Communication
N-allylcarbamates,[11] and show compatibility with chiral Brønst-
ed acid catalysts.
Table 1. Generality of the multicatalytic isomerization/arylation.[a]
In our initial studies, treatment of N-allylcarbamates with
a slight excess of arene, 10 mol% NiCl2·dme, 10 mol% triphos,
10 mol% of the commercially available BINOL-derived phos-
phoric acid ((Æ)-3) with 5 equiv of zinc, and HCO2H gave
access to a range of a-aryl carbamates in good to excellent iso-
lated yields (Table 1, racemic protocol). The developed catalytic
conditions proved applicable to arylation of both tert-butoxy-
carbonyl- and carboxybenzyl-protected (Boc and Cbz, respec-
tively) N-allylcarbamates with a range of electron-rich arene
nucleophiles in good to excellent yields. 2-Methylfuran and
2-methylthiophene proved compatible nucleophiles (2a–c),
providing the desired a-heteroaryl carbamates in excellent
yields. 1,3,5-Trimethoxy- and 1,3-dimethoxybenzene proved to
be excellent nucleophiles in this catalytic system, yielding the
expected a-aryl carbamates 2e–k.
Internal unsaturated carbamates could also be employed as
starting materials with arylated products 2g–i, isolated in 67–
78% yield. In a survey of other aromatic nucleophiles, 1- and
2- naphthol were both well tolerated by the reaction (2d and
2l, respectively). Intriguingly, it was observed that allylcarba-
mate isomerization occurred in the absence of formic acid
when MeCN was used as solvent under an argon atmos-
phere.[12] Enantioselective reactivity could thus be achieved
with indole nucleophiles by employing a sequential multicatal-
ysis protocol without the necessity to isolate reaction inter-
mediates.[13] The chiral phosphoric acid (R)-TRIP [(R)-3,3’-
bis(2,4,6-triisopropylphenyl)-1,1’-binaphthyl-2,2’-diyl hydrogen
phosphate], in combination with N-Boc allylcarbamates 1a
and 1c, allowed the desired a-indolyl carbamates 2m–r to be
obtained in good yields and uniformly excellent enantioselec-
tivities (Table 1, enantioselective protocol).
With a reliable procedure for the multicatalytic enantioselec-
tive a-functionalization of N-allylcarbamates established, we
next sought to apply the same catalytic reaction conditions to
a formal b-functionalization of N-allylcarbamates simply by var-
iation of the reaction partner. Considering that Masson, Zhu,
and co-workers have recently demonstrated a phosphoric-acid-
catalyzed enantioselective Povarov reaction[14] between ene-
carbamates and imines,[15] we elected to probe the develop-
ment of a multicatalytic version of this reaction using N-allyl-
carbamates as starting materials. Initial experiments employing
the aforementioned reaction conditions resulted in poor yields
of the expected tetrahydroquinoline product. It was found that
improved yields could be obtained by reducing the formic
acid equivalents and by pre-isomerization of the N-allylcarba-
mate for 1 h at 408C. According to the newly optimized ‘se-
quential multicatalysis’ reaction procedure, and employing rac-
emic (Æ)-3, a range of racemic tetrahydroquinolines were pre-
pared in good yields and good diastereoselectivities (see the
Supporting Information for details of racemic scope).[16]
[a] Isolated yield after column chromatography. [b] Performed at 608C.
[c] Performed at 1008C. Enantiomeric ratios (e.r.) determined by use of
analytical HPLC analysis over a chiral stationary phase. Triphos=bis(di-
phenylphosphino-ethyl)phenylphosphine, PA=generic phosphoric acid,
1,2-DCE=1,2-dichloroethane.
enantiomeric excess (ee). This decrease was established to be
caused by a competing racemic background reaction catalyzed
by residual HCO2H. Gratifyingly, simply by adding solid NaHCO3
after completion of the isomerization step, a series of enan-
tioenriched tetrahydroquinolines (4a–h) could be prepared in
good yield, diastereomeric (d.r.) and enantiomeric ratios (e.r.)
(Table 2). To demonstrate that no erosion of enantiocontrol oc-
cured as a consequence of the sequential catalytic protocol,
tetrahydroquinoline 4 f was prepared from an isolated sample
of the requisite ene-carbamate using catalyst (R)-5. Indeed, the
discrete Povarov reaction and the sequential procedure fur-
nished tetrahydroquinoline 4 f with almost identical e.r. values
(92:8 vs 90:10, respectively) and comparable yields (85% over
one step vs 76% over two steps, respectively).
Optimization of the sequential catalysis procedure for the
enantioselective preparation of tetrahydroquinolines then fol-
lowed. Phosphoric acid (R)-5, similar to the optimal catalyst
structure of Zhu and Masson, delivered promising initial results
in combination with N-Cbz allylcarbamates, albeit with reduced
&
&
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 1 – 5
2
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!