleish, Nature Reviews Cancer,
2004, 4, 314-322.
K. Dredge, J. B. Marriott, C. D. Macdonald, H. W. Man, R. Chen, G. W.
Muller, D. Stirling and A. G. Dalgleish, British Journal Of Cancer, 2002,
87, 1166–1172.
5.
6.
G. W. Muller, M. G. Shire, L. M. Wong, L. G. Corral, R. T. Patterson, Y.
Chen and D. I. Stirling, Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters, 1998,
8, 2669-2674.
B. Pandit, Z. Hu, S. N. Chettiar, J. Zink, Z. Xiao, J. P. Etter, D. Bhasin
and P.-K. Li, Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters, 2013, 23, 6902-
6904.
7.
8.
T. Ito, H. Ando, T. Suzuki, T. Ogura, K. Hotta, Y. Imamura, Y. Yamaguchi
and H. Handa, Science, 2010, 327, 1345-1350.
E. S. Fischer, K. Bohm, J. R. Lydeard, H. Yang, M. B. Stadler, S.
Cavadini, J. Nagel, F. Serluca, V. Acker, G. M. Lingaraju, R. B. Tichkule,
M. Schebesta, W. C. Forrester, M. Schirle, U. Hassiepen, J. Ottl, M. Hild,
R. E. Beckwith, J. W. Harper, J. L. Jenkins and N. H. Thoma, Nature,
2014, 512, 49-53.
9.
J. Krönke, N. D. Udeshi, A. Narla, P. Grauman, S. N. Hurst, M. McConkey,
T. Svinkina, D. Heckl, E. Comer, X. Li, C. Ciarlo, E. Hartman, N. Munshi,
M. Schenone, S. L. Schreiber, S. A. Carr and B. L. Ebert, Science, 2014,
343, 301-305.
10.
J. Kronke, E. C. Fink, P. W. Hollenbach, K. J. MacBeth, S. N. Hurst, N.
D. Udeshi, P. P. Chamberlain, D. R. Mani, H. W. Man, A. K. Gandhi, T.
Svinkina, R. K. Schneider, M. McConkey, M. Jaras, E. Griffiths, M.
Wetzler, L. Bullinger, B. E. Cathers, S. A. Carr, R. Chopra and B. L. Ebert,
Nature, 2015, 523, 183-188.
Acknowledgements
11.
12.
G. Lu, R. E. Middleton, H. Sun, M. Naniong, C. J. Ott, C. S. Mitsiades,
K.-K. Wong, J. E. Bradner and W. G. Kaelin, Science, 2014, 343, 305-
309.
We thank members of the Crews lab for useful discussions.
G.M.B. is a Fellow of The Leukemia & Lymphoma Society. P.M.C.
is thankful to the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for a
Feodor Lynen research fellowship. C.M.C. gratefully
acknowledges the US National Institutes of Health for their
support (R35CA197589).
J. D. Hansen, K. Condroski, M. Correa, G. Muller, H.-W. Man, A.
Ruchelman, W. Zhang, F. Vocanson, T. Crea, W. Liu, G. Lu, F. Baculi, L.
LeBrun, A. Mahmoudi, G. Carmel, M. Hickman and C.-C. Lu, Journal of
Medicinal Chemistry, 2018, 61, 492-503.
13.
M. E. Matyskiela, G. Lu, T. Ito, B. Pagarigan, C.-C. Lu, K. Miller, W. Fang,
N.-Y. Wang, D. Nguyen, J. Houston, G. Carmel, T. Tran, M. Riley, L. A.
Nosaka, G. C. Lander, S. Gaidarova, S. Xu, A. L. Ruchelman, H. Handa,
J. Carmichael, T. O. Daniel, B. E. Cathers, A. Lopez-Girona and P. P.
Chamberlain, Nature, 2016, 535, 252-257.
Conflicts of interest
14.
15.
T. Han, M. Goralski, N. Gaskill, E. Capota, J. Kim, T. C. Ting, Y. Xie, N.
S. Williams and D. Nijhawan, Science, 2017, 356.
C.M.C. is founder, consultant and shareholder in Arvinas,
LLC, which partially supports research in his lab. A. M. is an
T. Uehara, Y. Minoshima, K. Sagane, N. H. Sugi, K. O. Mitsuhashi, N.
Yamamoto, H. Kamiyama, K. Takahashi, Y. Kotake, M. Uesugi, A. Yokoi,
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.