Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
undertaken with the energy decomposition analysis–natural
To quantify the relative electrophilicity of P-based
orbitals for chemical valence (EDA-NOCV) method[30] as
implemented in the ADF modeling program[31] at the BP86/
def2-TZVP level of density functional theory (Table 1, see
Supporting Information for full details). Along lines de-
scribed by Michalak,[32] deconvolution of the covalent bond-
ing portion (Eorb) into s- and p-symmetry components for
1a·Fp+ gives donation s(P!Fe) = À61.7 kcalmolÀ1 (65.9% of
acceptor orbitals for 1a·Fp+ vs. 1b·Fp+, solvation-corrected
fluoride ion affinities (FIAs) were computed at the M06L/
def2-TZVP(CPCM:CH2Cl2) level of theory by isodesmic
reaction enthalpies according to Christeꢀs method.[33] The FIA
for 1a·Fp+ is computed to be significantly larger (-DH =
59.3 kcalmolÀ1) than that for 1b·Fp+ (ÀDH = 32.9 kcal
molÀ1). The low absolute values for the FIAs are indicative
a modest overall fluoride affinity,[34] but the difference
D(FIA) = 26.4 kcalmolÀ1 conforms to the interpretation that
P-based electrophilic reactivity should be favored at the
nontrigonal complex 1a·Fp+.
!
Eorb) and back-donation p(P Fe) = À18.1 kcalmolÀ1 (19.3%
of Eorb). An illustration of the electron deformation densities
for the three principal NOCV interactions of 1a·Fp+ is
presented in Figure 4. NOCV deformation density channel
D11 depicts depletion of electron density at P (red) and
accrual of electron density at Fe (blue) as would be expected
for an L-function s-dative interaction. NOCV deformation
density channels D12 and D13 correspond to the backflow of
electron density from an Fe dp orbital into P-based p-
acceptor orbitals with two distinct interaction energies
(DE2orb = À10.7 kcalmolÀ1, DE3orb = À7.35 kcalmolÀ1), consis-
tent with the lifting of pp degeneracy at nontrigonal 1a shown
The reactivity of 1a·Fp+ and 1b·Fp+ toward fluoride
addition was probed experimentally. Treatment of compound
1a·Fp+ with tris(dimethylamino)sulfonium trimethyldifluoro-
silicate (TASF) in acetonitrile resulted in an immediate
change in color from yellow to deep orange (Figure 5a). The
formation of a single new phosphorus-containing species was
evident by 31P NMR spectroscopy, as indicated by the doublet
resonance at d = À3.0 ppm, which displayed large scalar
coupling (J = 971 Hz) consistent with the presence of
by previous XAS evidence.[21] By way of comparison, EDA-
+
À
À
NOCV partitioning of the Fe P bond in 1b·Fp gives
a single fluorine bound to phosphorus via a direct P F
donation s(P!Fe) = À65.8 kcalmolÀ1 (70.8% of Eorb) and
bond. The large upfield shift in 31P NMR chemical shift is
consistent with an increased coordination number at phos-
phorus by fluoride addition, and this inference is confirmed
by observation of the complementary coupling in the lone
19F NMR resonance (d = 27.4 ppm, J = 971 Hz, Figure 5b).
The product was thus assigned to be fluorometallophosphor-
ane 1aF·Fp, in which a fluoride has been added to the
phosphorus of 1a·Fp+ to generate a neutral complex. In
solution, compound 1aF·Fp exhibits time-averaged molecular
Cs-symmetry with a persistent P-Fe bond; 13C NMR spectra
demonstrate an equivalence of the CO ligands (one reso-
!
back-donation p(P Fe) = À13.2 kcalmolÀ1 (14.2% of Eorb).
This analysis therefore quantifies the relatively weaker s-
donating ability of nontrigonal s3-P compound 1a as com-
pared to a compositionally related phosphorous triamide 1b
evident from spectroscopy (see above). Further, a combined
consideration of the spectroscopic, structural, and theoretical
data suggests a relatively stronger p-accepting ability of 1a vs.
1b.
2
nance at d = 211 ppm) with well-resolved JC-P = 49 Hz and
3JC-F = 5.7 Hz coupling constants. Treatment of 1b·Fp+ to
identical fluorinating conditions (TASF, MeCN, rt) does not
result in fluorination but instead returns starting materials
alongside some decomposition of 1b·Fp+. It is evident that
fluoride addition to a higher coordinate phosphorus ligand is
enabled by the enhanced electrophilicity of 1a·Fp+ as
compared to 1b·Fp+.
The air and moisture sensitive orange 1aF·Fp can be
crystallized by slow evaporation of a saturated CH2Cl2
solution at À358C (Figure 5c). X-ray diffractometry confirms
the structural assignment of 1aF·Fp as a metallophosphorane
resulting from addition of an exogenous fluoride to s3-P
ligand 1a without further substitution. With respect to the Fe
bonding environment, compound 1aF·Fp features an
À
increased Fe P bond length (dFe-P = 2.3047(9) ) as com-
+
À
pared to 1a·Fp , as well as a shorter average Fe CCO bond
length (dFe-C = 1.764(3) ) that coincides with a bathochromic
shift of the carbonyl stretching frequencies (nasym = 1952 cmÀ1,
nsym = 2007 cmÀ1). With respect to the P bonding environment,
metrical parameters give a geometry index of t = 0.35,
indicating a geometry closer to that of a square pyramid
than a trigonal bipyramid.[35] The addition of fluoride results
Figure 4. Contours of electron deformation density channels D11, D12,
and D13 describing the bonding between 1a and the Fp+ metal
fragments with corresponding energies and charge estimations
obtained from EDA-NOCV method.
À
in an increase in all of the P N bond lengths by 0.05 < DdP-
< 0.09 as is common for higher-coordinate main group
N
compounds that compensate for their formal “hypervalent”
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2019, 58, 15005 –15009
ꢀ 2019 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim