M. Nardi et al. / Tetrahedron 71 (2015) 1132e1135
1133
diethyl ether (DEE) as solvent reaction,14 giving often higher re-
action yields. 2-MeTHF allows easy product isolation because of its
water immiscibility, simple solvent recovery and drying, because it
forms a water-rich azeotrope at atmospheric pressure, and im-
proved extraction yields by reducing the number of extraction
The decrease of the amount of NaBH
and catalyst, respectively
4
to 1 and 0.1 M ratio (entries 9e12 in Table 1), shows excellent re-
sults at least in the case of CeCl $7H O (entry 9 in Table 1).
3
2
Surprisingly, when the same process was carried out in 2-
MeTHF, both cerium (III) and erbium (III) triflate gave quantita-
tive conversion of substrate 1 with very high yield of the allyl al-
cohol 1a (entries 14 and 16 in Table 1) especially in the case of
Er(OTf) , which showed high selectivity (94:6, 1a:1b) for the un-
3
saturated alcohol.
Decreasing or increasing the amount of the erbium (III) catalyst
did not improve yield and/or stereoselectivity of the process (en-
tries 17 and 18 in Table 1), whereas an excellent result was recorded
15
steps.
This solvent is increasingly being used in route development in
16
GSK and is considered negative for genotoxicity and mutagenic-
17
ity. Taken together these new data assist in broadening the usage
of 2-MeTHF in early phase development where the drug substance
is being prepared for short-term safety and clinical.
Thus, here we demonstrate that the Er(OTf)
3
in 2-MeTHF is
a very efficient system for the
a
,b
-unsaturated carbonyl compounds
4
using 0.75 M ratio of NaBH and only 5 mol % of Lewis acid, when
reduction to allylic alcohols.
a quantitative conversion of 1 with very high stereoselectivity for
unsaturated alcohol 1a was observed (entry 19 in Table 1). Finally, it
is worth noting that the same reaction performed in the absence of
catalyst, led to the quantitative formation of the saturated alcohol
1b (entry 20 in Table 1).
2
. Results and discussion
Our initial studies began with the optimization of the reaction
conditions using 2-cyclopentenone as lead substrate, Lewis acid
and NaBH as reducing system with different molar ratio substrate/
NaBH /Lewis acid.
2
Firstly, we compared the catalytic action of CeCl O, the
In light of these results the best reaction protocol was estab-
lished as follows: to a solution of the starting material and Er(OTf)
3
4
4
(5 mol %) in 2-MeTHF 1.0 equiv of sodium borohydride was added
under stirring at room temperature. Noteworthy, no purification
steps were necessary to isolate the organic products after work-up.
Anyhow, the work-up procedure itself involved the simple addic-
tion of water in order to quench the catalyst followed by the sep-
aration of organic phase and its evaporation under reduced
pressure.
Thus, to explore the generality of the described protocol, the
above reported experimental conditions were applied to the 1,2-
reduction of a broad range of a,b-unsaturated carbonyl compounds.
3
$7H
3 2
$6H O (Table 1) using
original Luche reaction promoter, and ErCl
the same conditions.
Table 1
Optimization of reduction reaction with 2-cyclopentenone as model substrate and
NaBH
4
as a reducing systema
Entry Lewis acid
Molar ratiob Solvent
CeCl $7H
Work-up Yield % Selectivityc
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
8
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
3
2
O
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
1/4/1
MeOH
MeOH
MeOH
MeOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
EtOH
2-MeTHF
2-MeTHF
2-MeTHF
2-MeTHF
2-MeTHF
2-MeTHF
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O/Et
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
2
O
100
100
42
100
100
100
44
100
100
100
100
40
100
100
100
49
97:3
95:5
92:8
90:10
96:4
91:9
93:7
91:9
95:5
Ce(OTf)
ErCl $6H
Er(OTf)
CeCl $7H
Ce(OTf)
ErCl $6H
Er(OTf)
CeCl $7H
Ce(OTf)
Er(OTf)
ErCl $6H
Er(OTf)
CeCl $7H
Ce(OTf)
ErCl $6H
3
We obtained almost complete selectivity for the majority of
substrates (Table). In particular, the selectivity was higher for six-
membered rings than for five- and seven-membered rings
(Table 2, entries 1 and 3) while for five-membered rings better
3
2
O
3
3
2
O
d
3
O
results were observed for
tries 2).
b-substituted compounds (Table 2, en-
3
2
3
3
2
O
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/4/1
Our results were comparable to the classical Luche reduction but
we realized a significant greening of the whole process compared
to several previous protocols that required the use of a stoichio-
metric amount of catalyst in harmful solvents.
0d
78:22
91:9
3
3
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
3
2
O
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.1
1/1/0.2
1/1/0.05
76:24
60:40
29:71
86:14
39:61
94:6
97:3
90:10
96:4
3
3
2
O
The protocol, tested on chiral substrates such as 3,5-
dimethylcyclohex-2-enone, (R)-carvone and (R)-pulegone, terpe-
3
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
3
2
O
15
noid important widespread in nature, displayed a significant
diastereoselectivity towards the cis-corresponding allyl alcohol
Er(OTf)
Er(OTf)
Er(OTf)
Er(OTf)
Er(OTf)
3
3
3
3
3
100
100
100
100
100
4
(Table 2, entries 8 and 9). This shows that NaBH prefers to ap-
proach the carbonyl group from the axial direction (Scheme 2)
forming the equatorial alcohol.
1/0.75/0.05 2-MeTHF
1/1/e 2-MeTHF
0:100
a
General reaction conditions: The 2-cyclopentenone and Lewis acid dissolved in
The yields obtained by our protocol were comparable with the
results reported in the literature, bringing at least three pivotal
advantages from an environmental point of view: escape the use of
alcoholic solvents, avoid the employment of stoichiometric
amounts of catalyst and reduce the use of organic solvent in the
solvent (2 mL) was added to sodium borohydride and left under stirring for 2 min
until complete conversion of starting material.
b
Substrate/NaBH
Ratio (1a:1b) and selectivity determined by GCeMS.
4
/Lewis acid.
c
d
6%, 20%, 6% and 3% of cyclopentanone for entries 6, 10, 13, and 15, respectively
determined by GCeMS.
3,4
subsequent products purification steps. Therefore our protocol
employing the Lewis acid catalyst in truly catalytic quantities and
2-MeTHF as solvent, is in perfect accord with the general principles
Considering the surprising advantages experienced recently
using triflate lanthanide salts as catalysts, we decided to explore
also the catalytic activity of Ce (III) and Er (III) tri-
fluoromethanesulfonates in the test reaction.
of green chemistry. Moreover, the method showed to be of wide
applicability being effective for both aldehydes and ketones.
3. Conclusions
As it is shown in Table 1, CeCl
tries 1 and 2 in Table 1) showed better catalytic properties than
ErCl $6H O and Er(OTf) (entries 3 and 4 in Table 1). Complete
3 2 3
$7H O and Ce(OTf) shown (en-
We have developed a new catalytic method for the regiose-
3
2
3
lective and diastereoselective reduction of
a-b-unsaturated car-
conversion of substrate 1 was again observed with cerium salts
when the reaction was performed in ethanol (entries 5 and 6 in
Table 1), while very poor stereoselectivity was observed in the case
of erbium salts (entries 7 and 8 in Table 1).
bonyl compounds by Er(OTf) in 2-MeTHF. The protocol allows
3
access to allylic alcohols in environmentally friendly conditions,
reducing the amount of catalyst required and simplifying extrac-
tion/purification steps thus avoiding the use of toxic solvents.