2
S. I. Bhat, D. R. Trivedi / Tetrahedron Letters xxx (2013) xxx–xxx
O
O
R3
90oC
R3
R3
O
O
R2
NH4OAc
R1
R2
HO
Solvent free
Catalyst free
R1
N
H
R3
1
2
3
4
Scheme 1. One-pot three-component synthesis of tetrasubstituted pyrroles.
Table 1
Optimization of the reaction
3
O
O
O
O
NH4OAc
O
O
OH
N
H
4a
1a
2a
Entry
Molar ratio of 1a:2a:3
Reaction temperature/time
Yield of 4a (%)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1:1:1
80 °C/180 min
80 °C/180 min
90 °C/120 min
90 °C/120 min
90 °C/120 min
90 °C/120 min
100 °C/120 min
42
48
74
83
93
80
84
1:1:1.2
1:1:1.2
1:1:1.5
1.1:1:1.5
1.1:1:1.2
1.1:1:1.5
In order to highlight the yield of the product at optimized condition, the number "93" is highlighted with bold font.
solvent-free condition. The reaction mass got slowly converted to a
suspension and partial conversion was observed after 60 min (the
reaction was monitored by TLC). Continuation of the reaction
yielded 42% of the product after 180 min. The reaction was then
optimized by varying the molar ratio of starting materials and tem-
perature of the reaction (Table 1). The molar ratio 1.1:1:1.5 of EAA
(1a), benzoin (2a) and ammonium acetate at 90 °C was found to be
the optimal condition for better conversion. The reaction mass got
converted to a homogeneous liquid under these conditions and the
desired product was obtained in high yield. Further, increasing the
temperature to 100 °C resulted in decreased yield due to the for-
mation of unknown impurities. The pure solid product was ob-
tained after recrystallization with ethanol–water (80:20) mixture.
In order to explore the synthetic utility of the current protocol, a
series of reactions were carried out using various 1,3-dicarbonyls
(1), benzoin derivatives (2) and ammonium acetate under opti-
mized conditions.16 The reaction proceeded smoothly with various
1,3-dicarbonyls. However, the reaction with dibenzoylmethane
failed to yield the products through condensation with benzoin
even at elevated temperature. This may be attributed to the poor
reactivity of carbonyl groups due to the presence of adjacent bulky
phenyl groups. Also, increasing the reaction temperature (>130 °C)
resulted in the decomposition of starting materials. Unlike the
reaction with symmetrical 1,3-dicarbonyls, in the case of unsym-
metrical 1,3-dicarbonyl compounds, mixtures of regioisomeric
products are possible. However, with all unsymmetrical 1,3-dicar-
bonyls (1a, 1b, 1d) used, only one regioisomer has been obtained in
high yield under present reaction conditions. This may be attrib-
uted to the difference in reactivity of carbonyl groups influenced
by the nature of substitution on it. The resonance effect in the ester
group (Table 2, entries 1–6) and steric effect in the benzoyl group
(Table 2 entries 10–12) reduced the reactivity of the carbonyl
group and hence remained as side chain in the corresponding pyr-
roles. The structural evidence was ascertained by 13C NMR analysis
of the pyrroles. The carbonyl signal of pyrroles 4a–4f appeared
ꢀ165 ppm corresponding to the ester carbonyl group and carbonyl
signal of pyrroles 4j–4l appeared ꢀ194 ppm corresponding to the
benzoyl carbonyl group while carbonyl signal of pyrroles 4g–4i ap-
peared ꢀ197 ppm corresponding to the acetyl carbonyl group. In
addition, from the SXRD (Single Crystal X-ray diffraction) analysis
of 4c, it was clearly found that the ester group was untouched
and remained as side chain in pyrrole 4c. Thus, the difference in
reactivity of carbonyl groups of 1,3-dicarbonyls leads to the forma-
tion of single regioisomer and hence the present protocol can be
considered as regioselective.
In order to evaluate the scope of the present protocol, the reac-
tion was extended to less reactive anisoin and heteroaromatic 2,20-
furoin. Interestingly, anisoin underwent smooth reaction under the
present conditions to afford the corresponding pyrrole derivatives
in good yield (Table 2, entries 2, 8 and 11). As a main reason for this
conversion, we assume that, the increased temperature (90 °C) and
a small excess of 1,3-dicarbonyls (1.1 equivalence), resulted in a
homogeneous reaction mixture facilitating the reaction. This was
supported by the early experiments, when equimolar ratios of
EAA and benzoin were reacted at 80 °C; the reaction mixture re-
mained as a suspension and resulted in poor product yield (42%).
The three-component reaction proceeded smoothly and good
product yields were obtained with heteroaromatic 2,20-furoin (Ta-
ble 2, entries 3, 6, 9 and 12).
The structure of the products was confirmed by spectral data
and elemental analysis. The 1H NMR and 13C NMR of known com-
pounds are in agreement with the earlier reports.14 Further, to con-
firm the structure of tetrasubstituted pyrroles unambiguously, 4c
was selected as a representative compound and characterized by
single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis19 (see Supplementary data
Fig. 1).
On the basis of electronic effects and regioselectivity of the
reaction, two plausible pathways for the present three-component
protocol are illustrated in Scheme 2. The reaction of the carbonyl
group of benzoin with ammonium acetate can form
a-hydroxy