Page 13 of 14
Journal of the American Chemical Society
**% 9\Yb# C% I%2 M\]hY# C% 9%# 7 FfYX]WhUV`m IY`YWh]jY 7`]d\Uh]W 9z>
El]XUh]cb HYUWh]cb Zcf 9cad`Yl Cc`YWi`Y Imbh\Yg]g% =AGCKAC &$$+!
(&-# ./*$./.%
*+% IW\k]nYf# <%2 E_Uachc# O%2 >Y]b]gW\# J%2 =i# O%2 FY``]nncb]# C% C%2
BYVfib# L%2 HYihYf# H%2 At\`Yf# L%2 BYk]g# @% 9%2 MUfX# J% H%# 7fh]Z]$
W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg1 HYUWh]cb IWcdY UbX Edh]a]nUh]cb IhfUhY[]Yg%
1FCJ# <CR# &$%,! &&-# (+)$)*(%
*,% Fqa]Yg# E%2 :]s[iYn# C%2 8rW_jU``# @%$;%# 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYb$
nmaYg ]b 7gmaaYhf]W 9UhU`mg]g1 AYm :YjY`cdaYbhg UbX <ihifY :]$
fYWh]cbg% /BR# =TKPF# 1?P?I# &$%)! (*,# (,-.$(,/-%
*-% Kdd# :% C%2 BYk]g# @% 9%# IY`YWh]jY 9z> VcbX ZibWh]cbU`]nUh]cb ig$
]b[ fYdifdcgYX cf Ufh]Z]W]U` aYhU``cYbnmaYg% 1QNN# :MGK# 1FCJ# 0GLI#
&$%+! (,# +/$,,%
*.% FYfYn$H]neiYn# 9%2 HcXf][iYn$EhYfc# 7%2 FU`cac# @% C%# 9caV]b]b[
YbnmaYg UbX cf[UbcaYhU``]W Wcad`YlYg1 bcjY` Ufh]Z]W]U` aYhU``cYb$
nmaYg UbX \mVf]X gmghYag Zcf 9z> UWh]jUh]cb W\Ya]ghfm% :NE# 0GL"
JLI# 1FCJ# &$%-! &,# .((+$.()*%
,+% FYhYfg# C% M%2 CY]b\c`X# F%2 =`]YXYf# 7%2 7fbc`X# <% >%# HY[]c$ UbX
;bUbh]cgY`YWh]jY 7`_UbY >mXfclm`Uh]cb k]h\ ;b[]bYYfYX 9mhc$
W\fcaYg F+,' 8C$*% 5# /J# 1FCJ# =LA# &$$'! &'*# (*++)$(*+,'%
,,% 9c``]bg# J% @%# J7CB El]XUbh 7Wh]jUhcfg1$ 7 DYk 7ddfcUW\ hc h\Y
7Wh]jUh]cb cZ >mXfc[Yb FYfcl]XY Zcf ;bj]fcbaYbhU``m I][b]Z]WUbh
FfcV`Yag% /AA# 1FCJ# <CO# &$$&! (*# ./)$.0'%
,-% 9c``]bg# J% @%2 HmUVcj# 7% :%# JUf[Yh]b[ cZ >][\$LU`Ybh ?fcb$J7CB
7Wh]jUhcfg Uh >mXfcWUfVcbg UbX 8YmcbX% 1FCJ# <CR# &$%+! &&,#
0(+'$0(-)%
,.% 9\U\VUbY# D%2 FcdYgWi# :%$B%2 C]hW\Y``# :% 7%2 9\UbXU# 7%2 BYbc]f#
:%2 HmUVcj# 7% :%2 IW\fUaa# A%$M%2 9c``]bg# J% @%# <Y???zJ7CB$
WUhU`mnYX [fYYb cl]XUh]jY XY[fUXUh]cb cZ h\Y Unc XmY EfUb[Y ?? Vm
>)E) UbX cf[Ub]W dYfcl]XYg1 dfcXiWhg# hcl]W]hm# _]bYh]Wg# UbX aYW\$
Ub]gag% 3NCCK 1FCJ# &$$+! .# +0$,.%
,/% HmUVcj# 7% :%2 9c``]bg# J% @%# CYW\Ub]gh]W Wcbg]XYfUh]cbg cb h\Y
fYUWh]j]hm cZ [fYYb <Y???$J7CB UWh]jUhcfg cZ dYfcl]XYg% /BR# 4KLNE#
1FCJ# &$$-! +&# +.($,)(%
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
*/% :Uj]g# >% @%2 MUfX# J% H%# 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg1 9\U``Yb[Yg
UbX Eddcfhib]h]Yg% /1= 1CKP# =AG# &$%-! *# (()'$((*-%
*0% BYk]g# @% 9%# 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg UbX CYhU``cdYdh]XY 9UhU$
`mghg Zcf Ef[Ub]W Imbh\Yg]g% /1= 1?P?I# &$%'! (# )0,+$)0.,%
+'% CcbbUfX# <% M%2 Dc[iY]fU# ;% I%2 >Y]b]gW\# J%2 IW\]faYf# J%2 MUfX#
J% H%# >iaUb WUfVcb]W Ub\mXfUgY ?? Ug \cgh dfchY]b Zcf h\Y WfYUh]cb
cZ Ufh]Z]W]U` aYhU``cYbnmaYg1 h\Y UgmaaYhf]W hfUbgZYf \mXfc[YbUh]cb
cZ ]a]bYg% 1FCJ# =AG# &$%'! )# *)-0$*).+%
,0% =\cg\# C%2 D]_\]`# O% B% A%2 :\Uf# 8% 8%2 IYb =idhU# I%# CYW\Ub]ga
cZ 7`Wc\c` El]XUh]cb Vm <YL E! Uh Hcca JYadYfUhifY% 4KLNE# 1FCJ#
&$%)! *)# ((.0)$((.0/%
-'% Akcb# ;%2 9\c# A%$8%2 >cb[# I%2 DUa# M%# CYW\Ub]gh]W ]bg][\h ]bhc
h\Y \mXfclm`Uh]cb cZ U`_UbYg Vm U bcb\YaY ]fcb j!zclc Wcad`Yl%
1FCJ# 1LJJQK# &$%(! *%# ,,.)$,,.,%
-(% DUdc`m# <%2 A]YZZYf# H%2 @YUb$=sfUfX# B%2 =cil$>Ybfm# 9%2 :fUmY#
C%2 7bXf]c`Yhh]# 8%# <Y J7CB!B]&hYfh$Vihm` \mXfcdYfcl]XY Ug U bYk
WcaV]bUh]cb Zcf VYbnm`]W 9z> cl]XUh]cb% >CPN?FCBNLK 7CPP# &$%)! *+#
),(.$),)'%
-)% :Ug# 7%2 Dihh]b[# @% ;%2 IhU\`# I% I%# ;`YWhfcW\Ya]WU` 9z> clm[Yb$
Uh]cb UbX U`Wc\c` XY\mXfc[YbUh]cb ]bjc`j]b[ <Y$clc gdYW]Yg ig]b[
kUhYf Ug h\Y clm[Yb gcifWY% 1FCJ# =AG# &$%-! &%# .,+)$.,+/%
-*% :ibXUg# 9% C%2 :YacbhY# :%2 FUf_# I%# IhfYdhUj]X]bzV]ch]b hYW\bc`$
c[m1 ]adfcjYaYbhg UbX ]bbcjUh]cbg ]b W\Ya]WU` UbX V]c`c[]WU` Ud$
d`]WUh]cbg% /MMI# 8GANL@GLI# 0GLPCAFKLI# &$%'! .,# 0*+*$0*,*%
-+% HYb# G%2 =ic# O%2 C]``g# C% H%2 HmUVcj# 7% :%2 9c``]bg# J% @%# Eb
h\Y ?fcb L! HYUWh]j]hm cZ Ub 7[[fYgg]jY JU]`$<`icf]bUhYX JYhfUUa]Xc
CUWfcWmW`]W B][UbX J7CB! 7Wh]jUhcf% 2QN# 5# 4KLNE# 1FCJ# &$%)!
'%&*# (++,$(+,)%
-,% UWYhcbY kUg gY`YWhYX Ug Wc$gc`jYbh hc YbgifY X]ggc`ih]cb cZ h\Y giV$
ghfUhYg% ?hg dfYgYbWY ]bZ`iYbWYg h\Y dfcXiWh X]ghf]Vih]cb Vm X]a]b]g\$
]b[ U`Wc\c` cl]XUh]cb% IYY I? Zcf acfY XYhU]`g%
--% JJED fYZYfg hc hchU` hifbcjYf biaVYf# UbX ]bW`iXYg h\Y 9$> \m$
Xfclm`Uh]cb UbX U`Wc\c` cl]XUh]cb dfcXiWhg# eiUbh]Z]YX Vm =9$<?:%
IYY I? Zcf acfY XYhU]`g%
-.% =\cg\# C%2 I]b[\# A% A%2 FUbXU# 9%2 MY]hn# 7%2 >YbXf]W\# C% F%2
9c``]bg# J% @%2 :\Uf# 8% 8%2 IYb =idhU# I%# <cfaUh]cb cZ U Hcca JYa$
dYfUhifY IhUV`Y <YL E! 9cad`Yl1 HYUWh]j]hm JckUfX KbUWh]jUhYX 9z
> 8cbXg% 5# /J# 1FCJ# =LA# &$%(! &(+# 0,)+$0,).%
-/% AibXi# I%2 J\cadgcb# @% L% A%2 I\Yb# B% G%2 C]``g# C% H%2 8ca]$
bUUf# ;% B%2 HmUVcj# 7% :%2 9c``]bg# J% @%# 7Wh]jUh]cb FUfUaYhYfg Ug
CYW\Ub]gh]W FfcVYg ]b h\Y J7CB ?fcb L!zElc El]XUh]cbg cZ >m$
XfcWUfVcbg% 1FCJ# 2QN# 5# &$%)! '&# (/'*$(/('%
-0% Ih% @c\b# F% 9%2 =iUb# O%2 A]a# O%2 A]a# I%2 FUhcb# H% I% FfYX]Wh]cb
cZ cf[Ub]W \cac`mh]W VcbX X]ggcW]Uh]cb Ybh\U`d]Yg Uh bYUf W\Ya]WU`
UWWifUWm k]h\ giV$gYWcbX WcadihUh]cbU` Wcgh% 9?P# 1LJJQK# &$&$#
((# )*)/%
.'% >cZZaUbb# H% M%# 7``m`]W (#*$ghfU]b Ug U Wcbhfc``]b[ ZUWhcf ]b
ghYfYcgY`YWh]jY hfUbgZcfaUh]cbg% 1FCJ# <CR# %-,-! -.# (/+($(/-'%
.(% I\]b$mU# A%2 Ii[YhU# >%2 I\]b# I%2 >UaUXU# O%2 AUhgiachc# O%2
E\bc# A%# 7Vgc`ihY 9cbZ][ifUh]cb UbX 9cbZcfaUh]cb 7bU`mg]g cZ ($
F\Ybm`Yh\Ubc` Vm CUhf]l$?gc`Uh]cb ?bZfUfYX UbX L]VfUh]cbU` 9]fWi`Uf
:]W\fc]ga IdYWhfcgWcdm 9caV]bYX k]h\ :Ybg]hm <ibWh]cbU` J\Ycfm
9U`Wi`Uh]cb% 5# ;FTO# 1FCJ# / &$$+! &&&# /,0/$/-',%
.)% C]``Yf# @% 7%2 7`YlUbXYf# B%2 Ccf]# :% ?%2 HmUVcj# 7% :%2 9c``]bg# J%
@%# ?b g]hi YbnmaUh]W [YbYfUh]cb cZ >)E) Zfca E) Zcf igY ]b cl]XUh]jY
V`YUW\]b[ UbX WUhU`mg]g Vm J7CB UWh]jUhcfg% 9CS 5# 1FCJ# &$%'! (,#
*+//$*+0,%
.*% :cV`Y# C% L%2 @Ufj]g# 7% =%2 MUfX# 7% 9% 9%2 9c`Vifb# @% :%2 =thnY#
@% F%2 8u\`# C%2 AUaYf# F% 9% @%# 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg Ug 9UhU$
`mghg Zcf El]XUh]jY B][b]b :Y[fUXUh]cb% /1= =QOP?GK# 1FCJ# 2KE#
&$%,! +# (,(''$(,('.%
+(% Ec\cfU# A%2 EbcXU# 7%2 >UmUg\]# J%# >YacdfchY]bg HYWcbgh]hihYX
k]h\ 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU` 9cad`YlYg Ug 8]c\mVf]X 9UhU`mghg% /AA# 1FCJ#
<CO# &$%-! *'# 0+,$0,+%
+)% C]fhg# ;% D%2 FYhf]_# ?% :%2 >cggY]bnUXY\# F%2 D]`[Yg# C% @%2 Bi# O%#
7 XYg][bYX \YaY$Q+<Y$+IR aYhU``cYbnmaY WUhU`mnYg gi`Z]hY fYXiW$
h]cb `]_Y h\Y bUh]jY YbnmaY% =AGCKAC &$%,! (+&# ('0/$(('(%
+*% BYk]g# @% 9%# 8YmcbX h\Y IYWcbX 9ccfX]bUh]cb Id\YfY1 ;b[]bYYf]b[
:]f\cX]ia 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg Jc ;bUV`Y FfchY]b 9cbhfc` cZ
JfUbg]h]cb CYhU` 9UhU`mg]g% /AA# 1FCJ# <CO# &$%-! *'# ,.-$,/+%
++% HcY`ZYg# =%# BafH1 7 Ff]j]`Y[YX IWUZZc`X Zcf 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYb$
nmaYg% /AA# 1FCJ# <CO# &$%-! *'# ,+,$,,-%
+,% 9\]bc# C%2 CU[`]c# E%2 DUghf]# <%2 FUjcbY# L%2 :Y=fUXc# M% <%2
BcaVUfX]# 7%# 7fh]Z]W]U` :]]fcb ;bnmaYg k]h\ U :Y Dcjc :Yg][bYX
<cif$>Y`]l 8ibX`Y IhfiWhifY% 2QN# 5# 4KLNE# 1FCJ# &$%)! '%&*# **.($
**0'%
+-% BcaVUfX]# 7%2 F]ffc# <%2 CU[`]c# E%2 9\]bc# C%2 :Y=fUXc# M% <%#
:Y Dcjc :Yg][b cZ <cif$>Y`]l 8ibX`Y CYhU``cdfchY]bg1 EbY IWUZ$
Zc`X# :]jYfgY HYUWh]j]h]Yg% /AA# 1FCJ# <CO# &$%-! *'# ((+/$((,0%
+.% =f]aa# 7% H%2 IUiYf# :% <%2 Fc`Yb# J%2 P\i# B%2 >UmUg\]# J%2 E_iXU#
@%2 IW\kUbYVYf[# K%# 7 M\c`Y 9Y`` ;% 9c`] :]gd`Um F`UhZcfa Zcf 7f$
h]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg1 Fc`m d\Ybm`UWYhm`YbY! FfcXiWh]cb k]h\ U
H\cX]iazD]hfcV]bX]b CYhU``cdfchY]b% /1= 1?P?I# &$%,! -# )-(($
)-(+%
+/% >Y]b]gW\# J%2 MUfX# J% H%# 7fh]Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg 8UgYX cb h\Y
8]ch]bzIhfYdhUj]X]b JYW\bc`c[m1 9\U``Yb[Yg UbX Eddcfhib]h]Yg% /AA#
1FCJ# <CO# &$%*! ).# (.(($(.)(%
+0% B]Ub[# 7% :%2 IYffUbc$F`UbU# @%2 FYhYfgcb# H% B%2 MUfX# J% H%# 7fh]$
Z]W]U` CYhU``cYbnmaYg 8UgYX cb h\Y 8]ch]bzIhfYdhUj]X]b JYW\bc`$
c[m1 ;bnmaUh]W 9UgWUXYg UbX :]fYWhYX ;jc`ih]cb% /AA# 1FCJ# <CO#
&$%-! *'# ,/,$,0,%
,'% M]`gcb# C% ;%2 M\]hYg]XYg# =% C%# 9cbjYfg]cb cZ U dfchY]b hc U \c$
ac[YbYcig UgmaaYhf]W \mXfc[YbUh]cb WUhU`mgh Vm g]hY$gdYW]Z]W acX$
]Z]WUh]cb k]h\ U X]d\cgd\]bYf\cX]ia ?! ac]Yhm% 5# /J# 1FCJ# =LA#
%-+,! &%%# *'-$*'.%
,(% Ec\cfU# A%2 A]\]fU# O%2 C]nc\UhU# ;%2 ?bciY# J%2 >UmUg\]# J%#
9 gd*!z> 8cbX >mXfclm`Uh]cb 9UhU`mnYX Vm Cmc[`cV]b HYWcbgh]$
hihYX k]h\ CUb[UbYgY Fcfd\mWYbY% 5# /J# 1FCJ# =LA# &$%'! &(*#
(.)/)$(.)/,%
,)% A]``Y# I%2 P]``m# <% ;%2 7WYjYXc# @% F%2 HYYhn# C% J%# HY[]c$ UbX ghY$
fYcgY`YWh]j]hm cZ F+,'$WUhU`mgYX \mXfclm`Uh]cb cZ ghYfc]Xg Wcbhfc``YX
Vm `UVcfUhcfm Yjc`ih]cb% 9?P# 1FCJ# &$%%! (# .*/$.+*%
,*% P\Ub[# A%2 I\UZYf# 8% C%2 :YaUfg# C% :%2 IhYfb# >% 7%2 <UgUb# H%#
9cbhfc``YX El]XUh]cb cZ HYachY gd* 9z> 8cbXg ]b 7fhYa]g]b]b j]U
F+,' 9UhU`mghg k]h\ <]bY$JibYX HY[]c$ UbX IhYfYcgY`YWh]j]hm% 5# /J#
1FCJ# =LA# &$%&! &()# (/-0,$(/.'+%
ACS Paragon Plus Environment