A combination of directing groups and chiral anion
phase-transfer catalysis for enantioselective
fluorination of alkenes
Jeffrey Wu, Yi-Ming Wang, Amela Drljevic, Vivek Rauniyar, Robert J. Phipps, and F. Dean Toste1
Department of Chemistry, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720
Edited by Stephen L. Buchwald, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, and approved July 11, 2013 (received for review March 6, 2013)
opportunity to combine the principle of transition-state organiza-
tion with our recently reported chiral anion phase-transfer system,
with the hypothesis that an allylic hydrogen-bonding DG could
effectively direct an ion-paired chiral phosphate species for the
enantioselective electrophilic fluorination of alkenes (Fig. 1
E and F).
Our recent enantioselective halocyclization methods (18–20)
used chiral anion phase-transfer catalysis, in which metathesis
between an insoluble electrophilic salt (such as Selectfluor) and
a chiral lipophilic phosphate anion derived from catalysts such as
3,3′-bis(2,4,6-triisopropylphenyl)-1,1′-binaphthyl-2,2′-diyl hydro-
genphosphate (TRIP) generates a soluble electrophile in a chiral
environment (Fig. 2). In addition, we reported the enantiose-
lective fluorinations of enamides, using the same phase-transfer
system (21, 22). In the latter examples, hydrogen bonding between
the reacting enamide functional group and the phosphate catalyst
is hypothesized to facilitate the fluorination reaction.
On the basis of our previous success with amides as pendant
nucleophiles, we posited that allylic amides could be used as DGs
for direct alkene fluorination to provide access to allylic fluoride
products (23). The synthesis of enantioenriched allylic fluorides is
a synthetic challenge for which only a handful of approaches have
been disclosed. Recently reported general methods for the
enantioselective synthesis of allylic fluorides include the reaction
of allylic chlorides with palladium catalysts (24, 25) as well as the
fluorination of allylsilanes using cinchona alkaloid catalysis (26,
27). Furthermore, we envisioned that, upon removal of the amide
directing group, this method would provide access to enantioen-
riched β-fluoroamines bearing a fluorinated quaternary center,
a privileged bioactive motif and longstanding synthetic challenge
(28–33).
In initial experiments, enantioselective fluorination of sub-
strates containing no hydrogen-bond donor functionality was
attempted (23). As expected, in the absence of a suitable DG,
enantioselectivities no higher than 10% enantiomeric excess (ee)
were obtained. In stark contrast, under typical chiral anion phase
transfer conditions, allylic amide 1a underwent fluorination to
provide allylic fluoride 1b in 82% yield and 85% ee, along with
cyclized side product 1c (Table 1, Entry 1). Switching the solvent to
toluene increased selectivity for the desired allylic fluoride over 1c,
as well as enantioselectivity (Table 1, Entry 2). Finally, use of the
recently developed 12-hydroxy-1,10-bis(2,4,6-triisopropyphenyl)-
4,5,6,7-tetrahydrodiindeno[7,1-de:1′,7′-fg][1,3,2]dioxaphosphocine
12-oxide (STRIP) (3, see Table 1) in place of TRIP (2) as catalyst
further increased enantioselectivity and chemoselectivity in favor
We report a catalytic enantioselective electrophilic fluorination
of alkenes to form tertiary and quaternary C(sp3)-F bonds and
generate β-amino- and β-aryl-allylic fluorides. The reaction takes
advantage of the ability of chiral phosphate anions to serve as
solid–liquid phase transfer catalysts and hydrogen bond with
directing groups on the substrate. A variety of heterocyclic, carbo-
cyclic, and acyclic alkenes react with good to excellent yields and
high enantioselectivities. Further, we demonstrate a one-pot, tan-
dem dihalogenation–cyclization reaction, using the same catalytic
system twice in series, with an analogous electrophilic brominat-
ing reagent in the second step.
asymmetric organocatalysis hydrogen-bonding
|
|
n the history of asymmetric catalysis, directing groups (DGs)
have been instrumental for the achievement of selectivity in
I
transformations of great synthetic utility. DGs have likewise been
shown to play a central role in transition-metal catalysis, having
recently been used for site-selective C-H activation (1–6). The
advantage of using a DG lies in the ability to functionalize
nonpolar bonds (such as in alkenes) while maintaining beneficial
polar interactions between the substrate and chiral source;
however, DGs have rarely been used in organocatalysis. In this
context, the Miller research group reported the epoxidation re-
action of allylic alcohols, using an amino acid catalyst capable of
hydrogen bonding with the alcohol DG, and conducted elegant
studies delineating the importance of hydrogen-bonding inter-
actions for this and related systems (7–9) (Fig. 1). The Tan re-
search group has elaborated this idea through the concept of
induced intramolecularity, in which the catalyst reduces the en-
tropic cost of reaction by bringing together reactants and organiz-
ing the transition state through favorable binding interactions (10).
The peptide catalysts in Miller’s studies facilitate reaction
through organization of the reactants in the transition state (Fig.
1) rather than through formation of covalent adducts or lowest
unoccupied molecular orbital-lowering protonation (or hydrogen
bonding), which has generally required substrates containing
carbonyl or imine moieties (11–13). This generalization applies
to chiral phosphoric acids, which have been predominantly used
in activation of the electrophile, although hydrogen bonding to
the nucleophile has also been implicated as a key component
(14). More recently the anionic conjugate bases of chiral phosphoric
acids (i.e., chiral phosphate anions) have received attention as
counterions for positively charged electrophilic intermediates,
wherein ion pairing with the phosphate anion provides a suitable
chiral environment for subsequent enantioselective transformations
of the electrophilic species (11–13). The generality of the concept of
ion pair catalysis has allowed the application of these highly tunable
scaffolds to a diverse range of transformations in which carbonyl or
imine activation is clearly inapplicable (15–17). As part of both
aforementioned modes of reactivity, hydrogen bonds between chiral
phosphoric acids or phosphate anions and reacting functionality are
often invoked as crucial interactions for achieving high levels of
enantioselectivity (11–14). We speculated that hydrogen-bonding
interactions with substrate functionality may play a key role, via
transition state organization, even when the interacting functionality
does not directly participate in the transformation. We saw an
Author contributions: J.W., V.R., R.J.P., and F.D.T. designed research; J.W., Y.-M.W., A.D.,
V.R., and R.J.P. performed research; J.W., Y.-M.W., A.D., V.R., R.J.P., and F.D.T. analyzed
data; and J.W., Y.-M.W., and F.D.T. wrote the paper.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
This article is a PNAS Direct Submission.
Data deposition: The atomic coordinates and X-ray structures have been deposited in the
Cambridge Structural Database, Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre, Cambridge CB2
PNAS
|
August 20, 2013
|
vol. 110
|
no. 34
|
13729–13733