ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE • November 2000, Volume 7, Number 11
1273
than 22,000 visits per year. The separate psychi- tendon reflexes were 1 plus, plantar responses
atric ED averaged more than 5,000 visits per year. flexor, and no sensory deficit was recognized, her
symptoms were assumed to be psychogenic. She
was admitted to the hospital. Two days later an
Definitions. Our definition of conversion disor-
MRI revealed a thoracic epidural abscess com-
der conforms to the criteria of the Diagnostic and
pressing the cord.
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edi-
tion (DSM-IV),1 which can be paraphrased, in part,
Patient 3. A 43-year-old male prisoner was
as: One or more symptoms or deficits affecting vol-
brought in from jail (just prior to a court appear-
untary motor or sensory function that suggest a
ance) because of complaint of right-sided weak-
neurologic or other general medical condition; as-
ness, numbness, and pain in his neck and back. He
sociation with psychological factors, and lacking
was found to be very hard to examine because of
feigned symptoms; not fully explainable by appro-
his severe pain and apparent inconsistencies in his
priate medical investigation; significant distress or
motor and sensory examination. Conversion dis-
impairment of function, not limited to pain or sex-
order or malingering was suspected and discharge
ual dysfunction.
to jail with prescription of analgesics was planned,
but the patient angrily insisted on a more thor-
‘‘Conversion’’ in practice often serves as a sur-
rogate for a broader variety of nonmalingering
ough workup, since he had ‘‘a history of being mis-
presentations in which the neurologic deficits are
diagnosed’’ for prior problems. With this implicit
believed to be ‘‘unreal.’’ We have used traditional
threat of litigation, the consulting neurologist was
dualistic brain (‘‘organic’’) vs mind (‘‘psychogenic’’)
called, who detected a substratum of weakness be-
terms for convenience, recognizing the need for
neath the variable effort. An MRI demonstrated a
new ways of expressing the difference between
cervical disc herniation with compression of the
presently identifiable and nonidentifiable nervous
cervical cord.
system mechanisms.
In order to assess the educational resources
available to EPs and general physicians, we re-
Patient 4. A hostile, known sociopathic, 39-year-
old male intravenous drug abuser, with a history
viewed more than 30 leading textbooks and man-
of incarceration for major violence, presented late
uals of EM, medicine, family practice, psychiatry,
one night with complaints of abdominal pain, low
and neurology, and searched the journal literature
back pain, and bilateral leg numbness. After a lim-
to identify the guidance provided to nonneurolo-
ited exam, complicated by frightening threats
gists.
made by the patient, the EP suspected that the
problem was psychogenic, either conversion disor-
der or possibly malingering and drug seeking.
However, the EP later reconsidered his degree of
diagnositic certainty and called the neurologist,
who suggested further evaluation, which revealed
pathologic reflexes and urinary retention. Armed
with these ‘‘hard findings,’’ an MRI now appeared
justified and showed spinal cord compression at
Cases. In the six-year period 1994 through 1999,
we identified six cases in which major, presump-
tively neurologic symptoms were initially sus-
pected to be due to conversion disorder (or a su-
perficially similar psychogenic cause), but in which
serious organic pathology was finally diagnosed.
Patient 1. A 66-year-old woman with schizophre- cord level T 9–10, due to Staphylococcus aureus
nia presented with inability to void and complaint abscess.
of ‘‘my legs hurt, I can’t move them.’’ She was re-
Patient 5. A 24-year-old woman in the seventh
month of pregnancy presented to the ED because
of one week of increasing low back pain, numbness
in the legs and the saddle area, and lower limb
weakness. An orthopedic resident, called in con-
sultation, diagnosed a conversion disorder. The
consulting obstetrician harbored doubts, however,
and somewhat apologetically summoned the neu-
rologist. A cauda equina syndrome was diagnosed
and documented by MRI to be due to a herniated
lumbar disc.
garded as a verbally rambling, anxious, and un-
reliable historian with no focal neurologic deficits
and no bona fide neurologic problem. She was ad-
mitted and treated for a urinary tract infection,
but her neurologic complaints continued to be min-
imized as functional. The cause for her leg symp-
toms was not correctly diagnosed until two days
later, when an MRI showed spinal cord compres-
sion due to a compression fracture with a thoracic
disc herniation.
Patient 2. An 82-year-old woman with a history
Patient 6. A 36-year-old woman with a history of
of depression was evaluated because of ‘‘not being
able to get up’’ and because her legs were numb remote psychiatric problems and substance abuse
and painful. Because she ‘‘moved’’ all limbs, deep was evaluated for weakness in her left arm, first