S. Boland et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 4594–4597
4595
selectivity has also been investigated, as PDE4B was proposed as
the main PDE4 isoform mediating TNF-
release,14 while knockout
experiments suggested that inhibition of PDE4D would be associ-
ated with emesis.15 However, the improved therapeutic window
observed with several PDE4 inhibitors during preclinical studies
was not always confirmed in clinical trials.8
oxidized to the corresponding benzoic acids 4a and 4b, using
sodium chlorite (Lindgren oxidation) in combination with sulfamic
acid as chlorine dioxide scavenger. Coupling with 3,5-dichloropyri-
din-4-amine, after in situ conversion of 4a and 4b into acid chlo-
rides, resulted in intermediates 5a and 5b. Further nucleophilic
substitution with either 3-amino- or 3-sulfanyldihydrofuranone
yielded final parent compounds 6–9 in a single step. The corre-
sponding metabolites 6M–9M could be easily obtained by hydroly-
sis of the lactone structure with LiOH. As N-oxide analogs of
Roflumilast and related PDE4 inhibitors were reported to possess
significant inhibitory activity against PDE4,11,25 compound 10, rep-
resenting the N-oxide analog of 6 was synthesized using the same
procedure as described above, by replacing 4-amino-3,5-dichloro-
pyridine with 4-amino-3,5-dichloropyridine-N-oxide in the corre-
sponding reaction step. Finally, compound 11, an acyclic analog
of 6 was synthesized by alkylating 5a with the methyl ester of gly-
cine. As with 6–9, the corresponding metabolite 11M was synthe-
sized via hydrolysis of the parent compound with LiOH.
Evaluation of the candidate PDE4 inhibitors revealed strong on-
target activity. Comparative data with Roflumilast and Rolipram
are given in Table 1. Parent compounds 6, 7, 8 and 9 displayed sim-
ilar IC50 values in the low nanomolar range. Replacement of the
pyridine moiety by a pyridine N-oxide resulted in a significant
drop in potency, as illustrated by 10. This finding was surprising,
as the N-oxide analogs of Roflumilast are known to possess signif-
icant inhibitory activity against PDE4.11,25 Compound 11, repre-
senting an acyclic analog of 6, displayed slightly reduced (2–4
fold) potency. Significant differences were found between the
expected metabolites 6M, 7M, 8M, 9M and 11M. Indeed, 6M and
8M, which resulted from hydrolysis of a homoserine lactone struc-
ture, were markedly less active than their parent compounds,
while their sulfanyl analogs 7M and 9M essentially retained their
on-target activity. This conserved activity was not the result of
re-lactonization of the metabolites under assay conditions or stor-
age in DMSO stock solutions, as both hypotheses were excluded by
HPLC–MS analysis. A major drop of potency was also found for
11M.
a
Another possibility is to optimize PDE4 inhibitors towards top-
ical delivery.8,16,17 In this context a soft drug approach represents
an attractive way towards novel PDE4 inhibitors with improved
therapeutic window. Soft drugs, sometimes known as antedrugs,
are biologically active compounds that are designed to undergo
metabolic inactivation by controlled conversion of the parent mol-
ecule into a predictable, nontoxic metabolite.18,19 This strategy has
recently been applied to a series of boron-containing PDE4 inhibi-
tors, in view of dermatologic applications.20 We have recently
reported the design and evaluation of soft inhibitors of ROCK, a
kinase target of relevance for the treatment of respiratory diseases,
including COPD.21 Herein, we discuss the design and initial evalu-
ation of soft PDE4 inhibitors which are analogs of Roflumilast.
Crystal structures of PDE4 in complex with several inhibitors,
including Roflumilast, have been reported and provide a structural
basis for their activity.22 Those structures revealed multiple hydro-
phobic interactions with highly conserved residues sandwiching
the inhibitor in the active site, as well as H-bonding interactions
between the (halo)alkoxy group found in several inhibitors and
an invariant glutamine. The lipophilic nature of the Roflumilast
binding site was further emphasized in a later publication wherein
a linker of sufficient length had to be included between the main
inhibitor scaffold and ionic solubilizing groups.5 Interestingly, such
findings suggest an inactivation mechanism for the design of soft
PDE4 inhibitors, since generation of a charged species by drug
metabolizing enzymes could result in a metabolite with decreased
potency. The associated change in physical–chemical properties
can also result in reduced membrane permeability, which repre-
sents another way of modulating the functional activity of com-
pounds inhibiting an intracellular target.
For the design of soft PDE4 inhibitors, we chose to favor a c-lac-
tone structure, which was previously used in soft corticosteroids23
and more recently in the design of soft ROCK inhibitors.24 Hydroly-
sis of this lactone will result in a negatively charged species, with
increased polar surface area and decreased hydrophobicity. Candi-
date soft PDE4 inhibitors were prepared in 5 or 6 steps, starting
from the commercially available 3,4-dihydroxybenzaldehyde 1
(Fig. 2). Sequential alkylation of 1 first involved selective difluorom-
ethylation on position 4, using sodium chlorodifluoroacetate as a
source of difluorocarbene. Alkylation of the remaining hydroxyl
function of 2 was performed with alkyl dibromides, yielding inter-
mediates 3a and 3b. In the next step, the aldehyde function was
An important part of the observed structure–activity relation-
ships can be explained by the charge state of the different species,
and by the distance between charged groups and the main inhibi-
tor scaffold. Indeed, it is known that highly polar moieties are
poorly tolerated in the essentially hydrophobic binding site of
PDE4, unless a spacer of sufficient length is placed between the
ionizable group and the main inhibitor scaffold.5 All parent com-
pounds remain neutral at physiological pH and under assay condi-
tions, and consequently display strong on-target activity. The fact
that metabolites from sulfanyl analogues 7M and 9M retain strong
on-target activity suggests that the carboxylic group resulting from
Figure 2. Overview of compound synthesis: (a) ClF2CCOONa, NaOH, DMF, H2O, 120 °C, 2 h; (b) Br(CH2)nBr, K2CO3, ACN, reflux, 4 h; (c) H2NSO3H, NaClO2, AcOH, H2O, 10 °C,
30 min; (d) (1) SOCl2, toluene, 90 °C, 1.5 h; (2) 3,5-dichloro-4-aminopyridine or 3,5-dichloro-4-aminopyridine N-oxide, 60% NaH, THF, 10 °C, 1 h; (e) 2-oxo-3-amino-oxolane,
2-oxo-3-mercapto-oxolane or glycine methyl ester; K2CO3, ACN, reflux, 1.5 h.