F. A. Soares et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 4597–4601
4599
Scheme 1. Synthetic route used for preparing 1,4-dihydro-4-oxo-1-(b-D-ribofuranosyl)quinoline-3-carboxylic acids.
Table 2
Table 3
Fit of ITC experimental data parameters as in Table 1
Statistical parameters for the ITC experimental fit of compounds Neq138, 135 and 142
whose Kai pp values were determined against TcGAPDH G3P site
b
AICca
R2
Sum of squares
Sy.x
p Test
AICc
R2
Sum of
squares
Sy.x
p Test
Kai pp
(lM)
Neq135
Neq137
Neq142
Neq139
Neq140
Neq141
Neq138
ꢀ1010.61
ꢀ1111.48
ꢀ1160.74
ꢀ1348.52
ꢀ1517.80
ꢀ1298.13
ꢀ1506.56
0.92
0.96
0.96
0.97
0.99
0.95
0.98
0.12
0.06
0.04
0.01
0.003
0.01
0.004
2.94 ꢁ 10ꢀ2
2.07 ꢁ 10ꢀ2
2.00 ꢁ 10ꢀ2
9.09 ꢁ 10ꢀ3
5.05 ꢁ 10ꢀ3
1.08 ꢁ 10ꢀ2
5.25 ꢁ 10ꢀ3
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.001
<0.005
<0.001
Neq138 105.10 3.39
Neq135 150.94 3.62
Neq142 305.44 30.41 ꢀ608.767 0.91 0.15
ꢀ591.277 0.93 0.07
ꢀ629.492 0.93 0.12
0.02 <0.001
0.04 <0.001
0.04 <0.001
a
Second-order Akaike’s information criterion.
The standard deviation of errors in regression.
assayed against both the active and cosubstrate sites could prefer-
entially bind to where it is easier to compete for the site. It is also
noteworthy that the enzyme efficiency is higher for G3P than for
NAD+ at both expenses of larger kcat (faster turnover) and smaller
KM value. Moreover, the KM and Vmax values obtained when we var-
ied the G3P concentration are indicative of the noncompetitive
inhibition, since the KM values are the same despite the variation
of Vmax values.
b
ring. For instance, we get an increase of twofold in kinetic affinity
by just changing the bromine atom from position 6 to 7 (com-
pounds Neq139 and Neq135). Variation at the R6 position from
bromine (Neq139) to a chlorine atom (Neq140) takes place with-
out a significant change in the kinetic affinity. Following this trend,
by exchanging the methyl group from R6 (Neq141) to R7 (Neq137)
we get an increase of threefold plus in kinetic affinity. On the other
hand, by replacing a hydrogen with a methoxy group at the posi-
tion R6 to get compound Neq142, we observe a threefold increase
in the kinetic affinity, as compared to substitution at position R7
(Neq138). It maybe therefore speculated that this observation is
due to a stronger pKa perturbation of compound Neq142 that bears
the methoxy group at the C7 position. Moreover, the ITC KM values
for assaying study compounds against the TcGAPDH NAD+ always
The compound with lower Kai pp value towards TcGAPDH acting
on the NAD+ site, Neq135, was also evaluated against the hGAPDH,
and showed a tenfold increase on its inhibition constant value. This
is remarkably interesting considering that the NAD+ KM value for
hGAPDH has dropped to 22.31 0.48 M with an enzyme efficiency
of 31.
All results obtained so far compelled us to further understand
the biological activity of these molecules using in vitro models.
The first screening for cytotoxicity assessment of some chemicals
was performed on Saccharomyces cerevisiae17, once it grows fast,
with easy maintenance and detection methods like the fluorogenic
compound FUN-1Ò (Invitrogen/Molecular Probes).18 FUN-1 accu-
mulates in dead or metabolic compromised cells and they present
diffused green fluorescence at the cytoplasm, while live yeasts
metabolize FUN-1, being concentrated into cylindrical intravacuo-
lar structures (CIVS) with red fluorescence.19 Cell viability is deter-
increased, while Vmax remained constant at 0.24 0.01 l .
M sꢀ1
This means we can ascertain the competitive mechanism for these
inhibitors. Non-linear least-squares regression analysis is thor-
oughly used to calculate the kinetic parameters. Therefore, the
competitive mechanism is directly obtained from ITC measure-
ment curves and any transformation to linearize data, as in the
case of well-known double-reciprocal analysis of Lineweaver–
Burk,14 is not necessary. Nonetheless, when doing so the straight
lines cross the same point at 1/Vmax, which is, as a result, un-
changed. Since KM becomes KM + KM[I]/KI and thus the apparent
ES association gets weaker, KM gets larger, as demonstrated for
the competitive inhibition towards NAD+. In order to further vali-
date this, we have carried out the inhibition assays for compounds
mined as
a red/green ratio referring to live/dead yeasts,
respectively. This fast screening was performed to a subset of com-
pounds at the highest concentration that did not result in solubility
problems (500 l
mol Lꢀ1). Cytotoxicity was observed for Neq138
and Neq139 only (Fig. 2). This screening gave promising results
to undertake further studies of these molecules in other cell-based
assays due to the overall low cytotoxicity.
Neq135, 138 and 142 against the TcGAPDH active site where D-
glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate (G3P) is converted to the product
1,3-biphosphoglicerate (1,3-BPG), Table 3.
Table 4
Kinetic parameters for TcGAPDH G3P and NAD+
Neq138, 135 and 142 have inhibition constant ðKai ppÞ values that
are far higher when assayed against the TcGAPDH G3P site than
when assayed against the TcGAPDH NAD+ site. This provides an-
other evidence in favor of the NAD+ competitive binding mode
for the whole set, which are also noncompetitive in relation to
the G3P substrate. The lower KM value for TcGAPDH G3P over
NAD+ (Table 4) indicates the enzyme needs lower concentration
of G3P than NAD+, which suggests the same set of compounds
Parameters
Vmax
M sꢀ1
KM M)
G3P
NAD+
(l
)
0.63 0.01
34.10 1.23
146 0.61
4.28
0.24 0.01
40.14 3.13
51.37 0.33
1.28
0.917
0.011
(
l
kcat (sꢀ1
)
kcat/KM (ꢁ106 sꢀ1 Mꢀ1
)
R2
0.986
0.011
Sy.x