substituted carboxylic acids. The reaction of these carboxylic
acids with BH bromide 1 under basic conditions followed by
silica gel column chromatography readily provided the
corresponding 2-(methoxycarbonyl)allyl esters 6-11 in good to
excellent yields (Scheme 1b).
utilized di and tri-carboxylic acids to synthesize di and tri-
functionalized allyl esters to test whether these additions could
further enhance potency. For this purpose, carboxycarbonyl allyl
esters 21-23 were synthesized starting from terephthalic acid,
2,6-pyridinedicarboxylic acid, and trimesic acid, respectively
(Scheme 1b). Cell proliferation inhibition of 21-23 indicated
higher potency compared to monoesters of aromatic carboxylic
acids (Table 1).
We then carried out cell proliferation inhibition studies of
5-11 against triple negative breast cancer MDA-MB-231 cells,
metastatic murine breast cancer cell line 4T1, and pancreatic
cancer cell line MIAPaCa-2. These cancers are highly aggressive
in nature with limited treatment options and poor patient survival.
For these studies, we employed the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-
2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) cell viability assay.19
Cell cultures in 96-well plates were incubated with the
compounds for 72 hours, and MTT values expressed as percent
of vehicle-only (control) wells. The IC50 value was calculated for
each compound as the dose required to suppress the MTT signal
to 50% of control values. In general, both electron donating and
electron withdrawing carboxylic acid-derived α-carboxy allyl
esters 5-11 exhibited similar cell proliferation inhibition
properties (Table 1). We further evaluated the SAR of these α-
carboxy allyl esters by taking benzoic acid as a representative
example. Replacing the ester group and substituting with simple
allyl group resulted in allylbenzoate 12 and it did not show any
cell proliferation inhibition properties even up to 100µM
concentration.
As a demonstration of activity enhancing carboxycarbonyl
allyl esters from BH-bromide 1, we have synthesized the prodrug
24 of the clinically important anticancer agent chlorambucil,
which is used for chronic lymphatic leukemia, Hodgkin's disease,
and other types of lymphomas. Although chlorambucil exhibits
good activity against leukemia and lymphoma, it does not exhibit
strong potency against several solid tumor cell lines. For
example, chlorambucil does not exhibit any significant
cytotoxicity at 100µM concentration against MDA-MB-231,
MIAPaCa-2, and 4T1 cells. Carboxylic acid in chlorambucil was
converted into its carboxycarbonyl allyl ester 24 by treatment
with BH-bromide 1 under basic conditions (Scheme 1b). 24
exhibited enhanced cell proliferation inhibition with IC50 values
in the range from 49-83µM against all three cell lines compared
to its parent drug chlorambucil, which has no activity even at
100µM (Table 1).
It is interesting to note that parent BH alcohols 26 and
carboxylic acids (ex. 4-methoxybenzoic acid and 2,6-pyridine
dicarboxylic acid) did not exhibit any appreciable biological
activity up to 100µM concentrations. However, carboxycarbonyl
allyl benzoate 25 obtained from BH alcohol 26 and benzoyl
chloride exhibited cell proliferation inhibition properties albeit in
lower potency than some of the 2-carboxycarbonyl allyl esters
(Table 1). The biological activity of 25 could be attributed to the
leaving group capacity of allyl benzoate in the presence of
cellular nucleophiles.
The structural requirement of the ester moiety for
biological activity was tested by substituting methyl with ethyl
and butyl substituents. The corresponding BH bromides 3 and 4
were synthesized by reacting formaldehyde with ethyl and butyl
acrylates in the presence of DABCO followed by bromination
with HBr and H2SO4. The reaction of benzoic acid with bromides
3 and 4 in Na2CO3/DMSO followed by silica gel column
chromatography purification resulted in the corresponding
carboxycarbonyl allyl esters 13 and 14 respectively (Scheme 1b).
Cell proliferation inhibition evaluation of these compounds did
not result in any enhanced activity, and the methyl ester was
found to be the optimal structural unit for inhibiting cell
proliferation. We then determined the importance of the double
bond for biological activity, since our hypothesis involved the
reaction of nucleophilic cellular components with the candidate
compounds in an SN2’ and/or 1,4-addition fashion (Scheme 1a).
Dihydroxylation of the double bond in 5 with catalytic OsO4 and
NMO provided the corresponding diol 15 in good yield (Scheme
1c). As expected, diol 15 did not show any cell proliferation
inhibition properties against all three cell lines even at 100µM
concentration, indicating the importance of strong nucleophile
acceptance capability of the carboxycarbonyl double bond in
providing the biological activity. Subsequently, the SAR of β-
From these results, two lead compounds 7 and 22 derived
from 4-methoxybenzoic acid and 2,6-pyridine dicarboxylic acid
were selected for further mechanistic studies due to their higher
potency in mono and di-substitution. For this purpose,
concentrations of 7 and 22 equivalent to their 1X, 2X, and 4X
values of their corresponding IC50 of cell proliferation on MDA-
MB-231 were utilized, which corresponded to 8, 16, and 32 µM
for 7, and 4, 8, and 16 µM for 22, respectively. First, overall cell
morphology was examined by phase contrast microscopy after
both short (6 hr.) and longer (48 hr.) treatment times. For both
compounds, little change was evident at either time point at the 4
and 8 µM concentrations. For 7, cell rounding became noticeable
by 6 hrs of treatment with 16 and 32 µM, which by 48 hrs
advanced to clustering of cells into masses that detached from the
culture plate (Figure 1A). For 22 the highest concentration
tested (16 µM) led to noticeable cell rounding, and clustering was
evident at 48 hrs, although most cells remained attached to the
culture dish. Alkylator-induced cell rounding, caused by
perturbations of integrins, cytoskeletal organization, and cadherin
expression, has been reported previously.23
substitution on
5 was evaluated via synthesis of the
carboxycarbonyl ester 16 from the reaction of benzoic acid with
methyl (Z)-2-(bromomethyl)-3-phenylacrylate 2. β-Substituted
16 exhibited decreased activity compared to β-unsubstituted 5
(Table 1).
We then studied the SAR of expanded aromatic rings such
as naphthalene and anthracene with carboxylic acid functional
groups. 1-naphthoic acid and 9-anthracenecarboxylic acid were
reacted with BH bromide 1 under basic conditions to provide the
corresponding 2-carboxycarbonyl allyl esters 17 and 18
respectively (Scheme 1b). Evaluation of 17 and 18 did not
provide any improved cell proliferation inhibition compared to
the benzoic acid derivatives. Carboxycarbonylallyl esters 19 and
20 derived from cinnamic acid and 4-phenylbutyric acid,
respectively, also did not show any elevated biological activity
compared to aromatic carboxylic acids (Table 1). We then
The nucleophilic character of DNA renders it a highly
susceptible target for alkylation. Alkylating agents can react with
ring nitrogens and exocyclic oxygens to produce a variety of
adducts.24,25 Both monofunctional and bifunctional alkylating
agents can result in a range of complex effects, including DNA
strand breakage, cell cycle arrest, and activation of programmed
cell death pathways.25,26