.
Angewandte
Communications
Anti-infective Agents
Amphiphilic Tobramycins with Immunomodulatory Properties**
Goutam Guchhait, Anthony Altieri, Balakishan Gorityala, Xuan Yang, Brandon Findlay,
George G. Zhanel, Neeloffer Mookherjee, and Frank Schweizer*
Abstract: Amphiphilic aminoglycosides (AAGs) are an
emerging source of antibacterials to combat infections caused
by antibiotic-resistant bacteria. Mode-of-action studies indicate
that AAGs predominately target bacterial membranes, thereby
leading to depolarization and increased permeability. To assess
whether AAGs also induce host-directed immunomodulatory
responses, we determined the AAG-dependent induction of
cytokines in macrophages in the absence or presence of
lipopolysaccharide (LPS). Our results show for the first time
that AAGs can boost the innate immune response, specifically
the recruitment of immune cells such as neutrophils required
for the resolution of infections. Moreover, AAGs can selec-
tively control inflammatory responses induced in the presence
of endotoxins to prevent septic shock. In conclusion, our study
demonstrates that AAGs possess multifunctional properties
that combine direct antibacterial activity with host-directed
clearance effects reminiscent of those of host-defense peptides.
actions of AAGs were also reported for amphiphilic neo-
mycin and tobramycin analogues.[12,13]
Encouraged by the multimodal activity of cationic amphi-
philic host-defense peptides (HDPs) in the host-directed
clearance of an infection,[16–18] we developed an interest in
exploring whether AAGs can show HDP-like properties.
AAGs that combine direct antibacterial effects with the
induction of immunomodulatory responses in host immune
cells may display superior efficacy against multiple-drug-
resistant (MDR) bacteria. It is noteworthy that for cationic
amphiphilic HDPs like LL-37, the direct antibacterial activity
is antagonized by physiological concentrations of divalent
cations and polyanions, and other host factors.[16,17] However,
HDP-mediated protection has been observed in several
in vivo infection models, thus suggesting that the broad
range of immunomodulatory activities exhibited by these
peptides is the predominant function of HDPs for the
resolution of microbial infections.[17,19–21] With this in mind,
we set out to explore the potential immunomodulatory
properties of AAGs. We were initially interested in develop-
ing multitargeting AAGs that combine the direct antibacte-
rial effect of AGs with the membrane-targeting effects of
AAGs. We selected tobramycin (1; Scheme 1) as the parent
aminoglycoside since it is indispensable in intravenous or
inhaled therapy to treat P. aeruginosa lung infections in cystic
fibrosis patients.[22] Previous studies have shown that amphi-
philic tobramycin analogues bearing a lipophilic group at C-
6“ or C-5 retain potent antibacterial activity.[12,23] Further-
more, it was shown that C-6”-modified amphiphilic tobramy-
cin targets bacterial membranes as its major mode of
antibacterial action,[12] while C-5-modified tobramycin ana-
logues containing positively charged small hydrophobic
chains retain their capacity to interfere with protein syn-
thesis.[23] Moreover, there is crystallographic evidence that the
C-5 hydroxy group in tobramycin is not involved in direct
contacts to model RNA, thus suggesting that structural
modifications at this position may not interfere with RNA
binding.[24]
T
he world is facing an enormous threat from the emergence
and dissemination of bacteria that are resistant to almost all
currently available antibiotics.[1,2] Two strategies, multiple-
component antibiotic adjuvants[3] and single-component-
based antibacterial polypharmacology[4] are currently under
investigation to combat bacterial resistance. Both strategies
seek to exploit multiple modes of action. Recently, amphi-
philic aminoglycosides (AAGs) have emerged as a source of
antibacterial agents to combat bacterial resistance.[5–14] Mode-
of-action studies have shown that AAGs can show different
modes of action[9,11–13] to AGs, which bind to the 30S
ribosomal subunit, thereby leading to the disruption of
protein synthesis.[15] For instance, it was shown that the
antibacterial effect of a neamine-based AAG against P.
aeruginosa was caused by changes in membrane depolariza-
tion and permeability and not by inhibition of protein
synthesis.[9,11] Strong evidence for membrane-targeting inter-
[*] Dr. G. Guchhait, Dr. B. Gorityala, X. Yang, Dr. B. Findlay,
Prof. F. Schweizer
We report herein our investigations into the antimicrobial
properties of the C-5-substituted amphiphilic tobramycin
analogues 4a–f (Scheme 1), which were prepared from
tobramycin (1) by using phase-transfer catalysis for the
alkylation (Scheme 1). Compounds 4a–f were tested for
antibacterial activity by determining the minimal inhibitory
concentration (MIC) against a panel of bacterial strains,
including tobramycin-resistant clinical isolates (Table S1 in
the Supporting Information). Our results show that the
amphiphilic tobramycin analogues 4d–f, which bear lipophilic
tetradecyl, hexadecyl, and octadecyl ether appendages,
respectively, show good activity against gram-positive bac-
teria (GPBs; MIC = 2–16 mgmLÀ1) and reduced activity
Department of Chemistry, University of Manitoba
Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2 (Canada)
E-mail: Frank.Schweizer@umanitoba.ca
Prof. G. G. Zhanel
Department of Medical Microbiology and Medicine
Health Science Centre, Winnipeg, Manitoba, R3T 1R9 (Canada)
A. Altieri, Prof. N. Mookherjee
Department of Internal Medicine and Immunology
University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB, R3T 2N2 (Canada)
[**] Funding for this project was provided by CIHR (MOP 119335)
Research Manitoba and NSERC.
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW
6278
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2015, 54, 6278 –6282