Full Paper
MeCN). The aromatic clathrates display appreciable hysteretic
behavior, thus indicating the occurrence of some cooperativity
lographic phase transition and the SCO. For the other mem-
bers of the 1@guest series, the DS and DH values are slightly
smaller, but large in relation to those values obtained for other
(
Table 1). On the basis of the crystal structures of 1@tvp·2H O
2
II
and 1@2PhCN, this cooperativity can be attributed to guest···
Fe SCO compounds with similar SCO behaviors. Although no
guest and host···guest intermolecular interactions, which in-
crystallographic-phase transition was observed for the remain-
ing members of the series, we believe that subtle structural
changes related to orthogonal$oblique interpenetration labili-
ty of the layers should play an important role during the SCO
and represent an important source of entropy for these com-
pounds. This speculative idea is supported by the change in
the slope and the presence of several maxima in the cMT
versus T and DCp versus T plots, respectively.
II
crease in number and intensity as the population of the LS Fe
ion increases (see Table S5 in the Supporting Information). The
latter consideration can also be extended to 1@2PhCHO and
1
@2PhNO given that these compounds are strictly isostruc-
2
tural to 1@2PhCN at 300 K. The crystal analysis of
@2DMSO·3H O and 1@4 MeCN·4H O shows the existence of
1
2
2
hydrogen bonds between the H O molecules and the guests.
2
The strong disorder, however, prevented us from confirming
the presence of significant host···guest contacts. This effect
No direct correlation was found between T1/2 and the nature
(i.e., size and/or shape) of the guest molecule for the whole re-
ported series. A similar situation was noted for the clathrates
[Fe(bpbd) (NCS) ]·guest (guest=CH CN, MeOH (CH ) CO, EtOH,
should also be applicable to the isostructural 1@2DMA·1H O
2
derivative. Despite the lack of appreciable hysteresis for the
three latter compounds, the SCO behavior could be considered
to be moderately cooperative.
2
2
3
3 2
and PrOH). However, a general stabilization of the LS state (in-
crease of T ) with decreasing the dielectric constant e of the
1/2
[
18]
A common feature of the 1@guest derivatives, including the
previously reported 1@MeOH, is the occurrence of a more or
guest was found for the latter system. In the present case,
we observed correlation for 1@2PhCN,
a
clear eÀT
1/2
less marked change in the slope in the c T versus T curves,
1@2PhCHO, and 1@2PhNO , which feature comparable guest
M
2
clearly visible in the @(c T)/@T versus T plots. This change in
molecules and loading (Table 1). In contrast to the bpbd
M
the slope could reflect some structural change produced
during the SCO, which is characteristic of this family of com-
pounds and could be responsible for the crystallographic-
system, this relationship suggests that high e values result in
a LS-state stabilization. The eÀT1 correlation could be ex-
/2
plained by considering the noncovalent host–guest interac-
tions between the tvp and PhX aromatic centers in terms of
phase transition observed for 1@2PhCN and 1@4MeCN·4H O.
2
[
25]
Both derivatives reversibly change from the tetragonal P4/ncc
space group to the orthorhombic Pccn space group when
moving from the HS to the LS state. The change rends the in-
terpenetration of the layers less symmetrical, thus turning from
strictly orthogonal (HS) to slightly oblique (LS). Interestingly,
the same phenomenology was described for the [Fe-
Hammett parameters. The correlation between the Hammett
sp constant of the three aromatic PhX guests and the T1/2 value
of their inclusion compounds is similar to that observed in this
study for eÀT1 (Table 1), thereby suggesting that T , and
/2
1/2
II
hence the ligand field felt by the Fe centers, increases as the
electron-withdrawing nature of substituent X increases. Since
[
18]
(
bpbd) (NCS) ]·guest (guest=MeOH and EtOH) systems.
the location of the PhCHO and PhNO guests in the channels
2
2
2
Concerning the DSC measurements, the DCp versus T curves
must be essentially the same as that described for the PhCN in
1@2PhCN, it could be considered that the interaction between
the guest PhX and the tvp bridging ligand enhances the p-ac-
ceptor character of the latter. In turn, this effect increases with
the electron-withdrawing nature of X in PhX. It is worth men-
tioning that, despite the different nature of the system, a simi-
lar correlation between T1/2 and the Hammett constant was re-
show the occurrence of two or three peaks reminiscent of
those peaks detected in the @(c T)/@T versus T plots, which
M
correspond to the changes in the slope of the c T versus T
M
curves mentioned above. The DH and DS values are in the
À1
À1
ranges 15–23 kJmol
Table 1). Unfortunately, the lack of calorimetric data for the
previously investigated SCO MOFs of the [Fe(L) (NCS) ]·guest
and 81–107 Jkmol , respectively
(
II
ported for the series of dinuclear Fe complexes [Fe(X-pyri-
2
2
series prevents any comparison. Still, these values are in gener-
dine)(NCY)] (m-bpypz) (X=4-Me, 3-Me, H, 3-Cl, 3Br; Y=S,
2
II
[26]
al larger than those typically observed for Fe SCO complexes
BH3).
À1
(
50–60 Jkmol ). The DS value takes into account the changes
in the electronic and vibrational degeneracies of the system
DS +DS ) upon spin-state change, where DS is composed
Conclusion
(
el
vibr
el
orb
spin
of orbital and spin parts (DSel +DSel ). In a regular octahe-
We have investigated a series of inclusion compounds derived
from [Fe(tvp) (NCS) ], a rare nanoporous MOF constituted by
5
1
dron, the HS and LS states correspond to the T and A
2
g
1g
2
2
orb
II
terms, and consequently DSel =Rln(3/1). However, real Fe HS
two orthogonally interpenetrated identical stacks of 2D CPs.
The inclusion of aromatic molecules, such as benzonitrile, ni-
trobenzene, benzaldehyde, and tvp, or of aprotic solvents,
such as DMSO and DMA, among others, has been investigated
in this study for the first time with this type of porous material.
Magnetic and DSC analysis have revealed the occurrence of
complete SCO behavior, characterized, at least, by two re-
gimes, as clearly denoted by the presence of different slopes
sites are usually quite distorted and the actual HS state is also
orb
spin
an orbital singlet; consequently, DSel ꢀ0. DS
is Rln(5/1)=
el
À1
1
3.45 JKmol , a value much smaller than that experimentally
À1
observed. The excess of entropy DSvibr (36–47 JKmol ) stems
from the change in the vibrational degeneracy (molecular and
lattice) upon HS $ LS spin-state change. The much larger DH
and DS values observed for 1@2PhCN and 1@4MeCN·4H O
2
must be ascribed to the coexistence of the mentioned crystal-
and maxima in the thermal variation of c T and DCp, respec-
M
Chem. Eur. J. 2015, 21, 12112 – 12120
12118
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim