80
A.L. Bergamo et al. / Catalysis Communications 86 (2016) 77–81
Table 1
a
Ethylene oligomerization with 2a-d/MAO systems.
Oligomer distribution (wt.%)c
TOFb (10 ·h−1)
3
C
(α-C
C
(α-C
C
C
10 (α-C10
)
C
12+
Olig. (wt.%)
PE (wt.%)
Total product (mg)
Entry
Cat
[Al/Cr]
4
4
)
6
6
)
8
8
(α-C )
1
2
3
4
2a
2b
2c
2d
2d
2a
2a
2a
2a
2a
2a
2a
300
300
300
300
300
500
1000
1500
500
500
500
500
14.5
10.9
6.80
25.7
6.50
36.7
71.5
72.9
32.9
19.2
35.5
21.3
20.5 (81.1)
17.5 (81.4)
20.3 (86.5)
5.1 (96.0)
20.9 (92.4)
18.9 (90.9)
20.1 (88.2)
9.6 (98.7)
18.2 (92.4)
17.2 (90.3)
19.6 (79.1)
12.7 (93.1)
14.4 (85.5)
17.8 (94.6)
17.8 (95.4)
17.5 (95.4)
17.0 (92.8)
17.6 (89.5)
17.3 (90.0)
17.7 (96.6)
14.1 (91.8)
13.9 (89.6)
13.3 (85.6)
13.2 (97.9)
13.4 (98.4)
14.4 (95.1)
14.7 (94.0)
14.9 (94.0)
14.4 (92.2)
14.2 (88.9)
13.7 (91.1)
14.9 (95.3)
26.3
32.5
26.7
59.4
55.7
31.1
32.4
36.2
35.8
29.9
30.2
34.3
85.7
78.4
13.9
23.4
31.5
92.1
95.6
99.4
98.3
98.5
97.6
89.2
14.3
21.6
86.1
76.6
68.5
7.90
4.40
0.60
1.70
1.50
2.40
10.8
1440
970
3460
7450
1460
2790
5230
5140
2350
1370
850
d
5
6.6 (95.0)
9.9 (98.0)
6
7
8
17.2 (85.9)
16.4 (88.9)
13.9 (88.9)
15.5 (83.3)
19.7 (79.2)
19.9 (73.7)
15.0 (89.8)
19.5 (95.5)
18.7 (96.3)
17.5 (96.3)
17.3 (93.8)
18.6 (90.9)
18.9 (89.6)
18.1 (97.6)
e
9
1
1
1
0f
1
2
g
h
3340
a
Reaction conditions unless specified otherwise: toluene = 40 mL, [Cr] = 10 μmol, oligomerization time = 15 min, P(ethylene) = 20 bar (kept constant), T = 80 °C, MAO. The results
shown are representative of at least duplicated experiments, yielding reproducible results within ± 5%.
b
c
Mol of ethylene converted (mol of Cr)−1·h as determined by quantitative GLC.
, percentage of olefin with n carbon atoms in oligomers; α-C , percentage of terminal alkene in the C
00 equiv of MAO + 100 equiv of TMA.
T = 100 °C.
T = 120 °C.
−1
C
2
n
n
n
fraction, as determined by quantitative GLC.
d
e
f
g
h
Time = 5 min.
Time = 30 min.
Quite different results have been found for similar chromium com-
pyrrolide-imine complexes bearing amine/ether pendant groups
where the oligomer distribution is centered on lighter α-olefins frac-
tions with considerable amount of 1-butene (61.6–65.7 wt%) [16].
This distinct result indicates that such a minor difference in the ligand
structure has a significant impact on the direction of the catalytic
process.
Particularly for 2a-c, the K values (0.65–0.69) calculated from a plot
of log [mol%] vs carbon number (see Fig. S1) indicate that the distribu-
tion deviate little from Schulz-Flory behavior. In this case, we speculate
that these precatalysts operate by a linear chain growth alkene insertion
mechanism (Cossee mechanism) [21]. On the other hand, the higher K
value (1.04) calculated for 2d suggests that this precatalyst operates
via a different chain growth mechanism involving the formation of
metallacycles. [22].
In an attempt to decrease the amount of heavier α-olefins fractions
and polymer, an oligomerization reaction was performed using a larger
amount of TMA. However, the activation of 2d with MAO(200 equiv)/
TMA(100 equiv) resulted in a similar distribution of lighter α-olefins
fractions with a slightly decrease of C12+ and polymer along with a sub-
stantial decreasing of the TOF (compare entries 4 and 5).
plexes [Cr{L-C
,5-dimethyl-pyrazol, 3,5-diphenyl-pyrazol) complexes where upon acti-
vation with EtAlCl led to the exclusive formation of polymerization sys-
2 4 6 2 2
H -(N_CH)-3,5-tert-butyl-2-(OH)C H }Cl ] (L = pyrazol,
3
2
tems with activities in the range of 34–122 kg of PE/mol[Cr]⋅h with
production of high-density polyethylene [17]. These contrasting results
might be associate to the type of cocatalyst used to generate the active
catalytic species.
The replacement of the phenoxy by naphthoxy or pyrrolide moiety
promotes a significant impact on the activity and product distribution.
Thus, the activation of 2c,d with MAO lead to a primarily polymerization
systems with activities of 1191 and 2282 kg of PE/mol[Cr]⋅h, respective-
ly, and the amount of oligomers attained only 13.9–23.4 wt% of the total
of products. We assume that this contrasting behavior can likely be as-
sociated to the steric and/or electronic influence of these groups on
the nature of the active species and the oxidation state of chromium
metal center as already observed in similar chromium complexes bear-
ing monoanionic pyrrolide–imino-amine/ether tridentate ligands [16].
With regards to product distribution within the liquid fraction, chro-
+
mium complexes 2a-c produced oligomers ranging from C
4
to C12 with a
similar distribution for α-olefins as presented in Fig. 4. On the other
hand, 2d showed an oligomer distribution centered on heavier α-ole-
fins fractions. Contrasting results were found for related chromium
The DSC curves of the polymers produced by 2a and 2c showed only
one melting temperature peak at 128.9 and 135.9 °C, respectively sug-
gesting mostly the formation of high-density polyethylene (HDPE)
(
Figs. S6 and S8). Conversely, the polymers produced by 2b and 2d
displayed multiples melting temperatures in the range of 71.3–123.4 °
C (Figs. S7 and S9) suggesting the production of linear oligoethylenes
with low molecular weight [8,15].
To obtain further insights into the catalytic performance of this class
of complexes, oligomerization experiments were carried out with 2a
under different oligomerization conditions (entries 6–11). Activation
of 2a with other Lewis acid cocatalysts, including EASC and TMA pro-
duced neither oligomers nor polymer in significant amounts, presum-
ably due to the low Lewis acidity of these compounds.
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
2
2
1
1
5
0
5
0
Increasing the [Al]/[Cr] molar ratio from 300 to 1000 equiv caused an
increase in the activity by a factor of 5.0. However, the use of higher
MAO loading (1500 equiv) did not significantly affect the TOF
−
1
−1
[
72,900 mol(ethylene)·mol(Cr) ·h ]. Thus, the optimum [Al]/[Cr]
molar ratio was found to be 1000. At same time, the use of higher
MAO loading resulted in a slightly decrease in the lighter α-olefins
such as 1-butene (16.6 to 12.3 wt%) and 1-hexene (19.3 to 16.8 wt%),
5
2a
2b
2c
2d
+
and an increase of heavier fraction C12 (26.3 to 36.2 wt%). Furthermore,
Fig. 3. Influence of the nature of chromium precatalyst 2a-d on TOF and selectivity for
oligomers (T = 80 °C, 20 bar, time = 15 min, [Al]/[Cr] = 300).
a higher amount of MAO led almost exclusively to the production of