A. Genoni et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 56 (2015) 5752–5756
5753
Indeed, quinine (and quinidine) derivatives are small yet com-
N
N
plex molecules containing five stereogenic centers, a basic and
nucleophilic quinuclidine, a quinoline unit, a secondary alcohol,
an aryl methyl ether, and a terminal olefin (Fig. 1).12
OH
NH2
R
R
R = H or OMe
All of these points of molecular variety have been extensively
exploited for the facile modification of the naturally occurring
alkaloids to develop synthetic, tailor-made compounds for specific
applications. It is also known that Cinchona alkaloids can adopt in
solution several conformations; solvent change, protonation, or
quaternarization of the N-quinuclidine moiety may induce three-
dimensional structural modifications. Therefore we decided to
exploit the unique molecular recognition abilities of this natural
scaffold and to further explore the catalytic behavior of newly
modified Cinchona-derived picolinamides, characterized by the
presence of quaternary ammonium salt as additional steric and
electronic element of stereocontrol (Fig. 1).
N
N
Ar
Br
N
H
N
H
N
N
N
N
O
R
O
R
N
N
Scheme 1. Synthetic sequence for the preparation of novel Cinchona-based
catalysts for enantioselective hydrosilylation of imines.
In synthesizing the novel metal-free catalysts, we followed the
synthetic plan described in Scheme 1. Starting from the naturally
occurring alkaloid, the C9-hydroxyl group was easily converted
into the corresponding amine in a three step preparation and a sin-
gle purification;13 the amino-Cinchona derivative was then reacted
with picolinic acid to afford an enantiomerically pure picoli-
namide.11 Finally the reaction with benzyl bromide (or analog acti-
vated bromide) afforded the desired novel chiral Lewis base,
featuring a quaternary ammonium salt.
This straightforward and experimentally very simple synthesis
allowed the preparation of different Cinchona alkaloid derivatives
in good and reliable yields. Some representatives of this new fam-
ily of catalysts for enantioselective hydrosilylation of ketoimines
are reported in Figure 2. Epi-cinchonine and epi-cinchonidine qua-
ternary ammonium salts 1–3 were prepared, as well as analogous
epi-quinidine derivatives 4–6, typically by quaternarization of the
quinuclidine ring by reaction with benzyl or methyl bromide.14
For the sake of comparison in picolinamides 7–9, non functional-
ized at the quinuclidine ring, are reported in Figure 2.15
thus confirming the trend already observed in our previous work.11
However, poorer results were obtained with compound 3, which
features a more sterically hindering arylmethyl moiety at the quin-
uclidine nitrogen, clearly showing that it is not possible to directly
correlate the catalyst stereochemical efficiency with the bulkiness
of the ammonium salt substituent.
It is worth noting that molecules 1–9 are representatives of a
wide class of multifunctional chiral Lewis bases, as chiral catalysts
for stereoselective reductions, characterized by multiple possible
modes of action. Indeed, while compounds 7–8 feature the picoli-
namide group as coordinating unit to HSiCl3, and the basic quinu-
clidine ring that can also play a role in the activation of the
reducing agent, catalyst 2 has the only picolinamides as activating
unit of trichlorosilane. Furthermore, catalyst 9 might still behave as
a bifunctional catalyst, presenting a different coordination mode,
with the carboxyamide group and the quinuclidine nitrogen atom,
while catalyst 6 probably functions as a monodentate catalyst.
Further studies are required in order to further determine the dif-
ferent possibilities that the Cinchona scaffold can offer, principally
for tuning the catalyst behavior by exploiting steric and electronic
modifications in the catalyst structure.
All the catalysts were preliminarily tested in the model reac-
tion, the hydrosilylation of the N-phenyl-imine of acetophenone
(Table 1), using 3 mol equiv of trichlorosilane and 10 mol% of the
catalyst in dry DCM, for 18 h at 0 °C (Scheme 2).
Once 2 was identified as the most promising catalyst, a screen-
ing of the reaction conditions, that is, solvent and temperature, was
performed; the results are reported in Table 2.
While high chemical yields could be obtained in different reac-
tion media, chlorinated solvents seem to be the best option to guar-
antee high levels of enantioselectivity at 0 °C; while the reaction at
22 °C led to the formation of the chiral amine in lower enantioselec-
tion, by decreasing the temperature it was possibly to further
improve the enantioselection of the process, up to 92% ee, although
with a harsh drop in chemical yield. Finally, the catalyst loading was
In all cases excellent yields were obtained; as expected,
Cinchonine and Cinchonidine derivatives behaved as quasi-
enantiomers and led to the formation of the products with opposite
absolute configuration. Enantioselectivities range from modest to
very good (up to 87% ee), with epi-cinchonine derivative 2 per-
forming clearly better than epi-quininidine-derived catalysts 4–6
(Table 1). From the reported results, it can be noted that the benzyl
salt 2 showed an improvement compared to the parent catalyst 7
and that the picolinamides derived from Cinchonine (2) performed
slightly better than the catalyst synthesized from Cinchonidine 1,
(R)
(R)
R
H
R
N+
H
Structural modification by
- Salification of the tertiary amine
N
(R)
(R)
(R)
(R)
Ar
N
NH
NH
N
N
N
O
O
Quaternary ammonium salt
Additional stereocontrol element
- Electrostatic perturbation of the
secondary amine/amide
R = OAlk : higher steric hindrance
R = OH : hydrogen-bonding interactions
- Tuning of the steric shielding by
modulation of the anion
Figure 1. Novel Cinchona-based picolinamides featuring quaternary ammonium salts.