4716
S. Nanduri et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 14 (2004) 4711–4717
Table 3. In vivo hollow fiber assay results of andrographolide
derivatives
ovarian and renal cell lines (GI50 values less than 10lM)
compared to 12 and 14, indicating that the presence of
an ester functionality at C-14, and possibly also at C-3
and C-19, is essential for improving the activity of 6.
In view of this observation, a number of compounds
having ester side chains at C-14 and hydroxyls or alkyl
esters at C-3 and C-19 were synthesized and screened.
Compound Dose (mg/kg) SC score IP score Total score
1b
50
100
300
100
150
100
200
100
200
25
6
14
6
10
14
6
16
28
12
2
6a
9a
2
0
8
8
16
14
28
2
17b
18b
19b
20b
8
6
Thus, 16–18 having a N-Boc-glycinyl group, and 19–23
with substituted or unsubstituted cinnamoyl side chains
at C-14 with either hydroxyls or alkyl ester groups at
C-3 and C-19 were screened.
14
2
14
0
8
4
12
8
2
6
50
14
8
14
12
14
28
20
28
Their cytotoxic activity results indicated that
100
200
14
1. The activity of 16 with C-14 N-Boc-glycinyl moiety
and hydroxyls at C-3 and C-19 improved when the
free hydroxyls were converted to their corresponding
alkyl esters 17 and 18. Further, 17 having acetyl moi-
eties at C-3 and C-19 showed better activity com-
pared to its corresponding propionyl derivative 18.
2. When conjugated esters were added as side chains at
C-14 (derivatives 19–23), the activity improved con-
siderably compared to the parent molecule 6 against
all the cell lines. While these compounds possessed
GI50 values less than 10lM against all the cell lines,
20 exhibited potent activity against breast cancer cell
line (GI50 0.08M) and 19, 21, and 22 showed superior
activity against colon cancer cell line (GI50 0.5, 0.6,
and 0.4lM, respectively). Compound 23 was found
to be less active compared to the above derivatives.
a Compound tested against 4 cell lines.
b Compounds tested against 7 cell lines.
was observed with the acylation of the hydroxyls as in
compounds 9, 17–20. Of these ester derivatives, com-
pound 19 was found to be the most potent compound
exhibiting superior activity compared to both the parent
compounds 1 and 6. Further in vivo studies of 19 in var-
ious xenograft models are in progress.
4. Conclusion
In conclusion, in our endeavor to develop promising
anticancer molecules based on the naturally occurring
andrographolide 1, we have designed and synthesized
19 and a number of related analogues possessing potent
in vitro and in vivo anticancer activity.27 An analysis of
the in vitro results indicated that (a) the intact a-alkylid-
ene c-butyrolactone moiety of andrographolide, (b) the
D12(13) double bond, (c) the C-14 hydroxyl or its ester
moiety, and (d) the D8(17) double bond or epoxy moiety
are responsible for the cytotoxic activity exhibited by
andrographolide and its analogues.
To further understand the role of the epoxy moiety pre-
sent in the above ester derivatives of 6 for their potent
activity, the epoxy modified analogues of 9 (24–26) were
studied. All the three compounds exhibited lower activ-
ity compared to 9 suggesting that the epoxide is neces-
sary for retaining activity.
In summary, most of the ester derivatives of 6, exhibited
good in vitro cytotoxic activity possessing GI50 values
ranging from 1 to 10lM. Compounds 9, 17–20 along
with the parent compounds 1 and 6, were further evalu-
ated for their in vivo antitumor activity using modified
hollow fiber animal assay.25,26 The cell lines needed for
this assay were selected from in vitro studies. Poly vinyli-
dine fluoride hollow fibers containing different types of
human cancer cell lines were implanted intraperitoneally
(IP) and subcutaneously (SC) into Swiss Albino Mice
(SAM). The compounds were administered by IP route
at two different doses for 4days. The doses were deter-
mined based on the MTD values of the compounds.
The in vivo efficacy of the compounds was evaluated
by determining the percentage growth of the cells using
MTT assay. Compounds inhibiting 50% or greater
growth compared to the vehicle control were considered
active and a score of 2 was assigned at the different doses
tested. The results obtained were tabulated in Table 3.
The results indicated that Andrographolide 1, possessed
moderate activity at 50mg/kg and good activity at
100mg/kg doses. However, the corresponding 8,17-
References and notes
1. Gorter, K. Rec. Trav. Chim. 1911, 30, 151.
2. Chopra, R. N.; Nayar, S. L.; Chopra, I. C. In Glossary of
Indian Medicinal Plants; Council of Scientific and Indus-
trial Research : New Delhi, 1996; p 18.
3. Ambasta, S. B. In The Useful Plants of India; Council of
Scientific and Industrial Research : New Delhi, 1992; p 39.
4. Gupta, S.; Choudhry, M. A.; Yadava, J. N. S.; Srivastava,
V.; Tandon, J. S. Int. J. Crude Drug Res. 1990, 28, 273.
5. Deng, W. L. Drugs Future 1990, 15, 809.
6. Misra, P.; Pal, N. L.; Guru, P. Y.; Katiyar, J. C.;
Srivastava, V.; Tandon, J. S. Int. J. Pharmacognosy 1992,
30, 263.
7. Najib, N. A. R. N.; Furuta, T.; Kojima, S.; Takane, K.;
Ali, M. M. J. Ethnopharmocol. 1999, 64, 249.
8. Puri, A.; Saxena, A.; Saxena, R. P.; Saxena, K. C.;
Srivastava, V.; Tandon, J. S. J. Nat. Prod. 1993, 56, 995.
9. Choudhury, B. R.; Haque, S. J.; Poddar, M. K. Planta
Medica 1987, 53, 135.
10. Zhao, H. Y.; Fang, W. Y. Chinese Med. J. 1991, 104, 770.
11. Chang, R. S.; Ding, L.; Chen, G.; Pan, Q.; Zhao, Z.;
Smith, K. M. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 1991, 197, 59.
epoxy derivative 6 showed moderate activity at
300mg/kg. Improvement in the in vivo activity of 6