NMR Detection of Dihydrides
FULL PAPER
the polarization pattern of the resulting styrene. The hydro-
genation activities are rather similar for all these systems.
Characteristically, in all cases investigated, the resonances
of the dihydrides are present during the hydrogenation of
phenylacetylene to styrene. The apparent lack of formation
of any substrate-hydride complexes – similar to those de-
tected in the previously investigated platinum-tin sys-
tems[9] – leads us to the conclusion that the observed dihy-
drides may not be directly included in the catalytic cycle of
the hydrogenation, but might just be the precursors for re-
lated, catalytically active species. Alternatively, the rates of
the individual steps for this catalytic cycle might well be
rather different from those of the previously studied plat-
inum-tin system, with the consequence that the rate-deter-
mining steps shift with the result that such intermediates, –
if they are formed at all -, occur in such minute concentra-
tions that they cannot be detected in spite of the signal en-
hancement associated with PHIP.
Scheme 3. Formation of bis-phosphane rhodium dihydrides after
prolonged reaction time
The complicated mixture of resonances observed in the
PHIP spectra at room temperature after prolonged reaction
times (Figure 4, f) could be analyzed to consist of the over-
lapping thermal and PHIP signals of 3c, 2c, 7c, and of the
starting complex 1, respectively. This analysis was con-
firmed via PHIPϩϩ simulation of the expected resonances
for the components of this system and a subsequent
weighted summation thereof (Figure 4, g).
Conclusions
However, in order to achieve a complete fitting of the
observed patterns in the case above, the presence of another
tris-phosphane dihydride has to be postulated, namely of
8c. Its coupling patterns clearly display the cis-position
alignment of three phosphorus ligands. The chemical shift
of the H1 proton in cis-position to phosphorus is character-
istic for a trans-alignment of the tin-ligand. The difference
between the two rather similar dihydrides 3c and 8c can
only be due to variations in the structure of the tin ligand.
As has already been shown before,[13,14] tin(II)chloride pos-
sesses additional coordination abilities; therefore, it can co-
ordinate Lewis bases, leading to the formation of SnCl2D
ligands (D ϭ donor). Since this process could be strongly
promoted by the abstraction of chloride, we have also re-
corded the spectra of this system in the presence of added
AgBF4 to check out the relevance of this hypothesis. The
result shows a strong enhancement of the signals of 8c, add-
ing support to this suggestion. In addition, tin satellites are
clearly visible for the resonance of H1, exhibiting a value
for 2J(HSn), which is close to that of the related complex 3c.
By contrast to the PPh3 and PEtPh2 chloride systems the
addition of parahydrogen to the corresponding bromide
systems gives rise to relatively stable, tin-containing dihy-
drides which appear in polarization in the PHIP-NMR
spectra. Upon heating, the signals of 9c, which is the brom-
ide analogue of 3c, are clearly visible. The complexes 10c
and 11c can also be detected, which appear to be the tin-
tribromide analogues of 2c and 7c, respectively. The high-
field shift of the hydrogen in trans-position to the tin ligand
indicates a lower trans-effect of SnBr3– as compared to that
of SnCl3–. Furthermore, the intensity of the PHIP signals
observed in the bromide systems is generally lower than in
the corresponding chloride system, apparently because of
the lower concentration of RhI.
In comparison to PPh3, the PEt3 ligand has profound
electron donor properties, which causes an extensive incor-
poration of tin ligands into the resulting dihydrides. Accord-
ingly, when using PPh3 as the tertiary phosphane, the
formation of only one tin-containing dihydride is observed,
which is thermally unstable. By contrast, in the system
[RhH(SnCl3)5]3–/PEt3/CD3CN/parahydrogen four dihy-
drides are detectable, which all contain tin ligands. Two of
them, namely 3c and 2c, are rather stable species. The low
stability of the tin-containing complexes with PPh3 as the
ligand is apparently due to the competition of the tin and
phosphane ligands. Furthermore, this process is accompa-
nied by more extensive incorporation of acetonitrile into
the dihydrides.
In particular, the system [RhH(SnCl3)5]3–/PEtPh2/
CD3CN/parahydrogen is remarkable in the sense that it
gives rise to tris-phosphane complexes only. This fact can
be explained when assuming that there exists a fine balance
of σ-donating and π-accepting properties of the phosphane
which is apparently optimal for rhodium-phosphorus-bind-
ing here.
Experimental Section
1
1
General Remarks: All H, H PHIP-, 31P and 119Sn NMR spectra
1
were recorded using a Bruker AC 200 spectrometer; the H{31P}-
PHIP NMR spectra were obtained with a Bruker DRX 200 spec-
trometer. Chemical shifts are referenced to either external TMS
(1H), 85% H3PO4 (31P), or Sn(CH3)4 (119Sn), respectively. For re-
cording the 119Sn spectrum a repetition time of 0.5 s was used, and
the accumulation of 28000 scans was necessary to obtain a spec-
trum with a satisfactory signal-to-noise ratio. In order to obtain
the PHIP spectra, excitation pulses corresponding to a flip angle
of 45° were used. To record the conventional or "thermal" 1H
NMR spectra, however, the pulse width was set such that it corre-
Hydrogenation Experiments
Upon heating, all systems studied hydrogenate added
phenylacetylene in a cis-manner, as can be concluded from sponded to the conventional flip angle of 90°. The solvent CD3CN
Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. 2000, 889Ϫ894 893