C02/)2 D+ .+7 /D*,)7 9/-E(.)
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 4 of 4
DOI: 10.1039/D0TA02318C
UVWWX'@UA9@V'
!"#$%& '%()
: Y/Z I= G= "/-7(.> Q= k(,> 5= G= A= "+.(T> l= i(> A= "= i2/02> G= l2 /.D G=
&/.E> 12%$! F/7! Q%L! :;?a> II> \];]h\]:]q YMZ P= m=AU= k/,> "= i=
"2)6'> P= I,HH20> P= i0,9> G= 52.V2- /.D i= P= k+7)6'> ! A$! 12%$!
F/7! :;?a> +ME> ?;XWh?;\:q Y6Z P= 3= i/V,-,> "= [= I9200+ /.D 5= i=
O/0(D(.D(> 12%$N23(12%$> :;?K> D*> ??\\A?:?a=
@ Y/Z 3= A)/'(> &= "+-(V/R/> &= !'R/V(> O= A+V( /.D l= &/E/> F7&%'7%>
:;;?> DFM> :XKn:\?q YMZ 5= G= I/F()> O= /0D2(-/ /.D U= I= "/77'2R)>
F7&%'7%> :;?;> MDF> ?@@;n?@@@q Y6Z G= 3/.> G= c'/.E> G= l,> "= G/-+.(26
/.D 5= c= o(/+> 12%$! F/7! Q%L! :;?W> IM> \\]\h\]?:q YDZ G= o(> O= c'/+>
Q= k(> l= Q/+> U= c'/+> 3= l, /.D c= &/.E> "#'/(7#8%> :;?W> Q>
W;\:hW;\\q Y2Z O= c'/+> 5= c'/+> G= o(> U= l(.> = Q/+> A= "= O'/77/V>
l= m,> A= %SM/0> k= m,> l= Q/+> 3= l, /.D c= &/.E> 5'/.9! 12%$! V./')!
:;?X> M> W]]hWK@q Y8Z G= Ao= G(/.E> b= Ak= '2.> G= k,> l= A_= k(> &= m2.
/.D k= c'/.E> 12%$! 1/$$*'!> :;?K> NN> XWKK A Xa;:=
W Y/Z i= c',> 3= c+, /.D o= b,> A+L! @'%.93 I#)%.! :;?]> R> ?];??K@q
YMZ c= m/.E> G= U,/.E> G= "/+> o= Q,+> c= '2. /.D l= k/(> ! I#)%.!
12%$! A> I!%J ?;=?;@KL6K7/?:\\X6q Y6Z b= Al= I+.E> "= c'/.E> 3= Ai=
C2(> o= m/.E> I= AU= m2(> 5= Ao= c/.E> l= A&= _/. /.D = m= "/V> A'9%P!
12%$! 5')! @+! :;?X> NN> :;\@A:;\\=
a Y/Z I= I+.E> = l/.> G= U,/.E> $= k,> C= m,> G= m/.E /.D c= c'/.E> !
I#)%.! 12%$! A> :;?K> E> :W?];n:W?]aq YMZ U= m/.E /.D c= G(.>
F*()#&'#K8% @'%.93 V*%8(> :;?K> M> ?\@n?]@q Y6Z &= k(/+> k= O+,> A= I,>
l= Q, /.D c= 5,.> ! A$! 12%$! F/7! :;?]> +I*> K?aKhK?XXq YDZ I=
5/9/.7/> C= P2-9/> 5= 3+4 /.D &= O= "/*(> A1F A--8! I#)%.! 5')%.0#7%(>
:;?]> +*> :@?W;n:@?WXq Y2Z &= m/.E> 3= G(.> b= m,> G= c'2.E> b= k( /.D
O= !)7-(V+F> ! I#)%.! 12%$! A4 :;?]> Q> K::]nK:@aq Y8Z U= '2.> c= AQ=
Q,> 5= "(-T/> 5= AU= c'/.E /.D G= c'/.E> ! I#)%.! 12%$! A> :;?]> Q>
\?\an\?]?=
X Y/Z G= k(,> l= k(,> $= k(,> l= U/.> b= c'/.E> U= U,/.E> l= k(8)'(7T> 5=A&=
k22> G= c'+.E /.D c= O/.E> 56(2.62 :;?a> MIE> K\;nK\Wq YMZ _= U//)2>
&= i/.2-*22> Q= 5/F/)6(> = !6')2.820D /.D i= P= k+7)6'> V#.#+#3
,&(7*((! :;?\> D*+> :W\n:\Xq Y6Z P= 5= P4/)> _= U//)2> k= 572EM/,2-> Q=
5/F/)6(> _= C+D*/)V(> = !6')2.820D /.D i= P= k+7)6'> "#)! 1/$$*'!
:;?a> Q> ]a;]q YDZ &= i/.2-*22> _= U//)2> Q= 5/F/)6(> O= Q+77)6'0(.E> =
!6')2.820D /.D i= P= k+7)6'> ! A$! 12%$! F/7! :;?\> +MF> ?X::]n
?X:@Wq Y2Z G= m/.E> Q= !,4/.E> l= m/.E> b= o(/+> m= A5= k( /.D U= k(>
12%$! 1/$$*'! :;:;> NQ> ?X;? n ?X;W=
\ Y/Z U= U2..(E> A'9%P! 12%$!4 5')! @+! :;?a> NI> WW:Kq YMZ G= Q,+> l=
c'/.E> k= 5'(> l= c',> "= _= "(D2V)/> O= U+,> m= c'/+> I= m/.E> "=
c'/+> b= c'/.E> G= kF> G= c'/.E> b= m/.E /.D c= &/.E> ! A$! 12%$! F/7!
:;?\> +MF> ?\KXWh?\K\:q Y6Z o= k2(> b= k+.E> U= '2.> G= &/.> b= m/.E
/.D 3= '2.> 12%$! 1/$$*'!> :;?K> aa> ?WW\] A ?WW]?=
-29/(.) )(9(0/- M28+-2 /.D /872- H'+7+6/7/04)() Y_(E,-2 5??Z= _[5["
(9/E2) /0)+ (.D(6/72D -272.7(+. +8 8(M-+,) 9+-H'+0+E4 /872- 7'2
H'+7+6/7/04)() Y_(E,-2 5KZ= Cb3I +8 9:A3;$ /872- 7'2 H'+7+6/7/04)()
D+2) .+7 -2F2/0 /DD(7(+./0 )'/-H )(E./0)> D()6/-D(.E /.4 H+))(M(0(74 +8
'4D-+04)() +8 927/0 6+9H02< Y_(E,-2 5\Z= A872- / H'+7+6/7/047(6
2<H2-(92.7> 9:A3;$ R/) -29+F2D M4 62.7-(8,E/7(+. /.D % CA"5
/./04)() +8 7'2 -2),07/.7 )+0,7(+. -2F2/02D 7'2 /M)2.62 +8 T(.6= A00
7'2)2 2<H2-(92.7) ),EE2)72D / F2-4 E++D )7/M(0(74 +8 9:A3;$ ,.D2-
7'2 -2/67(+. 6+.D(7(+.= 5,6' /S,2+,) )7/M(0(74 H+))(M04 -2),072D D,2
7+ 6++H2-/7(F204 2.'/.62D c.Y%%ZA72-H4-(D(.2 M(.D(.E 6+.)7/.7 (. 7'2
H+0492- M/6VM+.2=
&+ E/(. 9+-2 (.)(E'7 +8 7'2 H'+7+6/7/04)() H-+62))> 0(E'7 -2)H+.)2
+. 6'/-E2 9+M(0(74 +8 9:A3;$ R/) 2<H2-(92.72D M4 20267-+6'29(6/0
(9H2D/.62 92/),-292.7 ,.D2- D/-V /.D F()(M02 0(E'7 (00,9(./7(+.
Y_(E,-2 WDZ= &'2 92/),-292.7 R/) 6/--(2D +,7 ,7(0(T(.E /S,2+,) ;=a
" $/:5!W )+0,7(+. /) 7'2 20267-+0472> ,.D2- /. /HH0(2D M(/) +8 n?=a P
F)= AELAE 0= &'2 2<H2-(92.7 D()H0/42D / 9,6' )9/002- )29(6(-602
,.D2- F()(M02 0(E'7 7'/. 7'/7 +8 D/-V 6+.D(7(+.> )(E.(84(.E D26-2/)2 (.
6'/-E2 7-/.)82- -2)()7/.62 /7 7'2 9:A3;$L20267-+0472 (.72-8/62 ,H+.
0(E'7 (00,9(./7(+.= &'2 02))2- -2)()7/.62 () (.D(6/7(F2 8+- /. 2/)(2-
H-+9+7(+. +8 20267-+. 7+ 7'2 6+.D,67(+. M/.D R'(6' 7-/.)82-)
20267-+. 7+ 7'2 H-+7+. Y_(E,-2 W8Z= _,-7'2-9+-2> 7'2 80/7AM/.D
H+72.7(/0 +8 9:A3;$ /7 HU ` \=] Y/S,2+,) ;=a " $/:5!W 20267-+0472Z
R/) D272-9(.2D M4 20267-+6'29(6/0 (9H2D/.62 )H267-+)6+H4 ,)(.E
7'2 "+77 56'+77V4 Y"5Z 927'+D Y_(E,-2 W2Z= &'2 "5 H0+7 -2F2/02D .A
74H2 )29(A6+.D,67(.E ./7,-2 +8 9:A3;$ R(7' 7'2 6+.D,67(+. M/.D
2DE2 H+72.7(/0 +8 A;=a; P YF) $U[Z= &'2 H+72.7(/0 () 9+-2 .2E/7(F2
7'/. 7'/7 +8 R/72- )H0(77(.E YA;=WX P F) $U[Z> H-+F(D(.E 2<H2-(92.7/0
),HH+-7 8+- ),662))8,0 H'+7+6/7/047(6 /67(F(74 +8 9:A3;$ Y_(E,-2 W8Z=
A) 7'2 I_& /./04)() )'+R2D 7'2 H-2)2.62 +8 U!"! +F2- &CA ,.(7> R2
/)),92 7'/7 7'2 &CA ,.(7 (. 9:A3;$ /67) /) 6/7/047(6 62.7-2 YH-+7+.
M(.D(.E )(72Z> R'2-2/) c.%% -29/(.) (./67(F2 D,2 7+ (7) +?; 20267-+.(6
6+.8(E,-/7(+.= $+7/M04> ,7(0(T/7(+. +8 _2Y%%Z> +Y%%Z /.D $(Y%%Z -2),072D
H'+7+6/7/047(6 D('4D-+E2. H-+D,67(+. (. 7'2 9(6-+9+0/-LE-/9 )6/02
Y_(E,-2 5?@Z=
%. ),99/-4> R2 '/F2 H-2)2.72D / .+F20 6++-D(./7(+. H+0492-
9:A3;$ '/F(.E )(E.(8(6/.704 '(E' H'+7+6/7/047(6 /67(F(74 8+- '4D-+E2.
E2.2-/7(+. R(7' :=Kd S,/.7,9 288(6(2.64 /7 W;; .9= &'2 D2)(E.
H-(.6(H02 +8 7'2 R/72-A)H0(77(.E H'+7+6/7/04)7 -20(2) +. (.72-9(772.7
D()-,H7(+. +8 6+.*,E/7(+. M4 c.%% 927/0 .+D2) 7+ H-+F(D2 / ),(7/M02
/9+,.7 +8 2<6(7+. )2H/-/7(+. /M(0(74 /.D 6'/-E2 6/--(2- 9+M(0(74= &'2
"+77A)6'+7V4 /./04)() 6+.8(-92D 7'2 82/)(M(0(74 +8 ),662))8,0 20267-+.
7-/.)82- 8-+9 9:A3;$ 7+ H-+7+. D,-(.E H'+7+6/7/047(6 U: 2F+0,7(+.=
$+7/M04> 7'2 9(00(9+02 H2- E-/9 )6/02 '4D-+E2. H-+D,67(+. R/)
/6'(2F2D R(7'+,7 6+A6/7/04)7= &'2 +M)2-F/7(+. H/F2) / .2R R/4 7+
-2/0(T2 &CA M/)2D 9+D2-/7204 6+.*,E/72D 927/0A+-E/.(6 '4M-(D
9/72-(/0 /) /. 288(6(2.7 '4D-+E2. 2F+0,7(+. H'+7+6/7/04)7=
] = b,> m= c'/.E> G= &/.E> = C/. /.D Q= l,> V./')! 12%$!> :;?]> Q>
aK:=
K Y/Z P= 5= "+7'(V/> C= 5,7/-> C= P2-9/> 5= I/)> 5= O= C/7( /.D &= O= "/*(>
'29= [,-= G= :;?K> :a> @]X\ n @]\Wq YMZ Q= I/9/)> = _= $= "/-6'(+-(
/.D = "= A-/,*+> ! N23(! 12%$! 14 :;?]> +DD> W\> :X]\X A :X]]]q Y6Z
G= O+)6+> "= i(DR200> U= '/> %) #8! "#)! I#)%.! Y:;:;Z= I!%J
?;=?;@]L)W?aX@A;?KA;aK?A?
?; Y/Z b= k(,> k= U2> G= c'2.E> G= Q,+> _= i(> b= "/> O= c'/+> l= k(,> 3=
5+.E /.D c= &/.E> A+L! I#)%.! :;?a> DE> @:\@ A @:\\q YMZ l= k(> G= &/.E>
k= U2> l= k(,> l= k(,> = '2. /.D c= &/.E> A+L! I#)%.! :;?a> DE> W;\a A
W;];q Y6Z 5= _,-,V/R/> G= 32M+,0> 5= I(-(.E> O= 5,9(D/ /.D 5= O(7/E/R/>
12%$! F/7! Q%L! :;?W> IM> a\;;ha\@Wq YDZ "= c'/+> O= I2.E> k= U2> l=
k(,> Q= k(> U= c'/+ /.D c= &/.E> ! A$! 12%$! F/7! :;?W> +MQ> ?\@] A
?\W?=
I=5= 7'/.V) 7'2 I2H/-792.7 +8 56(2.62 /.D &26'.+0+E4 YI5&Z>
Q+F2-.92.7 +8 %.D(/ 8+- 8,.D(.E +8 7'() R+-V ,.D2- 7'2 %$5C%3[
8/6,074 /R/-D %_AA?]L UA@?:=
U!$A&6/5. !A 6$5)#).5
?? 5= 3+4> A= i/.D4+H/D'4/4> "= I/)> C= C= 3/4> 5= O= C/7( /.D &= O=
"/*(> ! I#)%.! 12%$! A> :;?]> Q> aa]\AaaK?=
?: I= 5/9/.7/> 5= 3+4> 3= 5/)9/0> $= I= 5/'/> O= 3= C-/D22H> 3=
P()R/./7'/> 5= 5= AE/)7( /.D &= O= "/*(> A'9%P! 12%$!4 5')! @+!> :;?K>
NR> a;;]na;?:=
&'2-2 /-2 .+ 6+.80(67) 7+ D260/-2=
'!5). %$2 #)A)#)$/).
? A= Q+2HH2-7> "= T/,.> G=AC= G+.2)> Q= O= 5= C-/V/)' /.D Q= A= !0/'>
12%$! F/7! Q%L! :;?W> IM> \KKah];W]=
I B ! "#$%=> :;?:> **> ?A@
&'() *+,-./0 () 1 &'2 3+4/0 5+6(274 +8 '29()7-4 :;<<
C02/)2 D+ .+7 /D*,)7 9/-E(.)