Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
Scheme 1. Retrosynthetic Analysis and Construction of
Building Blocks for a Proposed Nitroaldol Coupling
Scheme 2. Unanticipated Formation of a Cyclic Nitroaldol
Adduct and Analogous Construction of the MTL 3,4,5-
Stereotriad
gel (in contrast to 8 itself), the potential use of cyclic
stereocontrol to bias the subsequent reduction of C6, and the
concise internal protection of the functionality at positions C4
and C6 in the form of a N−O linkage. We wondered whether
the 3,4,5-stereotriad of MTL might be established by a similar
chemical transformation, similar but not identical because our
original retrosynthetic analysis anticipated inversion at C3
rather than C4 (Scheme 1), as occurs in the formation of 17.
In theory, this could be rectified by using the enantiomer of
epoxy aldehyde 9, which we prepared by a two-step route
analogous to the one used to provide the (3S,4R) isomer, with
some changes to address scalability.21 When we prepared
(3R,4S)-9 and attempted coupling with 10 in the presence of
cesium carbonate (EtOH, 23 °C), we obtained after
chromatography the desired cycloadduct 18 in 32% yield
(minor) and, separately, the C5 epimeric cycloadduct in 50%
yield (major, not depicted, dr 45:55).
From a screen examining the ability of various chiral
catalysts to steer the diastereoselectivity of the coupling of
(3R,4S)-9 and 10 toward the desired diastereoisomer 18, we
found that a copper(II) system employing cyclohexanediamine
ligand 2022 afforded the initial nitroaldol product 21 with a C5
dr of ∼95:5 (1H NMR analysis; though inconsequential, the
distribution of indeterminate C6 epimers was estimated to be
∼85:15).23 Following disappearance of the limiting epoxyalde-
hyde component, triethylamine was introduced, and the
mixture was warmed to promote smooth cyclization of 21 to
isoxazoline N-oxide 18 (Scheme 3).24 Thus, this optimized
coupling was scaled to produce 16.4 g of 18 in 88% isolated
yield in one operation. C-Desilylation of this product with
tetra-n-butylammonium fluoride, followed by selective O-
protection of the sterically less encumbered propargylic alcohol
provided silyl ethers 22 (a = TBDPS, b = TIPS) in good yield;
the crystallinity of 22b permitted unambiguous assignment of
all stereochemistry by single-crystal X-ray diffractometry.
With suitably protected alkynols 22 in hand, we then sought
to identify conditions for transition metal-catalyzed cyclo-
isomerization to form the corresponding glycal. We observed
that both the isoxazoline N-oxide 22a and its reduced
counterpart 23 (formed in 70% yield upon warming 22a
with trimethylphosphite) were unreactive toward tung-
sten(0),25 rhodium(I),26 and ruthenium(II)27 catalysts for
glycal formation, leading us to speculate that the polar
isoxazoline N-oxide and isoxazoline functional groups might
serve as catalyst poisons. We elected instead to reduce the
by design also comprises a β-hydroxy nitro function,13
permitting its convergent assembly by a proposed diaster-
eoselective Henry reaction of components 9, an epoxy
aldehyde, and the nitro ether 10. Varying the latter
component, particularly through inclusion of an easily varied
element such as an alcohol, alkene, or masked aldehyde, would
permit facile diversification of C7.
Building blocks 9 and 10 were each prepared in multigram
amounts by known sequences of 4−5 steps from starting
materials available in bulk. The allylic alcohol precursor 12 was
prepared by formylation of tri-iso-propylsilylacetylene (11),
Horner−Wadsworth−Emmons olefination, then ester reduc-
tion.14 Sharpless epoxidation followed by Dess−Martin
oxidation then furnished epoxy aldehyde (3S,4R)-9 (90% ee,
determined by Mosher analysis of the epoxy alcohol
precursor).15 The nitro ether 10 was prepared from
enantiopure nitro acetate 1516 by acetate hydrolysis and O-
benzylation under acidic conditions, then recrystallization from
ethyl acetate−hexane (17.6 g, 66% yield from enantiopure 15).
Spectroscopic data and melting-point determination of the
resulting white solid matched literature reports for 10;17 the
product was found to be optically pure (≥99% ee) by chiral
HPLC analysis.
With building blocks 9 and 10 in hand, we investigated their
proposed coupling to form nitroaldol adduct 8 (Scheme 2).
Under a variety of conditions commonly employed for such
couplings (e.g., potassium tert-butoxide−tetrahydrofuran,
potassium carbonate−methanol, potassium fluoride−isopropa-
nol, silica gel), we observed complex mixtures of diastereo-
meric nitroaldol addition products, the separation and
characterization of which were complicated by their apparent
instability toward retro-Henry fragmentation on silica gel.
However, when we attempted coupling of 9 and 10 using the
chiral ligand 16 and copper(II) bromide,18 we observed the
formation of a notably polar byproduct, which was isolated in
30% yield and proved to be isomeric with the desired Henry
adduct. X-ray analysis of this crystalline material revealed it to
be the isoxazoline N-oxide 17, arising from the desired Henry
adduct (8) by nitronate formation and consequent cyclization.
Such cyclizations involving ethyl nitroacetate have been
documented by Righi and Jørgensen.19,20
While unanticipated, isoxazoline N-oxide 17 presented
several beneficial features in the context of our synthesis
goals. These included the stability of the product toward silica
6830
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2021, 143, 6829−6835