10.1002/cbic.201900630
ChemBioChem
COMMUNICATION
Figure 5a. In Vitro and In Vivo Data (Mouse) Comparison of Steropure G-
Strand PS Insertions Show Similar Trends.
and stereopure guide-strands (Figure 8a, Figure 8b and Table 2).
Based on our findings that G1S is detrimental to efficacy, we
limited this set to G1R containing isomers reducing the total
compounds to 32, of which 25 were synthesized. Consistent with
earlier data, a significant number of stereopure siRNAs have poor
efficacy when compared to the stereorandom control SB1391.
Only a subset of stereopure siRNAs (SB2277, SB2284, SB2301,
SB2308, SB2313 and SB2320) were comparable in efficacy to the
control. To our surprise, the disproportionate loss of efficacy for
most isomers did not translate to significant gain for the active
isomers. It is possible that extracellular stability, unknown uptake
mechanisms, limited Ago2 binding/loading, selective transport of
preferred isomers out of the endosome and other factors may be
influencing the stereopure siRNA efficacy and warrants further
mechanistic investigation. We also confirmed the impact of
increased 2’-OMe/2’F ratio and chiral PS insertions of key AT3
sequence and an additional gene target (PCSK9) in cynomolgus
monkey primary hepatocytes (Table 1 and Table 3).
Figure 6. AT3 siRNA Sequences With Varying 2‘-OMe Modifications.
0 .5 m g /k g S .C . S in g le D o s e
1 0 0
S aline
S B 1 3 91 (M ixtu re)
7 5
S B 2 3 33 (M ixtu re)
5 0
S B 2222 (G 1R ,G 2R ,G 21S ,G 22R )
S B 2477 (G 1R ,G 2R ,G 21S ,G 22R )
2 5
0
Since it appears that only ~10% of the 64 possible isomers
disproportionately contribute to efficacy, future studies would be
important to understand underlining reasons to help design better
molecules. As advances in siRNA dosing and delivery beyond
liver into more technically demanding tissues emerge, the
contribution of isomers to clinical profile may increase in
importance.[15]
0
1 0
2 0
3 0
4 0
5 0
6 0
7 0
8 0
9 0
T im e (d )
Figure 7. Mouse In Vivo Efficacy Data Comparison of Steropure G-Strand PS
Insertions With Two Different 2‘-Mod Patterns Confrim Translatability of Our
Learnings .
In summary, our systematic evaluation of stereopure PS
insertions into double-stranded siRNA demonstrated only certain
isomers have comparable efficacy to the stereorandom control.
Based on our data we conclude that G1R stereochemistry is
critical, G2R is important, G21S is preferable, G22 and P1/P2
tolerates both isomers. Importantly, the approaches translate
across two different sequences and ribose 2’-modification
patterns using 2’-Fluoro and 2’-OMe substitutions. In addition,
recent progress towards simplified synthetic methods[16] could
complement our studies and are a step in the right direction
towards stereopure siRNA therapeutics.
Saline
0.25 mg/kg S.C. Single Dose
SB1391
SB2274 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22R,P1R,P2R)
SB2276 (G1R,G2S,G21R,G22R,P1R,P2R)
100
SB2277 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22R,P1R,P2R)
75
SB2278 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22S,P1R,P2R)
SB2280 (G1R,G2S,G21S,G22S,P1R,P2R)
50
SB2284 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22S,P1R,P2R)
25
SB2289 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22R,P1S,P2R)
SB2296 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22S,P1S,P2R)
0
SB2298 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22R,P1R,P2S)
SB2300 (G1R,G2S,G21R,G22R,P1R,P2S)
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Time (d)
Figure 8a. Mouse In Vivo Efficacy Data of Steropure siRNAs Show Only a
Small Number of Isomers Contribute to Efficacy.
Keywords: Oligonucleotides • Stereopure Phosphorothioates •
Stereopure siRNA Design •
0.25 mg/kg S.C. Single Dose
Saline
SB1391
[1]
[2]
A. Fire, S-Q. Xu, M. K. Montgomery, et. al. Nature 1998, 391, 806-811.
C. Chakraborty, A. R. Sharma, G. Sharma, et. al. Molecular Ther. Nucleic
Acids 2017, 8, 132-143.
SB2301 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22R,P1R,P2S)
100
75
50
25
0
SB2302 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22S,P1R,P2S)
SB2304 (G1R,G2S,G21S,G22S,P1R,P2S)
SB2308 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22S,P1R,P2S)
SB2310 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22R,P1S,P2S)
SB2312 (G1R,G2S,G21R,G22R,P1S,P2S)
SB2313 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22R,P1S,P2S)
[3]
a) J. K. Nair, J. L. Willoughby, A. Chan. et. al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2014,
136(49), 16958-16961; b) V. K. Sharma, M. F. Osborn, M. R. Hassler. et.
al. Bioconjugate Chem. 2018, 29(7), 2478-2488; c) J. C. Rogers, S.
Kornfield. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 1971, 45, 622-629; d) T. P.
Prakash, M. J. Graham, J. Yu. et. al. Nucleic Acids Res. 2014, 42(13),
8796-8807; e) X. Huang, J-C. Leroux, B. Castagner, Bioconjugate Chem.
2017, 28(2), 283-295; f) K. Tatiparti, S. Sau, S. K. Kashaw. et. al.
Nanomaterials 2017, 7(4), 77.
SB2314 (G1R,G2R,G21R,G22S,P1S,P2S)
SB2316 (G1R,G2S,G21S,G22S,P1S,P2S)
SB2320 (G1R,G2R,G21S,G22S,P1S,P2S)
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Time (d)
Figure 8b. Mouse In Vivo Efficacy Data of Steropure siRNAs Show Only a
Small Number of Isomers Contribute to Efficacy.
[4]
[5]
a) A. D. Judge, G. Bola, A. C. H. et. al. Molecular Therapy 2006, 13(3),
494-505; b) E. Fakhr, F. Zare, L. Teimoori-Toolabi, Canc. Gene Ther.
2016, 1-10; c) K-H Kim, M. A. Behlke, S. D. Rose. et. al. Nat. Biotech.
2005, 23(2), 222-226.
a) J. B. Bramsen, M. B. Laursen, A. F. Nielsen. et. al. Nucleic Acids Res.
2009, 37(9), 2867-2881; b) M. Behlke. Oligonucleotides 2008, 18, 305-
320; c) W. B. Wan, P. P. Seth. J. Med. Chem. 2016, 59(21), 9645-9667;
Finally, we prepared a variety of single isomer siRNAs (6
chiral PS insertions) by combining stereopure passenger-strands
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.