10.1002/anie.201902730
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
COMMUNICATION
Reversible Nature of Coke Formation on Mo/ZSM-5 Methane
Dehydroaromatization Catalysts
Nikolay Kosinov*, Evgeny A. Uslamin, Lingqian Meng, Alexander Parastaev, Yujie Liu, Emiel J. M.
Hensen*
Abstract: Non-oxidative dehydroaromatization of methane over
Mo/ZSM-5 zeolite catalysts is a promising reaction for the direct
conversion of abundant natural gas into liquid aromatics. Rapid
coking deactivation hinders the practical implementation of this
technology. Here, we show that catalyst productivity can be
improved by nearly an order of magnitude by raising the reaction
pressure to 15 bar. The beneficial effect of pressure was found for
workers in the early 2000s [17] and, more recently, by Fila et al.
[18]. It was found that applying reaction pressures in the 3 – 6
bar range results in a more stable catalytic performance at the
expense of the maximum attainable benzene yield. The results
of a recent computational modelling study performed by Kee et
al. demonstrated that increasing pressure should result in a
higher benzene selectivity over naphthalene, the latter being
generally considered a coke precursor [19].
different Mo/ZSM-5 catalysts and
a wide range of reaction
temperatures and space velocities. High-pressure operando X-ray
absorption spectroscopy demonstrated that the structure of the
active Mo-phase was not affected by operation at elevated pressure.
Isotope labeling experiments, supported by mass-spectrometry
and 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, indicated the
reversible nature of coke formation. The improved performance can
be attributed to faster coke hydrogenation at increased pressure,
overall resulting in a lower coke selectivity and better utilization of
the zeolite micropore space.
According to Le Chatelier's principle, the equilibrium of
methane dehydroaromatization reaction is shifted towards
methane at increasing pressure:
6 ꢀꢁ4 ⇄ ꢀ6ꢁ6 + 9 ꢁ2
We also note that coke formation should be suppressed stronger
by increasing pressure (as nearly two times more molecules are
produced than converted):
ꢀꢁ4 ⇄ ꢀꢁꢂ
) + ꢃ( ) ꢁ2
ꢄ→2
(
ꢂ→0
Methane dehydroaromatization (MDA) over Mo-containing
zeolite catalysts is a promising reaction for the direct conversion
of natural gas to a mixture of liquid BTX aromatics (mainly
benzene) and hydrogen [1]. This thermodynamically limited non-
oxidative reaction requires temperatures as high as 600 –
800 °C to achieve a significant methane conversion. A major
challenge in the realization of a practical MDA process is the
rapid deactivation of Mo/ZSM-5 catalysts. Recent advances in
our understanding how these catalysts work at the atomic level
can aid in strategies to reduce the coking deactivation. It has
been demonstrated that the mechanism involves a pool of
(radical) hydrocarbon reaction intermediates relevant to the
formation of aromatics [2]. The structure of the active
molybdenum centers has been thoroughly studied by means
of 95Mo NMR [3], operando Raman [4] and XAS spectroscopy [5],
and other techniques [6]. There is a growing consensus that the
active centers are monomeric or dimeric molybdenum
(oxy)carbidic species which are stabilized inside the zeolite
pores, while larger Mo2C species on the external surface are
mere spectators [7]. Various methods to enhance the activity
and stability of Mo/ZSM-5 catalysts have been developed as
well and they include: (i) application of hydrogen-selective
membranes to remove hydrogen from the reaction zone and
shift the equilibrium towards aromatic products [8]; (ii) adsorptive
or oxidative scavenging of hydrogen for the same purpose [9];
(iii) periodic pulsing of small amounts of oxygen for the selective
coke combustion [10]; (iv) use of oxygen-permeable membranes
for a controlled supply of a small amount of oxygen for removal
of coke species [11]; and (v) reaction-regeneration cycling via
combustion or reduction of coke [12]. Furthermore, the influence
of such parameters as temperature and space velocity of
methane [13] and continuous co-feeding of hydrogen [14],
oxygen [15] and oxygenates [16] has been studied in great detail.
The reaction pressure remains a poorly explored parameter.
Nearly all laboratory MDA studies have been performed at
atmospheric pressure. In fact, to the best of our knowledge the
only reports on the effect of pressure were by Ichikawa and co-
To illustrate this point, Fig. S1 shows the results of
a
thermodynamic analysis. The maximum thermodynamic yields
of the main MDA products, except for ethane, decrease with
increasing pressure. The effect of pressure on product formation
increases in the order: ethane (no effect) << ethylene = xylene <
toluene
<
benzene
<
naphthalene << graphite (coke).
Accordingly, this thermodynamic analysis suggests that
performing the reaction at elevated pressure might lead to a
decreased coke selectivity and, therefore, higher catalyst
productivity [20].
In this work, we show that operation of the MDA reaction at
elevated pressure is an efficient way to increase catalyst lifetime
and total hydrocarbon productivity, by decreasing the coke
selectivity. Transient kinetic measurements using 13C-labelled
methane evidence the reversible nature of coke formation during
the MDA reaction. At elevated pressure, coke hydrogenation
becomes faster, effectively resulting in a slower build-up of
carbonaceous deposits. We also present operando high-
pressure X-ray absorption near-edge structure (XANES)
spectroscopy results, demonstrating that the speciation of the
active Mo species is not affected by high-pressure operation.
For the experiments, we used a 2%Mo/ZSM-5 (Si/Al 13, see
Table S1 for physico-chemical properties). Earlier, we have
shown that in such a catalyst nearly all Mo atoms are involved in
the MDA reaction [2a]. MDA activity measurements were
performed at 700 °C in a quartz reactor (i.d. 4 mm, o.d. 8 mm),
which can be safely operated up to a pressure of 20 bar. The
catalytic results (Fig. 1 and Table S2) demonstrate that raising
the reaction pressure results in a higher catalyst productivity.
The cumulative yield of aromatic products is substantially higher
at elevated reaction pressure. For instance, the cumulative
amount of benzene, toluene and xylenes obtained at 15 bar is
about one order of magnitude higher than that at 1 bar. About
four times more methane could be converted at 15 bar than at
atmospheric pressure, mainly due to a lower selectivity to
carbonaceous deposits that deactivate the catalyst. We observe
that with increasing pressure the formation of ethane is
promoted due to the fact that its production is least influenced by
pressure. The main reason for the enhanced hydrocarbon
product yields is a decreased total coke selectivity (from 32.6%
Laboratory of Inorganic Materials and Catalysis
Eindhoven University of Technology
PO Box 513, 5600 MB Eindhoven, The Netherlands
E-mail: N.A.Kosinov@tue.nl, E.J.M. Hensen@tue.nl
1
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.