.
Angewandte
Communications
4 but the source of the HC atom in absence of DTBPH is
unknown. In our conditions, simple consideration of the
respective bond dissociation energy (BDE) values suggest
that the eight benzylic positions of the ligand HL-Cl and
dicarboxylate mpdp2À are the most likely HC donors. This was
=
confirmed by titrating 1 by ArI NTs in absence and presence
of a very good HC donor, dihydroanthracene (DHA, BDE =
76 kcalmolÀ1) and monitoring the absorbance at 482 nm
(Figure S15). In absence of DHA, a plateau was obtained
=
after addition of approximately 0.9 equivalents of ArI NTs at
an absorption of 1.6. In presence of DHA, the plateau was
Scheme 3. Experiments used to determine the formation of 3, see text
for details.
=
obtained at approximately 1.0 equivalents of ArI NTs and an
absorption of 1.75. The higher value of the plateau in presence
of DHA indicates that in its absence part of the chromophore
is consumed. The quantitative difference of about 12% is
consistent with the presence of eight reactive benzylic
positions in the complex that would account for most of the
HC for the formation of 4. In the course of our low-temper-
ature experiments intended to trap 3 we noticed that at
À608C, after an initial time lag (Figure S2), formation of 4
occurred monoexponentially with t1/2 ꢀ 57 s. Since 3 does not
accumulate in the reaction, its decay by HC abstraction is faster
than its formation. Owing to the presence of 16 benzylic
hydrogen atoms it can be roughly estimated that at À608C the
rate of HC abstraction is kH @ 1/(t1/2)[complex] ꢀ 6mÀ1 sÀ1. This
value is in the range observed for the most reactive
compounds described by Sorokin[20] pointing to a very
strong HC abstraction capability of 3.
oxidation state (FeIIIFeII vs FeIIIFeIII) of the resulting complex.
The electron count of the reaction was determined by NMR
=
spectroscopy and HPLC quantification of the product/ArI
NTs ratio. These experiments are summarized in Scheme 3. In
a first experiment (A in Scheme 3), 1 was treated with
=
1 equivalent of ArI NTs in the presence of 1 equivalent of
DTBPH. UV/Vis spectroscopy showed the disappearance of
1 and formation of 4 while NMR analysis indicated the
formation of 1 equivalent of the dimer (DTBP)2 and there-
fore the abstraction of a single HC (Figure S9, S10). This result
showed that the oxidation state of 3 is one unit higher than
that of 4 and that 3 contains an NTs group. In a second
experiment (B in Scheme 3), 1 was again treated with
=
1 equivalent ArI NTs but this time in the presence of
10 equivalents of Ph-S-Me. The UV/Vis spectrum was
unchanged after the reaction and 1 equivalent of sulfilimine
5 Ph-S(NTs)Me was formed (Figure S11, S12). These obser-
vations revealed that the oxidation state of 3 is two units
higher than that of 1 and that it can transfer an NTs group. All
The experiments have provided evidence for the forma-
tion of 3 and shown that it cannot be intercepted and
spectroscopically characterized. To investigate its molecular
and electronic structures, we thus relied on DFT calculations.
Firstly, thanks to the extensive computational literature on Fe
complexes, we successfully calibrated our calculations of
structural and Mçssbauer parameters on related known
dinuclear Fe complexes as well as a mononuclear imido FeIV
species (Tables S5–7). Then both bridging and terminal
binding modes of the N(H)Ts group were considered. More-
over, because in 1 the solvent binds in the position trans to the
bridging phenoxide[21,22] whereas in the insertion product of
the non-chloroprotected ligand, the N-benzyltosylate is
bound in the cis position,[13] we considered both cis and
trans isomers for the calculations of 3 and 4. First, we explored
the tosylamido complex {FeIIIFeIII-NHTs} 4 and observed that
the terminal mode is clearly preferred, the bridging structure
being about 23 kcalmolÀ1 higher. The terminal cis and trans
isomers were very close in energy (cis 4.2 kcalmolÀ1 lower
than trans at the B3LYP level). An illustration of the
molecular structure and the bond lengths to each iron atom
are given in Figure S18 and Table S8. The relevant optimized
III
IV
=
these results suggest that 3 can be formulated as a {Fe Fe (
NTs)} species.
We then intended to characterize the high reactivity of 3
both in nitrene-transfer and HC-abstraction reactions in
a more quantitative manner. Owing to the very fast rate of
the sulfimidation reaction, we resorted to competition experi-
ments between substituted thioanisoles. In a typical experi-
=
ment, 1 was treated with 1 equivalent ArI NTs in the
presence of a mixture of 10 equivalents of thioanisole and
10 equivalents of a para-substituted thioanisole (p-X-Ph-S-
Me, X = NO2, COMe, Cl, Me, OMe). The reaction mixture
was analyzed by HPLC to quantify the two sulfilimines: Ph-
S(NTs)-Me and p-X-Ph-S(NTs)-Me. The ratio of the quanti-
ties of sulfilimines was taken as the ratio of the kinetic
constants of the two reactions. The results are summarized in
Table S4. Figure S13 shows that logkX/kH is linearly corre-
lated (r2 = 0.97) to the redox potentials of the thioethers with
a slope of À1.9(2). This result indicates that the sulfimidation
occurs by a direct nitrene transfer (instead of a one-electron
oxidation and recombination).[19] In addition, a linear corre-
lation (r2 = 0.98) of logkX/kH versus the Hammett constant
sp+(X) is observed with a slope À0.74(6) revealing the strong
electrophilicity of 3 (Figure S14).
parameters featuring the FeIII NHTs bond are in remarkably
À
good agreement with the X-ray structure of the six-coordinate
tolylamido FeIII compound described by Borovik et al.[14] with
an FeIII N bond of 1.968 ꢀ and a Fe-N-S angle of 1278,
À
whereas our optimized FeIII NTs bond is 1.94 ꢀ, with a Fe-N-S
À
angle of 1288. Compound 4 was isolated in the low-temper-
ature experiments as a mixture of two species differing mostly
by their QS values (Figure S3). The values of the Mçssbauer
QS calculated for the cis and trans isomers of 4 are in very
The strong HC-abstraction ability of 3 is the cause of its
transiency and we searched to assess this ability further. As
shown in Scheme 3A, DTBPH acts as an HC donor to produce
1582
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 1580 –1584