8
F.C. Schimpl et al. / Phytochemistry xxx (2014) xxx–xxx
However, the aril, which is free of caffeine (1) and rich in sugars, is
digested.
be an enzyme with dual functionality, similar to TCS1 of tea
(Kato and Mizuno, 2004).
Caffeine (1) can be degraded via theophylline (3) and theobro-
mine (2) (Fig. 1). Usually theophylline (1) is the main route occur-
ring with high efficiency, which explains its low concentration, for
example, in coffee tissues (Mazzafera, 2004; Suzuki and Waller,
1984a,b). Theobromine (2) is a precursor and a product of degrada-
tion of caffeine (1) in most of the species where the metabolism of
this alkaloid was studied (Ashihara et al., 2008; Ashihara and
Suzuki, 2004; Suzuki and Waller, 1984a,b). A transient accumula-
tion of theobromine (2) in young tissues of plants accumulating
caffeine (1) has been related to a high biosynthesis rate of the latter
alkaloid (Ashihara et al., 2008; Ashihara and Suzuki, 2004). How-
ever, transient accumulation of theobromine (2) in C. dewevrei
seems to be related to a more significant participation of the theo-
bromine (2) degradation route (Mazzafera et al., 1994a).
The significant accumulation of theobromine (2) in the vegeta-
tive tissues and flowers of guarana might be a consequence of low
conversion to caffeine (1), as observed in coffee mutants almost
free of caffeine (1) (Silvarolla et al., 2004). Support for this is the
very low expression of PcCS in vegetative tissues of guarana
(Fig. 8). However, based on previous knowledge of other plants,
this is not consistent with the amount of theophylline found in
these tissues, which was higher than caffeine (1). Unless guarana
presents a unique metabolism, in the plants studied so far, most
of the theophylline (3) was found as a product of degradation of
caffeine (Mazzafera, 2004), although the pathway xanthine
(7) ? 3-methylxanthine (8) ? theophylline (3) was found as an
alternative in tea seedlings (Deng and Ashihara, 2010). It may be
speculated that, coupled with low biosynthesis from theobromine
(2), caffeine (1) is low in these guarana tissues due to a higher deg-
radation rate, but theophylline (3) degradation might be slower
than in other plants investigated up to now for caffeine metabo-
lism. Only studies using labelled substrates may explain the meth-
ylxanthine concentrations and their metabolism in guarana
tissues, which was outside the scope of this study.
N-Methyltransferases of methylxanthine-containing plants
have greater similarity to each other within the same genus than
among different species (Ashihara et al., 2008; Figueiredo et al.,
2011; Yoneyama et al., 2006). Thus, theobromine (2) and caffeine
(1) synthases from Coffea arabica have more than 80% identity,
while tea and coffee caffeine synthases have only 34% identity.
The identity of the translated guarana PcCS was greater with theo-
bromine synthases (from 44% to 48%) than with caffeine synthases
(less than 35%) identified in other plants (Fig. 7). The contigs
assembled here using the EST sequences of the Realgene EST data-
base had 1083 bp and were similar to other assemblings carried
out with sequences retrieved from the same database [Supplemen-
tary Fig. S1, Figueiredo et al., 2011]. However, as these sequences
were not assessed for expression or their heterologous proteins
were not produced and assayed for activity, it is not possible to
affirm they were caffeine synthases.
The translated amino acid sequence was aligned with theobro-
mine and caffeine (1) synthases from other species and typical A,
B0, and C motifs and the YFFF region of methyltransferases related
to caffeine metabolism were found (Kato and Mizuno, 2004). A, B
and C motifs are characteristics of SAM-dependent O-methyltrans-
ferases (Joshi and Chiang, 1998). The B0 motif and the YFFF region
are specific features of the methyltransferase family, including caf-
feine synthase (Kato and Mizuno, 2004). Salicylic acid carboxyl
methyltransferase, benzoic acid carboxyl methyltransferase and
jasmonic acid carboxyl methyltransferase are other members of
this family (Ishida et al., 2009; Mizuno et al., 2003a,b; Yoneyama
et al., 2006). In addition to the presence of these motifs in the PcCS,
phylogenetic analysis showed that PcCS has higher identity with
methyltransferase sequences from theobromine-accumulating
species such as tea and cacao (Fig. 7), although these sequences
may code for theobromine (BTS1, ICS1, PCS1 – Yoneyama et al.
2006) or caffeine synthases (TCS1
Yoneyama et al., 2006).
– Kato et al., 2000 and
Consistent with the data of methylxanthines concentration in
seeds (Fig. 5), the expression of PcCS was significantly higher in
seeds of immature fruit (Figs. 8 and 9). Complementing this infor-
mation, attempts to determine caffeine synthase activity were suc-
cessful only using seed protein extracts from immature fruit (data
not shown). In order to prove that the PcCS was a caffeine synthase,
a heterologous protein was produced and activity was tested
against several substrates, including paraxanthine. In contrast with
all other caffeine synthases characterized until now, recombinant
PcCS showed theobromine (2) as the best substrate (caffeine syn-
thase activity), followed by 7-methylxanthine (6) (theobromine
synthase activity) (Table 1). No activity was found against any
other substrate tested, including paraxanthine, the best substrate
identified for other caffeine synthases (Ashihara et al., 2008; Kato
and Mizuno, 2004). Theobromine synthase activity of PcCS was
approximately 50% of the caffeine synthase activity.
Small changes in the amino acid sequence may partially explain
the affinity of PcCS for theobromine instead of paraxanthine. The
translated PcCS was aligned with other methyltransferase
sequences and the secondary structure of the caffeine synthase
de C. canephora CcDXMT1 can be used as reference for comparison
(Fig. 6). McCarthy and McCarthy (2007) studied the crystallo-
graphic structure of caffeine synthase (DXMT) from Coffea canepho-
ra and, based on the characteristics of the 15 amino acid residues
within 5 Å of the theobromine binding site, they suggested that
only three have crucial significance for discriminating the sub-
strate specificity of each enzyme, residues 27, 237 and 266. The
residues identified in theobromine synthase are Ala27, Pro237
and Phe266 and, in caffeine synthase, they are Phe27, Ser237 and
Ile266. It is not clearly understood in which way positions 27
3.2. Caffeine synthase activity and expression in guarana
Biosynthesis of caffeine (1) in plants is mediated by the activity
of three N-methyltransferases responsible for the methylation of
xanthosine (4), 7-methylxanthine (6) and theobromine (2) (3,7-
dimethylxanthine). Genes coding for these enzymes have been
characterized in some caffeine (1)-containing plants, but they were
particularly well characterized in coffee (for a review see Ashihara
et al. (2011) and Kato and Mizuno (2004)). Three genes are known
to code for 3,7-methylxanthine methyltransferase (caffeine syn-
thase – EC 2.1.1.160; CaDXMT1 – AB084125; CCS1 – AB086414;
CtCS7 – AB086415). Regarding CtCS7, it is a tentative caffeine syn-
thase because the heterologous protein has very low activity and
only against paraxanthine (1,7-dimethylxanthine) but not theo-
bromine (2). CaDXMT1 and CCS1 caffeine synthases seem to have
unique characteristics as they differ in regard to their affinity for
theobromine (2) (1200 lM and 157 lM, respectively), and their
expression profile, CaDXMT1, is expressed exclusively in immature
fruits while CCS1 is expressed in all tissues containing caffeine
(Ashihara et al., 2011; Kato and Mizuno, 2004). Curiously, both
enzymes have higher affinity for paraxanthine, a methylxanthine
found in minute amounts in a coffee cell suspension (Baumann
and Frischknecht, 1988; Sartor and Mazzafera, 2000) or in tea
leaves (Kato et al., 1996). However, a key difference between these
two enzymes is the fact that CaDXMT1 has low activity against 7-
methylxanthine (6) and theobromine (2) (1 and 4%, respectively,
considering 100% activity for paraxanthine) while CCS1 has much
higher and comparable activities (16–24% for 7-methylxanthine
(6) and 23–25% for theobromine (2)). CCS1 has been suggested to
Please cite this article in press as: Schimpl, F.C., et al. Molecular and biochemical characterization of caffeine synthase and purine alkaloid concentration in