L. Zani et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 3944–3948
3947
To learn more on the electronic structure of compound TZ1, we
computed the energy, geometry and electron density distribution
of its frontier orbitals by means of DFT calculations.24 The compu-
tational investigation confirmed that the HOMO and LUMO levels
are correctly aligned with the energy levels of TiO2 and the redox
couple to ensure electron transfer during operation of a solar cell
(Fig. 5); while the HOMO level of the dye is mainly localized on
the conjugate system centered on the thiazolothiazole bridge, its
LUMO is essentially located on the cyanoacrylic group with a smal-
ler contribution of the triphenylamine moiety, thus supporting the
charge transfer nature of the excitation process. TD-DFT studies
using the CAM-B3LYP functional gave a maximum absorption
son is prevented by the different fabrication and measurement
conditions applied in those cases; despite that, the possibility to
obtain a reasonable efficiency using a sensitizer with an alternative
structural arrangement was still noteworthy. The open-circuit po-
tential for TZ1 reached 0.712 V; such high value was comparable to
that obtained with N3, suggesting that the long alkyl chains pres-
ent on the dye backbone were effective in shielding the semicon-
ductor surface from the electrolyte, thus reducing the incidence
of dark current. On the other hand, the value of the short-circuit
current was much lower for the organic dye compared with the
ruthenium (II) complex: considering that the fill factor was the
same for both compounds, such difference is clearly the main rea-
son for the inferior performance of DSSCs built using the thiazolo-
thiazole sensitizer. The density of dye adsorbed on TiO2 measured
via UV–vis spectroscopy was 1.85 ꢁ 10ꢀ7 mol cmꢀ2. This value is of
the same order of magnitude of those found for other organic
dyes;26 furthermore, it is comparable to that reported in the liter-
ature for Ru-dye N3 (1.3 ꢁ 10ꢀ7 mol cmꢀ2).5a Therefore, we con-
clude that the observed short-circuit current densities should not
depend on the low adsorption of the sensitizer on TiO2 surface.
Possibly, the small driving force for dye regeneration deduced from
cyclic voltammetry experiments (see above) could be responsible
for the low Jsc. Indeed, regeneration of dye N3 has a much larger
driving force of approx. 0.75 V,27 which, coupled with its red-
shifted absorption compared to the new organic sensitizer, could
justify the difference in short-circuit current values reported in
Table 1.
wavelength in methanol of 408 nm with an excitation energy (Eexc
)
of 3.04 eV and an oscillator strength (f) of 2.419, in good agreement
with the experimental values; they also showed that photoexcita-
tion is mainly due to a HOMO ? LUMO transition, accounting for
approximately 53% of the total.
With the photoelectrochemical and computational data in
hand, we then proceeded to evaluate the performance of TZ1 as
a photosensitizer for DSSCs; the cells were fabricated using a pho-
toanode made with nanocrystalline TiO2-layered FTO glass, a Pt-
coated FTO glass as the cathode, and an electrolyte containing
the Iꢀ=Iꢀ3 redox couple (for experimental details, see Supplemen-
tary data). The results obtained under simulated AM 1.5 G
(131 mW cmꢀ2) illumination, including comparison with a refer-
ence cell built using the known ruthenium dye N3, are listed in Ta-
ble 1; a representative J–V curve is shown in Figure 6.
As can be seen from the table, the cells fabricated using com-
In summary, we reported the synthesis of a novel DSSC photo-
pound TZ1 had an average power conversion efficiency (
g
) of
sensitizer (TZ1) characterized by an unusual p–D–A architecture,
2.55%, corresponding to 44% of the value obtained with metal-sen-
sitizer N3 under the same conditions. The efficiency measured in
this study was therefore lower compared to those reported for
containing a highly conjugated light-harvesting system based on
alternate thiophene and thiazolo[5,4-d]thiazole heterocyclic units.
The compound was characterized from the photo- and electro-
chemical point of view, and its electronic structure and transitions
were investigated by means of DFT calculations. In spite of its pe-
culiar structure, compound TZ1 was found to have properties com-
patible with its employment in dye-sensitized solar cells. DSSCs
built with the new sensitizer had an average power conversion
efficiency of 2.55%, corresponding to 44% of the value obtained
with Ru-sensitizer N3 under the same conditions. The photovoltaic
devices showed high average open-circuit potential, comparable to
that obtained with the standard Ru-dye, but a relatively low short-
circuit current: the latter was attributed to an insufficient driving
force for dye regeneration when the Iꢀ=I3ꢀ redox couple was used.
We are currently addressing this problem through rational design
and synthesis of new unsymmetrical thiazolothiazole dyes with
optimized orbital energy levels: the results of these studies will
be reported in due course.
thiazolothiazole-containing D–p
–A dyes both by us (3.5%)10 and
by Zhou and co-workers (5.1%),14 even though a proper compari-
Table 1
Photovoltaic performance of DSSCs based on TZ1 and N3a
Dye
Jsc (mA cmꢀ2
)
Voc (mV)
Fill factor (ff)
g (%)
TZ1
N3
7.0
15.8
712
720
0.67
0.67
2.55
5.82
a
Measured under irradiation of AM 1.5 G simulated solar light (131 mW cmꢀ2) at
room temperature. Film thickness approx. 10
l
M, active area 0.25 cm2.
Acknowledgments
M.C. and M.L.P. are grateful to Regione Toscana within the POR-
FSE 2007–2013 program for a post-doctoral fellowship (FOTOSEN-
SORG project). A. C. and M. B. thank the ‘‘Polo di Innovazione Reg-
ionale, Progetto NANOXM – nanotecnologie per il mercato’’ for
financial support.
Supplementary data
Supplementary data (experimental procedures, synthesis and
characterization of all compounds, fabrication of dye-sensitized so-
lar cells and photoelectrochemical measurements.) associated with
Figure 6. Representative J–V curves for
a DSSC built using dye TZ1 under
illumination (solid line) and in the dark (dashed line).