2
F. Hermant et al. / Tetrahedron xxx (2014) 1e7
Interestingly, the cyclopropane 3a is also the ‘normal’ expected3
of the solvent and of the rate of the Grignard reagent addition were
put under scrutiny. The results are presented in Table 2, along with
the outcomes of experiments performed, for comparison purposes,
from the carboxylic amides 4bei.
product starting from the corresponding carboxylic amide 4a,
where the sulfur atom of 1a is replaced with an oxygen atom.7 Since
the production of 3a from 1a is rather peculiar in the light of the
results obtained with the other thioamides studied so far, we de-
cided to investigate the generality and mechanism of this intra-
molecular cyclopropanation of N-alk-3-enyl thioamides. In
addition, we wished to evaluate whether this process could be of
some advantage compared to the reactions of the corresponding
carboxylic amides.
The thioamides 1bei evaluated were all successfully converted
into the corresponding bicyclic aminocyclopropanes 3bei. Rela-
tively little influence of the addition time of the Grignard reagent
was observed, although a slow addition (30e60 min) gave some-
what better results than a typical dropwise addition (2e3 min) in
the syntheses of aminocyclopropanes 3c, 3d and 3g (entries 3, 4
and 7). tBuOMe generally proved to be the best solvent with respect
to the yields and the diastereoselectivities. These were markedly
better than in THF in almost all cases (entries 3e6, 8e9). A similar
observation had been made in an earlier study carried out with
related carboxylic amide substrates, where higher diaster-
eoselectivities were generally obtained in Et2O rather than in THF.10
The case of the synthesis of 3b (entry 2) can be considered as an
exception. Indeed, either starting from 1b or from 4b, the reaction
mixtures appeared heterogeneous in Et2O and in tBuOMe and fairly
large variations in the yields and diastereoselectivities were ob-
served when the experiments were repeated, which suggests
a problem of solubility.
2. Results and discussion
2.1. Syntheses of the substrates
For the purpose of this study, several homoallylamines were
prepared by zinc-mediated Barbier-type imine allylation8 and di-
rectly acylated, without purification, to afford the carboxylic am-
ides 4beh. The amide 4i, bearing the chiral centre on another
substituent of the nitrogen atom, was synthesised following an-
other route.9 The amides 4bei were then converted into the cor-
responding thioamides 1bei using the Lawesson reagent. The
results are summarised in Table 1.
Overall, comparative analysis of the results gathered starting
from the carboxylic amide substrates 4bei indicates that they
produce the desired cyclopropanes 3 more cleanly, often in
higher yields (entries 1, 4, 6, 8 and 9). The diastereoselectivities of
these reactions are also consistently more sharply in favour of the
Table 1
Syntheses of the N-but-3-enylamide and N-but-3-enylthioamide substrates
b
diastereoisomers,11 under otherwise identical conditions (en-
tries 2e4 and 6e8). This stereochemical assignment is supported
by NMR analysis of the isolated products and is unambiguously
illustrated by the crystallographic structure of the major di-
astereoisomer of cyclopropane 3g (Fig. 1).13 Most interestingly,
there are a few instances where the diastereoselectivities of
intramolecular cyclopropanations of thioamides 1 are reversed
compared to the those of the same transformations carried out
from the corresponding amides 4: this is the case for the syn-
Entry
1
Substituents
Amide 4 (yield)
4b (84%)a
Thioamide 1 (yield)
1b (41%)
R1¼Bn
R2¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R3¼Me
t
theses of 3c and 3d in THF (entries 3 and 4), of 3h in BuOMe
(entry 8) and of 3i in THF (entry 9). In the latter case, where
the chiral centre of the substrates is not included in the
chain linking the olefin and the (thio)amide moieties, this dif-
ference is especially significant with a 3 to 1 selectivity obtained
starting from 1i versus an almost non-selective reaction starting
from 4i.
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
R1¼Ph
4c (75%)a
4d (90%)b
4e (n.d.)c
4f (80%)10
4g (53%)a
4h (86%)e
1c (80%)
1d (69%)
1e (41%)d
1f (59%)
1g (58%)
1h (78%)
1i (56%)
R2¼Ph
R3¼Me
R1¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R2¼Ph
R3¼Me
R1¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R2¼Ph
R3¼nPr
2.3. Mechanistic aspects
R1¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R2¼CF3
A straightforward explanation for the formation of the bicyclic
aminocyclopropane products 3 is intramolecular 1,2-insertion of
the alkene group into the putative thiatitanacyclopropane complex
B (Scheme 3, hypothesis a). This would lead to a thiatitanacyclo-
pentane intermediate D. This complex is analogous to the in-
termediate involved in the cyclisation of the carboxylic amides 4,
the only difference being the sulfur atom in place of an oxygen
atom. The next elementary steps can thus be put forward following
this analogy: cleavage of the carbonesulfur bond and cyclopropane
ring-closure according to an SE2(back) mechanism after adoption of
a W-shaped conformation.14
R3¼Me
R1¼4-(Cl)C6H4
R2¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R3¼Me
R1¼4-(Cl)C6H4
R2¼4-(OMe)C6H4
R3¼H
R1¼CH(Me)Ph
R2¼H
4i (prepared by
another route)9
R3¼Me
a
Conditions: Ac2O, pyridine, 20 ꢀC.
b
c
Conditions: Ac2O, DMAP (cat.), pyridine, 20 ꢀC.
Conditions: nPrCOCl, Et3N, CHCl3 20 ꢀC. The yield was not determined because
Another consideration worth taking into account is the close
structural similarity between the metallated iminium species C,
likely to be in equilibrium with B, and the corresponding zincated
iminium E, the proposed key-organometallic intermediate involved
this amide was only partially purified and engaged as such in the next step.
d
Yield for the whole sequence from the imine.
Conditions: HCO2H/Ac2O, HCO2Na, CH2Cl2, 20 ꢀC. The yield given is for the
e
formylation step only.
in the conversion of
a-N-homoallylamino nitriles 5 into bicyclic
2.2. Titanium-mediated cyclisations
aminocyclopropanes 3, as described by the group of Chemla
(Scheme 4).15 In that work, careful mechanistic studies have pro-
vided evidence that a carbenoid insertion pathway and/or a process
involving an aza-Cope rearrangement can operate, depending on
The new thioamide substrates 1bei were submitted to the
titanium-mediated cyclisation procedure. The effects of the nature