3614
K. Balaraman et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 3613–3616
O
O
O
O
O
O
N
N
N
N
N
N
OCH3
(S,S)-Nap-(S,S)-Box (
H3CO
OCH3
H3CO
OCH3
H3CO
5a
)
(R,R)-Nap-(S,S)-Box (5b)
(S,S)-Nap-(R,R)-Box (5c)
O
O
O
O
O
O
N
N
N
N
N
N
OCH3
H3CO
4c
2-Naph-(S,S)-Box (
)
5e
)
(S,S)-Ibu-(S,S)-Box (
(R,R)-Nap-(R,R)-Box (5d)
Figure 2. Structure of tartarate derived bioxazoline ligands.
tically different asymmetric transformations with good
enantioselectivity.9
4-methoxyaniline (12a), and phenylacetylene (9a) under similar
reaction conditions. Propargylamine 10a with 22% enantioselectiv-
ity in low yield (30%) was obtained (Scheme 3). Apart from low
yield, very low enantioselectivity was also observed when com-
pared with the addition of alkyne to imine 8a (Scheme 2). Use of
cyclic amines such as piperidine and pyrrolidine instead of anilines
led to the formation of 1,3-diynes (Scheme 3).12 These two demer-
its forced us to optimize reaction conditions by using the pre-
formed imine 8a.
Other Cu(I) and Cu(II) pre-catalysts such as Cu(OTf), CuCl, CuBr,
Cu(PF6)(CH3CN)4, Cu(OTf)2, Cu(ClO4)2ꢀ6H2O, and Cu(OAc)2ꢀH2O
were investigated in this reaction in order to choose a suitable me-
tal partner (Table 1). Except Cu(OAc)2ꢀH2O, every other copper salts
catalyzed the formation of propargylamine 10a in moderate to
good yields. Among them Cu(ClO4)2ꢀ6H2O fared better in inducing
enantioselectivity (43%) at ambient temperature (Table 1 entry 8).
Further attempts to enhance enantioselectivity by reducing the
temperature to 0 °C were not fruitful. Even after 2 days, no forma-
tion of propargylamine 10a was observed (Table 1, entry 9).
5 mol % of Cu(ClO4)2ꢀ6H2O with 10 mol % of 5a at ambient tem-
perature furnished the target product 10a with better enantiose-
lectivity (81% yield, 52% ee) (Table 1, entry 10). After
identification of Cu(ClO4)2ꢀ6H2O as a suitable metal partner and
25 °C as an optimal reaction temperature we went ahead to choose
the appropriate reaction medium (Table 2).
Under the same reaction conditions optimized previously, a
profound solvent effect on the yield and the enantioselectivity
was observed. No product was isolated when the reaction was car-
ried out in acetonitrile, acetone, and dimethoxyethane (DME)
(Table 2, entries 4, 6, and 9). Reaction in dichloroethane, diethyl
ether, and tetrahydrofuran (THF) contrived only a trace amount
of propargylamine 10a in TLC visualization and hence no attempts
were made to isolate the product (Table 2, entries 3, 8, and 10). Up
to 70% yield was obtained with toluene, tert-butyl methyl ether
(TBME), and dimethylformamide (DMF) as a reaction medium
but very poor enantioselectivity was observed (up to 17%) in these
cases (Table 2, entries 5, 7, and 11). Excellent conversion (up to
87%) was observed only in chlorinated solvents such as
dichloromethane and chloroform. Enantioselectivity observed
in chloroform was better (52%) (Table 2, entry 1) than of
enantioselectivity in dichloromethane (29%) (Table 2, entry 2).
Thus chloroform was identified as the most suitable reaction med-
ium for the enantioselective synthesis of propargylamines using li-
gand 5a.
In our lab we re-designed tartaric acid derived bioxazoline
ligand (4) by introducing another stereogenic center as shown in
ligand 5 near the coordination sphere (Scheme 1). This modifica-
tion mitigated the poor chirality transfer of ligand 4, in asymmetric
transformations.
The application of newly developed bioxazoline ligands 5
(Fig. 2) in asymmetric catalysis was successfully demonstrated in
copper catalyzed enantioselective Henry reaction and good
enantioselectivities with
a broad range of substrates were
achieved.10 We applied the same ligand to achieve asymmetric
allylic alkylation (AAA) with >95% ee.11 Since the amino acid de-
rived bidentate bis(oxazolines) 2 and 3 are inefficient in catalyzing
enantioselective synthesis of propargylamines, we decided to ex-
plore the efficiency of tartaric acid derived bidentate bioxazoline
5 for the same synthesis. Only unnatural and highly expensive ami-
no acid (tert-leucine, phenylglycine) derived pybox ligands 1 are
responsible for very good enantioselectivity to synthesize propar-
gylamines, whereas our catalytic system was prepared using inex-
pensive and naturally available tartaric acid. This makes tartarate
derived bidentate bioxazoline 5 as an alternative in terms of price
and availability to achieve enantioselective synthesis of chiral
propargylamines.
An initial exploration of enantioselective propargylamine syn-
thesis was carried out using ligand 5a which was identified as a
suitable ligand for the asymmetric Henry reaction. The reaction
of phenylacetylene (9a) and imine 8a was performed in chloroform
(CHCl3) at 25 °C using 5 mol % CuI and 10 mol % of 5a. The desired
product 10a was obtained with 35% yield and 31% enantiomeric
excess after 72 h (Scheme 2).
This superiority of ligand 5a over bis(oxazoline) ligands 2 & 3
encouraged us to optimize the reaction conditions further to in-
crease enantioselectivity of the product.
In an attempt to enhance the efficiency of the reaction, we car-
ried out the reaction in one pot manner using benzaldehyde (11a),
PMP
PMP
HN
Ph
N
5a
/CuI
Ph
+
Ph
CHCl3, rt
8a
9a
Ph
35% yield, 31% ee
10a
Scheme 2. Copper catalyzed enantioselective addition of alkyne to imine.