Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
was fully inhibited (incubated for 24 h with 150 mm 6e) into
fresh medium without any AQNO. In this case, growth was
restored within 24 to 48 h, indicating bacteriostatic activity.
HQNO has been described as an inhibitor of the respiratory
chain, which typically leads to the induction of small colony
variants (SCVs) in S. aureus on agar plates. A dose-down
1
experiment confirmed that trans-D -NQNO 6e and NQNO
6
c also induced SCVs down to 3.125 nmol whereas the
1
corresponding cis-D -NQNO 6 f did not induce SCVs at the
highest dose tested (25 nmol, Figure 3A). SVCs have been
Figure 2. Production and activity of AQNOs. A) LC-HRMS analysis for
a–6 f in PAO1 extracts. The base peak chromatogram is given in gray
6
with the extracted ion chromatograms for 6a–6 f superimposed. EICs
of the synthetic standards (intensity-adjusted) are given at the top in
black. B) Representative growth inhibition experiments with 6e and 6 f
with the MRSA strain USA300 in well plates at 200 mm (top) and by
the disc diffusion method on agar with 25 nmol compound (bottom).
1
C) Growth curves of S. aureus USA300 with trans-D -NQNO (6e), its
Figure 3. Effects of AQNOs on metabolism and virulence of S. aureus.
A) Induction of small-colony variants of S. aureus NCTC 8325–4 at
12.5 nmol by 6c and 6e but not by 6 f. B) Inhibition of hemolysis of
S. aureus USA300 on blood agar. C) Testing for nitrate reductase
activity after different incubation times with culture densities given by
the OD600 values.
1
saturated version (6c), and trans-D -NQ (3e) as mean values of
triplicates.
bation, none of the AQs (3a-3 f) had inhibited growth and
also most AQNOs had not resulted in complete growth
inhibition (Table S1). The saturated NQNO (6c) was only
slightly active with an MIC of 200 mm. All other saturated
compounds including HQNO (6b) were inactive under these
described to be in an altered metabolic state where their
ability for quorum sensing via the agr system is compro-
1
[14]
conditions. However, the unsaturated trans-D -NQNO (6e)
mised.
The majority of S. aureus virulence factors are
was highly active against all strains with MIC values of 10–
coordinated via agr, and we were thus curious if at sub-growth
inhibitory concentrations, AQNOs may inhibit virulence. We
used the hemolytic activity of S. aureus as a readout for the
production of erythrocyte-disrupting a- and b-toxins as major
virulence factors. Whereas application of the saturated
À1
1
2
5 mm (3–7 mgmL ). In contrast, isomeric cis-D -NQNO (6 f)
did not result in growth inhibition even at 200 mm in liquid
cultures and did not inhibit growth in a plate diffusion assay at
2
5 nmol, at which the trans isomer produced a clear zone of
1
inhibition (Figure 2B). These results indicate a highly specific
NQNO 6c only resulted in incomplete inhibition, trans-D -
interaction of the trans isomer with its target. The unprece-
dented high activity of trans-D -NQNO (6e) raised the
NQNO 6e fully inhibited hemolysis already at 25 nmol
(Figures 3B and S4).
1
question as to how it compares to other antibacterial
compounds produced by P. aeruginosa. We tested pyocyanin
as one of the major antibacterial metabolites of P. aeruginosa
and obtained an MIC of 50 mm for the different strains of
It has been suggested that HQNO inhibits the respiratory
[
8b,15]
chain via cytochrome b.
While the architecture of the
respiratory chain of S. aureus is thus far only incompletely
understood, there are multiple instances where HQNO has
been applied in protein crystallization to mimic the native
1
S. aureus, demonstrating that trans-D -NQNO is even more
[
16]
potent than pyocyanin by a factor of two to five (Table S1).
To obtain more detailed insight into the growth inhibition,
menaquinone ligand in oxidoreductase enzymes. Although
these enzymes did not include a closely related homologue of
components of the respiratory chain of S. aureus, it may be
speculated that AQNOs are generally capable of blocking the
menaquinone-binding sites of various different enzymes. To
investigate this possibility, we selected the nitrate reductase
activity, which is exhibited by S. aureus under anaerobic
conditions. To this aim, S. aureus was inoculated at high cell
density in anaerobic nitrate-rich medium with either 5 mm
1
we measured growth curves for NQNO (6c), trans-D -
1
NQNOs (6e), and trans-D -NQ (3e) for the epidemic
MRSA strain USA300 (Figure 2C). With compound 6e, no
growth was seen at 10 mm, and growth only slowly restarted at
5
mm and 2.5 mm with a prolonged lag phase, while 6c only
incompletely inhibited growth at 100 mm. In contrast, the
1
trans-D -NQ did not significantly inhibit growth, pointing
1
again to the importance of the N-oxide group for activity. To
test if the antibacterial effect was bacteriostatic or bacter-
icidal, we diluted a culture of S. aureus Mu50 where growth
trans-D -NQNO 6e or DMSO. Whereas the DMSO control
clearly indicated formation of nitrite as detected with a diazo
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!