I. Rodrigues et al. / Journal of Organometallic Chemistry 743 (2013) 139e146
143
necessary to obtain significant conversion at room temperature
(run 6), but the 1,4-cis rate was found that time less than 80%. The
same was obtained by increasing the monomer to catalyst ratio
(run 7). By raising the temperature to 50 ꢀC, some polymer was
received with good conversion (run 8). Interestingly, complete
conversion was received in 12 h at 50 ꢀC (run 9) and also at room
temperature upon 72 h reaction time (run 10) when inversing the
addition order of trityl borate/Ali-Bu3. This better activity may be
correlated with the initial solubility of the active species (see
Section 2.5). In all experiments carried out with this (1/3 borate/15
Al) combination, at least ca 15% 3,4-defects were still present in the
polymer.
Basically, we observed that five equivalents of trityl borate were
mandatory in order to get high cis-rates, but at the condition to
change the addition order (ie first Al, second borate): when main-
taining the quantity of 15 equiv Al, 87% cis-rate (with less than 4%
3,4-polyisoprene, run 11) was received, whereas when adding first
trityl borate and then Al-co-catalyst, a polymer containing a high
amount of trans-motives (ca 35%, run 12) was formed. This result
could be connected to steric hindrance in the coordination sphere
of the neodymium atom [32]. With 25 equiv Ali-Bu3, ie with the
previous Al/borate ratio of 5, and upon reverse addition (first Al,
second borate), high conversion along with ca 90% cis-rate was
observed (run 13) at 50 ꢀC. In the presence of 25 equiv Al but this
time at room temperature, highly cis-stereoregular polyisoprene
(95.5%, and cis/trans ratio close to 99%), of relatively high molecular
weight, was obtained (run 14). At high monomer to catalyst ratio
(3000, run 15), however, no improvement in terms of molecular
weights but broadening of the polymolecularity was noticed. At
50 ꢀC, the activity was higher than at room temperature, together
with high cis-selectivity that was maintained at a level superior to
95% (run 16). When toluene was replaced by pentane with the same
co-catalyst conditions, the catalyst was less efficient, with higher
amounts of 3,4-polymer (run 17).
In terms of comparison with the literature for other neodymium
catalysts [14,29a], the catalytic systems presented herein are only
reasonably active (up to ca 16,000 g PI/mol Nd/h, run 10); this is
likely related to the presence of the sterically demanding three Cp0
ligands set surrounding the neodymium atom in the pre-catalyst.
An experiment carried out with just trityl borate in the absence
of co-catalyst yielded, within minutes, an intractable material
typical of cationic polymerization affording cross-linked material
(run 18). With pentafluorophenylborane B(C6F5)3 as activator, and
with the same Al/B ratio of 5, good conversion was obtained at
50 ꢀC (runs 19e21). The reverse addition of co-catalyst/activator
had this time no impact upon the final result. Good cis-selectiv-
ities were received (85e90%) but the SEC traces showed broader
polymolecularities. Reactions conducted with Cp03Nd and MMAO
(100 and 500 equiv) failed to produce polyisoprene and they are not
included in Table 1. The “simple” Cp3Nd (2) was also assessed as
pre-catalyst, in the presence of trityl borate ([CPh3]þ[B(C6F5)4]ꢁ) as
boron activator, and Al(i-Bu)3 as co-catalyst, but the experiments
were not successful (run 22). This may be attributed to the low
solubility of complex 2 in the solvent of polymerization. Additional
preliminary polymerization experiments were also undertaken
with the yttrium analog of 1, Cp03Y, which was synthesized as
described in Scheme 1 and characterized by 1H NMR and elemental
analysis.1 We were able to obtain polyisoprene with high activity,
but with addition of Al-cocatalyst and then borate activator in this
order (runs 23, 24). The high amount of 3,4-defects (ca 25%) in the
isolated polymer may be connected to the smaller size of the rare
earth element, by comparison with neodymium, which favors
single diene coordination.
3.4. Mechanistic investigations
As reminded above in the text, the reaction of a Bronsted acid
with a tris(cyclopentadienyl)lanthanide compound was published
in the early 1960’s [7]. Just recently, this strategy was utilized to
elaborate phenoxide complexes as initiators for lactide polymeri-
zation [33]. However, to our knowledge, such reactivity involving
tris(cyclopentadienyl) derivatives of the rare earths, had not been
exploited until now to promote the polymerization of conjugated
dienes [34]. Kaita et al. largely explored the potentialities in this
frame of Ln/Al bimetallics, in the bisCp* series, through borate
activation of alkyl precursors [35]. Our approach strongly differs
from Kaita’s one, since in our case the general idea was based on the
possibility to eliminate (at least) one h5 Cp-type ligand (here a Cp0
one) by direct protonation with an acidic borate activator. This type
of reactivity had already been reported by Ephritikhine ten years
ago in the case of a phospholyl abstraction (Scheme 2) [36].
We thus envisaged the three boron-based molecules e HNB, TB,
or B (see above) e as possible activators in our catalytic combina-
tions as described in Table 1. It is worth to be noted that the
abstraction of an h
5 Cp-type ligand (rather than an alkyl one in the
present case) by trityl borate was reported recently by Chen: a
mono(indenyl)bis(alkyl) scandium complex lost its indenyl ligand
by the reaction with TB to afford the corresponding Ph3Ceindene
and a dialkylscandium cation [37]. Tardif described on his side both
reactivity pathways, i.e. alkyl and ring abstraction, starting from
bisindenylsilylamido rare earths complexes with either anilinium
or trityl borate, giving rise to the elimination of an indenyl group
[38]. Finally, trityl borate was found capable to extract one C5Me4H
ligand from (C5Me4H)3Al [39]. We thus expected that CpR3Ln
(CpR ¼ Cp0 or Cp; Ln ¼ Nd or Y) would behave comparably (Scheme
3, boron activator ¼ HNB, TB, or B), to in fine generate an active
species by subsequent reaction with an alkylating reagent such as
AlR3.
The question of the displacement of a Cp-type ligand (noted
here as CpR) by an alkylating reagent could also be considered,
having in mind the above-mentioned article of Schumann [9]. Thus,
activation of a (CpR)3Ln pre-catalyst by an alkylaluminum reagent,
as depicted in Scheme 4, had to be taken into account in this regard,
despite the a priori steric saturation of a tris(cyclopentadienyl)
derivative, and as also confirmed by the weak NdeAl interaction
reported by Arnold when (C5Me5)Al is added to (C5H4TMS)3Nd [27].
On the other hand, comproportionation reactions that have
been observed in the Cp0 series, and which proceed through
bimolecular processes, account for a possible Cp0 “mobility” in
Cp03Ln compounds (Scheme 5) [2d].
We undertook a series of reactions at the NMR scale aiming at
identifying possible active species involved in the polymerization
process. When 1 was reacted with trityl borate (2 equiv) in C6D6, we
observed by 1H NMR the complete consumption of starting com-
pound 1 along with diamagnetic signals that could be compatible
with tert-BuC5H4CPh3 (see Experimental). Some paramagnetic
signals typical of a Cp0-supported Nd compound [15] were present,
but of low intensity due to poor solubility of the compound formed.
At the addition of Al(i-Bu)3 (10 equiv), all was soluble again,
1
To confirm this chemical formula, a synthesis of Cp03Y was carried out by ionic
Scheme 2. Activation of a Nd compound by protonation of a phospholyl ligand
metathesis from Y(BH4)3(THF)3. The isolated complex displayed the same 1H NMR
spectrum that the one isolated from YCl3.
induced by a borate activator (COT ¼ aromatic C8H8, P* ¼ aromatic tetramethylphos-
pholyl C4Me4P).