Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 153 ͑6͒ D99-D103 ͑2006͒
D99
0013-4651/2006/153͑6͒/D99/5/$20.00 © The Electrochemical Society
Electrodeposition of Oriented SrCO3 Coatings on Stainless
Steel Substrates
Sumy Joseph and P. Vishnu Kamathz
Department of Chemistry, Central College, Bangalore University, Bangalore 560001, India
Cathodic reduction of a strontium bicarbonate bath stabilized by a variety of amine-carboxylic acids as ligands resulted in the
deposition of micrometers-thick SrCO3 coatings by electrogeneration of base. The use of diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid
͑DTPA͒ yielded SrCO3 coatings with a distinct c-axis orientation. The degree of orientation is higher in thick rather than thin
coatings. The degree of orientation is also reduced when the DTPA concentration is increased or the pH is increased. These
observations suggest that oriented crystal growth is due neither to the template effect of the substrate nor any additive mediated
interaction due to DTPA but is solely due to the kinetics of crystallization. The Sr͓DTPA͔ complex has the highest stability
constant among the ligands studied, indicating the low degree of supersaturation in this bath compared to those stabilized by other
complexing agents. SrCO3 deposition is a good model for the study of aragonite CaCO3 deposition by virtue of being isostructural
with the latter and having the smallest lattice mismatch with aragonite among the heavier metal carbonates.
© 2006 The Electrochemical Society. ͓DOI: 10.1149/1.2188129͔ All rights reserved.
Manuscript submitted December 13, 2005; revised manuscript received January 23, 2006. Available electronically April 11, 2006.
The crystallization of inorganic materials by heterogeneous
nucleation in different living systems results in the formation of
high-performance materials. The unusual physical, chemical, and
mechanical properties of these materials is due to phase selection,
morphological control, or oriented crystallization that is engineered
by the biosystems during the heterogeneous nucleation process.1
There is considerable interest in mimicking nature’s methods by the
use of suitable additives or specially modified substrates which act
as templates by molecular recognition processes.2 CaCO3 is an ar-
chetypal example of an inorganic material, where phase selectivity
and morphological control has been exercised by the use of fatty
acids,3 block copolymers,4 and Langmuir monolayers.5
Electrochemistry is another method by which heterogeneous
nucleation can be induced on a metal/conducting substrate by the
application of a potential. Professor Switzer and co-workers have
pioneered the use of electrochemistry for the fabrication of
oriented,6 epitaxial,7 compositionally modulated,8 and nanostruc-
tured oxide films.9 Others have studied the electrochemical deposi-
tion of CaCO3 in the context of scaling problems encountered in
industrial water handling systems.10-12
Experimental
Sr͑NO3͒2, NaHCO3, and disodium salt of ethylenediaminetet-
raacetic acid ͑EDTA͒ were purchased from Aldrich Chemical Co.
͑USA͒. All other complexing agents were from Lancaster ͑U.K.͒.
All reagents were prepared using ion-exchanged Type-I water ͑Milli
Q
Academic water purification system, specific resistance
18.3 M⍀ cm͒.
Syntheses were carried out using EG&G ͑PARC͒ Versastat
model IIA scanning potentiostat driven by model M270 ECHEM
software operated in the galvanostatic mode. A cylindrical Pt mesh
͑geometrical area 28 cm2͒ and a saturated calomel electrode ͑SCE͒
were used as anode and reference electrode, respectively. A poly-
crystalline stainless steel ͑SS 304͒ flag ͑area 4.5 cm2͒ was used as a
cathode. The deposition current, i, was varied in the range
5–30 mA cm−2, and the time of deposition, t, was 10–120 min. The
charge input, Q, was calculated as ͑i ϫ t͒ mA min cm−2. Prior to
electrodeposition all the electrodes were degreased with detergent
and electrochemically polished as described elsewhere.22
Biogenic CaCO3 crystallizes in the aragonite modification13
while mineral CaCO3 is generally found in its thermodynamically
most stable form, the calcite modification.14 There is, therefore, con-
siderable interest in the laboratory synthesis of aragonite CaCO3,
especially by the use of electrochemistry. Unfortunately, aragonite is
metastable and is formed only in the presence of Mg2+ and at high
temperatures ͑50–80°C͒,15 while under other conditions calcite is
the only product.16
Baths were prepared by mixing equal volumes ͑25 mL͒ of
Sr͑NO3͒2 ͑0.05 M͒, complexing agent ͑0.05 M͒, and NaHCO3
͑0.1 M͒, in that order. The effective concentration of Sr2+ and com-
plexing agent is 0.0166 M while that of NaHCO3 is 0.033 M. Two
such baths were prepared for each experiment. One was allowed to
stand as control while electrodeposition was carried out in the other.
The control baths were observed for up to 42 h to observe their
stability. This was done to ensure that during electrochemical depo-
sition, no simultaneous chemical reactions took place. The diethyl-
enetriaminepentaacetic acid ͑DTPA͒-stabilized bath was prepared
with Sr͑NO3͒2 and DTPA solutions of 0.04 M and a NaHCO3 solu-
tion of 0.08 M strength. All electrochemical depositions were car-
ried out at the ambient temperature ͑24–26°C͒. The Sr2+ concentra-
tion was varied in the range 0.04–0.02 M and the ͓Sr2+͔/͓DTPA͔
ratio varied from 0.75 to 1.0. SrCO3 was also chemically precipi-
tated onto bare stainless steel flags to generate “electroless coatings”
as controls. No chemical precipitation was observed until the
͓Sr2+͔/͓complexing agent͔ ratio was 20.
All coatings were characterized by powder X-ray diffraction
͑PXRD͒ by directly mounting the electrode on a Siemens D5005
diffractometer operated in a reflection geometry. Data were collected
using Cu K␣ radiation ͑ = 1.541 Å͒ using a continuous scan rate
of 1° 2 per min and then binned into 2 steps of 0.02°. All PXRD
profiles were fitted by the Rietveld method ͑FullProf suite͒, using
the published structure of SrCO3 ͑ICSD no: CC 202793͒ ͑Pmcn,
a = 5.1039 Å, b = 8.4022 Å, c = 6.0210 Å͒.
17
Carbonates of heavier alkaline earth metals such as SrCO3
adopt the orthorhombic structure of aragonite CaCO3 and thereby
behave as model systems for the study of the latter. SrCO3 crystal-
lization has been studied using a self-assembled monolayer,18
thermally evaporated anionic surfactant sodium bis-2-
ethylhexylsulfosuccinate ͓aerosol OT ͑AOT͔͒,19 homogeneous pre-
cipitation by urea hydrolysis,20 and by surfactant-mediated
synthesis.21 All these studies are an attempt to fine-tune SrCO3 crys-
tallization by ͑i͒ the stereochemical effect of specific functional
groups or ͑ii͒ inhibiting crystal growth along specific directions.
This has the effect of controlling the morphology of the crystallites.
In this paper, we study the electrodeposition of SrCO3 on a poly-
crystalline stainless steel ͑SS304͒ electrode and report the growth of
oriented coatings. The study of SrCO3 is especially important, as
among the orthorhombic carbonates SrCO3 has the smallest lattice
mismatch with aragonite CaCO3 and can act as an epitaxial template
for the growth of the latter.17
z E-mail: vishnukamath8@hotmail.com
Scanning electron micrographs were obtained using JEOL JSM
Downloaded on 2015-06-11 to IP 132.239.1.230 address. Redistribution subject to ECS terms of use (see ecsdl.org/site/terms_use) unless CC License in place (see abstract).