ACS Catalysis
Letter
competition experiment between thioanisole and deuterated
thioanisole (thioanisole-d3) was undertaken, and a primary
kinetic isotope effect (KIE) of 3.8 was observed (Figure 1C),
implicating deprotonation in the product-determining step.39
Similarly, we monitored the progress of reactions with
thioanisole and thioanisole-d3 in parallel and found a KIE of
3.3, indicating that deprotonation is also involved in the rate-
limitingstep.29 Lastly, wantingtoassociateα-thioalkylradicalsin
the reaction, a radical clock experiment was undertaken (Figure
1D). When 70 was submitted to the developed reaction a formal
(3 + 2) cycloaddition product 71 was isolated. We propose that
71 forms through α-thio alkyl radical generation, cyclopropyl
ring-opening, sequentialolefinadditions, andaHATthatleadsto
product formation, which most likely occurs through a radical
process. Collectively, these data support oxidation to a sulfide
radical cation and α-C−H deprotonation as gateway events
toward α-thio alkyl radicals.
Scheme 2. Proposed Dual Catalytic Cycle
We then focused our attention on understanding how the
product is generated. Specifically, we questioned whether α-
EWG alkyl radical intermediates terminate through a radical
propagating HAT or reduction to an enolate equivalent (Figure
1E). To this end, thioanisole-d3 was submitted to the developed
reactionwiththeexpectationthat, ifHATweretheprimarymode
of termination, substantial deuterium incorporation would be
identified in the product. However, only 12% deuterium
incorporation was observed (eq 1), suggesting that a radical
propagating HAT is a minor pathway.40 With the same design
approach, but with thioanisole and D-methanol (CH3OD), 90%
deuterium incorporation was observed (eq 2). This suggests that
the main path to product formation involves reduction to an
enolate equivalent and protonation from the solvent cage.
Lastly, we sought to understand all the possible roles
CF3CO2Na could play in the reaction. We posited that TFA,
which is produced in situ after deprotonation of sulfide radical
cations, might serve to activate radical acceptors toward addition
and, in some cases, increase the thermodynamic driving force to
reduction of the α-EWG alkyl radical intermediate. This view
finds context in Yoon’s work, where TFA was noted to promote
α-amino alkyl radical addition to electron-deficient olefins.16
Additionally, the groups of Yoon and Knowles have documented
that Brønsted acids can increase the thermodynamic driving
force to reduction of carbonyl motifs.41,42 These precedents led
us to revisit the additive effect observed with TFA with a well-
behaved olefin (Figure 1F). Surprisingly, when TFA (20 mol %)
was used as the cocatalyst, the reaction went to near completion
after 24 h (entry 2), affording the desired product in 70% yield.
This is a considerable increase in yield compared to the control
reaction (entry 1) but not superior to that of CF3CO2Na (entry
3). These results implicate TFA as an active, noninnocent agent
in the developed reaction and suggest that CF3CO2Na plays
multiple roles in leading to product formation.
This reduction ultimately regenerates both catalytic cycles and
produces an enolate equivalent that after protonation affords the
alkylated products.
ASSOCIATED CONTENT
* Supporting Information
The SupportingInformationisavailablefree ofchargeathttps://
■
sı
Experimental procedures and data (PDF)
AUTHOR INFORMATION
Corresponding Authors
■
Edwin Alfonzo − Medicinal Chemistry, Research and Early
Development, Oncology R&D, AstraZeneca, Waltham,
Sudhir M. Hande − Medicinal Chemistry, Research and Early
Development, Oncology R&D, AstraZeneca, Waltham,
Complete contact information is available at:
Notes
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
■
We thank Dr. S. Tentarelli for high-resolution mass spectrometry
data and analyses. We gratefully acknowledge Dr. A. J. Metrano
and Dr. J. W. Johannes for proofreading and insightful
discussions. E.A. thanks Dr. J. J. Beiger, Dr. K. D. Reichl, Dr. R.
A. Escobar, Dr. L. Yan, and Dr. R. E. Ziegler for training and
discussions.
To summarize, a combination of experimental results and
literature precedents supports the mechanism depicted in
Scheme 2. Upon irradiation with visible light, Mes-Acr+ can
access its excited state and reductively quench thioethers,
furnishing reduced Mes-Acr· and sulfide radical cations.
−
Deprotonation of the latter by CF3CO2 affords α-thio alkyl
REFERENCES
■
radicals and TFA. We propose that TFA activates radical
acceptors through hydrogen bonding, lowering the kinetic
barrier of addition by nucleophilic, α-thio alkyl radicals. The
resulting activated α-EWG alkyl radical is expected to be reduced
at potentials more positive than its nonactivated counterpart.
Therefore, reduction by Mes-Acr· would be more exergonic.
Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 15486−15502.
Curr. Chem. 2017, 375, 82.
12594
ACS Catal. 2020, 10, 12590−12595