Li-I Exchange Mediated Atom Transfer Cyclization
J . Org. Chem., Vol. 63, No. 2, 1998 363
Sch em e 1
the better reagent for this purpose. During the early
stages of this research it was noted that reactions
conducted in the presence of MeLi failed to proceed to
completion unless a large excess (viz., >2 equiv) of the
reagent was employed. Indeed, a significant amount of
6-iodo-1-hexene (1) remains after prolonged treatment
with 1 molar equiv of MeLi (Table 1, entries 1-4).
Control experiments revealed that MeLi (but not alkyl-
lithium 2 or 3) was being removed from solution by fairly
rapid reaction with the methyl iodide generated in the
initial exchange (eq 1) to give ethane. Indeed, the
reaction of 0.1 M CH3Li with 0.1 M CH3I in Et2O at 22
°C cleanly produces ethane with a half-time of ap-
proximately 1.5 h. This sequestration of both MeLi and
CH3I over the time period needed for the cycloisomer-
ization of 1 (viz., 21 h at room temperature; Table 1, entry
1), effectively terminates the isomerization sequence (eqs
1 and 3).
There is no such difficulty when PhLi is used as
initiator and much less than a full molar equivalent of
this reagent serves to convert 1 to 4 in high yield (Table
1, entries 9-11). In fact, as required by the isomerization
sequence summarized above (eqs 1-3), the cycloisomer-
ization reaction is effectively catalytic in PhLi! Thus, as
illustrated below, allowing a 0.3 M solution of 1 in
scrupulously dry and deoxygenated pentane-diethyl
ether solution (9:1 by vol) to stand in the presence of 10
mol % of PhLi at room temperature for 18 h affords pure
(iodomethyl)cyclopentane (4) in 78% isolated yield (ca.
88% by GC) following workup and distillation. In prin-
ciple, a trace of PhLi should lead to complete conversion
of 1 to 4; in practice, it is exceedingly difficult to avoid
premature termination of the isomerization sequence via
inadvertent quench of organolithiums by proton abstrac-
tion from solvent or adventitious moisture when less than
∼10 mol % of PhLi is used to initiate the reaction.
The lithium-iodine exchange mediated isomerization
of 1 to 4 discussed above is superficially reminiscent of
the radical mediated iodine-transfer cyclization of 6-iodo-
1-hexenes that has been documented by Curran’s group.8
Indeed, the radical mediated isomerization of 1 to 4 is a
well-characterized process involving a chain mechanism
that may be initiated by even trace amounts of an alkyl
radical.8,9 Although a preponderance of evidence indi-
cates that the exchange reaction of an organolithium with
a primary alkyl iodide does not involve the generation of
radical intermediates,1,3b,10 it seemed imprudent to rely
solely on such precedent to exclude the possibility that
the conversion of 1 to 4 in the presence of MeLi or PhLi
was the result of a radical-chain process. In an effort to
address this issue, we investigated the reaction of MeLi
with two different alkyl iodide substrates (Scheme 2)
chosen on the basis of their ability to distinguish between
a radical-mediated process and one involving an anionic
intermediate. As demonstrated by the results presented
below, there is no evidence for the intermediacy of
radicals in reactions of MeLi (and by inference PhLi) with
primary alkyl iodide substrates incorporating the 5-hex-
enyl iodide moiety.
Reaction of 2-(allyloxy)ethyl iodide (5) with 1 equiv of
MeLi in Et2O at room temperature for 5 min results, as
shown in Scheme 2, in quantitative â-fragmentation to
give the lithium salt of allyl alcohol and ethylene along
with a 92% yield of CH3I. This behavior is characteristic
of the generation of (3-oxa-5-hexenyl)lithium via a
lithium-iodine exchange;11 the 3-oxa-5-hexen-1-yl radi-
cal, in contrast, is known to cyclize rapidly (k ) 8.5 ×
106 at 25 °C)12 to give the (3-tetrahydrofuranyl)methyl
radical. The reaction of an excess of MeLi with (E)-7-
iodo-1-methoxy-2-heptene (6) in Et2O at room tempera-
ture was also explored: Harms and Stille have previously
demonstrated that generation of (8-methoxy-5-heptenyl)-
lithium from this substrate by low-temperature ex-
The remarkable efficiency of the cycloisomerization
cascade (1 f 4) initiated by PhLi implies that the final
lithium-iodine equilibrium between (cyclopentylmethyl)-
lithium (3) and iodobenzene to give 4 and PhLi, depicted
generically in eq 3, must be quite one-sided. This aspect
of the isomerization sequence was investigated, following
the method pioneered by Applequist and O’Brien,2 by
determination of the apparent equilibrium constant7
(Kobs) for the rapid lithium-iodine exchange, 3 + PhI h
4 + PhLi, depicted in Scheme 1. While the highly biased
nature of this equilibrium (Scheme 1) precluded precise
determination of the apparent equilibrium constant (Kobs
) 340 ( 170), the result leaves little doubt that the
exchange between (cyclopentylmethyl)lithium (3) and
iodobenzene affords iodomethylcyclopentane (4) and PhLi
as required for successful operation of the catalytic cycle
(eqs 1-3).
(8) (a) Curran, D. P.; Chen, M.-H.; Kim, D. J . Am. Chem. Soc. 1986,
108, 2489. (b) Curran, D. P.; Kim, D Tetrahedron Lett. 1986, 27, 5821.
(c) Newcomb, M.; Curran, D. P. Acc. Chem. Res. 1988, 21, 206. (d)
Curran, D. P. Synthesis 1988, 417 and 489.
(7) Following Applequist and O’Brien,2 the apparent equilibrium
constant (Kobs) is derived (Scheme 1) on the assumption that both PhLi
and 3 are monomeric even though these organolithiums undoubtedly
exist as aggregates in pentane-ether solution;3 the actual degree of
aggregation of PhLi and 3 under the conditions of the equilibration
are unknown. The factors affecting the relationship of Kobs derived in
(9) Brace, N. O. J . Org. Chem. 1967, 32, 2711.
(10) (a) Bailey, W. F.; Patricia, J . J .; Nurmi, T. T.; Wang, W.
Tetrahedron Lett. 1986, 27, 1861. (b) Bailey, W. F.; Patricia, J . J .;
Nurmi, T. T. Tetrahedron Lett. 1986, 27, 1865.
(11) Bailey, W. F.; Punzalan, E. R.; Zarcone, L. M. J . Heteroat. Chem.
1992, 3, 55.
this way to the true equilibrium constant for
a
lithium-iodine
(12) (a) Smith, T. W.; Butler, G. B. J . Org. Chem. 1978, 43, 6. (b)
Beckwith, A. L. J .; Schiesser, C. H. Tetrahedron Lett. 1985, 26, 373.
exchange have been discussed.2